Cocelli Pizza in East Gwillimbury

18279 Yonge St #3, East Gwillimbury, ON L9N 0A2, Canada

★★★★☆
(471 reviews)
Categories: Pizza restaurant Chicken wings restaurant Fast food restaurant Italian restaurant Pasta shop Pizza delivery Pizza takeaway

About

Cocelli Pizza

Website
cocellipizzaeastgwillimbury.taliupexpress.com
Address
18279 Yonge St #3, East Gwillimbury, ON L9N 0A2, Canada
Plus Code
3GF8+VH East Gwillimbury, Ontario, Canada
Time Zone
America/Toronto

Business Hours

Monday
11 AM–11 PM
Tuesday
11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday
1–9 PM
Thursday
11 AM–11 PM
Friday
11 AM–12 AM
Saturday
11 AM–12 AM
Sunday
11 AM–11 PM

Services

Service options
Delivery Takeaway Dine-in
Highlights
Fireplace Sport
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park Wheelchair-accessible entrance Wheelchair-accessible seating Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Offerings
Late-night food Small plates
Dining options
Lunch Dinner Catering Seating
Amenities
Toilets
Atmosphere
Casual Cosy
Crowd
Groups
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards Debit cards NFC mobile payments Credit cards
Children
Good for kids High chairs
Parking
Free of charge street parking Free parking lot Parking

Photos

Reviews

4.4
★★★★☆
471 reviews

Most Mentioned

wings (21) toppings (11) pepperoni (10) panzerotti (9) meatballs (6) area (6) crust (6) dough (5) italian (5) business (5)
5 stars
321
4 stars
83
3 stars
23
2 stars
10
1 stars
34
★★★★★
December 17, 2024

Dino; the owner is friendly and very welcoming. Took time to explain other food options available and other customers in the store were happy with Dino's service and the meal options!!

★★★
December 5, 2024

This used to be some of the best pizza I’d ever had. We’d order it every couple of weeks like clockwork. Some time in the last two weeks they completely changed the menu, and the pizza is terrible now. They’ve clearly cheaped out on the ingredients and it shows. I don’t think we’ll order from here anymore. Oh well. We’ll always have the memories.

★★★★★
October 31, 2024

My partner and I needed to stop for a quick bite after a late night delivery and seen this place! IT WAS WORTH THE STOP BECAUSE MAN! The food was so good, the pizza was a mix of gourmet and extra cheese lol. As i picked it up it fell apart, and the wings, very well cooked. Never-mind the amazing customer service from the 2 ladies working halloween night. This was an actual Pizza place worth leaving a review, thank you for putting care into your cooking! 10/10

★★★★★
October 4, 2024

We recently had Cocelli Pizza cater a late-night snack for my brother’s wedding, and it was a huge hit! We arranged the delivery a week in advance, and everything went perfectly. The pizza arrived right on time, hot, and absolutely delicious. It quickly became a fan favorite among the guests! Cocelli has always been a family favorite for us, and their quality and service remind us why they’ll always be our go-to pizza place. The staff is wonderful and so easy to work with. Highly recommend!

★★★★★
August 20, 2024

Was recommended by a friend so called to order a party size Hawaiian pizza. Phone service was good, pizza was ready on time and was great! Love the way they do their ham in small cubes not slices. And overall the way the pizza and dough was made are just awesome. I’m really particular about crust and sauce to topping ratio but they hit the mark on both these. Something you can’t find at allot of pizza places around Newmarket/Aurora area. Also need to note that the pizza are priced at a reasonable price absolutely amazing, will be back!

