Pelican Jo's Pizzeria -- Milliken, Colorado in Milliken

903 Broad St, Milliken, CO 80543, United States

★★★★☆
(237 reviews)
Categories: Pizza restaurant

About

Pelican Jo's serves New York style pizza with the best ingredients and fresh dough made daily. Unlike our competitors we offer free local delivery and are locally owned and operated. We have been serving the Milliken and Johnstown communities for 3 years now and the Windsor community for 12 years.

Website
pelicanjospizzeria.com
Address
903 Broad St, Milliken, CO 80543, United States
Plus Code
84JR+4W Milliken, Colorado, USA
Time Zone
America/Denver

Business Hours

Monday
11 AM–9 PM
Tuesday
Closed
Wednesday
Closed
Thursday
11 AM–9 PM
Friday
11 AM–9 PM
Saturday
11 AM–9 PM
Sunday
11 AM–9 PM

Services

Service options
Kerbside pickup No-contact delivery Delivery Takeaway Dine-in
Highlights
Fast service
Popular for
Lunch Dinner Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Offerings
Alcohol Beer Comfort food Quick bite
Dining options
Lunch Dinner Dessert
Amenities
Toilets
Atmosphere
Casual
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards Debit cards NFC mobile payments Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Parking
Free of charge street parking Free parking lot Parking

Photos

Reviews

4.3
★★★★☆
237 reviews

Most Mentioned

price (17) garlic knots (16) calzone (10) pizza rolls (9) pepperoni (8) wings (7) order (6) crust (5) jalapeno popper (4) jalapeño popper rolls (3)
5 stars
161
4 stars
35
3 stars
8
2 stars
20
1 stars
13
★★
November 17, 2024

I debated on making a post about this as I thought it was a once off issue. We order here frequently as the food is very delicious (garlic knots are a must), anyways, there have been several times now that our food has arrived looking a little rough. See photo for reference, tonight one of our pizzas was nearly folded in half. Not to mention the estimated time of arrival was supposed to be 5:25, and our order did not arrive until after 6. We always spend over $100 and tip well, so this is a bit of a disappointing experience.

★★
November 16, 2024

Never again! Next time I want good pizza I will just get in the car and go somewhere. It will be faster than ordering from here. This place was great when it opened but has been on a steady decline. My last order took 1 hr and 15 min, my calzone was just luke warm. I sure wish this town would get a few more restaurants instead of food trucks.

★★★★
November 14, 2024

The only thing that’s stopping me from giving these guys a five star review is they can’t make garlic knots I thought maybe the first time I ordered them was just a fluke but the second time confirmed it. They don’t even deserve to be called garlic knots they should just be called bread knots because there is no garlic or butter or parsley or any wonderful thing that you would expect on garlic knots they’re just dry knots of bread. Wonderful, pizza, horrible garlic knots.

★★★★★
November 5, 2024

We stopped for an early dinner on a Sunday night. Store was very clean, game was on 2 tvs, we ordered pizza and jalapeno popper rolls, they came out quickly and were hot and so delicious! Staff very pleasant and efficient! Highly recommend!

★★★★★
June 14, 2024

Garlic knots were so good. Would definitely recommend Pelican Jo's to anybody who loves pizza or garlic. The garlic knots were so rich and fluffy! The pizza crust is very similar to the bread knots, without the garlic. I got a customized pizza, and it came out amazing. We are around 20:30, and it was nice and quiet.

★★★★★
April 28, 2024

I had the Italian, and I was not disappointed. I will be returning to explore further in hopes of more delicious food. Edit: I had the Italian 4 times before I could even try anything else. Take that as you will. Today I did the Philly pizza, and I ate over half the 14" in one sitting because it is SO GOOD. Love these guys!

★★
March 22, 2023

My boyfriend and I used to love Pelican Jos, but lately we've been consistently disappointed with the quality of food. It's hard to justify supporting a local business when the $20+ specialty pizza you ordered comes with barely any toppings. The garlic knots are still tasty, but for pizza we'll be looking elsewhere from now on.

