Pie Guys Pizzeria in Niagara Falls

8278 Thorold Stone Rd Unit1A, Niagara Falls, ON L2H 1A9, Canada

★★★★☆
(324 reviews)
Categories: Pizza takeaway
Website
pieguyspizzeria.ca
Address
8278 Thorold Stone Rd Unit1A, Niagara Falls, ON L2H 1A9, Canada
Plus Code
4V76+HW Niagara Falls, Ontario, Canada
Time Zone
America/Toronto

Business Hours

Monday
11:30 AM–9 PM
Tuesday
Closed
Wednesday
Closed
Thursday
3–8 PM
Friday
11:30 AM–9 PM
Saturday
12–9 PM
Sunday
3–8 PM

Services

Service options
Delivery Takeaway Dine-in
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Offerings
Late-night food
Dining options
Dinner
Amenities
Toilets
Atmosphere
Casual
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards Debit cards NFC mobile payments Credit cards
Parking
Parking

Photos

Reviews

3.9
★★★★☆
324 reviews

Most Mentioned

wings (69) cooked (16) pepperoni (10) subs (9) call (8) thursday (6) toppings (6) steak (5) tray (5) cold (5)
5 stars
196
4 stars
35
3 stars
20
2 stars
24
1 stars
49
★★★★★
October 28, 2024

Owen, John and staff went above and beyond meeting dietary restrictions for gluten-free and onion allergy. Very pleased with how careful they were and how seriously they took it. Will definitely be coming back!!!

★★★★
October 3, 2024

Gentleman was very friendly. Service was great. Nice clean restaurant. Happy when pizzerias have a washroom. The pizza was very good. Didn't even know they were the best in Niagra. Overall good pizza. Good service

★★★★★
July 7, 2024

I’m actually a bit of a pizza snob and I am shocked that this pizza place only has a 3.9 rating. Honestly Niagara Falls doesn’t have a great pizza scene so maybe people in this area prefer low quality pizza but this pizza is darn good. Great chew on the crust, nice sauce, high quality toppings. I’ve had it twice now and was pleasantly surprised both times .

★★★★★
November 13, 2023

Wow! Great cheesy pizza and bomb wings!! Got the 12 slice with 2lbs . Hot Buffalo and Cajun, both so delish!! 🔥 see you again for sure

★★★★
November 1, 2023

Order from here on the regular. The pizza is top notch as are the wings - they are large and always cooked perfectly! I encourage you to order on wing night - Tues and Thurs for 1/2 price. They offer cup and char pepperoni which is my favorite (kids find it a little spicy so we don't always get it) and I get the wings Buffalo style. My picture is from the next day lol, so its much better fresh :). The only reason I didn't give 5 stars is the wait time is an issue, I can never order when in a hurry - last night waited an hour, other times have been told an hour and got there and waited another 30 mins. Busy is good, and I don't mind waiting for fresh food, but it means some nights I cannot order from here.

★★★
July 8, 2023

The pizza and wings were good! A little doughy for my liking but good. I would rate higher but when compared to other pizza joints around it was a bit more pricey. So now I asked myself did the pizza taste that much better to value that price difference i don't think so.

June 10, 2023

We ordered dry Cajun crispy wings which came rare and bloody . We called and they wanted photos which I sent a photo of the inside of the raw wing . She asked for photos of all the wings so I did send a photo of the other uncooked wings I had put on my plate . The other wings were probably red inside as well . They were trying to figure out how many were raw ! Lol what a joke ! They were seriously only going to give us a few rings! Horrible pizza as well ! They were not interested in making it right . Never going there again

★★★
May 28, 2023

The wings were great! The pizza was great! But they could have put the wings in the bag standing up so when I brought it home I don’t stand it up by accident and the sauce leaks everywhere. The containers would fit that way. Also, if you see the pizza, the one stand to keep the box from touching the toppings was put upside down. No, I didn’t do it on purpose. When we took it off, it was embedded. You can see it on the pizza.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 9, 2024

The pizza was very good the sauce no and the guy at the front was very friendly.

★★
December 2, 2024

$33 for a party tray with 1 topping

★★★★★
November 23, 2024

Came in for a quick slice. One of the best peperoni slices I have ever had. Clean place and friendly staff.

November 23, 2024

Lack of customer service

★★★★★
November 23, 2024

We get Pie Guys on Thorold Stone once a week! Hats off to the chef, the pizza is consistently delicious. Excellent service too!

