11 Main St E, Grimsby, ON L3M 1M7, Canada
I order from here often. They have amazing food all around. Their pizza is to die for. It doesn't make you feel bloated or acidic afterwards. Must try their pizza!
So disappointed!!!We’ve been looking for a great pizza place and I thought we finally found it.First time we ordered pizza was great but didn’t get the dipping sauces we ordered.Let that go it’s just dip.Now having a party and ordering 2 slab pizzas,was told 40 minutes.Just over an hour passed and no pizza.My husband calls and they said another 5-10 minutes,ok no problem,Another 22 minutes and it finally gets here.We ordered it well done as we do everywhere and they are burnt on the top,both of them. Now I have to serve my guest pizza with black crust.So disappointed 😕
I recently relocated to the Grimsby area and was on the lookout for some great local spots. I stumbled upon this gem, and I have to say, it's hands down the best pizza and wings I've had in the area! The pizza was perfectly cooked with a crispy crust, rich sauce, and topped with fresh ingredients. The wings were just as impressive—crispy, flavorful, and packed with the perfect amount of sauce. The staff were friendly, attentive, and patient. Whether you're a local or new to the area like me, I highly recommend Amici’s Pizzeria. It’s definitely become my go-to spot!
We ordered the dill pickle and Mexican pizzas. Delicious! The bottom of the pizza had the perfect crisp. This could be the only pizza place I can justify buying pizza from. I just wish they had a dine in area. #independent #local
I stopped by Amici’s Pizzeria this weekend. After seeing some good reviews, I figured it was worth a try. The service was great, the order was ready on time and was greeted with a smile. The prices were a little higher than other similar pizza places, also considering the extra large size looked more like a large. The toppings were a good amount and tasted fresh, as did the cheese. The sauce was very good, nice seasoning and garlic taste. The crust was good as well, soft yet chewy at the edges. Overall a good pizza and a fair price. Would definitely recommend checking out Amici’s for your next pizza craving.
It was so tasty I tried many but this omg great taste pizza and wings love it It’s small place clean great food I definitely go every week thanks they have dine in now.
This is one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!! I ordered a Large pizza with Pepperoni, mushrooms and green olives and 2Lbs of wings for $50. The quality is what counts in why I would agree to pay 50 dollars for a simple thing. Fresh ingredients and the chicken wings don’t get me started. Very very good wings, I would order the wings on their own if I was craving them. Breaded Buffalo is my go too flavour for them! I should’ve looked at the menu better for the same price it shows I could’ve gotten 3Lbs and a large pizza. Now I know for next time when I order again. I recommend this place to everyone in the area. Support local!
I tried Amici’s after the ownership had changed to see how it compares to the original. Amicis has been in Grimsby for decades. I was a bit disappointed to find out of a new owner and changed recipes. I just didn’t want to see another shawarma or gyro style pizza place. They do have that and it’s not good. Gyro is Greek and Shawarma is middle eastern. The gyro is the same spinning coagulated pre-made thing that everyone already has. Stay away. Our pizzas were made fantastic. They had a lot of toppings. The crust is far thicker than the old Amicis so next time I’ll order thinner crust. Stick to the basics and you get a fantastic pizza. The prices are fair and the service is good. I’m not sure why they ask for tips on pick up. This place does it and so does Gino’s. I’m not cheap but come on, I’m picking up my own pizza. You’re not sitting me down for a meal or delivering it to me. I’ll give this place 5 stars and hope they continue to separate themselves from the others. Grimsby is a small town with a lot of pizza places. Gino’s ran king for a long time but competition is catching up. These small guys are better than all the chains generally. There is a bit of difficulty with parking here as you need to go the street beside it to park and grab your pizza. I’d like to see the selection on DoorDash to be similar to what you find online.
Lemon pepper wings were bomb!
Pizza was great not over cooked , I will order again. Great staff
food was good, cashier was nice, and felt pretty calm
Thin cheese is FIRE!
Luscious pizza
Great pizza! Good stuff!
Fantastic pizza. Crunchy on the bottom, bright sauce and toppings. What a treat!
Delicious pizza! Crispy bottom, gooey cheese, fantastic flavor! Will definitely be ordering from here again!
I got a medium pizza and 2 pounds of wings for $47 , the medium pizza is actually the size of a small in my opinion it s over priced for pizza , anywhere else it s $10-12 for a medium not much flavour to it both the pizza and wings.