December 1, 2022

We used to love this place and didn’t mind paying more for a better pizza than the big chains, but lately it’s been going downhill. The last time I ordered it looked like someone had chewed on the pizza, and the pieces were cut into absurd sizes. The cheese bread was so oily on top it was hard to pick up, only to discover it was completely raw in the middle. I emailed pelican joes, as this order was $60, which is an absurd price for what I received. It’s been a couple weeks and still no response from the owner. I would love to support my local businesses - but I may just have to stick with the big chains from now on.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2024

Great service and it s awesome they deliver out to us. Always friendly staff. Must try!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 17, 2024

Great pizza! Loved it.

★★★★
December 16, 2024

Pizza was great, but maybe don t mess with the cheese cake it was next level terrible my wife and I got one slice to split and we didn t come close to finishing it because as I said b4 it was terrible

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 8, 2024

Edit: Its still so good! We moved to Milliken from the metro area and this pizza is better than anything Ive had in or around Denver. Crispy chewy crust, delicious toppings (we usually go for the Jalepeno popper pizza, topped with fresh jalepeno slices, cream cheese and bacon---OMG ). The restaurant itself has a nice vibe; small, cozy and trendy. Its still quiet enough to talk to each other, even with multiple larger groups of people sitting and eating at the same time. We mainly order for pick up. Theyre very fast! Pizza orders are ready in 15 minutes and so hot and fresh. Delivery is offered and has always been timely and polite. While not the cheapest pizza around (theres a Little Ceasars in the area) its not even close between the two. Pelican Jos is just so much better in terms of quality that price isnt an issue. We love this place and will continue to order from it weekly/biweekly.

★★
Local Guide
November 22, 2024

Ordered to go and showed up 15 min later just to sit and wate for another 30 min for a small pizza. Place was not busy at all. Pizza is hit or miss.

★★★★★
Local Guide
November 22, 2024

Great atmosphere and definitely great food and especially Pizza!!

★★★
Local Guide
October 22, 2024

Very good on the first order. Very different on the second order. Double extra cheese means just that. Inconsistencies stop me from giving 5 stars. Extra cheese means that. Your business is a shame on honesty. Food

★★★★★
October 22, 2024

Love this place. Our go-to lunch treat.

★★
September 22, 2024

Playing the GI lottery at this point we made it halfway through an order of pizza rolls before realizing that what we thought was cheese pull was actually raw dough.

★★★★★
Local Guide
September 22, 2024

This place slaps fr go to it the pizza is good fr and support this small business it deserves it

★★★★★
Local Guide
August 22, 2024

Get specials every day under $5

★★★★★
August 22, 2024

Never disappoints!

★★★★★
Local Guide
July 22, 2024

My husband and I thought this would be a half decent pizza place when we moved to town, and its become a ruiner of any other pizza and calzone. My husband loves them because theyre one of the few places that has artichokes as a topping and I love the fact they serve epic pesto or alfredo sauce. They are one of the only pizza places I go to now, besides The Sink in Boulder. Nowhere else is worth the time! One 14 pizza with olives, artichokes, and cheddar cheese on alfredo sauce and a second 14 with meatballs, onions, olives, peppers, cream cheese, garlic, and extra cheese on pesto cost about $50 with tip.

★★★★★
Local Guide
July 22, 2024

Best pizza around! 2 years later and their still rocking it! Food

★★★★★
Local Guide
July 22, 2024

The pizza was hot and delicious. The crust was thin and crispy yet could hold up to a good pizza fold. Will be back to have again!

★★★★
Local Guide
July 22, 2024

Usually good but ordered the jalapeño popper rolls last night and the dough was not cooked.

★★★★
Local Guide
July 22, 2024

Good pizza and super friendly service from a good local pizza shop. Definitely try Jos instead of one of the big chains.

★★★★★
Local Guide
June 22, 2024

Im not sure what has changed. But the pizza has gotten even better lately thank you crew for making an excellent!

★★★★★
June 22, 2024

Small, quiet joint with great food and even friendlier service. Pelican Jo s is one of my favorite places to eat :)

June 22, 2024

Neighbor had a pizza delivered and the young kid in a white VW was speeding through our neighborhood and when confronted by a neighbor from across the street about his excessive speed he laughed at her and sped off . That alone will make me order from somewhere else.

