Pizza Amore in Colborne

Good even Great

He made the vege pizza as per our dietary need & it was delicious

My partner and I ordered some pizzas and sides, and received the completely wrong order. When we called to rectify the issue, they brought us what we thought was the correct order. But they did not give us the sides we had ordered. In addition, they took back the order we had received and said that they were going to deliver it to the people it was meant for. I am all for not wasting food, but this is a massive health and safety risk. We will not be ordering from here again. Very disappointing.

Pizza was fresh & cooked to perfection! I recommend for a good meal!

Pizza Lovers beware the worst pizza I have tasted on the planet uncooked cardboard I had to leave one star Which they don t deserve to give my true honest opinion 100% cardboard and I had to beg for a napkin

Burger tasted like really low quality meat. Bun was burnt. Missing items.

Pizza store with no washroom

Pizza was soggy and overpriced. Not good at all

Simply good

We ve enjoyed their pizza several different times now. They re always consistent and always very kind!

They make delicious pizzas. Weve never had a bad one. They are friendly and courteous and the pizzas are always ready on time.

I dont understand why a dedicated pizza shop wouldnt make dough from scratch? Pizza was pre made low quality garb. This was their second last chance. DONT BOTHER YOU WILL BE DISAPPOINTED

Not sure if owners have changed but food is now lousy and under par

Forsure one of the best in the area. Great food, quick service and reasonably priced. Highly recommended. Food

Every time I try to order panzos they are out of dough. What kind of pizza place runs out of dough??? It used to be so good.

Ordered a small bbq chicken pizza, and a side of sweet potato fries. Pizza was ok, nothing special, but not bad enough to complain about it. It tasted like frozen dough. But Ive had much worse, in all fairness, if I was in the area, Id probably try it again. The sweet potato fries, could have been cooked a bit more. But also could have been somewhat from sitting for about 8 minutes in Styrofoam container . Id give it 3.5

Was craving pizza, visiting family stopped in here and turned around and walked out. The place was filthy. If it s this dirty for the public eye I don t want to imagine what the kitchen looks like. Basic storefront cleaning fail!

Great food and good prices

We stopped at this restaurant since it is well rated. Unfortunately, if you want to eat there, choose another pizzeria. Firstly, there is no server. Two, we ate on paper plates as well as with plastic utensils. Imagine cutting a pizza with a plastic knife?? Three, you must serve yourself and clear your table. In other words, it should only be for a take out. The crust of the pizza is ok, the sauce is not very good, but the topping is good. If this restaurant boasts of being the best pizza in town, I cant imagine what other pizzerias look like...

Wow the worst pizza I ve ever witnessed. They also don t respect speed limits in campgrounds. They fly like it s Brighton speedway, and rude.

They are theaves and they dont know how to do math

Excellent experience with these guys, perfect food, and absolutely wonderful service. Been coming here for a while, and I have nothing but excellent things to say about this place! 10/10!!

Got a Greek pizza. Where is the Feta cheese hiding exactly? Regular dough Crust is similar to a non-descript commercial pizza from a grocery store. Really Disappointing. I wanted to give more stars, sorry. Only positive points are they offer gluten-free dough and the service was nice.

My husband and I usually get the 2 pc fish and chips or the Amore Special pizza. We have always loved the food

Excellent food, the best pizza for miles and theyre wings are fantastic too. Overall a great experience and highly recommended, totally delicious!

The food was amazing. Fresh chuck burgers, not frozen patties. The chicken bacon burgers are thick and juicy. The service was great, She was very proud of the quality of everything on the menu. It makes it hard to choose because everything is good!

Excellent lasagna. Great people

Ordered pizza around 5:45pm and was told it would be ready in an hour ish went there at 7:15pm to give them extra time. Got there and waited for an hour in the store.. got the pizza, wings and garlic bread and it was all stone cold. I would not recommend going here on a busy night. Had it on a random tuesday and it was awesome. but this time, worst pizza i ve ever had.