★★★★★
August 6, 2024

Pizza is amazing but i pretty much always have their panzarotti, love their panzarotti, Did i tell you i love their Panzarotti. Their panzarotti is amazing, and their pizza is great

★★★★★
May 7, 2024

AMAZING! 5 stars isn’t enough to describe this place. They use fresh ingredients which shines through in the quality of their food. The wings and pizza are fantastic but their Panzo’s have now taken the crown as the best I’ve ever had. I used to think a spot in Richmond Hill had the best Panzo’s however last time I went there I was disappointed when I had Cocelli’s Panzo they took the top spot for me. Amanda and Dino were very friendly. I heard Amanda on the phone with customers while I was waiting for my order and you can tell she loves what she does. 10 out of 10 for Cocelli’s I would highly recommend if you haven’t tried it yet.

★★★★★
November 26, 2022

Just ordered take out from here tonight. Heard some great reviews and wanted to try this place out. The pizza was excellent, great crush, sauces is very nice and just overall a great pizza. The price is reasonable and they have good combo deals on their website. Would recommend this place for sure. I will be coming back!

★★★★★
December 21, 2024

Great pizza and pastas. And now Turkish menu added can t wait to try

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 15, 2024

Very good pizza for a fast food takeout place and have expanded their menu drastically since my last visit Looking forward to trying all of the new items... Food

★★★★★
December 8, 2024

Awesome pizza, and pasta as usual. Now they have doner. Ive tried doner today, and it is the best doner i have ever had in Canada. Awesome work!

★★★★★
December 1, 2024

Good job berk such a nice kid!

★★★★★
Local Guide
November 22, 2024

Good food, friendly service, and fair prices! I d eat here again sometime.

★★★★★
Local Guide
October 22, 2024

Very nice staff and delicious food, and a great plus - inexpensive.

October 22, 2024

This place deserves negative stars, the staff doesn t know how to talk to people. I called and the person was so rude on call. There food is also very low quality. Should shut down.

★★★★★
Local Guide
October 22, 2024

We enjoyed 2 great pizzas tonight. Great quality toppings and cooked exactly like we requested.

★★★★★
Local Guide
October 22, 2024

Best pizza ever , actually everything is sooooo good especially the shrimp and chicken pasta

★★
September 22, 2024

Below average pizza. There are about half a dozen pizza places in the area with better pizza, at similar or better prices.

★★★★★
September 22, 2024

Great food and experience!

★★★★★
September 22, 2024

I love everything, this is my new weekend spot

★★★★★
September 22, 2024

Second time trying this place. Both times Ive had a great pizza, and the staff were all very friendly.

★★★★★
September 22, 2024

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free pizza is delicious! Food

★★
Local Guide
August 22, 2024

I usually really like the food here. But today was terrible. Clearly the driver did not care about delivery. Very disappointed.

★★★★★
Local Guide
August 22, 2024

Wonderful experience loved everything about this place.

★★★★★
Local Guide
July 22, 2024

Delicious pizza, well priced, nice staff.

★★★★★
July 22, 2024

I live in Ottawa and always make a point of stopping in for this pizza. If youre just looking for a classic cheese pizza this place does it well. The sauce and cheese ratio is perfect and its cooked well so you get that droopy slice. The sauce is super tasty as well and th pizza is not too greasy. Currently craving some rn

★★★
Local Guide
July 22, 2024

Pizza was undercooked, and the slices just drooped over and all the toppings slide right off. Dough was raw. Chicken wings werent very good either.

★★★★★
Local Guide
July 22, 2024

Great tasting pizza! Good price good ingredients. For a quick family dinner they arw great. They also have pasta. Will review that next

★★★★★
Local Guide
June 22, 2024

Order here for the first and very satisfied with the food. Reasonably priced food with friendly service. We will definitely be going back.

★★★★★
June 22, 2024

I love this place. Best pizza around.

★★★★★
May 22, 2024

Great pizza, their pepperoni large is my favorite order. Nice and thin and chewy, perfect

★★★★★
Local Guide
April 22, 2024

Amazing food...friendly family....great prices.

★★★★★
April 22, 2024

The pizza here is one of the best Ive ever had. I have been working in the area and getting pizza here every week for the past month or so and it has been great each and every time. Definitely recommend Cocelli pizza.

