Orsini's in Newmarket

16700 Bayview Ave #1, Newmarket, ON L3X 1W1, Canada

★★★★☆
(274 reviews)
Categories: Italian restaurant

About

Orsini's Restaurant has been open for 7 years we are an Italian restaurant in the Newmarket, ON area we offer a variety of options including Seafood, Pata, Beef, Lamb, Ribs, and lots and lots of Italian food.

Website
ristoranteorsini.com
Address
16700 Bayview Ave #1, Newmarket, ON L3X 1W1, Canada
Plus Code
2GRX+63 Newmarket, Ontario, Canada
Time Zone
America/Toronto

Business Hours

Monday
Closed
Tuesday
11 AM–2 PM – 5–8 PM
Wednesday
11 AM–2 PM – 5–8 PM
Thursday
11 AM–2 PM – 5–8 PM
Friday
11 AM–2 PM – 5–9 PM
Saturday
5–9 PM
Sunday
5–8 PM

Services

Service options
Delivery Takeaway Dine-in
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park Wheelchair-accessible entrance Wheelchair-accessible seating Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Offerings
Alcohol Beer Cocktails Coffee Healthy options Small plates Spirits Wine
Dining options
Lunch Dinner Catering Dessert Seating
Amenities
Bar on site Toilets
Atmosphere
Casual Cosy Romantic
Crowd
Groups
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards Debit cards NFC mobile payments Credit cards
Children
High chairs
Parking
Free of charge street parking Free parking lot Parking

Photos

Reviews

4.3
★★★★☆
274 reviews

Most Mentioned

seafood (12) calamari (11) food and service (9) veal (9) feel (8) dining (8) penne (7) plate (6) party (5) business (5)
5 stars
183
4 stars
50
3 stars
11
2 stars
11
1 stars
19
★★★★
September 25, 2024

Came here as part of my Bachelorette party. I was so nervous about the wedding so I only got the soup but it was just what I needed. It was a beef based soup that was filling and flavourful. The tortilla chips added a good crunch. The server was also very nice and we enjoyed talking with her. My friends ordered pasta dishes which were big portions so definitely getting your money's worth. Looking forward to coming back and trying more dishes.

★★★★
June 20, 2024

First time to Orsini, me and my wife enjoy the dinner here. Traditional Italian food, seafood linguine and Veal Fungo. Portion a bit small otherwise it’s perfect. Service is great.

★★★★★
May 30, 2024

Love this place,nice atmosphere amazeing food sooooo good, portions are fair aswell , I can eat alot and dident feel hungry after, had the lasagna and bruschetta to start both where very tasty, tasted authentic also very fresh. Been to alot of Italian restaurants and this one pushed its way to #1 No doubt we will be back!

★★★★★
May 27, 2024

I picked Orsini’s for a family celebration dinner of 20 based on location, reviews and that they had chicken parmigiana on the menu (my son’s fav!). Mike and his team did not disappoint. The food was delicious and tasted like we were in Italy! We were treated like family and felt like we had been going there for years. We now have a favourite spot in Newmarket and can’t wait to go back! Thank you for accommodating our family and making my son’s such a memorable experience!

★★★★★
April 7, 2024

It was the first time at Orsini's by a chance, and what a discovery. The food and the service were excellent. From an appetizer to the main dish, to wine, to macchiato. Delicious. And the service on top of it definitely makes you coming back for more.

★★★★★
April 7, 2024

If you’re ever in Newmarket this place is a gem! It was a low key night with a friend so we didn’t drink or eat as much as we usually do so I will definitely have to go back! Our server was so nice and attentive to us. He made great recommendations and knew the menu very well. Our food was delicious. I’m obsessed with arancini so if it’s in the menu I’m ordering it. They didn’t disappoint. Sold as one ball but a generous enough portion to share. The sauce was delicious! The signature penne orsini was yummy! Pasta cooked perfectly and a balanced amount of toppings with sauce. My friend had the veal parmigiana which she loved and had enough to take some home! We skipped desert and only had sparkling water so it’s on my list to go back when I’m not driving and with a bigger group! Restaurant can definitely accommodate big groups with large comfy booths! Loved this place and would definitely recommend it for others to try!

