Geno's Steakhouse in Black Creek
N8755 Old Hwy 47, Black Creek, WI 54106, United States
Business Hours
Services
Photos
Reviews
Most Mentioned
Our first time here. Everything was great. Very nice salad bar. Homemade soups. Streaks were great. Will definitely be back.
The salad bar very very small. Poor selection too of salad toppings. The cheese for crackers looked very old and honestly, gross! It was spread like butter didn't look real. We arrived at opening. The place is not roomy. Friday it was packed. Tables in same room as salad bar. Difficult to get around with wait staff and tables. DINERS were not polite or yielding at salad bar. They would push in front, linger or ponder to long over choices, two soups. Clam chowder was 2 out of 5. Our waitress knew nothing about my fish dish. Had no idea what dish contained as far as seasoning. I am allergic to paprika. ( hives) She was clueless to a lot of things. However, food arrived swiftly. Perch hubby ordered were very small. Expensive. You get a loaf of bread. Our bottom was coal black. The bread itself was cold. I cut off the bottom. My haddock was okay. Slim 4 inch piece. 3 piece. I ate one. Service was excellent though. We will not go back, parking is very poor.
They were super busy - but that was what we expected at 6 pm on a Saturday. My fiancé and I just grabbed a table and enjoyed a couple drinks (I had the Moscow mule special.). I ordered the broiled seafood with twice baked potato and he had the steak special. I loved mine. He enjoyed his meal. Salad bar was fun as always (say Wisconsin with gizzards on the salad bar!). We were not in a rush so it was fine but someone else could get frustrated.
After considering going to Geno’s for years, we finally made the trip as we live in Appleton. It was very busy but somehow we were seated very quickly by a wonderful server named Taylor. She made our first experience there absolutely A+. She was friendly, relaxed, conversational, and along with her pleasant smile, just a joy to have met. She told us she’s been serving for 5 years there and she loves her job, which certainly showed. I’m a retired retail general manager of a large area business, and I would have done anything to have such a wonderful person work with me! Oh, the food, everything from the salad bar to the main dishes were excellent as well! We will definitely be back.
Driving through rural Wisconsin this past Saturday, we were pleasantly surprised with dinner at Gino's. The bartenders and our waitress were efficient and courteous. The steaks and even the grilled seafood platter were delicious. The salad bar was very fresh, but mediocre with their selection. The restaurant bar is a great place to hang (if you can get a seat).
Do NOT sit at a table in the bar area to eat, you get ignored. We had to get our own silverware from the waitress station and were never even asked/offered a drink!! (we went to the bar and got water, their loss) People at the bar seemed to get great service, locals???
Fantastic experience! Great service from the bartender and waitstaff-everyone was so friendly! One of the best prime ribs I've ever had-so tender and seasoned perfectly. Broiled scallops were delicious and larger than most places I've had them. Husband's ribeye was tender and cooked a perfect medium rare. His potato skins were crispy and served with a zippy sauce, really good. Salad bar with two soups and fresh bread at the table. Top notch supper club, can't wait to go back!
One of the best places to get a steak. Very friendly people and great cooks. We always feel welcome and always leave happy and full. Very good value and id highly recommend for anyone looking for a good dinner. Great for date nights but also family friendly. Make sure you try dessert!
Always a pleasant experience, great food and drinks. I highly recommend the ribeye Wheelchair accessibility: 1 spot and a ramp
Great food and salad bar, only complaint was the amount of parking wasnt adequate for the number of people that were there
Is it worth the drive? Absolutely
So busy, we waited forever to get a table. Had to be 20 people over Maximim Capacity, couldnt get out the front door to leave
Had high hopes! Nothing stood out, just average food.
Great Seaford platters and salad bar. Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp. Food : 5/5 |
Amazing food, super pact tho
Wonderful place. Food was excellent. Prepared just the way you requested. Ample salad bar. Soup included. Large portions. Autumn, our server was friendly, helpful, professional. Will return. Thank you for a great meal.