Dont like staff attitude.
Great pizza! Kind service
I ordered a medium pizza.and received a small pizza instead. Price was over $20 ridiculous. I do order from pizza pizza alot, and know this was not a medium size. I called the store and they ignored my request to solve my problem. They could have help to work with me to solve my problem. But they decided to feel customers do not matter. So I would ask people to be aware of this place or be cautious of your order or you could be duped. I ask them for Pino the original owner, but they said he is no longer ger ther over 8 years ago, but I spoken to Pino the owner two years ago, so you can see something is wrong here lying is not professional. So think before you order. I do t hate this place, but be professional and work with customers
We order wings and pizza for a party on the weekend. Loved the pizza, crust was perfect with a little char. Wings were cooked and sauced well. Will definitely be back.
Delicious pizza always
Used to be my go to place in Grimsby for pizza. Went after the ownership changed and not near as good unfortunately. No different than any other middle east owned pizza place. I wont be back.
best pizza in Grimsby by far, I highly recommend this pizzeria.
We have only ordered the pizza. We find them to have a very good crust and the additional sauce toppings are fresh. They also have more Italian entrees.
Ordered wings for the first time.. im new to he area and they were extremely accommodating. Thanks !
Great Pizza. Best in town!!
Great Pizza . The thin crust pizza definitely hits the spot. Added bonus was it did not feel salty!
Ive ordered in multiple times and I have never been disappointed. They are consistent with their attention to providing fresh, delicious, quality pizza - hands down best in the area!!
We ordered for delivery. We ordered three small pizzas, two orders of wings, and a panzerotti. My family really enjoyed the wings, my son said his panzerotti was good but not the best hes had, and we liked the pizza; however, we did find it too well done (almost burnt), we were a bit disappointed given the many positive reviews.
Phenomenal meat ball sub!
Yesterday I tried the Greek Pizza from Amici s Pizzeria, at first, I thought it look like an average pizza store, but I was blown away by the flavor and texture of this classic dish. I expect my pizza to have a medium-thick crust with perfectly crisp on the outside and soft on the inside and Amicis was just right. Even the crust was flavorful and had a nice chewiness to it, making it a perfect base for the toppings. The olives on the pizza were plentiful and oregano with black pepper added just right amount of spiciness. The cheese melted to perfection and had a rich, gooey texture and feta cheese complemented beautifully. I don t know the if there was something different about the tomato sauce which was tangy and adding balance out the richness of the cheese. Overall, I was extremely impressed and never thought an average pizza joint can churn out delicious and satisfying meal. I look forward to trying more of their offerings in the future !
Sold the place to someone else. Just not the same.
Decent gyros
Good crust and sauce.
This place is awesome! We just stopped through on our way to the US, and automatically the small shop looked great. Very clean, very friendly. We got a small Canadian pizza and it was so good. Enough to feed 3 of us!! Highly recommend!!
Pickle pizza
Excellent quality food - had the Greek fries and a meat lover pizza- quick delivery from a friendly driver, used debit on delivery. Will order again!
Great pizzas!
Very good pizza and excellent service I could get from here. Hope they will continue the same . no dine in option available
Amici s makes a great pizza; fantastic toppings and specialty pizzas, incredibly consistent, and a good price. I think this is New Jersey style pizza, so the crust is a bit thinner, slightly towards crispy instead of chewy, and tasty sauce. The pickle pizza is one of the best topping combos I ve ever had, and others like gyro and shawarma are excellent too. Don t sleep on their other menu items either; the shawarma and gyro sandwiches are excellent sizes and reasonably priced, and the wings are good pizza joint wings. The staff are always friendly, never make mistakes, and provide accurate time estimates. YUMMMMMMMMM
Very good pizza right next to the Lego store :) The lady serving was also very nice :) Greetings from Poland
Just okay... fresh items used but just not better than an average pizzeria.. not like the New Jersey style that used to exist at this location when Al owned it and previous owners
Very good pizza, very tasty I will eat this every week definitely
We placed an order for 2XL pizzas and 5 pounds of wings through skip the dishes. We got our pizzas and 2 pounds of wings(which were fresh and AMAZING) but shy 3 pounds so we called the store(5:15pm), the gentleman on the phone said the skip driver forgot the box with the other 3 pounds of wings. No biggie, accidents happen. The gentleman at Amicis instructs me to refund part of my order through skip and the store will rebill(at a discounted rate) me for the 3 pounds of wings directly and deliver them as soon as we are off the phone, sounds great right?! Well then an hour and a half go by(6:45pm) still no wings!! so I call again, The gentleman on the phone now says Hell be pulling in your driveway any minute. finally at 7:15pm the driver pulls in saying it was really busy, we had a lot of local deliveries (We are only in Beamsville 9 minutes from the store) he was very nice and seemed to feel bad about the situation but in other words the store kept bumping my order back and back and back until all their closer deliveries were done and to hell how long my family had to wait for the rest of our order. And its not like they remade the wings, no that would have been to costly for them so instead they send out 3 pounds of wings that have been sitting on a shelf for the past 2 and a half hours and are now cold and hard. We order often from Amicis between family gatherings and events we host but unfortunately because of this we will be taking our business elsewhere, a very easy solution would have been for the guy to just tell me they were to busy to send there driver that far or to just leave it at to refund part of my order through skip
Bad service and clod food
Order very often from Amici ,very very friendly stuff ,polite,food is also good .very nice delivery guy .
