Formerly Tony's in Lindsay

Best pizza ever! Its fresh and made with love!

One word delicious

Da bomb best pizza in town

Great price . Giant slices . Good food

It was a decent pizza. I found the crust a bit hard but that could just be my preference. We ordered two medium two topping pizza was $48 with 4 dips and 4 pop.

Wad told it was the best pizza in town. No argument here!!

There are far too many pizza places in Lindsay and everyone has pizza preference. For the most part, Formerly Tonys is my first choice for pizza. It is my opinion that their pizzas simply taste like they use better quality ingredients. Many of the chain pizza places have had the quality of their pizzas slide, probably cutting corners to save money. I can honestly say, Ive never had bad food from Formerly Tonys. Parking: The parking lot at Formerly Tonys is fairly small. Wheelchair accessibility: Unless they have an accessible entrance I dont know about, this location is not wheelchair accessible as there are a few stairs to get into the front entrance.

Best Pickle Pizza EVER!!!

Classic pizza joint, just like Tonys but not quite.

Food and service is great but I do find their prices to be quite a bit higher than other pizza options in Lindsay. Dill pickle pizza is yummy, but it is a bit higher in price.

Thank you.

Stop what you are doing forget about dinner and get some fried panzos....theyre maybe the best thing ever Dont be shy of the pickles either.. Food

Great pizza and wings!

Great staff, great food, worth the price, and they always have good deals and specials for bulk orders

Ordered an Extra Large Pepperoni pizza earlier in the day for 6:15 pm and it was ready right on time and delicious!

It all disappeared in a hurry!

Was not disappointed at all. Great pizza and wings, cooked to perfection.

When will you open in time for ordering our pizzas?

Wish the website was more clear as to when relocated restaurant was opening

I bought a double cheese medium walk-in pizza and I wont order a pie from here again. More expensive than the best pie in town (a med. double cheese is over $20 here) and very little to no sauce. No wonder they questioned me twice on the dipping sauce...

The new location is very nice.

Picked up two small pizzas this evening. The ingredients were very light. Didn t like the crust very chewy. Very little flavour.

Great pizza!!!

Puzza was good

Great food, great service. Highly recommend

Kid-friendliness: Its pizzia Food

Great Pizza in Linday ! Since Dunsford Pizza closed, there hasnt been a solid Pizza available for us on the East side. This has all changed now with Formwrly Tonys!. Great pies, excellent toppings, perfect crust... yummm

Excellent service, excellent food! Staff are extremely friendly and accommodating, even carried my food to my car, which is so very much appreciated. Great job Formally Tonys.!! Parking: No issues, the parking lot was busy but lots of space available.

Pepperoni slice was quite large and tasted very good . Excellent value.

Always great pizza! Best deal in town on slices

I would absolutely recommend this spot!!!!

Bought two family combos for birthday celebration meal. Average quality. Above average price.

As always great tasting pizza!

Staff was very friendly. Highly recommended

Best pizza in town! The only place we eat from!!

Absolutely love these guys tonight my child on the spectrum ordered for the first time and like always staff was super polite

So this place is absolutely awesome in not only customer service but quality of food. We had to recharge our electric vehicle at the community sports Centre and thought we could just go to a restaurant while it was charging but there was nothing around so they actually delivered right to the charging station and the pizza is phenomenal and the service we got was just incredibly exceptional. I would highly recommend this place to anybody who is either in Lindsay or travelling through Lindsay Ontario

Best pizza in town

We were told we HAD to try the pizza when we moved in to the area. Have never been disappointed. We have tried many things on the menu now, all is delicious. The workers are kind and have gone above and beyond for us in the past. Would highly recommend to everyone!

Best pizza and best wings

Not from the area but stopped to get a slice and holy definitely top of the list for me, they serve a big slice and it s really 10/10 taste, not greasy or anything

Tried for the first time as we just moved to Lindsay. Had the Deluxe & medium wings, delicious!

Very good pizza! The crust was really good (good level of crunch without being too hard). Got the TexMex pizza which was really good, although very spicy (I guess my spice tolerance isn t as high as I thought). Would definitely go back!