Very friendly place. Food is great.
Genos is always a great place to dine. The service is always a 10 star even though 5 is max. Your glass is never empty and the salad bar is the best.
Porterhouse was tough drinks were good, pricey.
Excellent steak. Salad bar was fresh. A bit loud atmosphere. The twice baked potato was served in a dish without the skin. I prefer the skin too.
Could have been a completely different experience with better service. Our waitress ghosted us from the start. We pretty much needed to fend for ourselves. Our time and money is way to important and will definitely not be back!
Service was poor, potatoes were burnt black. Clean bathroom but not reason enough to try again .
Drinks were a 3 on my chart!
Love the Friday fish. Bar area is a little small, but staff is friendly and a great place.
Very disappointed, they were not even busy when we got there. Didnt get the chance to eat, the bartender was terrible! We sat there and waited for 10 minutes, and no one took our drink order, people came in after us, the bartender served them before even looking our way will not be returning.
Good food, good salad bar, good drinks, good service! Cant really go wrong here!
Excellent meal.
Steaks are phenomenal and the asparagus hollandaise topping is wonderful on a ateak but I ordered the steak combo dinner and for a full extra $30 i got a 0z lobster tail that was so extremely overcooked. Also the salad bar was 1 of the best
Truly a great steak!!
Great salad bar. Old time supper club.
My best friend and I had more than a fabulous time. The staff was incredibly friendly courteous and knowledgeable. We were skeptical about the wait due to the number of people, but they got us in in no time! And table 1!! That was cool. The salad bar was immaculate with items I had never seen in a supper club before, which was awesome, so we tried it. Im not telling you what the items were you should go see for yourself! We ordered the lovers special. 2 ribeyes 2 lobster side mushrooms & onion. We are happy we skipped the potato. We were so full and had enough for 2 more dinners!! Cant wait to go back. THANK YOU
I know this place is really popular with the locals. But maybe it s because of the bar. The bar is almost always packed. But the restaurant leaves much to be desired. Now, granted, I m from Philadelphia, and I ve lived in New York, Miami, Washington D.C. and Los Angeles. I have had some amazing food. I have never left a piece of Prime Rib, or any steak for that matter, on my plate unfinished. Until this trip. The salad bar is smaller than the local high school, and most everything tasted like it came from a bag. Which I will guarantee the jalapeño poppers did. So, while I truly desire to support local, small businesses, this is one that I will not be back to. Perhaps their other food is good. But I m not willing to risk my money to find out. Sorry.
Very good food. Great staff! It could be a little bigger. Gets very busy on Fridays and Saturdays. Standing room only for about an hour wait for a table. If you dont mind that then the food is worth the wait and the crowd.
I had the stuffed haddock with Oscar hollandase sauce to die for! Excellent
Great time
Consistently Great food and service!
If you want a old school wisconsin supper club vibe this is the place. A small supper club in the middle of corn fields. The place and service was good.
We love this place. Great salad bar and soup.
Very good service. Bartenders and wait staff did an excellent job. I had the Broiled seafood platter which was a perch butterfly, a piece of Haddock, 3 scallops and 4 shrimp. Choices of potato sides were potato skins, Baked. American fries, French fries and sweet potato fries. My wife had the 12 Oz tenderloin. Menu listed tenderloin 12 , 16 or maybe a 24 Oz choices, A poterhouse that said 10oz. But all steaks that I saw were larger than what was listed. My wifes 12 Oz was more like 16 Oz and was tender. Salad bar was very good , it included 2 soup choices.
We do our family Christmas dinner here and have for 5 plus years and are always impressed with the food and service.
Very nice service. Good food. Just north of Black Creek.
Great food. Good price...
Always excellent food with friendly staff. This is a hidden gem!
Fantastic food!
Amazing steak
Friendly fast staff both at bar and in dining area, food was very good, properly prepared, will certainly go back again!!!