★★★★★
December 10, 2023

Relaxed Satisfaction at Orsini: A Lunchtime Delight My recent visits to Orsini for lunch were a pleasant culinary experience worth sharing. On both occasions, I opted for different pasta dishes and found the overall atmosphere, service, and food to be quite satisfying. During my first visit, I enjoyed the seafood linguine with oil sauce. The pasta was cooked to a delightful al dente texture, providing a good foundation for the dish. The oil sauce was well-balanced, not too heavy, allowing the flavors of the seafood to shine through. The selection of seafood was fresh and added a nice touch to the overall composition. On my second visit, I tried the pasta of the day, featuring a vegetable sauce. Once again, the pasta was cooked just right. The vegetable sauce, a mix of seasonal veggies, offered a lighter alternative. While not overly intricate, it showcased the freshness of the ingredients and made for a satisfying meal. The service at Orsini was notably friendly and attentive. The staff, including the person serving us, provided helpful recommendations and ensured our needs were met throughout the meal. It was a nice touch that added to the overall positive experience. The atmosphere at Orsini was relaxed, making it an ideal spot for a leisurely lunch. The cozy setting and subtle ambiance contributed to a comfortable dining experience without being too formal. In summary, Orsini offers a solid dining experience with well-prepared pasta dishes, friendly service, and a laid-back atmosphere. While not an over-the-top culinary extravaganza, it's a reliable choice for those seeking a satisfying pasta meal in a relaxed setting. I would comfortably rate Orsini as a solid five stars for its consistent performance in delivering a pleasant dining experience.

★★★★★
February 11, 2022

The best Italian food in Newmarket! It was our first time trying Orsini's, they did not disappoint. All the food we ordered through Uber Eats, was delicious, fresh and came piping hot. Attached are pictures of some of the food we ordered. Garlic bread, pasta al fungo and linguine Portofine. We also ordered the calamari fritti, caprese salad and house salad.This will be our new go to place for Italian food!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 19, 2024

Perfect place for great food and a casual meal.

Local Guide
November 24, 2024

I am sitting here in the restaurant and been here 15 mins and no one has even asked if we wanted a drink. I think its a good sign to just head out, but my wife keeps telling me to be patient, lets see

★★★★★
Local Guide
October 22, 2024

As a repeat visitor to Orsinis, I knew what to expect. The staff are most curteous and friendly. The food, as usual, was excellent. Great value for your money. Its definitely highly recommended. Food

★★★★★
September 22, 2024

Excellent service excellent food high-quality produce very tasty. A very pleasant experience. Definitely will return.

★★★★
Local Guide
September 22, 2024

Old school menu and charm in a newer school environment. Food is fantastic, classic Italian menu but with some creativity, reminds me of what Id find in Little Italy NYC. Service is great, location is convenient (for those in Aurora, Newmarket).

★★★
Local Guide
September 22, 2024

Food was good, service was good. It was just good. Nothing insanely impressive and nothing bad. It was just good.

★★★★★
July 22, 2024

My wife and I had a beautiful meal with excellent service. I would recommend this restaurant and will be returning. Food

★★★★★
Local Guide
July 22, 2024

Great! Italian food in Newmarket, service is great and food is fantastic. Truth

★★★★★
June 22, 2024

I brought my girlfriend here for her birthday and it didn t disappoint. The food and service is worth coming back for . We had the seafood dinner for two ( padella) .

★★★★★
Local Guide
June 22, 2024

Amazing food, great service, and a relaxing atmosphere. I really recommend this hidden gem.

★★★★★
June 22, 2024

Wonderful service, staff and food. Hosted a family event here and it didnt disappoint! Great place!

★★★★★
June 22, 2024

Nice time at this beautiful and delicious restaurant Flavio and Giuseppe amazing guys amazing time there . Out daughter was amazing by the nice and delicious soup .

★★★
April 22, 2024

My daughter made reservations and took me here to celebrate my birthday which is on Valentines Day. When we arrived we were told that we would have to share our booth table with another couple. I ve never heard of this before and the restaurant was not busy and there were other tables available. The waiter was rude when we said that was ridiculous. We ate the mediocre food and left before the other couple arrived. Won t be going back.

★★★★★
April 22, 2024

Had a lovely lunch at Orsini The calamari was exceptionally The caprese salad was delicious Our server was great Food : 5/5 |

★★★★★
Local Guide
April 22, 2024

Fast and quality service accompanying top Italian dishes. Highly recommended.

★★★★★
Local Guide
April 22, 2024

My husband loved his birthday dinner meal here. There was a pork dish on special he liked. My pasta was good too.