★★★★★
May 22, 2024

Didnt expect such a great sandwich!

★★★★★
Local Guide
May 22, 2024

Must try the jalapeño popper pizza! It s a good small town/small business restaurant experience.

★★
April 22, 2024

The first time we ordered from Pelican Joes, it was awesome! That was a couple of years ago, now it is hit or miss. I love their calzones, but the last time I ordered one, it was overcooked! We ordered on Friday night, because I could get a pesto sauce pizza for my granddaughter, she liked that. The extra cheese pizza I order was far from good. It looked like it had hardly any cheese on it at all. Was very disappointed!! I dont know that I will take another chance and order from them again!

★★★★★
Local Guide
March 22, 2024

We love ordering from our favorite local pizza spot! The salads are always a generous size and the pizza crust is always flaky, flavorful and cooked to perfection. They offer a large selection of specialty pizzas and calzones and many ways to customize your order to your liking. Were very lucky to have Pelican Joes in Milliken as a local dining and take out option as an alternative to the fast food and chain restaurants that seem to be taking over our once small farm community. Support local!

★★★★★
Local Guide
March 22, 2024

Great food! We ordered pizza on a night when they were very busy and the host and manager were so kind and helpful!!!

★★★★★
Local Guide
January 22, 2024

Always super chil place. Amazing pizza, friendly staff. Good options. Can get delivered as well. Highly recommend the Sammy pizza. Food

★★★★★
Local Guide
January 22, 2024

Great food and customer service. Also, a lunch deal that wont break the bank.

★★★★★
Local Guide
January 22, 2024

I really like this place because I have a yeast allergy (which soulds strange) :). But they are the only place I have ever been about to order cauliflower crust and the crust does not have yeast in it. This is the only place Ive ever been able to eat pizza.

★★★★★
January 22, 2024

Way better than those pizza joints down the road

★★
January 22, 2024

DIRTY!! This place needs a serious deep clean. The walls, booths and tables and floors are disgusting. Especially next to the soda machine. If the dining area is this dirty, I don t even want to know what the food prep area is like. This place has great food, but cleanliness is a major issue.

★★★
January 22, 2024

3 stars, C- rating Its an okay local pizza place. The salads are ok. The wings are good. Pizza is okay, not great. Also, whoever cuts the pizzas needs some help. The slices are never even. The in house made brownies are a nice treat that I will never order again. Found a 2-inch long blonde hair in my last one. Gross!! For a small town pizza place, its just okay, in a bigger city, it couldnt compete.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Update: Today I was contacted by the store manager. I appreciate that she took my complaint seriously and said she was going to have a meeting with everyone to ensure this type of behavior will no longer be tolerated. With that said, I will give them another chance because I do like having them so close to ho, the food is always good, and I prefer to support local business than a corporation. I would give 0 stars if I could. The immature workers here believe it is funny to write inappropriate things on the sandwich wrappers when specifically asked to write only a letter to identify whos sandwich is whose. When I called and spoke with a manager she asked if it was for my son, who used to work there. When I told her no it was not, the only response I got was Ill just tell them not to do it. Well, I am done with this place and they will not see another dime from me when they cant even take responsibility for their unprofessional conduct and I would advise others to do the same.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Cant wait to return for another delicious Italian sub Sammy!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

The calzones are a must try, great flavor and a nice portion!! Great customer service and fairly priced

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Staff was great and foid was awesome. We ordered a pizza, jalapeño popper rolls and pepperoni rolls... All great. Kid-friendliness: A casual place. Perfect for families. Wheelchair accessibility: Ground floor without barriers.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

The staff is always incredibly nice to me and my boys. Pizza is always perfect. Tables are always dirty though.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Good food here.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

We try theyre pepperoni and Hawaiian pizza, and it was delicious, we always drive by this neighborhood place and finally we decide to stop to grab some late pizza, I regret not to stop before , were definitely going to be back

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

We love the garlic knots

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

My go to for pizza whenever Im in Milliken.

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Pizza and Garlic Knots are out of this world! Definitely Coming Back later in my life!