★★★★★
April 22, 2024

Great pizza, they re always consistent and use fresh quality ingredients. Their walk in specials are a great bang for your buck as well.

★★★★★
April 22, 2024

Best place in town 100%

★★★★★
Local Guide
March 22, 2024

Best pizza around

★★★★★
March 22, 2024

We shared a large pizza. Crust was nice and crunchy without sugar. Pizza sauce was good too.Amanda was excellent. All the boys in the back were quick and had sense of urgency. Owner was so humble. Please support these local by giving lots of support. We will be back soon

★★★★★
Local Guide
February 22, 2024

I was in Newmarket for the weekend and was craving pizza for Superbowl Sunday. We stopped in to place an order. Everything about this business is fantastic. I was greeted and looked after so incredibly well all the while, the phone was ringing continuously and people coming to pickup orders. It was apparent that they were prepared for the day and the staff were looking after all the customers. I highly recommend this location. The pizza was delicious and toppings aplenty. Tired of big box store pizza? Try them, you wont be disappointed.

★★★★
Local Guide
February 22, 2024

Update Feb 14th 2024: Stopped by for Wings, pizza and focaccia. Absolutely delicious! The owner was very nice Italian man. You should definitely try their focaccia, its super thin and cheesy . Pizza is a 7.5/10, tasted great. Definitely a nice spot in new market.

★★★★★
Local Guide
January 22, 2024

Great food. So tasty and good. Excellent people & good service. One of my fav Pizzerias, pasta is also great

★★★★★
Local Guide
January 22, 2024

I recently tried the pizza at Cocelli Pizza, and it exceeded my expectations! The crust was perfectly crispy, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. The sauce had a delightful balance of tanginess, making every bite a delicious experience. The chicken wings are well cooked and served with nice sauce. The staff was friendly, and the service was prompt. I highly recommend Cocelli Pizza for a delightful pizza experience!

★★★
Local Guide
January 22, 2024

Pizza was floppy in the middle due to excessive cheese, ask for it well done.

★★★★★
Local Guide
January 22, 2024

Been getting pizza from this place for a while now. Great pizza and always consistent. Very friendly service

★★★★
January 22, 2024

Its a charming pizzeria with delicious pizza varieties, homemade pasta, and salads. The staff is friendly, parking is convenient, and its our favorite spot for celebrating family birthday dinners!

★★★★★
January 22, 2024

Best pizza in east Gwillimbury

★★★★★
January 22, 2024

Pizza it s delicious and very nice people I recommend to everyone

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Great experience! I got pasta and was not disappointed. Would recommend!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Get the walk in special. Pizza here is tops! Food : 5/5

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Pizza was excellent. Generous toppings. Will be coming back!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Really good pizza here , if you want a slice or family sized they make them all, with great friendly service, nice to see.

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Crispy and tasty pizzas with thin crust. Creamy pasta with a right balance of ingredients. Great portion and nice service.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Good pizza, lets say regular nothing extraordinary if you are pizza fanatic but better the Pizza Pizza by a mile. They deliver but pick up 15 min and done. Recomend if you tired after work and not in mood to cook.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Best pizza in Newmarket area PERIOD! Wings are also on point, and cant beat their deals and pricing!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Nice mom and pop place with great food.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Best pizza in Newmarket!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Ultimately the BEST pizza Ive ever had. The crust, is do delicious! You cant go wrong going here.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Never going to another pizza place. Always great quality, and easy to order website. I have a special request and its never been wrong. Cant say enough

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

We ordered Family Special menu two medium pizza with a pasta. Both were great and stuffed very well. Honestly we didn t expect to receive this quality with this price. I recommend this place and I ll go back there again whenever visit that area. Food

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

My husband and I LOVE pizza. Cocellis is our number one pick. We live in Georgina and will go out of our way to get it. Absolutely incredible taste and a generous amount of toppings. The sauce is to die for! Thank you for your wonderful food and friendly service.

