Old Stone Farmhouse in Lovenlund

Lovely meal, and service.

The staff here are amazing and so is the food! I took my kids to eat here during our vacation. They all loved the food including the appetizers we ordered. This place isnt cheap, but its well worth the price! You cant find food this good just anywhere.

Big hint: drive until you get between 2 buildings and wait for valet. This is the only way. There is no parking before that. The valet was not there when I got there and didnt know what to do and then a car came up and I had to reverse to give them room. It isnt ideal, but everything else about your evening will be I had the filet and it was done perfectly. She had Sea Bass and the many flavors and textures flawlessly went together. Extensive wine and bar selection. As many appetizer options as entrees. Entrees are between $40 to $75. Plan on spending $100 per person and have a wonderful evening. I called in the reservation about an hour prior on a Saturday night for two. Sat at a quiet table in the corner. Cool architecture. I wish I could have walked around to look more but didnt feel that was welcome. Service was very attentive. On the intrusive side. You will get top quality food on the island here. Price is worth the quality. Dress up if you want to

Loved it! Delicious! If they are offering the surf and turf, GET IT!!!!!!!

Amazing, fresh food! One of the best restaurants on the island. The surf and turf is the perfect dinner for two.

Enjoyed a very good dinner. Beautiful old stone house.

Beautiful place, amazing inside. Food is so tasty. But need reservation

Excellent food & drinks. Great service

Food was spectacular

Very good. Cool stone vibe and high quality service and cocktail.

My husband and I had dinner here during our stay in St. Thomas and it was great. The food and wine were good, but I mostly enjoyed the atmosphere.

While the food was good and the chefs effort shone through, the service made this an awful experience. The first waiter was talking down to us. The second complained about her ~$40 tip quite vociferously. My friend was paying the bill so she effectively embarrassed him in front of his friends.... a real no-no in my view. When I realized he was already giving a 10% tip on what had been a poor service experience, I did not feel badly about what hed tipped, but the waitperson had the sense of entitlement and gall to complain about that left me with a very poor impression of this establishment. Maybe staff is not paid well, maybe they are not trained, but gratuities are voluntary and based on the guests service experience, and the tip left was appropriate for an awful experience. I felt terrible for my friend. Parking: Difficult to find the parking (you have to continue around the restaurant)

Great atmosphere, very pleasant staff. Not a fan of Valet but on this small island having to not park was a welcome relief. I had the Tuna which was magnificent and the parsnip chips were on point, my wife had the sea bass and said that was amazing also

Our experience was lovely. Great food and a memorable atmosphere. The food was delicious.

Excellent food. Great atmosphere. Highly recommend eating at this excellent location. Be prepared to spend a pretty penny but it is worth it.

Everything was amazing!!!!!! From the valet to the waiter to the food I cant believe we stumbled on this place just from driving around . The best meal Ive ever had ...period!! The steak was done perfectly the lobster tail was totally worth it . It was her 30th and first time in st Thomas, i had to make resevations very glad I did Be sure to check this place out and indulge in all they have to offer its a lil pricey but again.... WORTH IT

Delicious dinner and excellent service. Thoroughly enjoyed the surf and turf dinner, as well as swordfish and sea bass. Can t wait to return next year!

So happy to have found this place! The food, service and atmosphere were incredible. My husband and I enjoyed our time and will definitely be back

This is an incredible restaurant in so many ways. We went for a later dinner, and the soft lighting on the old stone and brick walls and arches was stunning. It is a gorgeous setting. The service was impeccable and everything I ate was absolutely delicious. I had the Farmhouse salad to start, which was a perfect balance of ingredients with a very tasty dressing. For my main dish I had the Pan Seared Sea Bass, which I think is quite possibly one of the best plates of food I have ever eaten! I ate every bite which didnt leave much room for dessert, but I couldnt resist sharing the mango creme brûlée (which was amazing as well). Over all it was a magical evening!

We celebrated my boyfriends birthday. Best restaurant, service, food, drinks, and atmosphere!!

Delicious Food with very attentive service in a superb 300+ year old venue.

Atmosphere, food, service...5 stars all the way. We got to experience dinner and brunch here. Both amazing.

We visited with our 5 & 3 year old. Service was slow but it was busy so that s okay. The issue was when my 3 year old was crying, as most toddlers do, the host/owner came over and asked if everything was okay. Initially I thought she was just checking on her until she said it s a disturbance to other customers and we should take her on a walk. Children will do what children do and she essentially asked us to leave because our toddler was being a toddler. It was at the very end of our brunch service and was extremely rude and unprofessional. Needless to say, we will not be returning. Such a disappointment! Kid-friendliness: This is not a kid friendly restaurant.

We came with a group of 7 and wow is an understatement. I ordered the surf & turf and it was amazing. Jimmy, our server was on point. We all agreed it was one of the best meals we have ever had and thats saying alot as we are world travelers. Highly recommended!

We loved EVERY aspect of this place, the food, the ambience, the wine selection, the service - literally everything - I would 6 star this if I could!! The grounds we quiet and elegant yet had the old rustic charm befitting of its age. I have a tendency to review things I loved and this would be one of them. We are planning on being back very soon and without a doubt we will be coming here for dinner again. Had we planned ahead of time and could have pulled it off multiple nights - we would have.

Me and my wife Made a dinner reservation for her birthday. We went and had our dinner It looked like the server wasnt informed about the occasion or she didnt care because we didnt even get a candle on our dessert. After we let the server know the occasion she just brought a candle in the glass, felt disrespected I didnt expect such a behavior from a restaurant which has a good reputation like this it was very disappointing

Party of 8 and absolutely the best service and best food all of us have had on the island and we ve been coming for a long time. 15+ years. Gorgeous building and loved the open air rustic but elegant vibe! Thank you so much OSFH for a wonderful experience .