The service was very bad and after waiting ten minutes to order I finally got to I waited another thirty minutes to go back to get my order and it wasn t even started

Late. They gave my order to someone else. Had to wait for a remake order then still 35 min until delivery. Onion rings soggy breaking apart cant reheat in oven even. Garlic toast burnt. Pizza pep and cheese the top Pic is their banner pizza off fb and the bottom Is what showed up. Got a small Cesar salad that I already ordered for free for this run around.

Love the pizza. Friendly staff.

Sad to say but it was bad third time trying first two great last one the panzerotti wasn t shoes like one had a whole and all the grease from the dryer filled it.. I ordered deep fried panzerotti one was chicken bruschetta and it was made totally different than the first two times.. it was olives and so many it was awful.. I m afraid the new owners have let the kids do the cooking g now.

hard pass. just moved here and was hoping for a good pizza joint. food arrived cold twice (gave it one more short, as an optimist) and the dough was not cooked through even after I asked for well done.

Ordered a large meat lovers delivery around $50. Center of pizza dough seemed undercooked and pizza was cold. For the price and quality we cant justify ordering here again

Excellent food, large portions at good prices

Good food! the staff was absolutely considerate on my different requests everytime, being a vegetarian! The new veggie burger is a steal, must try! Also, Ive never seen my order being cheap-ed out on toppings that Ive wanted on my Veggie pizza. Good food, good staff!

Order pepperoni and onions, all on top of the pizza so that they are properly singed. Delicious.

I have a great home make hamburger here and it was great. They also have great pizza.

Highly recommended!! We really enjoyed their dip dished pizza and Pickled fries. They have good sitting space and so much variety in their menu. New management and staff was very friendly.

Good food. Competitive price. Super nice staff.

The lady I talked to was rude the menu is totally different than what it was on the menu. Have order there before it was good. Wont ordered anything again

Really great food and nice folks. Getting really busy so order early

Cheap,but very dirty and slow response.

New owners again. Pizza ok. Interior needs some work, very grimy, not great for dine in.

2 hours to deliver a cold xlrg pizza for $40...5 minute drive from restaurant! Hate a tip being asked for ahead of time and charged to credit card. I remember when tips were given for good service...now it is expected regardless. Another 15% fee on already overpriced food.

Ordered 3 subs, no brown buns, took 28 minutes, as they ran out of lettuce. Sub is not cut, 3 pieces of meat, very little lettuce, not impressed. Must be new owners, last time I was there, I was very happy,, not this time. I wish I could post picture of this sub, looks pathetic

This a great place to order food. We typically order for delivery....Pizza, lasagne, Ceasar salad, wings, veal sandwich (although they have many other items). Food tastes great. Hot food is hot, cold items are cold. Great value, great prices. Quick delivery. If it happens to be an extremely busy time, they will let you know that, and give an accurate delivery time. Check them out!

Ordered pizzas for a specific time and it was on time, hot and delicious! Everyone was asking where it was from the whole party.

Vegetarian options: Veggie option

Food was ok. Delivery took 2 hours when we were told it would be 1 hour.

Parking: I cant write what I want to say kitchen staff not good nothing Food

Gave me food poisoning several times ( uncooked chicken), overall not good food as well.

Need to get the facts straight with visa an debit while getting delivered..love the food..but visa and your every day debit card are completely different..completely different..no 3 digit code on back of debit card just a credit card.. he kept asking for it. I wanted to pay with my debit card! No 3 digit code on em.. Just credit cards! Steak subs are great.pizza good.

Moved to Colborne three years ago and have been ordering from them since we got here. For whatever reason their pizza is just getting worse and worse to the point that the last time we ordered it we ate one slice each and threw out the rest. Unfortunately we won t be ordering from them anymore.

Great pizza strange side conversations from behind the counter. Id return for the pizzas. Prices are good

Really delicious pizza and the garlic bread was to die for! I definitely recommend if youre ever in the area :)

Brutal experience after dealing with these guys many times. I called for delivery as Ive done many times and things started off fine. Towards the end of the conversation I was told my wait time will be 1.5 hours. I said I hope it wont be any longer and the guy laughed and said maybe longer like 2 hours or more. He followed up with but dont worry the pizza will be warm I let that go and simply waited for the delivery. 3 hours goes by so I call in and the manger said its simply a shortage of drivers and offered zero sympathy or discount for this stupidly long wait. 20 minutes later the girl arrives with the pizza that i no longer cared about and was very apologetic. I hold no grudge against the driver but completely on the management and whoever answered the phone. Hopefully this is a lesson on how to be professional and run a business properly. Maybe use someone else to answer the phone as the young guy cant seem to deal with basic customer service.