★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Delivery was extremely slow. Pizza was soggy and over cooked. For double the price of regular spots, I wont be back.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Always very friendly and their pizzas are delicious, ask about their promotions

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Pizza sauce is fire

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Been getting pizza here since they opened. Never a complaint. Always good, staff always friendly.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Best in town hands down. Only pizza my kids will eat.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Great pasta

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Amazing! we are from out of town and expecting a propper restaurant, and were disappointed to find fast food, there are tables so we sat to eat, and were verry pleased with the food and service, delicious, good options, good deals, good service, all around fantastic experience. Also The hot sauce was excellent.

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Clean place amazing chick wings and poutine do recommend

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Best pizza ever! Toppings are cooked to perfection! I absolutely love this pizza!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

best pizza north of gta i would definately go back. the place is clean and the people are super friendly and they know they make a mean pizza. everything is home made and meals are made to order. apparently the pasta is good as well according to the owners which is what i will try next. they have good specials and the washrooms are very clean.

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Excellent pizza!!! Great experience, pick-up & Delivery.

December 22, 2023

First time here. People are nice but the pizza was the floppiest soggiest pizza Ive ever had. If you like picking up a slice from the crust and having all the ingredients slide off as the rest of the slice flops then this pizza is for you.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Best pizza, I took two party Suze to a family gathering and everyone raved how good they were.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Great pizza

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

best pizza in EG

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

We ordered a large amount of pizza for our Wedding and Cocellis delivered right on time and everything was tasty!

December 22, 2023

I ordered large pizza. I asked them for only herbs and olive oil as sauce and topic roasted garlic and mushroom ! pick up my order and got home I receive pizza which taste of a garlic hell ! My blood pressure went crazy down not prescient it !not going back for sure !!!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

I JUST got my pizza from here. I am eating it, right now! I ordered through Doordash. I got a small pepperoni pizza, thin crust. 2 garlic dipping sauces and a coke. Let me tell you, I had to leave a review right away. This is one of the tastiest pizzas I have ever had. The sauce isnt too spicy or tomato-y. Perfect amount of sauce, too. The garlic sauce is creamy, not overpowering. The only reason I am not doing 5 stars is, the thin crust was made a bit soggy by the cheese. A tad annoying but really, takes nothing away from the amazing flavours. Thank you! Edit: soggy crust was made better by just waiting a minute. So good!

Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Worst pizza I even had in my life

Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Not clean place and needs to be renovated

★★★★
December 22, 2023

Very good slices. And pizza is always great. And fast service

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Great

December 22, 2022

Order was delivered cold and disgusting. Will never order again. Stay away from this company.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Good pizza kinda salty but I love the caramelized cheese

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Great pizza

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

We tried their pizza, overall it was pretty decent, a little too salty

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Amazing panzerotti, delicious pasta, fast and friendly service. We grabbed takeout after grocery shopping at Costco. Placed the order online for pickup and although it said it would take 30 mins to prepare, it was ready in 15 mins. We were parked outside so that was a pleasant surprise. Staff was super friendly and we got our food. On the short drive home, the smell of the food was absolutely intoxicating. We were so excited and Im glad to say that it did. It disappoint! The panzerotti was on point! My wife really enjoyed her pasta. Big portions! Im not sure why the negative reviews, as it seems that it was just due to delivery issues. If you are in the area or are driving by, stop in and grab some takeout. The website is super easy to use so it made the ordering process that much better. All in all we went there for the food, and the food delivered on quality. Will be our go to pick-up place after our Costco visits!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

My new favorite pizza. I got the party size for just under $25 with 1 topping, tax Inc. The sauce is brilliant and the cheese is loaded on to this bad boy. The crust is on the thinner side but not crispy. Its an easy choice if you are in the area I cannot think of another pizza with a similar taste that I have had in a while.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Great pizza but always get it well done!! crust and sauce is very good