Just had a great dinner.The night was wonderful great service and the food was awesome

You cannot miss the opportunity to dine in such a wonderful restaurant. Cocktails of prefection... brunch was excellent! Variety and creativity abound. The staff were friendly and oh so attentive. Looking around at those at other tables, you can see that everyone feels theyre dining in a special place. Thats how we felt.

Great food, service and ambience.

A truly outstanding dining experience from start to finish. Every bite was delicious. The staff are attentive and knowledgeable. You can t find a more beautiful atmosphere. You may want to bring a little bug spray for your ankles if you eat after dark. This has to be the finest dining on the island. Menu from our Feb 2024 visit is attached.

A little bit out of the way but well worth the visit. Food and service were all very good; however the menu is a bit limited which is why I gave this restaurant 4 stars overall (5 for food, service, and atmosphere).

My tuna was cooked PERFECTLY (rare)! The lobster tail was phenomena! We will definitely be back. Great service and the atmosphere is quaint. 10/10 recommend. Don t waste your time with Oceana if you are deciding between the two.

By far the nicest restaurant on the island!

We stayed at The Ritz Carleton and had dinner at all there restaurants they should eat here to see what the best tastes like. If you travel to St. Thomas dont miss dinner here. Great place a little tough to get to. Valet parking. The staff here is friendly and welcoming. Bar has a great selection of top shelf choices. We Ordered the Sea Bass with a lobster cream sauce fresh wild mushrooms and spinach. It was the best my wife and I ever had anywhere.

By far the best restaurant weve been to in St. Thomas! The food was decadent and the flavor profiles were fantastic! The service Jimmy provided was phenomenal, hats off to him. The atmosphere was delightful, the stonework is original from the 1650s which enhanced the dining experience! The Old Stone Farmhouse is a must! Cant wait to go back.

Very neat old farmhouse to eat in. Nicest place we have been to on St Thomas. The new chef was able to make my meal Gluten-free with a few adjustments to my meal. Highly recommend. The gentlemen doing the valet parking was on it. Remembering our car without us saying a word.

Best restaurant in St. Thomas ! My husband and I love it. Last night I had the best duck ever. Our waiter was right, I will never had duck like that before. That means I will have to come back often to paradise

Excellent atmosphere with good drinks and service. I found the food lacking in flavor and definitely needed the provided sauces to make up for it, which is disappointing given the price point.

Amazingly awesome service the staff is phenomenal! The food even better! Try the filet mignon and lobster, oooh and the seafood chowder is easily the best we have ever had. Skip the salads go big or go home

Fanciest place in town. Highly recommended.

They accepted our reservation late and still delivered exquisite service!

My wife and I enjoyed our experience very much. We had the surf and turf special for 2 and it was amazing. The deserts were also amazing. I would highly recommend going there at least once while you re on the island. Parking: The valet parking was a very nice touch

Beautiful ambiance, delicious food, and outstanding service from Jimmy. Thank you for a wonderful evening.

Best meal on the island! The atmosphere and the food are amazing. Try to get a table with Jimmy if you can.

Jimmy took great care of us and the food and drinks were delicious.

Great meal and experience. Service was excellent, from the floor manager to our server, busser, and even the valet. Never felt rushed and was never too noisy to converse.

Sunday brunch is out of this world.. I ll never forget the atmosphere, how great the service was and the food was absolutely mind blowing full of flavors, thinking about it makes my mouth drool

Great food and great drinks.

Great food! Service was superb

Nice ambiance

Everuthing is close to perfection Im still at dinner and stopped to give a review. This place is top notch

This place by far was our best meal during our visit. We had the surf and turf special and the Lobster was cooked to perfection as well as the boneless ribeye steak. The place is hard to find and recommend taking a taxi.

We had a wonderful Sunday brunch at Old Stone Farmhouse. The overall atmosphere, food, and service were impeccable. Our waiter Jimmy was especially attentive, courteous, and friendly. We didnt have to ask for really anything, as he was always a step ahead of us. A true professional! We highly recommend Old Stone Farmhouse. The bottomless Prosecco wine was awesome. See you soon!

Brunch was good. The customer service was welcoming. The food I got was fresh and tasty. However, the dining area was too warm. It would have been more comfortable if it was cooler. Vegetarian options: A few vegetarian options. Kid-friendliness: Seems to be a children-friendly place.

Wow! I can t speak highly enough of this spot. By far the best dinner we had in St. Thomas, especially of the higher end places. To start, Coco and the team were on point making sure our large group always had water and other drinks, making sure our questions were answered, and making sure the newly wed couple had an amazing wedding dinner! Thank you Coco & Co!! For drinks and food, I started off with the Paul Sutton Old Fashioned which I really enjoyed. Simple and straight forward and delicious. For the appetizer, we shared a Lobster Cargot which was well balanced and tasty. For the main meal, I had the Grass Fed Filet Mignon and my wife had the Grilled Atlantic Salmon. Both were great dishes! Hard to pick a favorite but I really enjoyed mixing it a bit and dipping my filet in the Hollandaise sauce that came with the salmon. Fun crossover! To top it all off, I finished the evening with their Apple Crisp which was well balanced with the scoop of vanilla ice cream. Thank you for a great experience!! Will be back when we visit St. Thomas in the future

A hidden gem in St. Thomas. Warm & welcome greeting. Ambiance is perfect for date night or an evening with the family. The service was outstanding, the food was delicious and the dessert was to die for. Wow! Food

Food was delicious ans service was exceptional. A must try restaurant in ST. Thomas.