★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

The family loves it when we get dinner from pelican jos with 4 stars was the review. Now a year or so later not so much. Quality went down and service is slipping

December 22, 2023

This used to be very good but now stay away. How can you serve Costco frozen pre-made and expect a 30% tip. What a joke

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

A very nice and chill environment. Not too much of a high energy place and I found it comfortable. The food was awesome of course!

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Usually do carry out or delivery so cant say much on the atmosphere but the food is excellent!

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

I cant speak for the atmosphere or service, bit the delivery people are always nice and on time. The food is always good too.

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

The salads were big and delicious and the pizza looked good as well. My kids also enjoyed the wings.

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Great pizza, as always!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Love the pizza, and delivery to Johnstown is free! Love the garlic knots!!

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Love this place!

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Perfect casual but delicious pizza joint! A gem in Miliken. And they have great lunch specials.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Wish I would have taken a picture of our pizzas - not only did they look heavenly but they also tasted amazing. This was our first time trying the pizza at Pelican Jos and it wont be our last!

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Courteous, fresh salads, delicious.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Wonderful homemade pizza with a flaky and light fluffy crust.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Pizza rolls were good Customer service was not good at all they were to busy on there phones Food

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Great food, great staff, great daily specials!

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Really good stopped by on my lunch and ordered a calzone the people are very friendly would recommend to anyone

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Delicious pizza!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

I uave been here twice . the grandkids and i share garlic knots and pepperoni pizza. i like the thin crust and the garlic knots are sooo good.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

The lunch special is a great deal. 2 slices and a soda fir under $8.

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

We always love Pelican Jo s! The best crust, and the mango habanero wings are always my fav! Delivery is always quick too. Dietary restrictions: Their cauliflower crust is sooooo good!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Awesome pepperoni rolls!!

Local Guide
December 22, 2022

I ordered 2 kids meals that were 15min later than they said they would be ready when ordered online. Stuff happens but I get home and find my 4 year olds chicken fingers completely raw. Good thing I cut them open before giving them to him.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Amazingly delicious pizza! Regret not getting a larger pie!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Always wanted to try this place but kept forgetting about it until today. Absolutely delicious! Not greasy like dominos has a brick oven taste Delivered within 40 min to to Old Johnstown! Very impressed to bad I m moving soon, should have tried this place out a long time ago. Free delivery too!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Just moved to town and this is some of the best pizza we have had in a long time! The garlic knots were yummy too! Cant believe this place wasnt slammed on a Friday.

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

Great pizza, one of the best place to eat around!

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

The whole pizza was good, especially the crust and the staff was very nice and friendly.

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

On way from Greeley to denver, stopped in and had lunch. It was amazing!

★★
December 22, 2022

If you cant tell folks whats on a specific specialty pizza when ordering online, then I cant order from you.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Always good, always fast, always great staff, always a good choice!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

I love this place, Im gonna miss the food and awesome staff

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

I went here for the first time yesterday. We got the pepperoni rolls, garlic knots and two drinks. It was only like 20 bucks! We were both quite full and had leftovers. Did I mention that the food was delicious! Ill be back!

December 22, 2022

We eat here at least 2-5 times a month, typically we have decent food from here. Today I spent $4 just to literally throw it in the trash. I am super disappointed this would be sent out, as Im sure no one else would want to eat rotten lettuce.

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

Delicious and great service!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

We always love it here! Food and employees are great

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

I felt it was time to post another review as I have been eating here since Pelican Joes opened and have probably ordered over 50 times at least. In all of the times I ordered the only thing that ever happened ONCE, was my garlic knots were a little chewy and they remedied that immediately. The pizza and sides I have ordered have been consistently fantastic and the delivery is always on time. The staff are always friendly on the phone, at the store when I do go in and when they deliver. I take care of the delivery drivers and they take care of me. If you havent noticed, its not easy to find great staff anymore and yet you can see that they make it one of their priorities. Kudos Pelican Joes!

December 22, 2022

Not sure if this place is still in business. Called 3 times at 11:45 am on Monday and no answer. Google said they were open, very confusing. Used to be good pizza.