Amazing place, poutine and pizza are amazing will be heading back to try more!!! Staff is incredible!!!! Always clean and welcoming.

Great price and combos available. Their sauce is fantastic and they put plenty of cheese so rethink your extra cheese choice. The wings are also great.

Had pizza,wings and fries. Everything tasted good. Could have been hotter but the food was good.

Amazing

Always delicious

Great food on the menu...wi gs may be the best in Northumberland

I have been enjoying the food for 3 years. New owner of one year and I remained a loyal customer, tonight was the first time to order delivery ( and my last ) only accept cash received less food than I ordered for same price and no recipe tat is e not the law in our country never again aduusing our governments

Awesome employees they work hard

good service but the pizza dough and toppings are very poor when compared to the price. Pretty much plastic dough and cheese. You guys are a pizza place, your highest quality menu item should be the pizza. wont be coming back. Quite a rip off for quality.

Exceptional pizza- nice staff. All iteams on menu is must try.

Nice staff. Worth driving to colborne, always fresh.

We always have great food from Pizza Amore! They are always willing to accommodate us as vegetarians, which is SO appreciated! We have tried almost everything and it is all so delicious... the falafel is one of our favourites. The staff and drivers are always friendly. We love the payment flexibility, especially EMT option. See you again soon!

Awesome pizza. Will definitely go back for sure

Great food. Awesome wings.

Had banquet burgers ad fries was delicious....best burgers around

Pizzeria... so you d think I went for pizza LOL. No. My boyfriend and I were in Colborne and we were starving. So we ended up getting burgers from Pizza Amore. Wow! They were outstanding. Flavour was incredible. Size for price was excellent. Figure I have to try the pizza next... even if it s half as good as the burgers, it s a win.

My self & my wife were at colborne during Victoria day long weekend and we happened to try the chicken wings , greek fries and veg pizza . It was just amazing taste . The wings were very tasty with the creamy sauce . The Pizza was so well made with generous portions of cheese and fresh vegetables as toppings. Over all very good value for the money . Not the least...the service was fast & courteous. A must visit place if u are travelling from GTA towards Ottawa or Kingston .

Star rating is related to NOT offering Pizza Slices... I drove thru town and stopped for a quick snack, and had to try the place across the street, even though I wanted to try pizza here first, due to the better reviews..so I called, they said no slices, so I tried the other place and was disappointed in that slice, and just finished a review on their pizza.... I hope this place adds slices to their menu for passer-byers can pick up a snack.. Small town, but people do pass by, or workers driving by may want a slice and not wait for a small pizza to be made...

We grabbed Wings & Pizza Combo 2 at Pizza Amore. Friendly staff and service, we ordered the thin crust, but the pizza was still very thick. But wings were great. Pricing is affordable!

Good pizza

awesome little spot, great food and employees

Great pizza, fresh toppings!

Very good place I had to eat there is beuth pizza Love I think we are the only Mexicans who have visited that restaurant greetings to the BOSS there is very good service it was like three years or four greetings

Great service, got fresh tasty meal. Loved everything

My wife and I ordered coconut shrimp with Ceasar salad and combo # 2 for delivery and everything was fantastic.Arrived nice and hot and cooked perfect.Thank you so much.Cheers.

Weve been here a couple of times, the first time we had sandwiches, very little flavour, and mostly peppers ,onions, and mushrooms on their steak sandwich. The second time we had pizza. On their window they claim to be the best pizza in town, if thats the best, thats just sad. It wasnt horrendous, but it definitely wasnt the best in town.

Love the taste and always fresh. Wonderful staff and fast service. Very pleasant experience..!

Delicious Pizza. Excellent service and staff

Great pizza and boneless chicken wings.