Great food and service
Food was delicious, and the old fashioneds tasted great as well! Salad bar was very tasty too. Everyone is very friendly as well.
I wish they wouldve told us when we checked in it was going to be a 2.5 hr wait for dinner. The food was good enough. It was so crowded, it had to be over compasity.
New York Steak French Fries
The steaks, salad bar, and cocktails are amazing! The wait staff was very sweet and a lot of fun - well be back!
Giving 4 stars because the venue isn t large enough for the amount of people that come to dine, but the food and service is great!
First time here and impressed immediately with the fast service & friendliness of the bartender! Ordered our drinks, looked at the menu, and they took our order right away. Salad bar had everything you could want on it and 2 different soups, which were both delicious! Our food was delivered before we could even finish our salads! No long wait, which was amazing considering they were so busy. Husband got haddock and fries and said it was very good. I had the ribeye and loaded baked potato. It was a little thinner cut than what Ive had at other places but it was very good. I would have preferred it a little more seasoned & a bit more charred, but it still tasted very good and I had quite a bit to take home (made for awesome breakfast the next day with eggs ). Our server was awesome! She checked back often making sure everything was ok and to see if we needed anything else. Had a great conversation with her about her raising and showing her chickens (they sell farm fresh eggs and I wanted some but they were sold out) thats how we got on the topic. Very pleasant and friendly. All the servers were on top of it from what we saw. Great job! Food was hot, as it should be, not just warm or cold like what I usually end up being served at other places. Had an enjoyable time and great tasting supper on my last day of vacation! Will definitely be going back again, and bringing family next time! Parking: Plenty of parking. Parking along the front and both sides but also have an extra lot to one side as well Wheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp for wheelchair access
This is a small restaurant/bar. Food was great and staff was friendly. Looking forward to go there again.
Busy Sunday night ,still got a table and great food in less than 30 minutes.....
Must have a new cook the meal was nearly mediocre
An average Wisconsin experience. We had steaks, a sirloin and a ribeye. Both were prepared to our liking. The salad bar was primarily lettuce with the normal accompanying toppings and dressings.
This place gave me food poisoning. Will not be returning.
Great food, lots of people but that just means people love it! And Trenton is a great employee.
Salad bar and soup were excellent. Service was great. Food I was not impressed with
Restaurant located out in the country. Frequented by many locals. Have a drink at the bar. They will take your order and tell you when the table is ready. Nice salad bar along with good food. Service was good also.
Awesome food and service thank you
Excellent Ribeye steak. Great service.
Great food & drinks!
Awesome everything
The fish in the platter was over cooked, the tomato sauce on the chicken parmesan dinner was nothing but canned tomatoes. Bitter. Always wanted to stop here very disappointed. Wheelchair accessibility: Nice ramp
First time here, and wife and I really wanted to love this place. The dining rooms are small and the noise level from other patrons was so high we couldnt enjoy our meal. Parking: When we first arrived we had to park well behind the building, but spots opened up quickly.
We had a couple old fashioneds that were wonderful, our barkeep was great and fun to talk too. The salad bar was amazing as always, our steaks were made the way we like them, our waitress was awesome she was so accommodating and kind. As long as you go with good company you will have a good time here!
Excellent bar & restaurant with a fantastic atmosphere. The food and drinks were perfect and everything was reasonably priced.
Everything was excellent.
Great service, great people, literally the best
Delicious meal! Friendly & welcoming bartender (Rochelle) and waitress (Taylor) ... Very satisfied!
Excellent food, small bar but great drinks! Little out-of-the-way but well worth the travel. One of our personal favorites.
As busy as they were they did a great job getting us in. Food was very good. I would definitely go again.
Food and service was great.
Awesome food and service!!!! Thank you so much guys!!!