Pizza is okay but defiantly got expensive 6$ for a slice. I didnt find it overly special. I know their slices are super large and I didnt finish it. If be intrested in cheaper slices with a little less pizza for a lunch option.

Loved it! We called up for delivery tonight and were very impressed with the taste and service. Would absolutely order from here again

Pretty decent, but super pricey. Like to support local, but bought 3 slices and it cost twice as much as the competitors large walk in. When its delicious, its delicious. Woo!

Great wings!!

Best pizza. The woman that runs the place is so personable and also professional. Recommend their dill pickle pizza to everyone I know.

If you are in Lindsay, check out this place!!! Pizza is perfect and the wings are delicious also.

Best pizza I ve had in awhile! Great sauce, dough and toppings. Fast and efficient service. Wings were good too. I think everyone should grab a pizza from here on their way up to the cottage.

Very good pizza & wings

Pick up store only, no seating. Staff was pleasant enough but only one person ran the front and kept me waiting while she took a call. Pizza was OK. Better than frozen but not very interesting. Needed more sauce. The cheese didnt add any flavour. At least they used real bacon and not the crumble. This pizza was the better after a day type. The leftovers tasted better the next day. The sauce and the mushrooms were more pronounced and the crust didnt dry out and harden like other crusts.

Best pizza place in Lindsay no question.

Great service and food. Very affordable

We are new to the area and were struggling to find a pizza place that we enjoyed. We were blown away by the food and the friendly staff at Tonys Best. Both the salad and pizza were amazing, we will be ordering again

Great pizza every time!! Owner and his staff are hardworking and very pleasant

The pizza is super awesome and the Desert pizza is something super unique and a must try.

Amazing pizza!

Fresh hot and perfect pizza. Always a smart choice.

Excellent food and even better people

Boated in from out of town. Had these guys deliver a huge combo to the dock side. Some of the best wings I have ever had. And thats as a large man that enjoys his wings. Great staff very accommodating to us. Pizza was great wings were great. 100 percent recommend all day.

We were driving through Lindsay and placed an order for pick-up...we werent sure what to expect but the pizza was AMAZING. Friendly service as well! Well be back for sure.

Probably the best pizza I have ever had. Would legitimately come back to Lindsay just for the pizza here. Great staff.

Love the pizza. go there every week. highly recommend

Both pizzas were amazing, but the pickle pizza will have us making that 20 minute detour again!

Was good not great. Toppings and thin crust was good. Not a fan of the sauce. Good Pizza for the money.

15 bucks for a small one topping pizza aahahahahahaha what a bunch of donkeys.

Over priced greasy mess. Head over to somewhere else.

Definitely the best! Sauce has just the right amount of flavour so as to not overpower the other toppings. And the crust could stand on its own for texture and flavour!

Tonys pizza is our favourite pizza place in town!! When we first moved here it was the only place that would deliver to us (outskirts of Lindsay), and thank god for that because they are easily the best pizza around. Now it doesnt matter that other places will deliver to us, cause were still choosing Tonys!

Food is amazing. Never been diapointed

Excellent food, amazing service. Very great prices and the staff were so friendly.

Greg is always working hard. The Pizza is delicious. Highly recommend

Very good

Really good food.

Great great pizza

Wow. Excellent Food. Excellent Service. Excellent Price! Thank you

Hands down the best wings I ve ever tasted!!! Please order from here, you ll love it.

We order Tonys Pizza and Wings every Friday, the best pizza and wings we have ever had. Always hot and tasty highly recommended yum

Okay Pizza and really great Wings. I have stopped going recently because they arent putting much sauce on the wings which is too bad because they were my favorite wings.

4.5 very good

I had finally tried Tonys today as I follow them on facebook and was wanting a change. My family and myself were blown away at how good everything was. The amount you get and the quality of the products are amazing! Everyone said we have to order from here from now on. It was great! Thank you!

Best pizza and wings!