★★
December 22, 2022

We had the margarita pizza tonight and, frankly, the one I had at Paneras last was better. Tonights pizza was hardly warm, the mozzarella was thick, not melted and very sparse, there were very few basil leaves. Guess Ill go back to Panera.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Food was great and employees were super nice. Great to see a locally owned place. The happy hour specials were amazingly well priced.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Great pizza and wings!

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

The pizza we got was delicious! Honestly one of the best I ve ever had!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

I was in Milliken for business and decided to try this pizza place. They have excellent pizza by the slice lunch specials. I tried the pepperoni pizza rolls with a fountain drink lunch special. Great value!! They were filled with plenty of pepperoni and mozzarella cheese with a light dough shell. VERY GOOD Sorry no picture of the pizza rolls, I was starving and forgot to snap a pic.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Decent tasting pizza especially if youre around town and craving a slice or 2. Great customer service though.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

My favorite pizza place very prompt

★★
December 22, 2022

It was so disappointing. The pizza was so undercooked. You could taste the rawness of the dough. This is the third time in the last 3 months Pelican Jo s in Milliken has done a terrible job. Previous times the garlic knots were so salty they couldn t be eaten. We ordered a pepperoni pizza for the boys that looked like somebody put the pepperoni on with their feet. The pizza had pepperoni on about 2/3 of the pizza. It wasn t even cut either. It is quite pricey and I expect better. . . The way it was a year ago. I hope they figure it out. At this time I would much rather have Little Caesar s. They are delicious, affordable, and higher quality.

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

I love this place its my new go to pizza delivery, and they have not only a gluten free pizza but gluten free cheese cake. The people that work here are amazing and super nice. Dietary restrictions: They have a wonderful gluten free pizza and a gluten free cheese cake both are delicious.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Great food and very clean

★★★★
December 22, 2022

We love pelican Jo s, however we decided to try a new pizza and ordered the Christmas special which was supposed to be a bruschetta type pizza, we received something completely different being pepperoni with red and green peppers we were very disappointed

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

First time we have ordered from here. Food is awesome and came earlier than expected. Meatball sandwich and Italian beef melt. Both delicious and seasoned perfectly. Cheese sticks are mostly cheese instead of mostly fried coating. Very tasty!! Great job! Will definitely be ordering again. Highly recommend!!!!!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Really yummy Pizza and local

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Great pizza every time!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

BEST artichoke dip on earth!!! Overall all the food is pretty great and service is also great! Thank you!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Fantastic pizza same as the one in windsor. 100% recommended for anyone!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

I had them when they first opened in Milliken. Wasnt very impressed. But tried again about a year later and liked what I had. Theyve changed things around. It was pretty good..... Ill do it again.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

First time ordering from here. Very fair pricing. Tasty pizzas w bacon perfectly cooked! Poppers were a surprise as they were wrapped n wat tasted and appeared like true homemade dough. Service was quick and friendly. Def will b ordering from here next pizza Friday.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Great service and even better food. Highly recommend going and trying them out.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Amazing wings, great pizza and friendly staff.

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

Nice clean place to eat. We enjoyed the pizza and a little sport action on the ! The best customer service and hospitality..and the menu is very fulfilling!!! Probably eating again soon(tomorrow).

★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Chicken parm sandwich was great but I will not be back during the pandemic. Staff do not wear masks. I can somewhat understand not requiring your customers to wear them but there is no excuse to not have the staff wearing them.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Loved my meatball sub - best Ive ever had!

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

Give this establishment a try! Friendly staff and clean restaurant. Also best parmesan garlic wings hands down! Also appreciate the freedom of choice to wear a mask or not

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Really good. Big fan of their lunch specials

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Love this local joint! Pizza has the best crust!

★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

We live 5 min away and came to get a pizza and it wasnt hot, or warm. Pretty disappointed about that. The pizza itself was ok, nothing to write home about. Will most likely get again because they are local but was pretty disappointed with our first go.

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

Love their pizza

★★★★
December 22, 2021

Good pizza, the mozzarella sticks are great and the staff is always super friendly and prompt to take care of you as soon as you walk through the door. Definitely a family pizza night favorite.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

So good ! Great service, great prices, awesome employees ! I love this place !