The staff at Amicis are some of the nicest 9ve met. Friendly staff and good pizza. Its heating harder to find pizza shops that still use quality ingredients and at amicis its all fresh and high quality. I personally love the wraps but try it all they dont have a bad dish in the bunch.
Best Pizza comparing to those larger franchise, price and potion are reasonable, staff always friendly and ready to server. Well always return here once in the area.
Service very good
Great pizza and wings. Quick service. Good lunch option.
I have decided that Amicis pizzeria has the best pizza in Grimsby. Reminds me of a place called fourth man in the fire back in Toronto. The dough was really good. So was the sauce and the toppings. They use red onions which makes the experience so much better. Clearly they know how to make a pizza. The side of garlic sauce was so good. Lots of garlic. This will be my pizza joint. Prices are reasonable too.
I came here for the first time yesterday, it was so good that I came back for lunch today. I got the shawarma wrap made with their amazing homemade bread - the serving was huge and loaded with chicken! I also got their home cut fries - yum! Today I got a panzerotti and it was so big that they gave it to me in a medium size pizza box! It was so big that I asked them to cut it in half - definitely a large enough serving for 2 ppl! The staff was super friendly too - highly recommended!
We just moved to Grimsby and found this really great pizzeria the pizza is sooooooooooooooooooooo good - delicious & the perfect amount of everything my husband & I love it and will definitely be ordering again & always recommend to family and friends. Thank you @ Amici s
I would like to thank the friendly staff the great pizza and wings me and my family enjoyed the food we havent had a good pizza as this one drove all the way from Hamilton and will be back soon for sure worth the drive keep up the good work amicis
Sadly disappointed with the pizza here. We used to drive from Niagara to get the pizza from Amicis .. it was a different style. The wings used to be so much better too. We asked for Buffalo style, Frank s and butter and they have us a sweet medium sauce that was nothing like Buffalo style. If I was the owners here, change your name. Don t play it off like your Amici s pizza, and say the food is the same on the phone and than we drive 20 min to have not good wings and not the pizza we are expecting.
The best pizza around. Wings are better then wing spots. Great staff and service. Love it, highly recommend!!!! If youre out of the area, its worth the drive.
Surprised the reviews are so high, it s why we ordered and were let down. Yes it s fresh and has quality ingredients, but the problem is there is no flavour, very bland. It s a bland dough, bland sauce, no seasoning, with fresh toppings is all. I also asked for extra sauce and got almost none. Had to add our own sauce and seasoning just to want to finish, and we were hungry which is always a bad sign. It looks good though
Good pizza. If you are on the fence about Amicis, now youre not. Put the order in you wont be disappointed.
Ordered several times for company .great food and service !
New to the area and my boyfriend came here for a sub the other day. He raved to me about it, and that the people who worked here were amazing as well as the food. Got some pizza and wings from here tonight this place is amazing definitely one of the best pizzas I ve ever.
Best Pizzeria in Town. And Greek fries are to die for
The best pizza and wings and the town will be back for sure
I am SOOO impressed with this pizzeria!!! If you haven t tried ordering here, please do so. You will have one of the best pizzas Grimsby has to offer! The owner is super friendly and goes above and beyond!