★★★
February 22, 2024

Good food but very small portions not worth the cost.Left the restaurant still hungry

★★★★★
Local Guide
February 22, 2024

Friendly, fresh, clean, good veal and rapini dish the spigola was really good

★★★★★
Local Guide
January 22, 2024

Great food , atmosphere and service. Its always a pleasure to dine here. Food : 5/5

★★
Local Guide
January 22, 2024

Food was okay, but overpriced

★★★★★
Local Guide
January 22, 2024

Can t find enough good words to say on delicious food and great companion

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

excellent service and fantastic food 10th time there

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Wonderful meal for New Years, tonight. Great value, fantastic quality and people that enjoy serving their customers. I will continue to return here. I recommend you make a reservation and try for yourself. The shrimp cocktail tonight was superb!! Thank you, Orsini staff!!! Parking: Steps from the door!!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Attentive and friendly servers. Simple and reasonably priced Italian food, especially the desserts.

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Fabulous dining experience at Orsini s! The food was amazing and service was excellent! We took my mom out for dinner for her birthday and had an amazing night! Gratitude and applause to our wonderful server Flavio. He was fun, attentive and really helped make our night special. We will definitely be returning!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Good experience at Orsinis. The food was good, and prices are reasonable. The waiter seemed to forget about us as soon as we didnt order dessert and we waited a while for the bill but at least we werent rushed out. Parking: It could use more lighting at night.

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

2 to dine in. Service was excellent. Food was delicious. Very reasonable price for fine food. Definitely will return to this place and recommend anyone to try this place.

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Excellent food. Wonderful atmosphere. Amazing Enza for her service.. great evening and food.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Great atmosphere

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Fantastic!

December 22, 2023

Mediocre. Four of us went there for dinner. Three of us had Grigliata di Pesce with linguini aglio e Olio, $42/plate. Part of the fish called for crab legs. Instead, we got small knobs of crab in the shell. Pasta portion extremely light. We asked for Extra Virgin Olive oil and balsamic vinegar to dip our bread in. We received some type of light colored oil, NOT Extra Virgin Olive oil. Potato and leek soup was very good. Will not be going back. Will not recommend to anyone.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Great food, good portions, and the best customer service. Been there twice in the past 2 weeks, they never failed to make you feel welcome. Will visit again soon Kid-friendliness: Great service as always, make you feel at home

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

The food was fantastic and the service was on point, thanks to our servers. We will be back and recommend.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Atmosphere: 11/10 Food: 12/10 Flavio: 13/10 Food : 5/5

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Great food, not cheap.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

I loved it. Staff and owner were cool people, food was delicious. Would eat there again!

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Amazing food and great service.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Second time in a month period arrived around 7:15. And very few left in the restaurant. It appears most people go early. Very good service. Had the cannaloni and the veal Mediterranean. Both dishes were very, very good. The house wine is a very good bargain. Enjoyed the experience well come again.

★★★★
December 22, 2023

Food and service are excellent , decor is okay but PLEASE play some music It was like walking into a morgue . Atmosphere is a big part of the dining experience.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

This restaurant is wonderful The food is absolutely fantastic! We had excellent service and the atmosphere is really nice. My husband enjoyed our meal, we were not rushed at all and the server was just the right amount of attentive. I was surprised and sad to see that the patrons were dressed in extremely casual attire. Ripped shorts and tank tops and track pants..... Im not saying dress to the nine, but please dress appropriately, they deserve better than cut off shorts and tank tops.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Delicious food, friendly attentive service. We love visiting this restaurant. Each new dish I try is better than the last.. so far, the Gnocchi is my favorite, but the penne Orsini was packed with great flavors. I love the fact that you can make special requests here if something isnt listed on the menu. They offer a seafood dinner for two, and Ive always skipped past it. We tried their fish & calamari recently & were overly impressed, so I think I might try that seafood dinner sometime when I can tear myself away from ordering their Gnocchi I usually go for.

★★★★★
December 22, 2023

Great food, great service! Best Italian food in Newmarket

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2023

Amazing food and a lovely staff always make for a wonderful dining experience! A bonus is their fabulous light fixtures

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Wow! First time trying it here as weve recently moved into town. Mike is a sweetheart and his chef is excellent. We ordered a bit off the menu even, a white pasta with spicy Italian sausage and it was perfect. We got the mussels and caesar salad and the calamari. Would order all again!! Cant wait to go back and dine in person. The wine selection looked fab

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Great food! Lasagna is amazing. Wonderful, polite staff.

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

Mike and his staff are great. The food is amazing. The fishing and seafood are fantastic. Especially enjoy the fried calamari. Love the espresso.