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

The food was very good. Paige was our server and was totally awesome. Way to go Paige!! Definitely will go back.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Amazing, delicious and fresh!! The staff is friendly and helpful. We had a pizza roll, the kicken sink pizza and some golden BBQ wings. Everything was hot, fresh and delicious!! Will be back for more!!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Pretty low key, yet nice eatery. While the pies are a little on the pricey side, they are quite tasty. Service was great, and the place had a good layout to it. Located right off the main drag in town it is easy to get to. Stop by, youll like it.

December 22, 2021

Tired to order some pizza tonight (Friday) before 9 because on google it says they re open till 10 buuut they didn t answer. So we called back just after 9 and they answered this time, she said they re closed even though it says 10pm online and she goes on to blame google for randomly changing the close time lol. So to me it seems they purposefully Ignored our phone call before close (9pm) and then chose to answer (after 9pm) saying sorry but WE RE CLOSED. How convenient. Not smart for a small business in a small town. Ordering dominos now! Thank!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

First time ordering and they did a great job right down to following a special request on delivery. We had a chicken bacon ranch and the cheesy bread, both were cooked perfectly and tasted great. A nice thin crust that wasnt soggy and the bread had some garlic but not overpowering. Did the online ordering and selected a delivery time, showed up early! Bravo!!! Well order again.

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

I loved the pizza and the wings were pretty good too my kids enjoyed it as well

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

Food is delicious probably one of the best pizza places in NoCo

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Very good jalapeños Poppers.

★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

The food is pretty good, but overpriced for what you get. The pizza was browned on top. I like it that way, but my wife doesnt. They were stingy with the ingredients on my Italian beef melt and they forgot to bring the mango habanero sauce that I ordered. We probably wont order from them again.

★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

This place was awesome from the start but not so awesome now! Our pizza must have been Hot N Ready awaiting our phone call because it was old and stail! The cheese bread was terrible too! Both the pizza and the cheese bread were so thin I thought about measuring them with a micrometer!

★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Pizza is good when its hot and fresh.. Garlic knots were burnt on the outside, completely raw dough on the inside.. and forgot sauces, marinara and ranch. Paid for extra ranch, also didnt receive those. Way overpriced for what you get..

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

The food is amazing! We ordered the Garlic Knots, Pizza Rolls, and a Pepperoni Pizza. All of it tasted absolutely amazing and well worth the price for the clear amount of hard work thats been put into everything they sell! If you need a delicious dinner, go here.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Great pizza. Friendly staff

December 22, 2020

I ordered 2 pizzas and wings at the milliken store at 7:03pm my order was suppose to be delivered by 7:48 8:00pm I get a call the driver is lost she will be there in 5 minutes 8:10 I get another call saying the driver really got lost give her 5 minutes so 8:25 rolls around still no pizza so I call the store I talked to the manager Brian said he would call me back to see where his driver was he calls back says he didnt know where his driver was I told him I better not have cold food 8:35 rolls around my pizza finally shows up my pizza was cold and folded in half I couldnt eat the wings they were hard I will never be back.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Tasty

★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Ordered 2 pizzas 1 was Hawaiian which only had pineapple. My husband said there was small chunks of Canadian bacon but couldnt taste it. Large Hawaiian and large meaty 50.00 big ones. First and last time.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Enjoyed a gluten free pizza.

December 22, 2020

went here to order a large pizza when they first opened .pizza was $20 and very small and burnt.way too expensive for what you get.i can get a better pizza from little caesars.first and last to order here

★★
December 22, 2020

Not very good tazting. Left certain meat off and added chicken

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Nicest ordering experience ever. Then I was (really) late picking the pizzas up and they remade them. I would never expect that extra step since the error was mine. But I can t express my appreciation enough. In this day and age, this is a sweet and wonderful happening. Locally owned wins! Thank you to Kyle and the team!

December 22, 2020

Ordered large pizza and got a small, ordered pizza rolls that came in a bag th they put the marinara in and the cups melted and got sauce everywhere. Called and complained, they said they would refund entire order, never did. They also remade order. It took over 2 hrs to feed the family. This place is trash and do not follow up with their word. 1 star is too much.