First time visiting since ownership changed. Ordered the shawarma pizza and three lbs of wings. Pickup was ready quickly and both were good. The reason behind the two stars is the wings looked like there weren t that many in the box given how much we ordered Weighing with box and all on a kitchen scale there were barely over two lbs. I d chalk this up to an innocent error, but didn t receive a reply after reaching out through email so thought I d post letting other customers know to watch out
I m really disappointed with my order today. We had chicken shawarma, good cook, and reasonable price. But it was so salty. We couldn t finish it.
Amazing pizza and service.
Best pizza in the area. We come all the way from Vineland for it. It s that good.
Rating this a 3 to give benefit of the doubt. Both our pizzas were soggy and floppy, crust barely cooked pizza near cold after picking up at exact time. Wings were mediocre. Both dips were great. Had high hopes and understand this is a small business so hope to see better of them.
Lived in Grimsby for over 20 years, had the original Amicis pizza my entire life. This is a well known establishment for the Jersey style pizza. Unfortunately the new owners did not keep this trend. Will not be continuing business with them, hot wings are not hot, pizza looks terrible, undercooked dough. Its sad they kept the original name, farthest thing from it! Should be made clear that it is not original recipe.
Ordered Shawarma Pizza, its was super cheezy and best taste, its a must try in Grimsby
Excellent pizza and very kind staff! We had the Shawarma Pizza and Vegetarian!
Good it great. But they need to change their hours. They are never there at 12 like google says. Lights are completely off and no one answers. Please update your hours
I love their Shawarma pizza so much !
The best pizza in Grimsby. Friendly staff. Be sure to order ahead and try the garlic knots!
Pizza was delicious and staff were very friendly, will Order again!
A pretty spectacular pizza. A little pricey but worth it.
Great find in sleepy Grimsby. Way more value and flavour than you get from the pizza chain joints close by.
Their food is awesome, the service is great and the people are great. If you want a creative pizza that tastes good all the way to the crust, Amici s is one of the better local pizza spots in Grimsby.
Disappointing experience
Friendly staff, fast service, amazing pizza! If you want any of these things Amici a is where you need to go.
Incredible staff, food is amazing, great experience. Pino and his staff are a blast to chat with and have been very accommodating to our orders. Simply the best pizzeria in town!
Best gourmet pizza shop in Grimsby, hands down. Locally owned and operated this a must try, if I might suggest the Dill pickle pizza...wow.
Hands down the best pizza and service around! We have been a repeat customer for years and Pino never disappoints.
Best pizza anywhere! Pino is a genius. Dill pickles on pizza! Love that! The Jay Jones, simple the best creation! Cant wait to order again. Chain restaurants dont taste anything like the quality of Amicis in Grimsby!
Amazing pizza and wings! Amicis is on our weekly menu (sometimes more than once)
Best pizza in town! My favourite is their pickle pizza. Always great service...Curb side pickup is super convenient.
Always a delight. Im from the falls and I will go out of my way to come to grimsby not only for the pizza but the dill pickle wings literally great service everytime too. Thank you!
Overall a pleasant experience, I tried their sweet bbq wings. Friendly staff and tasty food.
We ordered smoked BBQ wings and they were delicious! Such a friendly vibe and great service too! We shall order from them again! I can see why they get great reviews on wings. Theyre crispy and good amount of sauce spread on them and the flavour was perfecto
My boyfriend and I moved to town a little while ago and naturally everyone needs a go-to pizza place! Lets just say we wont be ordering from competitors again... Thanks for excellent service, excellent food made with love, and a treat during these unprecedented times. Well be back! (A lot )
Very good pizza and thin crust
Delicious! And great service on a busy Saturday night.
In live with their pizza!!!!!
Best pizza Ive had in a while without a doubt
Fantastic pizzas and fantastic service!
Very prompt and friendly service! We ordered the chicken and ribs meal, with an added extra rack. The food was absolutely delicious!! Best ribs we ever had. A great choice of family meals to choose from. Definitely ordering from them again!!
Just ate there for the first time and the wings and pizza were amazing Ill definitely be going there alot more
Best Pizza! You gotta try them!!! Super fresh. Tasty ingredients! Wings are a good size too! Loved the Caribbean jerk flavour. Reminded us of Jamaica!!! Pizza was amazing!! The dough was soo fresh and toppings on our meat lovers and Hawaiian were to die for. -Maldini was nothing but friendly and professional! We definitely will be back thanks so much for the excellent service and delicious food!! I have to say the new owners have taken over and done an amazing job keep up the great work guys!