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

Always excellent!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Great slice. Crust is perfect....light and not doughy. Delicious!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Good pizza. Had good calzones too before they stopped deep frying them but still all around a good place to eat.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Cocelli Pizza delivers a delicious, bready - almost sweet pizza with delicious and clearly high quality toppings. With good valued prices and good menu variety, I would absolutely recommend checking this one out if youre in the area.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Awesome pizza - great tasting and fresh. My family and I come here all the time for our family pizza night. Highly recommend.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Great pizza had it with thin crust and it turned out amazing

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

Stopped in for a slice. What a wonderful surprise. Crispy, cheesey awesomeness!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

I have been going to Cocellis for many years and I have enjoyed every slice of pizza they have served up! By far my favourite pizza place in the gta

★★★
December 22, 2022

The pizza is the best around. But Id prefer you guys to wear your masks when dealing with my food... I dont care if it isnt required anymore.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Very underrated pizza. It was delicious fresh and cheesey! I will continue to order from Cocelli pizza.

Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Not impressed, took over an hour to arrive. Pizza very doughy and overcooked. I ordered bacon on my Hawaiian and got pepperoni! How do you mess that up?? Wings are so small I d call them mini wings and are overly breaded. And the medium wing sauce is basically just spicy pizza sauce. Won t be ordering from here ever again!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Loads of toppings , wings look extra bready but surprisingly crunchy and really good! Staff are friendly , quick 5 stars!!!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Havent been for a while I was great good pizza

Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Mediocre pizza. Upon opening the box I thought I received someones thin crust order. Their microscopic chicken wings are definitely frozen for months on end with the bones breaking like crackers. More breading than the scab thats supposed to be meat. Clearly fried with oil thats older than my grandma. Mild Sauce that a toddler can casually consume was poured on top rather than tossed with the wings. On top of that the cashier was extremely rude and didnt know what a wet wipe is. Pizza pizza holds greater standards. Never again.

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

Great good. Easy to order online. Would order again.

December 22, 2022

Used to be my go to pizza place. Last time I ordered online they left out the Caesar salad I ordered. I called and they confirmed that they realized this and they would refund me. A week later I still hadnt received the refund so I called them. They told me that the only thing they could do was give me a free salad the next time I ordered and it had to be within 30 days. Terrible customer service.

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

We ve ordered from here a few times, and when the take out was taking longer than expected, they gave us a couple of pops on the house and some water for our dog. They were very apologetic and gracious. Really appreciated the sincere customer service - will be back!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Delicious recipes for Pizza and chicken wings. Good prices.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Love the pizza here.

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

My favourite pizza in Newmarket. Not too doughy, and the sauce is really good.

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

This was our first time ordering from the Newmarket store. We loved the dough of our pizzas and generous toppings. Service was friendly and it was an overall great experience. Well definitely order from here again!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Amazing pizza.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Not much of an eat in place. Although there are tables. I always get take out. Their pizza is fantastic. The sauce is flavorful and ingredients fresh. Ive had their spaghetti and meat sauce, with meatballs and Alfredo with mushrooms and spinach. Absolutely delish!!!!

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

Just the experience my family was looking for. Excellent food and service. Our server, wish I got her name, was probably the best we have had. Ordered pizza, lasagna and spaghetti with meatballs. The kids, wife and I loved everything. My wife and I are happy that we found a place with tasty homemade food and hospitality that gets families. Definitely will be returning.

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

Food is always fantastic. Wings were super hot

★★
December 22, 2022

Ive been going here for over a year and everytime I ask for extra sauce on my wings its hit or miss. The management seems to be focused on saving costs and the place is disorganized. These wings today were so disappointing the I couldnt even finish them. If theirs no sauce left at the bottom of your container after ordering extra sauce, then theirs something very very wrong with the establishment or staff.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

First time ordering from Cocelli and we are not disappointed. Fantastic quality pizza. Looking forward to trying more of the menu. Vegetarian options: Many options. Enjoy Parking: Location is good. Close to home for my family. Kid-friendliness: What kid doesnt love pizza? Enough said.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Seriously good pizza and reasonably priced. This is our go-to pizza shop.