Always such a lovely dining experience here! The staff is so welcoming & attentive, the food is always spot on, the atmosphere is so uniquely elegant. We love it here! Highly recommend for a nice white table cloth meal-- be sure to call ahead to make reservations! It can get booked up! We also love that they have a valet option!

Wonderful restaurant near Magens Bay, great brunch and dinners. Beautiful interior in an old stone farmhouse, with attractive patio seating for brunch.

I hate having to write this review because the service and ambience were great but it must be said. I ate here on 8/25/23 in celebration of a wedding taking place the next day. I ordered the tuna. I ended up getting severely ill early the very next day. I ll spare you the details. I was very close to missing the wedding. I didn t fully recover until today, 3 days later. I really hope an employee or manager sees this review. Please be careful with the storage, preparation and handling of the seafood and meat that you serve.

I cant understand why this place is closed doing the off season. We came here to St.thomas on our 30th anniversary in September for a reason. Be able to enjoy the island, food, people without the hassle of crowds. It really puzzles me that a place like this would even consider closing doing the socall off season.

The food and atmosphere are top notched. The service is first class. This is more than dinner, it s an experience. Highly recommend.

Our dining experience at the Old Stone Farmhouse was the best! Barb welcomed us with a warm professional smile. We enjoyed Coco s professional, efficient service. Our food was amazing, cooked to perfection and delicious from the lobster bisque, Roquefort cheesecake, to the phenomenal surf & turf special! Our dining experience at the Old Stone Farmhouse was our best dining experience on St. Thomas.

This is a beautifully restored and renovated old farm house. It s made of beautiful stone and is more like a piece of art. It s surrounded by trees in a rustic setting. You feel like you have stepped into a jungle oasis. There is indoor and outdoor dining and a bar area. The food is excellent, service is excellent, and the atmosphere is beautiful. They have a great wine list. If you want something different and want to get away from it all, this place is just what you will like.

Excellent night at the Old Stone Farmhouse. Everything was wonderful.

Pricey, delicious food, courteous waiters. We were driving along and saw the sign for sunday brunch, thought we d give this place a try. The place itself is beautiful. We had the french toast and curry tofu scramble. The french toast was one of the best Ive had and the curry tofu was also good. Bill came upto $50 for two people ( we did not get any drinks or dessert). They also had valet service. Nick our waiter was great.

What an amazing night. Barb our host was gracious and inviting. Mac the bartender made us some fabulous cocktails. Coco our waitress was fun and attentive and the chefs did an incredible job with our meals. This will be a must stop Every time we get to the island.

Gorgeous grounds and building. The staff was wonderful and the food okay of the price.

One of the fancier places on the island. The food was good, though not amazing, but the dining room is a really nice and perfect for a romantic occasion. Note that it was quite expensive though. Id recommend it and give it 4*.

Amazing brunch!

The staff here went above and beyond for our dinner here. They even gifted us a bottle of our favorite wine as a congratulations for my upcoming wedding. Was so surprised when they brought out this super cute congratulations I ve cream! Cannot recommended more highly if you re in St. Thomas.

The setting and food are amazing. Just a little pricey, but worth it. Waiting for a cab can be an issue when you leave.

2nd time visiting this restaurant and 2nd time falling in love with it. Ms. Barbara, thank you for allowing us to feel so welcomed and appreciated to be there. Our attendant Kyle, I believe, was wonderful, attentive and didnt miss a beat. Congratulations on the ability to have staff work with such diligence. Looks like an awesome work culture. We plan to return again, and for the record I HIGHLY Recommend this restaurant.

Spent $285 on meal with wife. Meal itself was top notch but the $70 lobster tail (12oz) was more like a $30 Red Lobster Restaurant. So definitely worth going to but forget the lobster.

I really wanted this to be a five star review because this place has everything except our meal was not hot. It s an absolutely gorgeous building and our waiter was great (Nick) but we were extremely disappointed with brunch. My fiancé and I both ordered the Lobster Benedict. It came with home fries that were a sad sparse luke warm and limp with grease portion doused heavily and unnecessarily with Old Bay and a not quite ripe watermelon slice. With all of the local fruits available that was just an insult. I was picking an abundance of passion fruit off of a friend s vine just two weeks ago and there s a mango tree loaded with fruit down the road from us, not to mention real bananas (figs) are literally everywhere, but I digress. The Benedict itself again was not hot, and the muffin was more like bread and not that wonderful toasted on the outside and chewy tender on the inside you would expect. In fact I don t think it was toasted at all. Maybe lightly. Very lightly. The tiny piece of lobster they put on each muffin did not warrant the $28 price at all ($150 total bill - two entrees, drinks, and one dessert). My eggs were not as runny as I would have liked either. Neither of us is the sort to send a plate back but now I wish I had, or at least spoken up. To end on a positive note, I will say that his Bloody Mary was very good, the piece of key lime pie we split was excellent, and the valet was on top of things. Having said all of that we will go back to give it one more try. The place has great reviews and I hate that we did not have a great experience.

The Sunday Brunch is the Best! From the food to the customer service, its worth the visit! I would recommend Old Stone Farmhouse to anyone. Its my favorite place to go for brunch!

All I can say is if you go anywhere for dinner this should be your first stop. I am married to a 5 star Chef. With that being said Chef Justin totally impressed me. Accolades to him!! The ambiance, to the bartender Mack who is an amazing bartender!! Appetizers, main course Ribeye,lobster,Brussel sprouts, mashed potatoes with truffle butter and homemade hollandaise. Everything cooked to perfection. On to dessert chocolate moose incredible light and airy and when you turn your spoon over it stays there. Perfection.. We will return again and again!! When you can impress a 5 star Chef that speaks volumes kiddos!

Dinner was amazing. All of our dishes were great. The waiter was attentive and the atmosphere wonderful. Would definitely recommend!