Amazing pizza new owners are very inviting updated inside would count me as a returning customer
Pizza and wings were awesome! I highly recommend this place. New owners were nothing but friendly, welcoming and professional. Food was fresh we definitely will be coming back again! Thanks again
These new owners did an amazing job turning Amicis into a new and improved pizza place. I tried their pizza and wings yesterday and the pizza was cooked perfectly and was very flavourful. Also their wings were just simply fantastic! Especially the Smokey BBQ. Will definitely be going back there!
Simply The best! Highly addictive!
Had the schwarma other day. Was super good so I returned again to try the Gyro and my god was it ever good. Next time i will be trying their pizza and wings, but for sure that is my new spot for Gyros. Price is very good too. Definitely recommend
Gyro was
Delicious pizza. Shawarma is amazing. Hand made pita is tasty
Amazing! Just food coma yummy! And when the wedges were forgotten for the 17 yr old daughter, went back and got them right away. Awesome service, awesome food!
This was my first pizza experience in Grimsby and I m glad it was. Ordered the Greek and Veggie pizza and they were both absolutely delicious. I specifically liked the quality and quantity of the toppings. The Greek pizza was especially tasty. A must try!
Pizza was phenomenal and the staff fantastic
Best Gyro I ve had in a long time!
Split a gyro , shawarma and a panzarotti with wife. First we ate the Gyro wrap, it was huge for $7 and overflowing with delicious gyro meat! Next we had the shawarma , again tons of meat overflowing out of a custom type bread pocket, possibly made out of pizza dough, it was delicious. The meat was juicy. We thought we would be too full to enjoy the panzarotti, we were wrong! Also we had the new pizza recently and definitely recommend it as well. Amicis will definitely be our go to for shawarma and gyros in the area.
Best chicken shawarma and Gyro I ve ever had! Homemade bread. Definitely coming here again
We LOVE this place!!! New to the area and this place is on repeat almost every other week or when we have events. The wings are to die for, they have been a repeated order numerous times. The sauce is too delicious. And the pepperoni pizza is our favourite as well.
This was my absolute favourite pizza place when Pinot was there , hadn t been in awhile and didn t realize they changed . Ordered what I always did and was so excited meat lovers and there garlic sauce opened the box and knew it wasn t right, wasn t that signature crust. A more generic pizza now, so disappointed and was my favourite pizza! Miss the amazing garlic sauce as well. Nothing wrong with service or anything just not the same quality anymore reminds me of Ginos.
Amazing staff and I just LOVE the food! Prepare yourself for the Ultimate Shwarma Experience! Many thanks for your kind service...
Just tried this pizza for the first time since the new ownership. I ordered the gyro pizza and the shwarma pizza. They were both very good. The meat was tasty and fresh. Lots of toppings and sauce. The man that served me was very friendly. I will be going back there.
We got the medium chicken shawarma and gyro pizzas, and they were both amazing - very flavourful, perfectly cooked crust, and lots of toppings. The dipping sauce was amazing too. Best of all, the price was very reasonable, and given that two slices were filling enough, the value is great. Id definitely recommend giving it a try.
I head Amici s was under new ownership and checked out the menu online. I ll admit the shawarma and Gryo pizza had me intrigued. I ll also add tam hat their prices are great - our usual go to in town has increased prices and the quality has gone way down hill. Happy we tried this place out. Had people over and everyone raves about the Gyro pizza. We also had wings, the honey garlic where the hit, I m partial to the Smokey bbq. Everything was delicious, quality ingredients, no skimping on ingredients or sauces. The wings are lightly breaded, how I prefer them and the sauces were delicious. The staff was super friendly on the phone and when I went in to pick up my order. (Again, the other spot has been very short and messed up our orders recently.) Happy our party was a hot thanks to the food! Amici s we will be ordering again!
This time I tried, and I cried after being overwhelmed with the deep down deliciousness of their Shawarma Poutine. This is comfort food x 10. A real pandemic blues buster. These guys just make pure yummy for your tummy.
First time customer...really enjoyed their pizza! Fresh toppings you can taste and the staff was excellent. I am returning again and again...Bravo!
Probably the best shawarma wrap Ive ever had. Great price and friendly staff. Definitely will be back!