★★★★★
Local Guide
November 23, 2024

Tasty. Like how the green peppers were actually tasted roasted instead of raw like chain pizzeria usually do. The wings were solid too.

★★★★★
November 23, 2024

Best steak sub ever.... best meatball sub... both fully loaded!

★★★★
Local Guide
November 23, 2024

Good place to get wings. Half off on Tuesdays and Thursdays! Fast and friendly service.

★★★★★
October 23, 2024

Awesome pizza! Weve never been disappointed! Wings are always great. Have tried a few of the sides as well and everything has been great!

Local Guide
September 23, 2024

Run down dive. Pizza was just grease on a thin sheet of grease. I picked it up in Niagra Falls to take to my hotel a half hr away and couldnt even eat it.

★★★★★
September 23, 2024

This is good shiz. Niagara Falls is very competitive for good pizzaand this is one of the good ones. The dough is fresh and soft. *chefs kiss.

★★★★★
August 23, 2024

Their walk in special is better quality then any other business. I rather pay a couple more bucks for quality any day.

★★★★★
August 23, 2024

Awesome pizza shop close to Niagara region, their 1lb wings for 8.99 cant be beat.

July 23, 2024

Tried calling and the phone number didnt even work

★★★★★
July 23, 2024

Best pizza and wings around! Great staff too!!

★★★★★
Local Guide
July 23, 2024

Hands down the best pie in the city. It was the tragedy of 2024 that the McLeod location closed, but the location on Kalar and 58 is cranking out absolute works of art. Simply the best.

June 23, 2024

Way over priced! $73 for 2 subs with no fries and chicken fingers. The fries were under cooked and the chicken fingers were burnt. Ordered pizza before and was also burnt, will never order from there again!!!

★★★★★
June 23, 2024

DOMINATE PIZZA AND WINGS

★★★★★
May 23, 2024

Pizza and wings were spot on

★★★
April 23, 2024

Wings are good except they are overdone and hard to chew. Im a senior with teeth issues, something to consider. Thank you.

★★★★
Local Guide
March 23, 2024

Small place with very limited seating. Ok. Thats it for the negatives. The food is absolutely delicious and a good bang for your buck. Staff is very friendly and welcoming. Highly recommend thier pizza with the cup and char pepperoni.

★★★★★
Local Guide
February 23, 2024

Had an Uber coupon and decided to try . Gotta say I m sooo picky on pizza.. usually order from franks which is good but cheap on toppings.. pie guys is the best pizza I have had in 5 yrs of living in Niagara .its not cheap by any means but its the best why waste money and be disappointed.. from now on its pie guys or nothing!!! And if you knew how picky I was you would know that s a HUGE COMPLIMENT LOL

★★★★
Local Guide
February 23, 2024

Decent food but expensive and really long delivery and pickup times. And, why do you close at 9pm on a Saturday??? Argh

★★★★★
January 23, 2024

We ordered 7 trays and wing combo for a bowling group for Christmas. As usual everything was great you guys never disappoint. Keep up the great job.

January 23, 2024

Paid more than $40 for a tray delivered. A miscommunication with the person on the phone apparently. Got a topping that my daughter is allergic to that wouldnt even cross my mind to order because of that. Good news though! They offered a credit for a free topping on my next order. What a joke. Wont order here and wouldnt suggest it.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2023

We are already a fan of their wings and pizza, but had some issues with their subs. Gave them one more try the other night and was definitely happy. The steak subs were awesome especially the sub buns. If everything remains the same well be ordering subs again for sure.

★★★★★
December 23, 2023

Awesome wings this side of the border, pizza & steak subs...

★★★★★
December 23, 2023

I had a great experience with pie guys! I had a very large and complicated order but Rebecca was extremely helpful in describing my options and helping me decide. The food was delivered on the time we agreed on and it was absolutely delicious! Will definitely go back again.

★★★
December 23, 2023

Pizza taste it OK, It was way too thin and not cut always through.. Service staff are friendly..

