Baxter Pizzaria in Alliston

Service & food was very good at first but they have stopped trying. Last 3 orders the pizza came slightly undercooked and they put spices on it without me asking. The last one was a Hawaiian... pineapple and basil don't mix. Very disappointed to see things go downhill so quickly.

Worst pizza I've ever had... terrible flavor..over spiced ... most expensive too... $13.95 for 2 slices.😬

Tuesday night, great east coast lady , Katlyn or Katherine, served up a great pizza and chicken wings. Fair price and the pizza was more like the authentic speciality pizzas I had in my younger days at Joe Cool’s in London and small non franchise places near TO. Really good, she made sure the wings were well cooked. Definitely back for more of that. Plus $25 for the pizza, $15 for 12 wings, best price around.

The lady that made my pizza makes an amazing pizza better then the others she was also very resoectful I will be back for more pizza

First time seen this Pizzeria shop Meat lovers slice was delicious and hot. $6.99 (two slices) I'll be back to try something else soon thank you for your service.

Pizza was very tasty, love the pepper medley over top, but a bit pricey for an 8 slice meat lovers. Great in a pinch and I'll order again!!!

Had a negative experience with 2 pizzas on Monday night that were not made with the toppings I ordered. Spoke with the manager and they remade my pizzas tonight. So glad we gave it a second chance, because these pizzas were phenomenal. So many toppings and so much flavour. Thank you for providing such incredible customer service. We will definitely be back!

Excellent pizza at a comparable price. Haven't had one this good in a very long time.