Amazing pizza and wings. Highly recommend to anyone looking for that ma and pa restaurant. Always reliable when your craving the perfect slice
The service is friendly, the place is clean and the pizza is delicious. I think its THE BEST PIZZA in Grimsby! Update: By now I had at least 10 different pizzas from Amici and every single one of them was delicious! I highly recommend this place
Ive never had anything like a dill pickle pizza! The owner and staff are so friendly. Hubby had the cool ranch wings and enjoyed those too.
I know its been said in other Google reviews of Amicis, but yes, quality ingredients make for a quality pizza. A+
Really good pizza. Friendly staff. Would definitely go back!
I had the pleasure of filming some video content for Amici s. Pino and Katie are wonderful people that make you feel right at home and they make some great pies. I love Amicis Pizza and wings!
Hands down Best Pizza in the Hamilton/Grimsby area. wish I could give it 10 starts not 5!!!! Keep up the great work Pino.
Best service and pizza in town! Huge fan
First time was AMAZING! Thank you!
Best pizza in Niagara. We order here to go quite often and the flavour and quality is always really good. Fast service also and the owners are very friendly. Our fave is the dill pickle pizza and their 3rd best wings which should really be 1st place.
Our family s favourite place to order wings and THE Jay Jones is a staple. Our family movie nights would not be the same without Amici.
Best pizza in hamilton
Great food, good customer service.
Best pizza in town, friendly staff and quick delivery!
PICKLE PIZZA Great pizza Friendly service
Excellent as usual! Best pizza and best owners and staff in town!!
Try the panzerotti!
Fantastic pizza and wonderful staff! Our go to for pizza in Grimsby.
Pinot and his crew make the best Pizzas, and wings. They have a great selection of toppings for your pizza. The deep fried pickles and cauliflower are amazing. But most importantly the staff are friendly helpful, and accomadting. We always leave with smile.
The wife loves the wings. Not a fan of the pizza...too much sauce, my toppings are always in the box when you grab a slice...every slice... Good cold
Great pizza with a great team. Small but entertaining area to eat in or just pick up. Creative menu and variety of pizza. The dill pickle pizza is a winner. Pino and his staff are a great crew.
Nice to have a few local restaurants in the area that arent big chains, and this is one Ive enjoyed for sure.
This local pizzeria has excellent food and amazing service. The price is great too! Fabulous experience.
Nice people..good service..good eats
We were passing through Grimsby and were craving pizza. We decided to order ahead and pick up but when we arrived we changed our mind so we sat in. Im so glad we did because the staff here is just as awesome as the food and the manager/owner checked up on us to make sure the food was good and was super friendly. There was singing to George Michael going on in the kitchen and the staff just seemed to all work well together. Well definitely visit again when were in the area. The pizza was delicious in case it needed to be said again. Thanks for the great service and food. P.S. Happy Endgame day!
Was great, the owner is a awesome guy and the pizza rocks
Had an absolute awsome experience! The owner was so nice, he even let me be a guinea pig on a new pizza creation. Thank You. Pizza here is phenomenal
Delicious food, fresh ingredients and lots of menu items to choose from. Top this off with friendly service makes this is a must try pizzeria.
Our pizza was awful.. first and last visit.
Best pizza in the whole Niagara Region!
Would highly suggest a party pizza. Great service
Really DELICIOUS PIZZA EXCEPT NEXT TIME MORE WELL DONE. PLEASE THIS IS FROM.PAPPA JACK VIA OAKVILLE NOW IN GRIMSBY.
Great pizza and sides. friendly owner and staff.
Great people and awesome customer service! The best pizza and wings around!!
Im not sure if they were having a bad night or what was going on but this was one of the most dissapointing pizzas Ive had. There was practicall no sauce or cheese, (as you can see by the photo, the slice almost looked bare!) The toppings were scarce and the dip was extremely watery. The staff were friendly and we enjoyed the wings but the pizza was hugely dissapointing
My order: 1 LG 2 topping ( pepperoni & bacon), 2lb wings (honey hot), fried pickels & 2 garlic dips. It came with an extra garlic dip, cheddar dip, blue cheese dip & carrots. Ordering- call for pickup oh, the gentleman who answered was very polite. Food. Pizza- plenty of toppings, sauce- 2 people like it how it was and another wanted more, cooked just how all 3 of us liked it. Wings- Saucy, not over cooked, great taste, good quality & medium size. Pickels- Great taste & perfectly fired Garlic Dip- Not the greatest but points for homemade. Good taste I just prefer otherones Ive had in the past Cheddar dip - Best one Ive had anywhere and I dont really like these. Blue cheese dip - I like this and Im not a fan of most blue cheeses Carrots - Fresh they seem like they are cut just before I pick them up A great pizza place with great service.