Old Stone Farmhouse knocked it out of the park. Started with an incredible appetizer, the Scallops St Jacques, but the star of the show were the two fish entrées we got: sole meunière, served in a sea of butter, with the sole cooked to complete perfection, and then interrupted with the brightness of capers and the crunchy hericot verts, and then the locally caught yellowfin steak. Oh what a dish. A perfectly seared rare to medium rare, it came stop a bed of mashed potatoes and a delightful velout sauce, but the standout was the roasted cloves of garlic and the mushrooms. Wow. Inventive, surprising, and just worked on all fronts. A true delight. Add to that a fantastic server named Nick, who balanced us alongside a 12 top flawlessly, and just, wow. Pitch perfect, and one of the better meals weve had, here or anywhere. Couldnt be happier. Oh, and the bread and butter was ridiculously good and came in handy for sopping up the various sauces! Highly recommend!

Great service and fantastic food.

best on the Island, just do it and go!

What a beautiful location! Had the Oyster Rockefeller app, Sole and tuna entrees, Key lime and creme bulee desserts. Yum yum!

From the time we walked and sat at the bar, service to drinks to food were excellent!! Would definitely recommend to anyone vacationing in St. Thomas!

Outstanding food and service. Couldnt have been more impressed.

We were staying in an AirBnB very close to this restaurant and decided to eat here. It was amazing from the food to the employees. 100%, everything was top notch and better than we have ever experienced. I took pictures of almost everything we ordered because they were that beautiful. If you are interested in a fine dinning experience on St.Thomas this is a must!

Parking: Valet

Absolutely stunning restaurant! Beautiful space and lovely dishes. I enjoyed the butterscotch martini, which is as delightful as it sounds. For an appetizer we shared the Steamed Mussels which were delicious. We chose the fish special, butterflied Branzino, as our entree and absolutely loved it. The staff was friendly and our experience was the special night out we had hoped for.

I have lived here in St. Thomas 27 years. We have frequented the Old Stone Farmhouse many times. The food is delicious. Today, I had to pour my own sparkling water. The French 75s tasted just like Mimosas, not with fine cognac and Grand Marnier. The Hostess insulted us, twice, the waiter, Sandy, charged 20% automatically for less than stellar service. Bye Bye.

Exceptional food and service!

We had our wedding dinner here and it was OUT OF THIS WORLD AMAZING. A truly breathtaking dinner. We had the steak and lobster board and it was a dinner I will never forget. The vibe of the restaurant is so relaxing and ambient with the stone house Asthetic and rustic decor. Service is flawless. There is just not a bad thing you can say about this place.

Great dinner out on our Honeymoon. The service was great and the food was even better. The mussels and scallops were prepared beautifully. It was a little far of a drive from the hotel but it was worth it.

Excellent!

This restaurant should be at the top of the list for ambiance, food, and atmosphere. After a horrendous time at another restaurant, I called and scored a reservation. The drive away from the touristy area and into the upper area of the island was nice. The parking isnt the greatest for self parking but there is valet parking which I assumed was paid but was no (make sure to carry cash for tips as a rule of thum). Barb was a gracious hostess. Our server was amazingly attentive and one of the friendliest I have met had so many recommendations that it was definitely hard to nail down exactly what we wanted. The cocktails that we had were amazing and went down easy, I had a kombucha cocktail that was exactly what a person could want after a day at the beach. My wife ordered the seafood chowder with chili oil and it was delicious. It was definitely a bowl where you wanted bread to mop up that wonderous broth. It was packed with seafood that was prepared perfectly as well. No chewy clams or tough scallops. We split a charcuterie board special that I believe should be on the menu permanently because for two people it is the ideal appetizer to prepare you for your meal. Our meal was the surf and turf special for two. A large 14oz grilled ribeye and equally large 14oz carribean lobster tail with mashed potatoes, grilled asparagus, drawn butter, hollandaise, and a beautifully complex demi for the steak. Had I had room for dessert I would have the chocolate terrine because the way it was described sounded fantastic. I really recommend getting out and enjoying this beautiful establishment.

This is a beautiful restaurant with super friendly staff and delicious food ! Highly recommend ! We really enjoyed the whole experience! Thanks you Old Stone Farmhouse!

Nice place to visit dinner was excellent

What a wonderful experience! Hope to see you again soon.

If youre a French toast Lover this is the place for you. Try it out people:)

Great atmosphere and food, but not a very warm welcome from hostess... due to a mix up in reservation time... felt belittled.

1. The bottom of the plates were dirty. 2. The waitress was rude. 3 The food was cold after a 45 minute wait. 4. The maitre d was pleasant but..... 5 Well done steak was pink. 6. Did I say that the waitress was rude?!?

good food. big portions.. awesome staff!

First of all the food is horrible after taking the first bite of the food it was loaded with salt the fish tasted like stale fish it was hard and stiff. It s not like we ate the food and then complained we called the manager immediately and she was horrible. I would not recommend this place to anyone because their prices are expensive and simply not worth your hard earned money we don t usually complain but I cannot let this one go THE FOOD IS HORRIBLE HORRIBLE HORRIBLE.

This place was a huge disappointment. It is a stunning venue and we were so excited to be there. However, from the moment we sat down, We didn t feel like we were being attended to. Not a good feeling. I must say that we all loved our appetizers. I wish that we would ve only had those. But we didn t and It completely went down hill from there. Our entrees were all salty (party of 4) all of them! The fish did not taste fresh. We never send food back but this one time, we sent mine back and did the best we could with the other 3. We however were made to feel as if we were just complainers or much worse...trying to get free meals. Something that is extremely insulting. Absolutely horrendous customer service with an attitude. The place was highly recommended by our hotel but I can see now why they have very few reviews. Should ve known better. Unless you want to throw your money away and be treated badly while you re doing it, don t go!