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

We stopped by at Cocelli Pizza on our way home. We never heard about this place and just happened to be in the area. We are so impressed by the service, friendliness and quality of the food. The staff were so welcoming and the pizza was fantastic. We will definitely come back and recommend to others. Thank you for making it such a wonderful experience.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Really nice place. Great pizza with a bit more italian dishes to offer. A bit more gone cooked than big chain stores

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

By far the best pizza in Newmarket... High quality ingredients and fast service! Pizza is perfect with nice crust and cheesy.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Consistently great pizza. Family run place with excellent service.

★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Ordered the Lg 3 topping pizza (pepperoni, salami, ex-cheese) & pasta combo. Pizza was overcooked and it did not have the extra cheese feel, disappointing. The wife had the alfredo fettuccine chicken pasta which tasted like it was cooked from frozen. Id give the place a 3.5 ranking at best. It wasnt worth the $30 dollars in my opinion.

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

A ma zing!!!

December 22, 2021

Unfortunately I did not have the pleasure of tasting my delivered food as the delivery driver failed to contact us when it was left at the door. I m sure the raccoon that ran away with three pieces would provide a more generous rating. The restaurant refused to deliver another pizza and insisted that the problem could only be rectified through DoorDash. Sadness.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Awesome pizza fast service!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Easy online ordering experience. Good was ready when I arrived to pick it up. Pizza was some of the best I have had in a while and I was very glad I decided to try a new pizza place.

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

Delicious, timely and theyre always very nice. Our go to pizza place.

★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Called for 20 mins w/out an answer.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Amazing pizza

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

excellent and delicious pizza

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Always great pizza .

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Best pizza place in town !!! Great pepperoni and the sauce!!! Damn good sauce!

Local Guide
December 22, 2021

For the price of this pizza we thought it was going to be something special. But instead, we got two pizzas soaked in grease. The fat was pooling on top of it and the dough got soft and soggy because of all the grease. It was terrible. So yea, you get that at double the price of other places.

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

After a disappointing Friday night pizza last week from the Hut, we decided to go local this week and boy are we glad we did! We ordered the Cocelli Special which is 2 Medium Pizzas with 3 Toppings, 1lb of wings and any pasta dish for $45. Not only does that SOUND like a good deal, when you see how much food that gets you, it REALLY IS an amazing deal. The pizza was really fresh tasting and super cheesy, the wings were crispy and not overly breaded and the pasta was huge and also tasted super fresh. I honestly think this will feed our family of 3 for the entire weekend! Will be returning very soon as its actually the closest pizza place to us and we sure are glad that it is!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Pizza was really good and the Cesar salad was good. The wings were crispy but the sauce was just poured over them in the container. Will I be going back? Yes

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

The best pizza place and they followed all instructions as posted in order comments.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Excellent food!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Very good to choose your stile. Very professional people assist you.

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

Best thing crust pizza around

★★
December 22, 2021

Pizza is good but service sucks. Ordered 2 times from here, first time didnt get my drinks with my order and 2nd time didnt get dipping sauces. Driver told me to call the store and the store said its not their fault and I have to deal with door dash and hope someone nearby orders if I want what I paid for. Wont order again

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

Best pizza Ive had in awhile, amazing sauce and cheese, higgghly recommend them!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Excellent pizza, the one and only real pizza in town.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Good pizza

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

The Chicken Sandwich with all the extras is amazing! And I take a S2 Spaghetti & Meatsauce for home later, Heavenly!

★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Its pizza

★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

This was our first time trying the food here. Flavour wasn t too bad but my husband ordered the spaghetti and meatballs but he didn t get any!! I would have taken it back but it was just too far to drive. Very disappointing.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Love the baked panzerotti

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Great pizza, beats pizza pizza any day!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Best pizza in town.