Best pizza in Grimsby by far. The crust is phenomenal, the sauce is second to none and the toppings are proportional to your pizza. No skimping on toppings here. Thanks as always for another great za!
Best pizza in Grimsby hands down! The owner and staff always make us feel at home. He treat you like family. Super great place and the pizza cant be beat!
Called to get information on some food. All the girl wanted was my # and my name! Not very helpful at all. Of course I gave that information. Never again.Very diapointed in the sevamce
The best pizza ever in Grimsby and Hamilton area..love it
Best pizza and wings around - the staff is just as amazing as the food!
Pino is an artist! Best pizza in town! Never dissapointed!!!
Bomb
High quality ingredients, amazing sauce and great pizza and wings!! Try their blueberry wings.. I know sounds weird but omg they are so good
Love it!
Super friendly place. Amazing wings too.
Great food options for my picky eaters! The owner is friendly and always smiling. He makes your pick up experience worth comin in. The pizza choices are amazing and they ll make it just the way you like it! Pastas are great along with the tasty wing choices. Usually like the medium or sweet BBQ, but glad I got talked into trying the dill pickle wings! They re delicious! Definitely will be back!
Incredible pizza. Amazing wings. And fantastic service. Only place in Niagara to get food. Also, if you love pasta, theyve got you covered. All round amazing Italian food and people ! 5 stars all round. Bravo!
I love the fresh pizzas, so many options and the owner is always trying something new. The chicken parm is my absolute favourite . The service is always friendly and nothing is too much trouble. A great family run pizzeria . No 1 pizzeria in town.
Amicis is our go-to place for pizza, wings and salad! The ingredients are always fresh and you can just taste the difference in the crust from the commercial chain pizzerias. Pino and Katie the owners are so kind and make you feel like family! LOVE AMICIS!! :)
Great food. The Dill Pickle (yes, really!) pizza was awesome. Excellent friendly owners too.
Best pizza in town
Pizza had no cheese crust sucked and wings were tasteless. For 40 dollars. Would not go back
After moving to Grimsby a number of years back we started ordering from various pizzerias in the area. After all, youve got to figure out who has the best pies in town, no? Our first phone order to Amicis we were greeted with an enthusiastic and exceptionally friendly voice that set the tone - but would the pizza match the service? While pizzas cant physically be enthusiastic or friendly per se, they managed to be metaphorically so from our mouths, to our gullets, and ultimately our stomachs. And the consistency - both service-wise and quality-of-food-wise has not diminished since. Theres simply never a question as to whom were going to order from when that pizza craving catches us - which is far too often I might add (and how dare you be so nosy as to question the frequency of our pie eating endeavors!). In all seriousness, our friends and family have always asked us where we got our pizza when theyve joined us. I couldnt imagine ordering from anywhere else.
Great wings and service.. The pizza is excellent!
Best pizza in the area. Very friendly staff.
Our favorite go to pizza place! Not your typical chain pizza. We ordered for a party and still have people ask us where we ordered from. Service is always cheerful!
First and last visit. One of the worst pizzas I ve ever had. Called in order for pick up, was told a half hour and still waited for an hour. Pizza had maybe one tablespoon of sauce at MOST! Manager angry and yelling at staff. Don t know how this place gets so many five stars...you people have no clue what GOOD pizza tastes like....it sure ain t this place. STAY AWAY!!!
Always delicious! Started going here a few years ago . Wont buy my pizza anywhere else. Friendly polite staff. Great food. Good prices!
Best pizza around....and its not close. Everything you could ask for. Friendly, honest, and amazing food. A refreshing experience to say the least. Will be back, over and over and over and over and over again.
Not a lot to say. Fantastic pizza. Fair prices. Super nice folks.
We love Amicis! Our family Friday night tradition is their pizza, wings & cheesy garlic bread. Their pepperoni pizza is my favourite ever! We also love their new dill pickle wings. SO GOOD!
First local pizza we had after moving here ten years ago, and it just keeps getting better. Great owner with really creative ideas. Must read menu!
Friendly staff good food
Great pizza from great people