Great restaurant on ST Thomas

What a superb experience! DO. NOT. MISS. The initial drive by the building to reach the valet belies the stunning grounds. Enter by a broad, curving stairway which reveals a lush inner courtyard and beckoning fountain. Filmy sheer draperies flow gently in the breeze in contrast to the immovable stonework. Outdoor tables are set under pavilions and stone archways offering openness or seclusion, as you may desire. Wend your way inside to the long, gleaming bar where you meet your hostess. No table is a lesser one. The high ceilings, rough stone walls, and dim lighting adds to the romantic mood. The cuisine does not disappoint. Clever, locally inspired cocktails are but an initiation to the exquisite dining. True to the skills of a fine chef, every flavor blends fabulously: the whole more than the sum of its parts. Our wait staff heard us mention our anniversary and decorated our final dessert course accordingly. Such thoughtful attention to detail.

The food was horrible and the waitress was rude, and the food was expensive $100 for a Surf n Turf. I do not recommend this place.

This was by FAR the WORST! ABSOLUTE WORST! Experience I ve ever had! My food was COLD, after telling the manger/owner that our food was cold, we were asked to pay our drink bill and leave! The absolutely WORST! I do not recommend this restaurant. A nice, and stunning view though.

Ambience is top notch and the food is amazing. Filer Oscar

Our meal was excellent. I had the crab eggs Benedict. They were rich and amazing with a perfectly poached egg. The ambiance was great the old stone farm house is charming and beautiful. I would highly recommend this restraunts for brunch we will definaetly be back next time we are on island.

I never leave reviews. So to say that I am taking the time speaks volumes about how great this place is. We had the salmon. It was amazing. Highly recommend this place. This place should have a michelin star

A must go to when visiting st Thomas. The views on the ride up are awesome. The house is very cool, take a walk around and see the rooms. Food and service were awesome of course.

Great dining experience... Professional staff. Excellent food and a beautiful setting.

This place was in our must-go-to places - turned out to be an atrocious experience. People here are super rude and arrogant! We literally had to wait for an hour to get our food and they had a problem because we didn t order a bottle of wine and asked us if we were expecting fast food treatment - very rude manager (racist)

Excellant place for fabulous food, drink, and service. Highly recommend this establishment!

We had high hopes for this restaurant given their good reviews and seeing pictures of the beautiful location. Unfortunately, the restaurant did not deliver. The first issue was that we often dine with our 4 year old son and clearly no one at the restaurant gives any thought to this. Many visitors to VI will come with their kids and kids generally like more simple meals. When we asked what they could do for him the best they could offer was gnocchi (which most kids hate) or a small filet steak. They could have easily served him a dried pasta with sauce and charged us $30 and wed have been happy. It seems pretty clear no one working in the kitchen has ever dined with a child. The second issue was the food was overpriced and lacked even the most basic flavor. The adult version of the gnocchi was more salad than pasta. At first we couldnt find the gnocchi in the greens it was served on, but then we finally saw a few sad, not very tasty gnocchi hiding inside. We actually called the waiter over to ask if we got the right meal, and we werent the only table that did that. The other main we ordered as the grouper, which was flavorless and a bit chewy. Given that this dish is $46 it should be a lot better than it was. The only item we ordered that was kinda okay was the scallop starter, but that was mostly because the sauce was good. The scallops themselves were nothing special - I can make better at home. Overall, we left with a bad taste in our mouths. $160 in food and hungry kid and disappointed adults. My son said it best when the bill came - this is not a good restaurant. We are frequent restaurant eaters being from New York City and he is actually pretty experienced in this area. Overall, this was the most disappointing meal we had in St. Thomas only because of the food. The location was beautiful and staff were decent - the kitchen needs to do some work.

Fantastic, our best meal,however both the server and bus girl could be nicer . Got strange looks and attitude from both. Really strange for such an beautiful and amazing place.

Best meal on the island in this humble clowns opinion. Seriously. The food was wonderful

Best restaurant we ve experienced on the island. Service, food and atmosphere very classy. We have traveled and dinned in many countries, after reading the negative reviews we thought it should be Michelain rated

This really deserves 0 stars. But this doesn t allow me to review without adding just one. My husband and I were in St Thomas to celebrate his birthday. I made my reservation in advance and was looking forward to celebrating his birthday at brunch at a venue that came highly recommended. I made the reservation for 6 but we were notified in the morning that 4 of our guests were not able to make it unless we went earlier. I called the restaurant to see if they could accommodate that but they didn t answer so I left a message. Since I didn t receive a response and still wanted to make sure my husband still had a nice time even though the others were not going to be able to come my husband and I came in time for our original reservation time. We walked into a beautiful restaurant, i was so excited. We walked up to the hostess and I let her know that instead of a party of six it would be a party of two. She was visibly annoyed and began to reprimand us for not calling ahead of time and not be respectful to restaurant during a busy day. I told her that I had called and she continued to tell me that she never received the message. She very rudely started to walk us to a table and I once again tried to show her on my phone that I had called because she clearly felt like I was lying. She then put her hand in my face and told me that I would not be comfortable eating there and that I should leave. In a dining room full of guests. I have never been so humiliated in my life. Let s not forget that she ruined what was supposed to be a very special moment in our trip to St Thomas to celebrate my husband s birthday.

Just fantastic. The crab cake is literally the best Ive ever had. Definitely recommend that. Difficult to get a cab back to your hotel if you have a late reservation, but definitely worth the trip.

Great European architecture and great steak!

Best dinner of the vacation. The service is incredible. The Filet Oscar was fantastic.

Excellent food. A step up from anything weve had on the island.