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Great service killer pizza

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Placed an order for delivery, very impressed with the options for the pizzas, reasonable prices, no delivery fee. It showed up in under 30 minutes on a Friday night and the pizza was very good! Im glad this place found a home in Milliken!

★★★
December 22, 2020

Decent but pricey

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Delicious

December 22, 2020

Ill start off with I was super excited that there was a pelican Joes coming closer to my home. With that I ordered a couple pizzas for pickup. I was told the pizzas would be ready in 15 to 20 minutes. I finally show up 20 minutes later just to wait in line for 10 minutes to take two orders and then after I let them know I am there to pick up my pizzas they walk around for 5 minutes and then let me know that they were never made so 15 minutes later I finally get my pizzas. I love the pizza but I will never show up to this location again.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

This was our first visit, we got a large kitchen sink pizza to-go. It was awesome, we loved it! Cant wait to try some of their other pizzas!

★★★★
December 22, 2020

Good pizza and nice people

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Both pizzas we ordered tasted great. Hot and fresh when they arrived. When I placed the ordered was told 30-45 and 20 mins after ordering had a knock on my door and the pizza was here. 10/10 will be ordering again!

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Excellent pizza and excellent customer service from Brian and Kayleigh!!! I will definitely be back soon, I highly recommend!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Great pizza rolls for a good price!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

The Calpine is the best around, so are the pizza rolls. We were a little disappointed in the pizza crust, but the pizza tasted good. Well be back again. The staff is friendly and helpful. Food comes out quickly. The booths are easy to fit in and comfy. Outdoor patio is also avail. Great place to get a quick bite!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

WOW!!! I got the jalapeno popper pizza. A Freaking Mazing. Service? A Freaking Mazing. Best pizza Ive had in a long while. 6 stars.

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

First time here. The service was awesome and the food was delicious!!! We are visiting from Parker, wish you guys were closer! It was so delicious! We ordered the chicken, artichoke calzone and the lunch combo pep pizza. Oh and the garlic knots.

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Excellent pizza. Highly recommend.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Always have a great pizza at Pelican Joes

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Great pizza

★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Extremely slow. We were the only table in there and everything took FOREVER. Appetizers came out after our lunch was brought out. Everything did taste fabulous and the order was correct

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

First time order via delivery, garlic knots and pepperoni. Typically go to Perrys in Johnstown but enjoyed pelican joes and very glad to a nearby option. Will order again.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

The Hawaiian was Very good!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

First time trying this place and was not disappointed. The whole family enjoyed it. Crust was a little thin but every pizza place does it differently.

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

We love the make your own calzones. and the staff are great

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

AWESOME! FAST, DELICIOUS! You made the day! My Niece and family are new to Miliken, just moved there today! Pelican Jos youre exactly what I needed! You made the day! Food was delicious. Thanks for making it possible for me the Uncle in Arizona who could not be there to help them move into their first house have a good pizza, salad and cookies delivered from 800 miles away! Thank you!

★★
December 22, 2020

When this place is great its GREAT!!! BUT, the inconsistency with portions and ingredients is overwhelming. Sometimes you get very very good food that makes you want to order again and sometimes you get food that is absolutely disgusting with hardly any ingredients.. for instance in our order we consistently always have a calzone with pepperoni, jalapeno, and pineapple, more often than not, we will get a calzone that is overloaded with pineapple a few jalapenos and no pepperoni! Even though we are paying for the extra. When you bring it up nothing is ever addressed accordingly. You bring it up to some of the staff and they say weve never had those items in our menu.. or due to covid we cant give you that item(drink or pepperoni) but they charge the same... We really want to support this business, as we understand SOME inconsistency with new hires and the uncertainty with a pandemic...but, when we are spending our money at your business we expect consistency and understanding when things are completely incorrect. If its wrong, its wrong. Please address your inconsistencies from a management standpoint.

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Delicious pizza!