Always friendly n helpful n good food for a reasonable price

Good service. Caesar salad was good. Pizza was good but better after a quick trip to a frying pan to crisp up.

Best place ever

Its okay just the last couple times I had was over greasy was very unsatisfying

My suggestion? Dont bother going there after 7 pm. Apparently closing at 8 pm actually means 7. We arrived at 7:22 pm and were turned away because they had turned everything off. The open sign was on I might add. My partner and I run a food business and we would NEVER turn our stuff off until our doors are officially closed (at ADVERTISED time!!!)- because guess what? Customers are NOT an inconvenience. Theyre the reason we can pay our bills. What a waste of time. #falseadvertisement #badbusinesspractice #wontbeback

Ordered pizza tonight. XL meat with no sausage. Sausage all over the pizza. They blamed us for not checking before we left the shop. Said they accidentally put sausage on but took it off. That it is maybe only a couple pieces. On my two slices alone had over 7 pieces. Hung up on my dad during conversation. Would not recommend this business.

Prompt delivery and delicious burger and loaded poutine Best burger w reasonable price.

Wonderful place with wonderful staff serving delicious and flavourful food. Highly recommend for pizza and burgers.

We ordered a panzerotti and a burger with a poutine and it was amazing great food great service there pizzas are amazing aswell

We are regular customers. In fact I would say LOYAL customers who never complain about mistakes (we are all human after all) but..when it s every time we order.. it gets a bit frustrating. Our family likes to order almost once a week. Every time there s a mistake. Either our garlic bread is missing (four times we ve counted) or they get the order wrong.. I m being careful of stating details to prevent from being bullied from owner as I have just seen on another review here. Anyways. I ll continue to order because it s rather delicious.. BUT I have to inspect my food so wrong ingredients aren t used. A small discount was great so I ll let it slide this time. But please.. next time say sorry please don t say I know I did it right own up to your mistakes so you don t lose customers. Trust me. I come from a large family who own and run very successful restaurants. Please don t forget my bread next week

Excellent food

Food just isnt the same since new owners took over

Really good pizza & good hamburgers

Best pizza in around area, fresh toppings and fresh dough. Hands down !!

Poutine with super savory, cheezy, ridiculously rich brown gravy. Chicken strips crispy and delicious. Worth the drive to taste for yourself . two thumbs up.

Great food and service! Also owners very pleasant.

Absolutely great little place. I go here often And have never had a bad experience, its Family owned and operated, easily the best pizza in Northumberland. Update May 15 /2020 this USED to be a great place and the food quality is still there however..... since the new owners took over its absolutely rediculous ! They often run out of pizza dough or wings, they close early, ect.. ive recently started ordering from Vitos simply for convenience

love your food.

I feel like Ive been duped. This is hands down the worst pizza we have ever tried. It took 40 min. to make so I was optimistic t would be good. How wrong I was. The crust tastes like crumbly cardboard. It honestly doesnt even taste like pizza. There was next to no sauce. Very tasteless. So disappointing after reading all of these glowing reviews.

Pizza in Colborne should not be this expensive. The pizza quality is ok, but noy special by any means. The boneless wings are atrocious.... The only way pizza like this should get a good rating in Colborne is if its a good price. Hard pass next time.

Ordered a large Pizza and it was absolutely mouthwatering. Toppings and cheese were heavily loaded and as per my request the pizza were perfectly cooked to my spicy(Hot) level. Poutine was definitely my fav. Although it was bit expensive but it was worth a try and fries were cripsy. Thank god I found this place on my way and it made my day. Will definitely come back soon. Thank you for your quick and friendly service.

Great pizza and super friendly and clean staff. So many things to try on the menu. We want to try deep dish pizza next! Our pepperoni pizza was great because they use quality ingredients. My husband doesnt like when there are fennel seeds in the meat or in the sauce, like in Montreal. This pizza didnt have that. Theres parking directly in front of the shop. The stores on this main street strip in Colborne are elevated on a platform higher than the street level. Just outside Pizza Amore there are benches where you can enjoy a slice it sandwich on a nice day. Its a very cute town to visit with lots of antiques, restaurants, spas and cottages near the lake. Pizza Amore is a special place!