The owner Barb is incredibly rude. We walked in and waited 20 minutes for our table and proceeded to walk out when she was extremely rude to us while seating us. Hate these people, go read the one star yelp reviews and thats a pretty accurate review of this place

Great food and great service!

Visited with a party of 8 and we all raved at how delicious our meals were. I had the filet and it was possibly the best steak Ive ever eaten. Wonderful dining experience and fantastic service.

Was there in November 20 Wonderful drinks & amazing food! The ambiance was magical

Amazing place, customer service and food. My favorite on island.

Never had a bad experience. Tried Sunday brunch and it was awesome.

Worst customer service we have received on the island, the steak was dry with no flavor. You could only eat it with a sauce to stomach it. So disappointed with this restaurant, do yourself a favor and find a better restraunt. Everyone in our party had an issue with the lackluster service and their meal. Not to mention we waited over 90 minutes before we were even served our meal.

Terrible!! Absolutely do not recommend this place. Waited over a hour in a half to get food. Waitress was extremely rude!!! Food was terrible definitely not worth the money do not waste your time.

STOP! Save your money! Do not go to this place- The absolutely worst place we have visited! Worst customer service, rude staff, and terrible food. They need a lesson in customer service.

Awful experience! The steak was tasteless and simply not worth the money. The service wasnt much better with our waitress being rude and obnoxious! We asked for the bill to be separated into 3 individual tickets as we were 3 couples. At first she said she couldnt then she arrived with 3 tickets with 20% gratuity already included overall the service, the food were below standard you would expect! Stay away this place will leave you disappointed!

I never leave reviews, but I felt this one was warranted. It was a three couple anniversary dinner and we all were looking for a fun night. 90 minutes for a meal that was so overcooked and I asked the waitress to please look at the filet my wife ordered medium rare (well done) and I ordered a filet cooked medium (well done). I never send anything back, but this was a $70.00 filet and I felt it was deserved. The waitress agreed, and the chef requested to see the steaks, and we were told they were preparing another filet for us. I apologized to the waitress and acted like it was our fault. 20 minutes later I get another filet cooked identical to the first and ate two bites and passed the rest aside. So, the bottom line is the over cooked my filet, no big deal. The way we were treated was so wrong and shouldn t happen. The waitress bought the ticket and added her tip into the bill and she said, don t worry about the tip I added it. I always try to bless hard working people people and my tips are always based on one thing... attitude. It was so wrong in so many levels.

Old Stone Farmhouse was a combo of old world charm, and amazing food. The service was exceptional and Barb and the staff offered genuine hospitality. We had some difficulty getting a taxi, but Barb made sure to coordinate with our hotel to send one down, and offered comped cocktails while we waited. We highly recommend this place, and will definitely be returning on our next trip to St.Thomas.

The lump cake was amazing. But I believe that food is overpriced for what you get.

Beautiful atmosphere, service was fast and friendly, and the food is so delicious, my first time and I had a great time. Definitely will be back.

Amazing food and service!!!

My family and I went for Brunch! Our entire experience was amazing! Service was on point and the ambience was awesome. Food was delicious and we really enjoy brunch to celebrate our Matriarchs 70th Birthday!

Amazing brunch in an incredible building and garden space. We got the French toast and the salmon Cobb salad which was especially tasty. Also the bottomless mimosas rocked!

Its been almost a year since we last had dinner at OSFH, but I feel compelled to update this previous 5 star review after our experience this past weekend. It was a special occasion as we were introducing friends to this venue which is located in a spectacular setting with incredible ambiance. Unfortunately, the food did not live up to this standard this time. My wife had the scallop appetizer and was extremely ill the next morning. I had an essentially burnt lobster cake that was beyond dried out even with the creole sauce. Others had the steak and frites... the steak was lacking to say the least. Reading recent reviews this is becoming a trend at OSFH... and I fear all is not well in the kitchen! Is the new chef even still there?? And then we have the paper napkins... not acceptable at this price point! Also, the restaurants now doesnt allow split checks or personal wine (even with corkage charge). Its really unfortunate how inconsistent restaurants are becoming on St Thomas! Previous review; Incredible food under the new leadership of Executive Chef Justin Werle. Our dining experience was perhaps one of the best ever, and certainly the best over the past 20+ years at OSFH. Great food with French influences, Great Service, and Great ambiance... the perfect recipe for a fantastic evening with family and friends!

Really good food; attentive service. Excellent surroundings. Not terribly expensive. Highly recommended

Great place excellent food and great accommodating for special occasions and last minute plans and coordinating events. Thank you to Barb and the rest of their team!!!

This was by far the best dining experience we had on St.Thomas, St.John and the USVI in general. The food was amazing, every dish we got was delicious, especially the lobster/scallop udon, the scallop appetizer, the calamari, and we tried 4 out of 5 of the deserts and loved all of them but our favorites were the creme brûlée and flourless chocolate cake. The service was perfect, our waitress refilled our wine glasses quickly and was very responsive and kind. On top of both of those things, the ambiance was wonderful and the building was historic and great. We enjoyed every minute of this experience and will 100% be back, would recommend this to anyone, it was worth the price and could give it more than 5 stars if possible.

Dinner at Old Stone Farmhouse The place itself is historic in nature. If youre a fan, your going to love the venue. Service was amazing. Our servers name was Coco. Ask for her. Sitting outside was a plus. Decent wine selection. loved that the menu was somewhat limited. This usually means they can perfect a few dishes. Make sure to check the menu out before coming to see if it matches your taste. We tried getting lobster everywhere we went but kept striking out including here . Everyone in the group enjoyed their food. Wife and ordered The steak for 2 and still had leftovers.

Food was not good. Salty and not fresh. Lobster udon and bouillabaisse specially very fishy. Way over priced especially for the quality of food you receive. Will not be back.