★★★★
December 23, 2023

Very good pizza. Accurate orders, even when the orders are large.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2023

Excellent friendly neighborhood pizzeria. Parking: Parking is not the greatest, seems some what dangerous Food : 5/5 |

★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2023

Pizza crust and slices not the same size. Ordered wings saucy and hot and ended up with barbecue sauce

★★★
December 23, 2023

We have tried this location 3 times now. Our latest we ordered a tray with 3 pounds of wings and deep fried pickles. Wings were dynamite but we were given deep fried jalapeños instead of pickles even though the box said pickles. They were really good. Pizza was okay, not the best, not the worst.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2023

This was my second time here, wings were great just like they were the first time I came. I tried the gluten-free pizza and was pleasantly happy with it. The gluten-free pizza dough was surprisingly good, then, not too crumbly, not to doughy, well seasoned, well cooked. The cheese and toppings were also good quality, good proportions, cooked right and very tasty. The sauce for me was just okay. It wasnt bad, but nothing special. Service was friendly and my order was ready when it was supposed to be. Definitely will be back.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2023

Amazing food!Everything tastes amazing!!!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2023

All around a great experience, good deals, great service pizza and wings were good. Store was very clean. We will definitely be back.

December 23, 2023

May 31, 2023 walked in pie guys in Niagara Falls Ontario. Showed the casher a picture of a review of a pizza they made loaded with pepperoni just the way we love it. No problem, so I ordered it for 2 hours later. Sorry to say picked up my loaded pepperoni pizza and guess what? They decided to draw a bull s-eye with the pepperoni. I told the front line workers look right on your store window, pizza loaded with pepperoni no bull s-eye.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2023

Their pizza and wings are excellent. The wings seem a bit pricey, but theyre huge and they have a good special on them Tuesdays and Thursdays.

December 23, 2023

The pizza tends to be quite good or quite bad. Last night was bad. Basically you couldnt even take a slice out of the box since the dough was uncooked/wet/floppy. We had to put the pizza in our own oven only to end up with an overcooked pizza since its not a pizza oven. Its like rolling the dice ordering from there. We had the same experience 3 weeks ago. Its a shame because the place is close to us and when its good its good. There needs to be better consistency in who is actually cooking the pizza.

December 23, 2023

Pizza was gross, uneven thickness which resulted in the centre being paper thin. Burnt all over and puddles of sauce. Barely any topping. I have no problem paying for decent pizza but this is by far the worst I have ever been served.

★★★★★
December 23, 2023

Incredible place. Amazing wings, great pizza, friendly staff. Couldnt recommend enough.

★★★★★
December 23, 2023

Great pizza! Wings special on Tuesday & Thursday is amazing

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2023

My favourite pizza in Niagara! Definitely worth the price. Delivered in a reasonable time, and delicious!

December 23, 2023

Told me 30 minutes and I ve been waiting 25 minutes in the restaurant. 3 orders have gone out after my order. Not impressed.

December 23, 2023

Worst stuff!!

★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2023

Online order wasnt the best experience, unfortunately... I asked to remove the cheese on my pizza and that didnt work out. Also my family had another order which was 40 minutes late and was missing a lot of items! For the one time I am visiting Canada... Its quite a disappointment.

★★★
December 23, 2023

Consistency.. this is why this place gets a 3.. my wife and I have had nights where its spot on but too many nights have been not even close.. I think this name on the wall has all the right idea but unfortunately we are all at the mercy of the staff that is in place.. definitely give this place a try bc when they are on point they are really good!!!! This is just my review after many attempts.

★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2023

Pizza looked good and is highly rated but it wasn t too good for me. It seemed like there was no sauce on my pizza, just cheese and pepperoni. I wouldn t go back as a result.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2023

Delicious every time..... Which is once a week. Food

★★★★★
December 23, 2023

Great pizza and wings!!!

December 23, 2023

Ordered a steak sub and a poutine... was told 35 minutes ended up waiting 60 minutes and then I get home to a 10.99 bowl of gravy soup with cold French fries.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2023

Awesome food as usual and great service. Thanks Pie Guys

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2023

Excellent wings ! Had to wait for it though, at least 1 hr. Worth the wait!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2023

The pizzas really good.

★★★★★
December 23, 2022

Great Friendly Service, Hot n Fresh, On Time and Amazing Pizza. We had The New Yorker and Now Have Our New Pizza Place!

Local Guide
December 23, 2022

Very poor and inconsistent cooking. Many times Niagara Falls location has been a disappointment. Wings overcooked and lacking the required sauces. Avoid this location and order from the Mac Turnbull location in St.Catharines. We order Pie Guys every week. We have given them many chances to improve, very hit and miss with quality. Well we tried them again January 4 2022 , burnt pizza and overcooked wings yet again.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2022

Excellent Pie. A little pricey but very tasty.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2022

Swift and sharp business

Local Guide
December 23, 2022

Less ingredients even though paid extra charges for cheese, mushroom... So dissapppppponited!