Arrived and they were very busy inside was able to get a seat at the bar right away and the bartenders did a great job serving in a timely maner placed our order for the 4 of us and were seated at the table in about 20 minutes salad bar was perfectly stocked and main course was done perfect and our server was right on top of drinks and things cant say thank you enough to make a great dining experience for us being first time there for a 28 yr anniversary dinner will be back often worth the hour drive
Chicken was average for broasted, Prime Rib was way below average. To top it off, a large, clearly overserved and obnoxious group of ladies was brought from the bar and seated adjacent to us and repeatedly dipped into our quiet conversation. My 8 year old who is very rambunctious even commented on how loud and misbehaving they were. While I understand times to be tough, I can speak for my group and the group behind us that none of us will be back anytime soon. Catering to rude, obnoxious and extremely intoxicated guests is a choice that all too often results in that being the only groups a place can attract. In regards to the reply, I have not deleted and reposted an identical review any amount of times. Google does request some reviewers update or affirm prior reviews from time to time which if not ignored does renew the review. Ill make a point to ignore this request going forward. Best wishes, C
Great food and great service! Love it here
Great service, awesome food they have really good drinks and the salad bar is good.
Very popular steakhouse.Great food and good value.Be prepared to wait.
Nice atmosphere, best steak Ive had in a long time. Hood bloodys
Not impressed at all. Asked for Med well got dry nasty unflavored steak. Definitely will not return.
Great service and good food
One of our absolute favorites!
Tenderloin and Scallops are on point!!! Definitely coming back!!
We decided to try something new, and with all the amazing reviews, we were hoping the 45 min drive would be worth it. Unfortunately, it wasnt. We ordered the tenderloin and cajun haddock & the 16 oz ribeye. Steaks were cooked correctly but had absolutely no flavor. And the cajun haddock was flavorless as well. Although a few bites ot my tenderloin I could taste something like Old Bay Seasoning. Our server was ABSOLUTELY AMAZING and definitely left more than 20% . Hoping it was just an off night for the kitchen because it seems the a really neat place
Best out of town supper club! Worth the trip regardless of where youre coming from. Amazing steak, friendly staff, and great experience.
Excellent food and service, despite being very busy.
Great steak, friendly atmospher.
Service was excellent and the food was delicious cant wait to get back there
Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly. Very welcoming. Wheelchair accessibility: Yes there was a ramp accessible for wheelchair.
Frendly folks and good food, what more could you ask for in the times we are living in.
Delicious as always.
Great food. Way off the beaten path
Very nice little hideaway supper club just what u would expect, friendly and clean, the service was wonderful and the clientele were all friendly
We simply googled Black Creek Supper Club and discovered Geno s. Read a few reviews and decided it sounded very nice, but the truth is we found it to be extraordinary! Excellent service, the food was wonderful and cocktails were a delight. Great value and we d definitely visit again. It was a full house on a Wednesday night in the middle of farm country that alone will tell you it s a destination even for locals. So glad we found you!
Had the stuffed shrimp. Food was fantastic. Amazing bar tender and our server was great too! Highly recommend!
Excellent food ..fresh salad bar steaks are perfectly made!
Great atmosphere, great service. We went for Tenderloin. We over ordered so we could have a delicious steak omelette tomorrow morning!! Food was excellent. If you havent been, you should seriously consider treating yourself to a wonderful experience!!!! P.S- add the sauteed mushrooms. :)
Busy place. Lots of fun and good service. Good food at a reasonable price
Great tasting food...amazing steak!
Food was very good and the service was excellent. We came in on a Saturday night and it was busy but they were very quick for the amount of people waiting.
Food was good and service was great. Very busy on a Saturday night.
Overall just fantastic.
Another great meal at Genos. We were greeted by Rachelle who got us seated quickly. We were served by Autumn who made sure that we had everything to make our meal complete. It was a great Birthday meal. Heres to another year and more great meals at Genos. Parking: Added parking lot allows for enough parking for customers.
I had the prime rib and it was absolutely delicious!!! The drinks are great and the staff are friendly and helpful. I have always went to the Black Otter for prime rib but tonight I found my NEW favorite place for prime rib!!