One of the best times we had on Saint Thomas! The atmosphere in this place was so casual and relaxing. The building is very unique and you feel like youve traveled back in time when entering it. The staff was friendly and attentive, they didnt make you feel rushed at all. The food was excellent! We will definitely be returning!

I made reservations here weeks in advance for my party of five. They were immediately accommodating when we arrived. I had the truffle risotto with the foie gras and it was exceptional. My two daughters had the steak and said it was the best they ever had. My other daughter had the salmon and she said it was phenomenal. One other had the duck, which was a little tough but the flavor was excellent. The cocktails were strong and on point. The ambiance was exquisite. This is an experience worth it in my opinion.

Excellent experience

I eat here quite often. The restaurant is absolutely beautiful. Barb, chef Justin and the staff are impeccable. Food is glorious. My favorites right now are the steak frites and tuna.

Spent 600 for tough steak and lobster

Dining was wonderful! And the place was amazing!

My husband and I are in St. Thomas for our honeymoon and HIGHLY recommend the Old Stone Farmhouse for brunch. We had the Crab Benedict and the Steamed Mussels that were both to die for. Our waiter Nick and the staff we encountered gave incredible service and were very friendly! The restaurant was also very beautiful!

The Sunday brunch meal and staff was amazing. I wished we would have tried dinner one evening. Definitely will return on our next trip!!

Excellent service and beautiful setting.

Truly the best restaurant on St Thomas... Ambiance, service, food... All on point and you will never be disappointed. Ever. Brunch is also awesome....

Ill start with how excited I was to make this reservation for my family over our Christmas vacation. I call and ask for a great table for 6 at 7pm on Christmas Day. They say theyre not open Christmas Day, but can accommodate us for Christmas Eve. Great, Ill take it. Reservation set. Anticipation begins. We show up and I check in my family and were a little early. Hostess says the group ahead is finishing up but we can grab a drink at the bar while we wait. No worries, we all grab a drink and chit-chat at the bar. Well, 7pm rolls around and weve all finished our first drink and our table is still not ready yet. Alright fine, well grab another drink. Clearly the table wasnt finishing up, but no big deal. We finish our second drink around 7:30pm and awkwardly hang around longer till 7:45. 45 minutes past the time I called a month in advance to reserve. Not off to a great start. We all sit down and the server greets us, explains the specials, and gets some drinks for those who need a refresher. He mentions he has one dish left of the daily fish - so I quickly say Ill take it- and just my luck, its reserved for me. He then comes back a little while later to deliver our drinks and take our orders. We order a couple of the specials that are being shared between my parents and my sister and her husband; my wife orders a filet mignon, and Im excited Ive got my fish. This all happens and the time is just past 8pm. Heres where everything spirals - and where this restaurant gets my worst recommendation and review Ive ever given. We wait another 30 minutes for our appetizers to come out, and were going on another 30 before I decide to have a chat with the manager. She mentions shell take care of it and goes back to the kitchen. I sit back down and she comes back from the kitchen and says theyre working on it and asks if she can accommodate us and get us anything to drink. We just want our food. They mention they can bring bread ( THEYVE HAD BREAD THIS WHOLE TIME?!). This next part is important...When our waiter brings the bread, he CLEARLY, AND FOR THE WHOLE TABLE TO HEAR, tells my father that dinner will be 50% off tonight for us having to wait so long. Well we go on waiting another 45 minutes. Its now just before 10pm, before we finally are served. Meanwhile, our waiter DOES NOT EVER COME BACK TO OUR TABLE. So we head up to the hostess stand and ask for our check after waiting even longer at our table. We all head to the valet/taxi area and leave my father to pick up the check (he insisted). Well, we wait about 10 minutes and hes still not with us...what is going on with this place!?!? My mom goes to collect him, but comes back to our group saying THEY HAVE CHARGED US FULL PRICE AND REFUSE TO ACKNOWLEDGE THE 50% OFF. We return and the waiter is now behind the hostess stand, standing next to the hostess and flatly lying to my father about what he said. The manager is hiding next to the bar, saying she has to believe what her waiter has told her, and the waiter is saying that HE IS THE MANAGER. What?? We refuse to pay the bill our of principle and how utterly terrible our service was all night - especially when we were told we would be receiving this discount (many of us were ready to give up after the bread came and before dinner because it seems very clear they hadnt even started cooking our food yet). Were in a standoff with the waiter not budging...AND THEN HE CALLS THE POLICE. To avoid any prolonged embarrassment we now feel having the police being called on us (we are not unruly, we are not aggressive, and with no justification for this) we decide to leave this restaurant lead by the worst management and staff Ive ever dealt with- and go home. To me, the only scenario I can think of that makes minimal sense is that the waiter never cleared this discount wIth management OR management told him it would come out of his own pocket to cover the cost. Either way, its no excuse for how terrible an encounter we had and with so much promise from the beginning. I could not more highly discourage

Do you want to wait 2 hours for your food, be blatantly ignored by your waiter, and have the manager disregard you when you request an explanation? Then come here! Complete with a greasy steak and a salad with three spoonfuls of dressing plopped on top. LOL. We had to laugh because these people have no idea how to run a restaurant. If you must come here, request a waiter other than Dean (thin with light brown hair) because he will surely ruin your experience. Don t count on the manager (lady with blonde hair) because she won t help you at all. For a better experience, far superior service, amazing view and tasty food, go to MAFOLIE instead!

Anniversary dinner was perfection. Best meal on the island. Very relaxing and romantic setting.

The spectacular food

The best steak that I have had in years and served with a hollandaise sauce. The Brussel sprouts were also amazing.

Very expensive for what you get, but so incredibly delicious and fantastic service. Our waiter was extremely knowledgeable and professional for our group of 8.