One of the only things I miss about living in KL

Their pizza is the best around, the new owners are just like the last. Very friendly, they care about their clients, and go above and beyond to make sure you are happy with your pizza and wings. They also have a Facebook group, and do giveaways. Nice touch, love this place. If your in the area, and need a nice hot pizza, one slice is about $5 but it comes with three slices! Love it!!

Great pizza, fantastic prices. Love this place.

This place is so good, my only regret is not trying it sooner!

Lindsay only great pizza and wings. The rest r just fast food.

Great pizza a little pricey but way better than most

Best thin crust pizza lve had in a long time.

Greaaaat pizza

Actually a good pizza. I got the meatlovers add feta and fresh garlic really enjoyed. Funny thing though ive never seen a pizza cut so poorly. If my friends worked there I would have thought it was a prank. Obviously didnt ruin the meal but it was ridiculous looking .

I had a Hawaiian by-the-slice, it was delicious but also a HUGE slice. Great taste & value!

Yesterday the lady serving came out of the store waving her arms trying to accuse us of stealing chilli flakes! Give your head a shake lady. I Usually come in for a slice, now i will be going else where.

Best pizza and wings ever! Can be a little pricey depending on what or how much you get.

Excellent pizza and fantastic deals on slices! You get half a pizza for just over 5 bucks! Good variety and friendly staff. One of those places you may drive by a million times - but once you have eaten there once you will not stop!

Great wings, great pizza...Great staff

Ordered the hawaiian and canadian pizzas, honey garlic and barbacue wings. Excellent taste! We all enjoyed them! Thank you for delicious pizzas and wings. Highly recommend.

We are from out of town best pizza we had in awhile cant get pizza like that from anywhere in our area we are about 2hours east wondering if they would delever to where we are

Big thanks to the staff at Tonys for helping us get some tasty pizza to our clients! These guys were super helpful and actually delivered!

Love their pizza. Always cooked to perfection and the staff are always friendly

Its too bad I live so far away from Lindsay, because this is the best hidden Little Treasure Pizzeria Ive been to in what feels like ages. I only ordered a simple pepperoni and within a few short minutes I walked out with it and was not disappointed. Though all may not share my same taste, I like a pizza with a delicious sauce and a good crunch to its crust and not burnt.

By far , the best wings I ve ever had!! Seriously good

Im from Montreal living in Brampton. This is the best Pizza in Ontario that Ive had. This is a gem for pizza. Believe I know my pizza coming from Mtl. I will be going back when I visit Lindsay again one day.

Really really good pizza. Customer service was excellent. A must try for passers by.

Pizza is amazing! slices are HUGE!!!!! Its a place i try to once a week. Super friendly staff!

Very good pizza 10/10 amazing wow cooked to perfection!

Honestly the best pizza and wings in town! Big slices. Amazing made in front of you pizza and the best honey garlic wings!

Rude management and under cooked food

Good pizza, great wings!

Local owners who care to make quality pizza.

Awesome pizza, pleasant staff and no waiting

Hands down the best pizza in the Kawarthas!

I ordered from Tonys for the 1st time a few days ago---- very, very polite service on the phone...pizzas were at my door in 40mins....delivery guy was fantastic.....and the pizzas were great. Tonys is now my go to spot for pizza. ( a few bucks more than the big name pizza franchises but worth it)

i love there pizza all away hot when there come to your door

The best wings and garlic bread in lindsay

Best pizza around always great food and service highly recommend

Best pizza and wings in the Kawarthas and excellent service

Id consider myself a pizza connoisseur, and I can honestly admit that this pizza was the best Ive ever had. Personalize your pizza with extra garlic butter, thick or thin crust, load it with sauce or hold the sauce, these guysll do any thing ya need. Or just throw a dart at the menu and enjoy the masterpiece thats crafted for you! TONYS PIZZA RULES

Great pizza

My favorite pizza place. Better pizza than I can find in Toronto.

Tasty fast and friendly

Hands Down the Best Pizza in Town! Greg and Constance (and their Team) are the absolute best. They provide the best service and the absolute best pizza, wings and Cesar salad (seriously, try it) in town. We look forward to our weekly treat and the chance to catch up with them.