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

Wow!!!!! Amazing and super clean. Orza was so fun and happy. I made a custom order for a bowl of mussels and they catered to my request on the spot and it was perfect. Service was quick, friendly and perfect. I highly recommend this gem. Hidden and very reasonable prices. Um definitely going back

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

Amazing food and service. Top marks for atmosphere and menu

December 22, 2022

What a ripoff! I ate here with my wife and son on May 8, 2022 (Mothers Day). An elderly lady and gentleman took turns serving us (I am assuming they were the owners). We were given the Dinner Menu, which was a bit strange since we arrived at 12:00 noon, which was lunchtime. Anyway, I had a look at the Dinner Menu and saw that most entrée prices were in the $25-40 range, which I thought was reasonable. Then the lady told us about the Mothers Day specials which were not on the menu. My wife chose a fish filet with rice and veggies, while my son and myself picked the veal chops with potatoes and veggies. My mistake: I did not ask about the prices before ordering, I just assumed that they would be fair and close to the entrée prices on the menu. When I got the bill, boy was I in for a shock! While the fish at $35 was a bit on the expensive side, they charged us a whopping $61 for each veal chop! It was just a normal size veal chop with mushroom sauce, some veggies and two very small slices of potatoes. To add insult to injury, I was still hungry afterwards. The food was good, but these prices were ridiculous. I mean, its a restaurant in an industrial plaza and not on top of the CN tower! This was our first and last visit here. Im not cheap, I just dont like being ripped off.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Very friendly staff, great Italian food. Very reasonably priced wine list with good selection. Great neighbourhood place.

December 22, 2022

I booked a reservation here today. My experience there absolutely terrible. We wanted to order some drinks before we ate but the waiter went straight to our order he might of misheard but we spoke loud and clear. The waiter could care less to tell us any of the recommended foods there. The waiter was also rushing to complete our order. Overall terrible experience and would not recommend!!!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

This place is the only authentic Italian restaurant in Newmarket. If you would like to eat real authentic delicious Italian food you cannot go wrong with this restaurant. Tell Mike what you want hell make it for you. You will get high quality meats, fish and the freshest vegetables, the key to Italian cooking. I usually have the soup which is made from scratch and Ill have penne aglio olio with grilled chicken and rapini, a dish I first had in Florence. Truly a diamond in the rough.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Wonderful experience, professional staff, elegant environment, delicious food authentic Italian eatery, and various options even those that are not on the menu. We really enjoyed our meal and the quality of service provided. Thank you Mike and team!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Wonderfully warm inviting dining experience. Fantastic food, quality ingredients.

Local Guide
December 22, 2022

If I could give zero stars it would have earned it. Worst food we have ever had in a restaurant.

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

Enjoyed an excellent meal here last night. Lovely, fun lady looking after us adding to a delightful experience. All of our meals were exceptional both from the menu and superb specials list. For a special, the chef had prepared one of the best agnolotti I have ever tasted a perfect combination of lemon and cream, chicken and spinach and a ricotta filling. The salad with fresh peaches was outstanding. The ratatouille was perfect. Very pretty, comfortable seating, clean restrooms and easy parking. It is always a lovely experience whenever we return to Orsini s. I highly recommend it..we are never disappointed.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

delicious food, great choices, wonderful service. down to earth wholesome food. highly recommend. thank you so much for such a wonderful evening

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

Great place, terrific food and service! I had the spicy shrimp and it was delicious! Parking: Lots of parking available in the plaza

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

I had the pleasure of dining in this wonderful restaurant! The food was absolutetly amazing and generous portions too. The owner Mike and his staff were very nice, they made us feel very welcomed. I Iook forward to coming back . Highly recommend

★★
December 22, 2022

Food was half decent, service was terrible. We were in a larger group, but people that got there after us, got their full course before we even got our entée. The owner was just going around, talking to random people and being buddy buddys with other patrons in the resturant with people that he knew, instead of making sure that the resturant is operating smoothly. Once again, good food, but the owner needs to get his priorities straight.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Amazing service, amazing food. Will definitely go back.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

The place is beautifully decorated, service was amazing, and the food was to die for. I will definitely be going back

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

Always so good!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Had an amazing experience here! The owner Mike, and the rest of his staff are all incredible. This is the only place where Ive been able to find truly authentic Italian cuisine. Its absolutely clear that they care about quality. HIGHLY recommend. You cant go wrong with anything on the menu.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Great meal, attentive service, and reasonably priced for an authentic Italian dining experience!

★★★★★
December 22, 2022

Came here on a Thursday night and it was amazing. First of all the place is beautiful, especially the hanging lights. It has a fun little Vespa right when you walk in. The service was amazing and they have so much to choose from on the daily specials alone. We were offered some spicy oil for our bread and it was delicious. The prices are also really reasonable especially in todays economy. Absolutely one of the best Italian restaurants in town and will be making it one of my regular places to eat at.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Great menu

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2022

Delicious food and exceptional customer service. The bruschetta is amazing, the manicotti had such a wonderfully light and tasty cheese filling, and the tiramisu was the perfect end to a great meal! Will definitely be back again!