The wine, food and service was absolutely first class however the owner needs to make the rest rooms reflectthe rest of the establishment. That is why I only have 4 stars.

Dont get the swordfish. The fish I got had char on the edges and didnt taste pleasant. The appetizers were very good and the company with us felt the entrées were delicious.

Incredible food and drinks in a pristine and historic (and gorgeous) building. Highly recommend; these folks know what theyre doing! Get the green curry mussels (a starter) and the 8 oz. filet tenderest Ive ever had!

Brunch is always delightful here at Old Stone. The manager is very attentive and accommodating to her patrons. The gravy and buscuit are super tasty, all of the egg Benedicts are on point as well. The Cajun skillet is also definitely worth a try. P.S. Its always better to get the bottomless mimosas.

Ordered brunch, smoked salmon bagel, and French toast, both were great. Service was also good, very attentive without being intrusive. Menu offered some drinks as bottomless. Old stone building had nice ambience. All five of us enjoyed our meal and would return. Pricing is moderate to high.

Pricey and fab food and impeccable service. St Thomas, USVI

Great style, great food, amazing lamb chop

If you are looking for an excellent dinner with a romantic atmosphere, look no further. I ordered the salmon and it was by far the best I ve ever eaten. Bring your wallet because it is very pricey (but well worth it).

Very expensive steak. I had to keep salting it to make it taste good. Wife had a burger and it was burnt. Not a great experience but they set up a whole outside villa for our company we were traveling with and the waiter was great.

Lamb chops were great

One of those meals I will remember for the rest of my life! Wonderful atmosphere, good service! Great place for a romantic dinner or celebratory milestone meal! We shared the surf and turf and it was perfect!

Excellent food, excellent drinks and excellent staff. Overall we were quite impressed with the dining experience will be back. Also loved the blend of indoor/outdoor seating. You sit inside an old stone building built in the 1700s yet the windows and doors are non existent so you can feel the breeze, hear the birds and enjoy the Caribbean atmosphere all while protected from the major elements.

Interesting locale and fantastic food!

Fantastic Sunday brunch! The charm of the old farmhouse makes this restaurant special. Pictures are of the lobster benedict, sausage and gravy, and a Smokey Bloody Mary. Highly recommend.

Delicious and great service.

I dont know how this restaurant is not Michelin graded. Delicious, imaginative menu. Fabulous setting, and friendly staff. Lavender ice cream was mind blowing incredible.

Best fancy restaurant on the island, great service, good wine list, great desserts

For our final meal, we decamped to the north shore, near Magens Beach. The place was housed in an old fieldhouse from the 1750s, whose original arches and brick construct were upkept. Guides have said its one of the most authentically preserved buildings from the colonial era, and even 1750 is nearer the end than the beginning of the era. Its name is, fittingly, Old Stone Farmhouse. Also, the chef was magnificent, and the supper commendable. Appetizers of burrata and scallops gave way to a rack of roast lamb drowned in butter as only the French can do. Although the appetizers were indeed exceptional creations, that lamb is the most succulent I can recall, with just enough Caribbean spice to remind us we werent in Lyon. The service, however, matched any top-tier French establishment; it was a perfect place for our final supper on the island.

We loved everything about this place!

Salad was better suited for a rabbit

Nice place to eat good food

Where do I begin, the owners are a lovely, the setting is so beautiful and the food....incredibly delicious. If you are in St Thomas dont miss this place, it wont disappoint.

Great brunch menu and outstanding service!

Number one out of the 10 best restaurants in the area for sure. Especially since the hurricane took out the majority of the competition. Number 2 would be the Grand Palazzo Club at the Ritz Carlton owners facility. After traveling to Saint Thomas since the early 1980s we have had dinner at this restaurant several times. It is certainly the best that it s ever been in my opinion. The food quality is top notch, the maître d and the waiters are very good. Good wine list. The atmosphere is romantic and so interesting being in old Stone farmhouse. It is open air but I ve always found it to be comfortable inside with plenty of fans and circulation. So yes you will pay a little more to dine in style and have the best tasting food on the island but I certainly advise you to go and it is worth the trip. A little hard to get to so I recommend taking a taxi although you can drive yourself if you are adventuresome and not drinking.

Service was wonderful, the building and ambiance was the stuff of dreams, but the food couldnt quite live up to the mark. My partner and I started with the baked brie as an appetizer. It had slivered almonds, bread, apples, grapes, and honey. It was a delicious combination of flavors that worked well as a shared appetizer. I had the scallops as my main, which was both delicious and very well executed. The scallops were cooked perfectly and very well seasoned. My partner ordered the lamb porterhouse, which consisted of two smaller portions of lamb, a perfect amount of protein. She ordered it at the chefs recommendation, which was medium rare. The lamb came rare and under seasoned. My partner said the first bite from the edge of the lamb was incredible but as she continued it was undercooked.and underseasoned. The fingerling potatoes that came with were also underseasoned, I had a chance to try them and agreed they were bland. Service, architecture, ambiance, and valet service were amazing. We were sorry the food fell short of that.

The Old Stone Farmhouse was wonderful! The ambiance was incredible, the farmhouse has been preserved and decorated very well! You can tell they use their space for weddings and other such events because they are a well oiled machine. The food was great! Went for their brunch and was not disappointed. Also their cocktails were original and good tasting! Would come back if we had more time!

Excelent food but way to expensive for the portion. You also have to ask for the sides.

A 4.2 rating is not ok. I dont know who could have rated this lower than a 4. Definitely stop here if you are staying towards n Megans Bay or Margaritaville. Not only is this one of the best meals weve ever eaten, the ambiance of a 1750s Dutch stable is amazing. The staff was great and the food was better.

Amazing!!!!