Get here early (per any decent supper club)! Friendly and attentive wait staff. Nice portions for delicious steaks! Wheelchair accessibility: Getting in the building is easy for mobility but inside would be kinda tricky
Great experience, good portions. Competitive prices Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp accessible although getting through the packed bar can be tough. Food : 5/5 |
The staff are always friendly and the food is great. Have never had a bad meal there.
Service and food were great. Thanks Niki and Rachel
Great food and beverage
Wow! Such an amazing place. Excellent food and great service. I will certainly be back!
First time there. Great drinks, food, and service. It was a Saturday night and EXTREMELY crowded and congested. This made it a bit unpleasant and unrelaxing. I would go back again, just at a not so busy time.
Dont get to eat here often but when we do it is wonderful! The prime rib is fantastic, best I have ever had.
They have some of the best food around. Steaks or whatever you want is going to be really good. Take the drive.
Great food and bartender was awesome
Excellent steaks, service was great. Very friendly atmosphere!!
Great prime rib .thanks for the great service.
Made me believe in steaks at a restaurant again. Delicious!!!!! Perch was fantastic, too.
If you plan to make a trip to Genos, order the Geno burger and dont let them forget the egg! This burger with nothing else is a meal in itself, oh by the way great salad bar, great drinks, awesome steak, recommend loaded twice bake with your steak, enjoy!
My boyfriend and I stopped in on our way home from a cabin up North. He had the Oscar style prime rib (definitely the way to go on steak) and I had the grilled salmon. Everything was super fresh and delicious. Staff was very friendly and genuine. We had a pleasant time and we will definitely be back.
Our waitress was awesome and the food was awesome. We will be back!!!
High prices pretty sure all food is pre cooked just disgusting one bite was a massive turn off
Good food, reasonable prices.
Tried this place twice recently. 1st time prime rib and my wifes chicken both were served cold. A few weeks later decided to give it another try. Potatoes were very lumpy, salad bar prep looked very rushed and no attention to details on egg prep or radish prep. Place has a lot of potential but seems the food is all made way ahead of time reheated and rushed out to your table to get you in and out to serve more people. I would suggest dining elsewhere.
Busy but great food. Very friendly service.
its the Best keep up the good work
Good service steak was perfect but a lot of grease on the plate mate
Excellent service and food
Was very busy when we arrived, but luckily the friends we were meeting already had seats for us in the bar area. After a coctail, we placed our order, and about 10 to 15 minutes later we were shown to our table. My wife and I had the lovers special, which was two 16oz prime rib and two lobster tails. It was delicious, and cooked perfectly. We will definitely eat there again.
Great steak and salad bar! Service is top notch!
Very good foo
Great atmosphere, people and the food is awesome
Great food
Love this place! Great food, great people, great prices!
Good food and bar, nice friendly people !
As good as Always
Old fashioned was not great, we never ordered because other customers that came in after us were extremely loud (yelling at each other) and they were literally standing touching us and every time they stared yelling we would get an elbow to the ribs. I am sure the food is great but the other customers are rude af.
Steaks we all over cooked
Love, love the service, cant say enough of this place.
Great food!!
Great prime rib
Was there last Saturday night and was very good steaks were seasoned perfectly like they used to be will definitely be back soon
Excellent and fast
Make reservations or go early. Food is delicious.
We arrived at 645pm on a Friday (we had res for 630 but I was late getting out of work), the bar was full but we only had to wait for one other couple before we were waited on. We explained we were a 630 res and they said they could get us in in a few minutes if we wanted. We order during our second drink and were seated during our third. Salad bar was good, there was the usual supper club items, including liver pâté and BBQ gizzards, and 2 a chili and a soup. The food was out shortly after we were finished with the salad bar items. I got a rare tenderloin and it was a little on the saltier side, but very very good. The rest of our party got fish or steak and everyone was very impressed. Overall very good experience our first time and we will be coming back for sure!
Seafood Alfredo is Awesomeness on a plate
Similar Places