★★
December 22, 2021

The food was tasty, however the portions were very small for the price, I left the restaurant feeling hungry and unsatisfied. The menu you get at the restaurant is significantly smaller than the one you see online, so if there is something you want specifically, Id suggest you call ahead and ensure its an item they still serve. The service was okay, nothing great. The waitress wasnt very attentive and never asked if we wanted drink refills, even after they were placed at the edge of the table and clearly empty. Overall, the food was good, but based on high prices, limited menu options, small portions, and below average service, I wont be returning here nor will i be recommending it to others.

★★★
December 22, 2021

Just not up to previous standard.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Been looking for a good Italian spot close by for sometime. Chicken Alfredo was creamy and tasty. Definitely going back to try something else

December 22, 2021

Worst ever experience. Ceasar salad came with penne pieces and chicken in Rosè sauce with not even a hint on shaved parmesan cheese.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

First time visiting, they were really easy to get a reservation with, and super nice on the phone! Staff were really great and patio was well organized. Food was great too! Will definitely be returning

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

great customer service very nice people food was absolutely amazing just overall a perfect experience

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

11 out of 10 of quality 11 out of 10 of service I cant say enough about each and every savoury dish my wife, daughter and I dive into everytime we eat in. Not to mention the fact that we even order threw skip the dishes sometimes and the quality AND HEAT/TEMPERATURE of the food is just as good as dining in. Please tell Mike (owner) that we send out love when you tackle your pallet with anything and everything on his menu

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

we went there for the first time last sat, enjoyed our dinner very much. nice decor and lightings, seats are comfortable, service is good and food was tasty. well be back

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

It was our first time at Orsinis last night, but it wont be our last. The food was excellent, as was the service. Everyone in our party had a different pasta and they were all wonderful. The portions were also huge and the prices were reasonable given the quality. In addition, the restaurant was also able to handle a peanut allergy, and have gluten free pasta to address celiac disease. I highly recommend Ristorante Orsini!

★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Called to order take out at 8:30 they told me they are closed even though their website says they close at 9pm. Not even a sorry please try tomorrow. Just we re closed, bye How does a restaurant that only serves lunch and dinner close at 8:30pm on a Saturday? Lost me as a potential customer. It saddens me because I love to support local business.

December 22, 2021

Lunch on September 24. I was treating a friend for his birthday. Ordered Seafood Linguini. Seafood consisted of 4 Mussels (2 dead, 1 cracked with splinters in the sauce, 1 containing a tiny mussel) 2 clams (1dead, 1 OK) 6 Squid ovals, so tough they were not edible, 2 crab knuckles with traces of meat impossible to retrieve but shell pieces in the sauce. 1 small scallop which was fine and so were the 2 shrimp. The sauce was tasty, the linguini cooked al dente. Dish was presented in a bowl where pasta and seafood were totally submerged in the brownish sauce. Wine and espresso was good. Overall very disappointing and whoever prepared the linguini should consider a career change since cooking in not in his/her blood. (I was not charged for the espresso)

★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Lunch with friends. Lunch not up to par, my veal was not finished. Service OK and nice ambiance.

★★★★★
December 22, 2021

Went for lunch with friends. Amazing soup, sandwich was very nice, good selection of wine and service was great. All around very happy.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2021

Amazing food and wonderful service! Flavio treated us very well and made our experience one to remember! 10/10 experience!

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Excellent server and delicious food! The pasta was all varied and tasty, and our server was attentive and explained the menu well.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

6 pm 9 people new year dinner. All different food orders are fantastic each. What you pay for what you getting. Service good. Price is good. Specially owner come talking to each person greeting and hosting clean up dishes. ... On and on good things Highly recommend this restaurant. So good !!!!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

My first time. Nice little cozy place thats nicely decorated. Waitress was very pleasant. The Owner ( Well, I think it was the Owner) was working the room making sure everyone was looked after. I had the Veal Parm. Fantastic!! I will definitely be going back.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Good food friendly staff will be back again.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Loved it, food was delicious and tasted as if straight from Italy. It was a little cold in the restaurant though but the food made up for it

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Friendly staff, excellent Italian food!

December 22, 2020

Just overall terrible. Very disappointing horrible service horrible everything. Please save yourself.

December 22, 2020

Food was disgusting. Service was horrible. The owner is a piece of work. Would pay not to go back!

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Great spot for some fine Italian food. Staff is always pleasant.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Professional chefs and friendly staff. So many unique dishes to try I will definitely be back.