Best pizza around!!!! Sooooooo delicious

Great tasting pizza!

Amazing pizza!!! Right on par with my favorite place in ptbo. Would definitely recommend.

This was my first time trying Tonys Best Pizza & Wings in Lindsay tonight and the quality was impressive to say the least! Not only was my pizza and garlic bread particularly well done, but I was also impressed with the work ethic, attention to detail and precautions for food safety that were taken even when things got busy. Greg Andrews, one of the co-owners of this place, definitely showed that he cares about his food, workmanship and the service he provides his customers. Would definitely recommend this place to others based on this experience!

Great pizza and wings Well worth the wait I will say!!!

They also have the best ice cream, took my Grandkids there and they loved it!!

Rude staff. Pulled in behind the delivery driver as there was a truck taking 2 spots and construction equipment on his other side With children playing in the little space the was. Driver came out and yelled at me to move. I tell him im just waiting for food. He continues to yell saying he needs to make a delivery and gets in his car. When I go in to pay a female staff attempts to apologize however cops an attitude when I gave feedback. I ended up leaving without my food. Unfortunate as this was my first time there. So no clue about the food but will never give my coin to an unprofessional establishment. My response to your response. Please understand I pulled into the space not occupied by children or a giant pick up truck. I would have had no issue moving but your drivers so called urgent request was rude. Then when I came in and approached the female staff about it she began to state she would talk to him but the conversation clearly did not go well as she was intent on defending her driver. Ok. Thats fine. When I note that both he and she were angry and the way I had been spoken to was unacceptable it became heated, you acknowledged you were angry and I unfortunately left as I was no longer comfortable purchasing from you. Good luck in your business.

This place was not even close to as good as people made it sound. The staff where barely personable. Let alone polite. The prices are so high you expect the best of the best. The pizza was nothing special very light on the sauce and toppings. No flavour to it at all. The only reason Im giving a 2 star rating as that the wings tastes great. But I only got like 5 wings for a pound of wings and they werent big wings. So needless to say I probably wont be back again. Ive since been back cause the wings where so good. And the wings are awesome pizza is still okay nothing special.

We go there often for the past year. Always good product and great staff. Was there tonight and recieved a free slice courtesy of a previous customer. If you read this, free pizza slice guy, I want to say thank you.

This place is awsome. Great pizza not bad price they do deliver a good distance. Service is awsome

Great family run pizza joint!!!!

5$ for and enormous slice of pie, cant go wrong with that.

Tasty pizza. All your pizza essentials done right. I really enjoyed the crust and sauce.

Holdin pizza tight yall!

Great pizza brought me back to the good old days of living in Italy

I thought the pizza I ordered was really good and the delivery dude was nice. But this place charges $3 almost $4 for delivery charge for like about a 2 minute drive away. Thats just ridiculous...

Great pizza! And absolutely fantastic wings and garlic bread. But its a expensive otherwise I would eat there more.

The best pizza ever!!!!

Consistantly fantastic pizza and wings!

cheap deals delicious pizza

Good pizza and awesome wings!

Really good pizza

Super friendly staff. Great pizza every time wow Its always first choice for us!!.

From the reviews, Tony s was a total letdown. Actually the worst pizza I have ever eaten in my life. It tasted like cardboard.

Great Food

My only complain with Tony s was not being open Sunday so I phoned and asked why. Little did I know that family comes before business here. That earns my respect. Service second to none on delivery even tho when you make the best zaa in town, yer gonna be busy at peak times. My late father s Friday night meal thrill!

Best pizza in town, hands down. High quality, fresh ingredients and good dough make for a great tasting pizza. Dont confuse them with typical chain pizza delivery restaurants, Tonys is in a category of their own.

The Best Pizza in Lindsay, Great staff, always enjoy going in and having a laugh while I wait.

Meh, Pretty expensive . Not bad but not great

They would deliver to British Columbia I think. Good Pizza, not the best prices, but you arent eating garbage. You get what you pay for.

Definately one of the nicest guys I have come across in a long time..The food is great and a slice is MASSIVE..Would recommend highly to stop in a give it a try!! Thanks Andy..