★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2022

I am a PizzaExpert on YT and did a video review of this pizza. First off- it s a softer bottom crust. I asked for it to be thinner crust than usual and it was like a pan crust from Pizza Hut. Second- it was a saucy pie. While the cheese wasn t great it had good cheese coverage. The excess sauce made up for cheese flavour. It s generally an above-average (for Niagara) pizza. Niagara doesn t have great pizza though. See my video review for more

★★
December 23, 2022

Thinnest pizza ever, one of those pizzas where you have to fold a slice in half to eat. Everything falls right off. Not enough cheese & 3 pepperoni on a slice

Local Guide
December 23, 2022

Average cardboard style pizza ...very cheap on the toppings....ugh

★★★★★
December 23, 2022

Amazing staff, amazing food.

★★★★
December 23, 2022

Pizza and wings were good and service at the counter was professional and polite.

★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2022

Brutal delivery. Weve had issues with both delivery services and calling direct to the store. Today we called early only to receive a call at delivery time to let us know that they messed up the order taking. The weekend staff is especially bad. If you need a reliable food service, i would choose somewhere else. Great pizza and wings though.

★★★★★
December 23, 2022

That cup and char pizza might be my new favourite pizza.

★★★★★
December 23, 2022

it was awesome, i recomens it

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2022

Pizza and wings are 10 out of 10! Will definitely come again next time we are in the area! Delicious

★★★★★
December 23, 2022

My family enjoyed delicious pizza and wings from your establishment. I was greeted by a very polite young lady at the register. Thank you for being open on an extremely hot day as we can relate to working in such a hot kitchen. Much appreciated, Thank you!

★★★★★
December 23, 2022

Best pizza I have had for sure

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2022

I heard a lot about this place how good the pizza was and it is fantastic very good from here definitely worth ordering the staff great there too

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2022

Parking: Lots

Local Guide
December 23, 2022

had a pie last Saturday. terrible. how can a pizza be soggy and burnt at the same time. Im not sure how it gets great reviews unless I just got a bad pizza on a bad night.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2022

Yummy! Had the steak pizza and was very pleased! My son made his own concoction and was equally impressed. Loved the crust. Service was good. Will add to the list of great places to order from.

★★★
December 23, 2022

I didnt think the pizza was worth the money and the wings didnt impress me at all wont be going back

Local Guide
December 23, 2022

Just ordered pizza and wings and the pizza is literally paper thin on the side with mushrooms. I paid $50 for this order and it s cold and the pizza is disgusting. I will not be ordering from there ever again. Super disappointed. Glad I didn t tip them well

★★
December 23, 2022

Went in for a slice at 12:30 in the afternoon. Prices have gone up on the slices, all while being so thin you cant even pick it up. A piece of paper might be thicker, might fill you up more too. 2 stars because it tasted alright. But almost not pizza. I can usually pick pizza up with my hand.

Local Guide
December 23, 2022

Ordered pizza and wings last night. The pizza was so thin and floppy. Some of the wings weren t cooked thoroughly so we had to cook them some more. Overall this place is a little too expensive and their product is less than good. Won t be ordering anytime soon.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2022

Great service Great pizza

★★★★★
December 23, 2022

Amazing pizza and wings, thank you! Not only a great price, but well worth the quality!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2022

** Jumbo Wings Special** every Tuesday and Thursday... $7.99 per pound.

★★★★★
December 23, 2022

Amazing food, amazing staff, didnt have to wait long for my food

★★★★★
December 23, 2022

Great place to get Wings!!!!! Friendly service. Great value!!!! Strongly recommend. Easily one of the top places in town

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2022

Can t say enough good things about this place. Such nice service, the best pizza and subs. Generous portions and excellent quality. Can t wait to return and glad I tried it! Always love supporting such friendly local places.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2022

Best pizza around

Local Guide
December 23, 2022

**WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE EVER** I had a skip pickup order. Reached @ 6:43pm as expected. There were 3 customers waiting for their order, and they left within 5/7 minutes. Cashier told me your order will be ready asap. Waited patently for 15 minutes. Later, Cashier told me ur order is coming out from oven and will take 2 minutes but still it wasnt ready till 7:14pm. When I started leaving @ 7:15pm without taking order, a young guy came out from kitchen and aggressively started yelling at me that I couldnt leave. He was very rude and was clearly passing racist comments on me. Pathetic Customer Service. **Order was simple 2 Medium Pizza and 2 wings.** **I waited there for more than Half Hour with no one to give me an update. You can see in the Image.** **0 Recommendation** **0 Customer Service**