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Best pizza we ever ate!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Very very good. I will not be ordering pizza from any where else. We have tried the pizza roll, wings, jalapeno poppers and pizza and are looking forward to our next order

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Definitely the best pizza in Milliken and Johnstown.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Awesome!! A+++

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Good pizza, clean environment , friendly staff

Local Guide
December 22, 2020

When they 1st opened. Everything was good hot fresh. We order here about one time a month and have been noticing a decline. Tonight was no different when I ordered a salad, got it home excited to eat as I put my dressing on my salad and bam... I am chewing on hair. Yep hair. Gross. Save your money..

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Amazing management. We messed up our order and didn t know it was outside for us. We called in and they brought us a fresh new pizza. This was our fault not theirs and they still gave us amazing customer service . Thank you Pelican Jo s Milliken, Co!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Always good. Super staff.

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

This location opened Monday 11/4/19. Its been crazy busy every night but is the best pizza Ive had in years! Noticed a lot of selfish impatient people but the food is worth the wait! Thank you Pelican Jos for opening a location in Milliken!

★★
December 22, 2019

Not impressed. First time we tried to go we were told 1 - 1.5 hour wait for pizza. Now I m trying to call and place an order and no one is answering the phone. I just get a message that no one can answer the phone and to leave a message. My husband was so excited only to be terribly disappointed. Edit: finally got a live person and placed an order. I will update after I pick it up and taste the pizza.

★★
December 22, 2019

Not off to a great start. Ordered a pizza for pickup, apparently there was some confusion and the pizza(s) weren t made. We asked for green olives when we placed the order, got home and there were black olives on the pizza. Not a huge deal but I think they should have mentioned that when we placed the order.

★★★★
December 22, 2019

Just picked up some pizza and it was so yummy!! Glad they opened up here.

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

Ordered 2 pizzas on the way home. Place was super busy and was quoted about 40 mins for my 2 pizzas. They were ready sooner than that and the pizzas are fantastic. We have a gluten sensitivity in our home and they even offer 2 different gluten free crusts that are really good. We dig it!!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Food was great. 5 days in business. Still working out the kinks. Service was friendly.

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

We are happy to have this new pizza place in our little town. We have ordered on two separate occasions and have been satisfied both times. Boyfriend is gluten free and we are happy with the options Pelican Jo s provides. I m not even gluten free but can confirm that the gluten free crust is tasty! Swung by after work this evening to check in on our order and the pizza was ready before the quoted time. In and out in 2 minutes. I would definitely recommend.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

I was familiar with the Windsor location because it is near my work. So I was quite excited to see Pelican Jos expanding to Milliken! They did not disappoint! I ordered online and picked up in store. The process was seamless and timely even with a full house and people flowing in. Oh, and the pizza is flavorful! I tried the jalapeno popper pizza for the first time and it was the best combination of burning spice and cooling cream cheese.

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

The food is prepared well. This is not a fast food pizza joint, like Dominos for example. The staff and atmosphere is very relaxed. It took about 15 minutes to receive my pizza, 3:30pm Dine in order, which again is perfectly acceptable. I rather have someone take time and effort to make my pizza versus slapping it all together and rushing it out in five minutes. Suggestions: Need alcoholic beverages, shades on the windows and the condiments stand needs a bottle of Sriracha.

★★★★
December 22, 2019

My husband and I tried them last night for the first time. Very impressed with freshness of produce. The pizza crust was delicious, not soaked in grease. Delivery to our home was prompt and on time. We will try them again.

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

GREAT PIZZA! Fast delivery!

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

Absolutely love this place! The boneless chicken and pizza is amazing! I had a mess up on our last order and when we ordered this time, even though I ordered a larger pizza, they didnt charge me for the pizza at all! Great customer service

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

Once for carry out and once for delivery. Pizza is the best Ive had for a good long while.

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

I thought I would share our experience with Pelican Jos. We decided to place a delivery order the other night. We ordered a childs pizza, buffalo boneless chicken wings, a calzone and an Italian sandwich. Online ordering was easy to navigate. It said it would take 45 min to receive our order but we got it in 30 min. Everything was SO good!! You can tell how fresh and handmade everything tasted. The kids pizza was bigger than expected but we werent complaining! The amount we spent was almost equal to the amount we spend at the chain pizza establishment. Definitely check them out!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Love that we have a pizza place close to home. It is very good. We like that its not greasy like some can be. We will definitely be back.