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Fantastic meal the whole family really enjoyed. We will fo again for sure.

★★
December 22, 2020

Chose this place for Valentines Day based on the good reviews and was quite disappointed. The evening started out great - hostess was quick to greet us and was pleasant. Were accustomed to having someone come over and take a drink and appetizer order first - not everything at once. Sure, they might have been busy for the occasion but the place isnt exactly huge and that is something you can anticipate and prepare for. It was absolutely freezing (yes, a very cold night but again something you can anticipate and prepare for). The one couple next to us asked to move further from the door and three other couples including us were putting jackets on which should have been more than enough of an indication to the staff to address the issue but nothing was done. One guest even tried to fiddle with a space heater close to us himself. The staff reacted in surprise and a little attitude toward the couple who asked to move. Service was slow. Our second glasses of wine with dinner were forgotten. Nobody came to check on us to see if we were enjoying our meals until we were nearly finished (which was our first opportunity to remind them about our wine). Manicotti was excellent but the seafood in the pasta dish we ordered seemed off. Definitely not fresh. We were super impressed by the bus boy (had lots of time to observe as we were sitting there for longer than we should have been). He was a ninja with refilling guests water and coming over with cheese and pepper. Hopefully he and the hostess get tipped out for their hard work. With so many other Italian options around, with fresh made pasta to boot - we personally will not be returning or recommending to anyone. Sadly I wish our experience was better as it seems to be a desirable spot. Go spend your money at Joia in Aurora instead!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Went with some good friends. Wasnt busy and service was great! They have a complete menu and the food was very good. I would go again

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Went with a large group and the service was amazing. The food came out hot and in a timely fashion and tasted delicious. I had the Penne ala vodka, was one of the best I have had. Alot had the fish special and were very pleased with it. Waters were constantly being topped up without having to ask. Would highly recommend ti anyone looking to enjoy a nice night out for good Italian food.

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Pasta is always good .The two waitresses are great!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Grill Calamari are a must try here. Love their daily fish. Mike the owner is very friendly.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Had a great dinner last night, with this Covid going on they do have a small patio with about 7 8 tables, or you can dine inside. So many great choices here, the fried calamari appetizer and the caprese salad app was incredible. Plenty to choose from for your mains. The Garganzola gnocchi had so much flavour, it was the best Ive had. If you are looking for a quality Italian restaurant in Newmarket, dont bother with the other ones, Ive been to them all. Orsini, to me has the best quality and tasting food. Highly recommended.

★★★★★
December 22, 2020

Love the food here. The staff and owner are excellent. Happy to support a local business that cares

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Staffs are so good. They noticed that we did not start the pasta plate and they offered to reheat for us.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Classy fine dining restaurant, nice service and the food is fantastic

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Great spot

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

Penne alla vodka is amazing!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2020

They serve a delicious calamari

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Service was excellent. Portions were quite large. Price was fair. Food was bland, was missing that zest that would make me say Mmmm this is good.

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

The best Italian food north of Toronto. I drive 45 minutes every two weeks to eat here. Mike is a great chef and owner.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

We really enjoyed Orsinis. I had the Veal Parm and it was quite good, but nothing spectacular. My in-laws had the seafood pasta & raved about it. They were very pleased. Our waiter was very friendly and helpful, we will return!

December 22, 2019

Service: BAD Food: ok Price: OVERpriced My 2 friends and I arrived at 8pm on Sunday evening (January 6, 2019) for dinner. The restaurant looked nice and we were very impressed by the design and atmosphere. The server informed us that the kitchen will close at 9pm and confirmed that the restaurant closes at 10pm. At 9pm, she started walking impatiently, shut down the TV (the only source of music), shut down some lights inside the restaurant, and we suddenly found ourselves in an awkwardly quiet and dim restaurant. I asked her whats going on, she said she is preparing for closing the restaurant. We were surprised and asked: you said that it closes at 10pm! when do you want us to leave the place?? she said: at 9:30pm, since there are no customers. we said: but we are customers!!! were sitting here! she said that there are no NEW customers, therefore the restaurant will close 30 mins earlier. ????? Dear owner, you lost THREE CUSTOMERS and their friends. I called you before posting this review and was very disappointed by your response.

★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Good food but the menu is a bit expensive

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

what a beautiful place and the food was fabulous so will go there again!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Orsinis was absolutely wonderful. The atmosphere was very warm and the service was great. The food was absolutely delicious, fresh and piping hot.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

I went with a group of 15 people. We placed our order a couple days before which I thought was a great idea! I was a bit late but was so happy to see that the food was already being prepared. Almost everyone was satisfied with their meal. I finished all of my penne alla vodka. A lot of people had seafood which everyone loved. The steak was a little dry but it was well done so, expected. I will definitely come again to try their seafood options. The service was also amazing! The only reason Im giving a 4 star is because some of that pasta werent as flavorful and the temperature was quite cold. Id suggest not getting plain pasta dishes.