The pizza here is excellent

So very disappointed. Waited for over an hour for burnt cardboard pizza, if I wanted that I would have let my wife cook

Pizza and wings tonight were amazing!! Will definitely order soon again and cant wait to try other items on the menu!!!

They had a pizza and wings special...the pizza tastes like pizza hut but better (less greasy) and the medium flavoured wings are very addictive...I will go again. EDIT: I went 3 years later and let me tell you how far the pizza has fallen from this place. The Pizza taste like frozen, it was awful and the wings were just OK. I will never be going back to this place again.

The customer service was good and the panzerottis were to die for LOL seriously Tri them

Delicious and great portions

What to say here... Burgers are fantastic, but fries are cooked in old grease making them not very good. Fix that and its a solid 4 stars from me easily

nice pizza place... They had only pan pizza and it was worth trying...

Glad to have this place in town!

Excellent pizza, Excellent service!

Tried this place on a recommendation of a friend. It was flavourless (main flavour was the pizza crust), kinda undercooked, and tasted like frozen grocery store pizza but worse. I have never been so disappointed by pizza. Ive had better pizza at all you can eat buffets. Maybe it was an off night but I literally dont understand all the positive reviews. Definitely never going back! People were nice though?

The foods always good and lots of it

Good fast service...Best Steak and cheese subs around.

Good pizza

I just moved to town and Every thing i have put of here has been amazing, the greek fries are addicting.

Just moved to town. They already know who I am when I order... which is sad for me actually lol.... I order too often I think... but that tells you how great they are. Amazing Greek fries, love their pizza, great Wednesday deal with pizza and wings.... havent tried anything else yet but Im impressed so far. Xoxo

Amazing food. Amazing people. Best pizza around

Great food, Great prices, Great Staff

This is hands down the absolute best food ive ever eaten. Seriously if you havent gone there, you need to immediately. The staff is amazing only second to the food. Why are you still reading GO NOW!

Great food, great staff

Great pizza will go again.

Great pizza

Best pizza in town.

Great pizza. Will definitely be back

Good but it needs dillivery decause its better than Vitos and Vitos is the only place with dillivery near me

Good food unfortunately they dont answer the phone to take orders within 45 mins of closing good thing theres another pizza place across the street.

No place other with home made food from scratch or just something fast come on and stop bye

Love their pizza-especially the barbecue chicken and other food as well. Today a bit disappointed when I found out that they took the philly steak sandwich off the menu.It was amazing

I came for the pizza, but I stayed for the delicious sandwiches and cheery staff.

Salad was very watery.....very little ingredents other than lettuce and barely any feta. Lasagna was good but pizza was different and not as good as last time we ordered.

Best pizza in town. There is only the one other place but this is far and away better. Rest of the menu is good as well.

Fantastic hand made pizza!!!!

Awesome food

Had meat lovers. Excellent.

The pizza is the bomb the chicken wings are delicious and the wraps are awesome everything you get from there is grwat good work everyone

Best restaurant in town

It was good pizza

Good pizza, nice crust. I would recommend the meat lovers pizza

Best pizza we have ever eaten. Great people slso. Five stars!!!!

Best pizza, great service...two thumbs up!!

Awesome pizza...no greasy taste...terrific dough..a very flavorful meat lovers pizza...service was very quick and friendly..

Great food and staff!

Great food and staff!

Great food and good service!!

Amazing pizza!

Amazing place, fast and great service

Consistently the Best Pizza this side of Toronto. Courteous and Friendly atmosphere. A definite Must Try for those travelling eastwards past Colborne On. Try Anything on the menu...you won t be disappointed!!

Great service and great people awesome food!!

Chicken bruchetta pizza is delicious, banquet burgers are fanominal. Great people to deal with

Best pizza you will ever eat in Canada, a must try. Great staff, great environment. Every dish will leave you satisfied

Some of the best food I ve had in a long time! Anything from pizzas, burgers and amazing Greek food always hits the spot. Always comes up with amazing new menu options and makes them perfectly to order! Prices are great too. If you re a fan of gyros this is a place to try!

Great service Great people amazing eats!