December 22, 2021

Ordered for delivery at 740 rep told me 40 min no call to say running late arrived 8:59 open box pizza was not hot and looked like it was on its side for a while very very disappointed . i called you to inform before i entered this as well,

Local Guide
December 22, 2021

This restaurant does not pack the food properly so that the soup goes all over me. And they refused to say sorry. But the food is good. Just be careful!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

This place is freaking bomb. Love their pizzas and love their hot and honey garlic wings *kisses fingers*

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

Weekly order and absolutely delicious every time!! The staff is amazingly personable and extremely efficient . Love it!!

Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Great pizza if they get your order, write it down and actually make it. Watched 3 consecutive customers come in with incorrect, unmade or lost orders. (Ours was 2 of 3) So if you dont really need to eat the pizza you order then order from Cocelli Pizza.

December 22, 2021

Went here the other night. Pizza dough was really tough and chewy. Pizza was lukewarm at best. Chicken wings had fragments of bones throughout them. Wasnt very good at all.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Great food, reasonable prices!! Definitely will be a returning customer...

★★★★
December 22, 2020

Very tasty pizza!! Crust and sauce are amazing and very quick!! Also has gluten free crust

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Really good pizza and wings with friendly service. Their pickup deals are also very well priced for the amount of food you get. I live near by and we drop in whenever we can.

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Very good food.

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Best pizza in Newmarket! Wings are also fantastic and great service & prices - highly recommend

★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Average food . Wanted to try a good pasta dish and tried the spaghetti and meatballs.. it was decent but didnt make me want to order it again. We just recently bought a bunch of pizza for a going away party and it was soggy and not really flavourful. Not sure if we will get this again but Im a fan of giving places more chances which is why I gave it 3 stars still.. not bad .. just nothing to write home about.

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Ordered the medium pizza with pasta combo cant say enough about how good it was great tasting pizza good toppings lots of them and the pasta I got spaghetti and meatballs and the sauce and meatballs were made in house or tasted as such and will happily be ordering from them again

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Best pizza in town, including Toronto.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Good food and great people working here

★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Cant tell about pizzas but lasagna wasnt upto the mark.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Good pizza but a little bit to salted

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

The pie is fabuloso!! The meatball sandwich was also amazing... My daughter and I were hungry after a heavy gym workout and this was just so

★★
December 22, 2020

The girl who took my order on the phone was rude. Panzerotti was soggy. Pizza was decent.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Friendly, polite staff. Store was well stocked and clean. Baked panzo was the best Ive had in a long time. Will definitely be back again.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Old school pizza. Bery good

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

The NICEST staff Ive come across! They are so welcoming and very polite over the phone. Not to mention that their pizza has to be the best in all of Newmarket. I DEFINITELY recommend you try this place if you havent. You will be changed forever!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Amazing pizza made to order. Have not been disappointed yet..

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Pizza was crazy good will be back

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

An enjoyable slice. Crispy crust, crispy pepperoni

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

The pizza are amazing!!! My kids love it so so much , tomato sauce are different w anywhere else, absolutely will order again.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

I think its the best pizza in Newmarket.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Great pasta with lots of vegetables. Pizza is great as well, highly recommend! Important to note they can make the pastas vegetarian although not listed on their menu.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Excellent

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Best Value for Italian takeout in Newmarket dollar for dollar they beat the big chains like Pizza Nova cant hold a candle to Cocelli Pizza is sumptuous.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Best pizza in East Gwillimbury or Newmarket.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Good for a slice. Clean and good food

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

Cocelli is the standard we should hold pizzas to. Fresh delicious ingredients, excellent dough, and perfectly cooked every time. My favourites are the bacon double cheeseburger pizza (ground beef, bacon, and cheddar cheese) and the Hawaiian. Best pizza in Newmarket that I ve had so far.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Amazing pizza great service and the price is perfect for anyone !

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Hands down best pepperoni pizza around!!!!! Every piece of pepperoni is curled up and crispy around the edge. Their sauce is also next level!!!!!!! Ive been eating this pizza for about 7 years now and the quality had always been the same!!!! Love it