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

We hosted my sons baptism lunch here and it was wonderful. The food, service and atmosphere were all excellent. Our guests really enjoyed the meal and were very impressed with how attentive the servers were- especially Helene. Highly recommended!

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

I consider myself a harsh critic when it comes to Italian food. After living in downtown Toronto for the past few years and having tried all kinds of Italian I can fully say these dishes are the real deal. Not only are the portions generous but I ve yet to be served a plate that wasn t hot and didnt t stay hot! Quality of food matters to me and if it does to you as well, I highly suggest trying the specials you won t be disappointed! Also if you re unsure which pasta to try first, the Penne Orsini has never let us down.

Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Attended this restaurant for new years eve dinner with my family and it was the worst experience ever... Poor customer service and small portions for an expensive price.. We felt pressured to leave and were rushed out. If I could give you a 0 stars I would... I will not reccomend this place to anyone go somewhere else where you will feel appreciated.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Great place. Food was fantastic.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Delicious. Knowledgeable staff.

★★★★
December 22, 2019

Delicious but the customer service is a bit rude

Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Im writing comments here not because of the foods but the female owners attitude. The lady treated customers unfairly made me feel shame of her. Yesterday was a Valentines Day. I went there with my husband without reservation. The lady told all tables were reserved (without placing the reserved tag on table), the only table available was next to the front door. We could only accept it as its almost 8pm & I believed its fully booked like the other restaurants. After couple minutes, another couple walked in to the restaurant without making any reservation, she leaded them to the other table inside. So did the other few couples came after me. There were at least 7 or more tables available when the time I came. I wanted to ask the lady why she treated customers differently. My hubby asked me not to be angry & ruined our mood to enjoy the Valentines dinner. He said just gave less tips. I didnt agree as the server was good. I told to the server my gut feeling when I paid the bill & he said he couldnt say something as the lady boss would scold him. As a business owner, you should treat customers fairly unless there are some trouble customers. I do hope the female owner can read this comment & do some reflections. I didnt complain to her directly but I will not go to this restaurant again.

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

Lovely! Wine list, menu and atmosphere are wonderful.

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

Love this place, amazing food, great service, wonderful owners

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Food is always very tasty and the staff are pleasant. Parking can be hard to find during the day. Big lot but many people use building.

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

Excellent food services and reasonably priced.

★★★★
December 22, 2019

We like this spot. Good food and good service.

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

Very great food and awesome service from the owners themselves

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Simply great

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Delicious!

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

Cool

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

Extremely accommodating. Very professional and courteous staff.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Great location. Nice and friendly employees Good but simple meals. Not overpriced. Always a great restaurant for a quick lunch or dinner.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Good food, good service and good people.

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

I drive from Bolton to have a decent meal , And service is amazing , I will be back

December 22, 2019

Horrible service. Horrible food. Would never return

Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Terrible. Save your money.

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

Great food

Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Dropped in for dinner without reservations. It were not even half full, but would not take myself and my friend. I will never return.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

My wife and I went for the first time to Orsinis July 23. I could finish righ here the review by saying we will definitely be back. The food has been described as simple which is true, simple and perfectly cooked, moist chicken, perfect vegetables. Service was friendly. The price was more than fair. Orsinis is a nice family restaurant and our family will go back.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Everything was great.

★★★★★
December 22, 2019

Tasty food

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Excellent food, service, and ambience. The tvs are a little distracting, though, and are the only thing that separates this from an upscale fine dining restaurant.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Great traditional Italian food.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Amazing dishes, reasonable prices all around great experience from every visit

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Very good food at a reasonable price. You wont find pizza on the menu but all that means is they are focusing on making specific dishes very well. I had the bruschetta, calamari, chicken parm, and tiramisu. All very good. Will go back.

★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

The service was slow, the waitress took really long to bring us waters to the table. The food cost was about $20-$25 per plate. I had the soup of the day which was a red pepper bisque $11 and it was okay in taste. Nothing to write home about. I also had the seafood pasta, the salmon pasta and the mussels. The pasta were a bit on the bland side with a big too much salt. The mussels $12 were tasteless and the bread for the table was cold ( not sure if that is how they serve it). The place was pretty though and the washrooms were well kept and there was free parking. At the end of the night, some gentleman came over to ask how our foods were ( not sure who he was) and the waitress made small talk at the ending of the night when the bill came. Not sure if I would go there again.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Caesar salad is superb. Delicious pasta. Nice place and attentive service.

★★★
December 22, 2019

Price is responsible.

★★★★
December 22, 2019

Great place to eat authentic Italian food!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Lovely

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Mike, his wife and all the Orsinis staff are very welcoming and friendly. The atmosphere is inviting and the food is awesome. If youre craving great Italian food, this is the place in Newmarket to go, youll love it, we do.

★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

We were the only table in the restaurant and we waited 45 minutes for our food.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2019

Always great food and service

★★★★
December 22, 2018

My husband and I love this restaurant!! Great food! I had the grilled calamari today which was perfectly cooked and the linguini seafood was simply delicious! The service is always good, we had Enza today and she was a delight. The prices are also very affordable.

★★★★★
December 22, 2018

Birthday celebration, all arrangements were made in advance. Management and staff very attentive. Excellent customer service. We will definitely be going back. Thanks.

★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

We shared a caprese salad and we both had the manicotti. The tomatoes in the salad had been in the refrigerator so long that they were ice cold and had started to wilt. The manicotti took forever. The homemade pasta was excellent but the filling had way too many breadcrumbs, was way too salty, and overspiced (nutmeg?). We couldnt taste the cheese at all. I think this is the first time either of us has left manicotti on the plate. Add in the relatively high prices and we wont be back. There are several other Italian restaurants in the area that are much better.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

Food is good . Atmosphere very nice. However any time I have gone there (4)times .We find it quite cold. Service is also good. Price for food good, but wine prices in my opinion are high.

★★★★
December 22, 2018

Simple Italian meals, very tasty and the owner carries the place. They need a younger more vibrant serving staff to attract the business lunch crowd but the meals are excellent and fresh. When they get a wood burning oven then Id rate it a five star.value for money wont disappoint. Bring the kids and enjoy authentic Italian cuisine at a price that wont disappoint.

★★★★★
December 22, 2018

Great food and atmosphere

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

All the dishes we had were delicious. Highly recommended the mushroom risotto, calamari. Actually any any seafood dish will do.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

The lasagna is unreal. Do yourself a favour and try it . Because you will LOVE IT

★★★★★
December 22, 2018

Nice place and great food. Will go again

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

Always an enjoyable place. Always great food and great service!

★★
December 22, 2018

average at best

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

Took my son and his girlfriend out for dinner on a Sunday night. It was a little later and the restaurant was not that busy at the time, being after dinner hour. We were treated very well, waitress was lovely. No rushing at all. Food was excellent. I would go back any time I am in the area.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

Very good food and great service

★★★★★
December 22, 2018

Food was great at a reasonably price would highly recommend you go.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

Had the penne arabiatta... amazing! My wife had the muscles, she was very Impressed as well. Finally found a good restaurant in Aurora as good as Joia

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

Fabulous experience. Great atmosphere, friendly and accommodating staff, fantastic food... The best dining experience Ive had in a while!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

Good food and good service give it a try

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

Great food, nice ambiance, good location .

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

Loved the atmosphere. Went for my mother-in-laws 70th birthday. The food was delicious and the staff was very attentive. We brought our 1 and 4 year olds, and they were doted on all night by the staff. Truly a family friendly establishment.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

The most welcoming restaurant I have ever been to. The owners personally greet you at the door, making one feel so warm. The service was on point. Now the food was so tasty we all eat our plates clean. Delicious.

★★★★★
December 22, 2018

Three of us had different pasta dishes, all were excellent. We will definitely be back.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

Fairly priced with great food. Staff is pleasant and makes you feel at home. Menu is detailed and doesnt leave much to imagination. Genuinely one of the better Italian restaurants in the area. Everything was clean from bathrooms to cutlery

★★★★
December 22, 2018

Very authentic Italian cuisine.

★★★★
December 22, 2018

Best calamari I ve ever had but one star off because the straw in my shirley temple was too short and it was hard to drink

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

Food was outstanding !

★★★★★
December 22, 2018

Excellent!!

★★★★★
December 22, 2018

Best italian restaurant around!!! Hands down! Food is authentic and delicious, atmosphere is beautiful and super clean and the staff is perfect, prompt and very polite! The owner Mike prides himself in his business and his food and the quality of service he provides! You gotta eat here! You will love it!

★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

Its nice and cozy set up. Prices are up there and food is ok. Service is good.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

Great atmosphere, great service and wonderful food

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

Awesome place!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 22, 2018

I have been before and wasnt very impressed, but this time I was pleasantly surprised - the food was delicious!