December 23, 2022

Worst customer service

December 23, 2022

<<< Horrible Pizzeria & Customer Service in Niagara Region >>>

★★★
December 23, 2021

We tried these guys after another regional Pizza place messed up our order really bad 2 times on a row. At first they were great but they too have messed up twice. First time our order did not print in the kitchen so when i went to pick up it was not ready, they did deliver it ( we live in Thorold South and NO one will deliver to us without a $10 charge and places like skip the dishes will not do it at all) and was supposed to give us a gift certificate but instead they messed up the order and i had to pick up the certificate the next day. Today i waited on hold for 17 minutes and told i was next in line only to have the phone ring like i was a new caller and bumped me BACK in line to 4th. So after being on hold for 35 minutes told it would take an hour. Called back to cancel and they answered right away.

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

You won t be disappointed! Unbelievable food and the staff is super friendly and accommodating! So happy to have a location in the falls!

★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

The pizza was good when we finally got it and got home. But service was slow, took almost an hour from time we ordered to receiving. But I guess that is better then the one in St.Catharines where I never received my food all together. My friend and I waited in my car while we waited and she kept checking every 5mins to see if ready. So no it didnt just sit there waiting for us to go back in. It was piping hot when we got it.

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Pie Guys is off the chain! If you are looking for super delicious authentic pizza, you are looking for Pie Guys. Fresh ingredients, with the most amazing crust. Do yourself a favour, stop reading reviews and order now, you wont be sorry!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

The lady on the phone was super friendly. Other businesses can learn from this! Delivery was quick. Food was hot. Pizza and wings were awesome. Wings are giant. I ordered extra sauce because the big wings soak up sauce and it was perfect. Hot wings had just the right amount of heat. My new regular pizza place.

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Loved it best pizza in along time

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Great Pizza and WIngs. Staff is always friendly. Raady on time and always hot. You may not find a better option in NIagara for wings!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Ordered a few times, has been excellent and consistent. Hot, fresh ingredients and never disappoints! The last time there was a slight mishap, and they gave us an entire additional pizza for free! Highly recommended. The pizza and wings combo is a bang for your buck without a doubt, lots of food with enough to enjoy in the morning!!

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Our family loves Pie Guys Niagara falls!! Thanks for the amazing food, as always!! For now on I will order directly and not through a delivery company!! Thanks for all your hard work, keeping Niagara fed. Ps- those wings tho

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Delicious!

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

The Pizza and wings were amazing! Thank you Faith for your help with my order when I called. Will definitely order there again Delivery was on time as well!

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Pizza was delicious. Staff were friendly.

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Great pizza and wings. Counter staff at the store were great for or pick up.

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Great pizza and wings. Exceptional service, quality ingredients, and friendly staff. Will definitely be ordering from Pie Guys again in the near future.

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Great place! Amazing staff and amazing pizza and wings!!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Go to place for pizza and wings. Subs are good to!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Great Pizza!! Has become a favourite in our house

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Absolutely, hands down, the BEST pizza and wings ( their wings are unreal) in Niagara Falls! Also their staff ( Becca and Sienna) are incredible. You will NOT be disappointed!!! A++

December 23, 2021

If I could give zero stars I would. I ve been visiting this establishment since it opened because I do enjoy the pizza. Unfortunately more often than not there seems to be a problem with this or that, so your order will not be ready when you get there on time. Also it probably won t be ready 15mins after you arrive there. Unacceptable for a business that is takeout. I happily will never order from this place again and suggest you do the same. Support local just not this place!

December 23, 2021

Horrible restaurant, repeatedly cancelled my order for no reason. Do not order from here

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Great Pizza hand crafted by an excellent staff!

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

We order from here all the time and tonight was the best amazing pizza, Caesar salad, Garlic bread and wings OMG delicious! the best we have ever had from here. Tons of cheese and real ingredients, keep it up! we will keep ordering from here.

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Amazing food and even better customer service :)

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Great pizza and wings.

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Great tasting pizza and wings!!!! Super friendly staff!!! I will definitely be a repeat customer

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Great service great pizza

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Tried Pie Guys in Niagara Falls for the first time tonight. Best pizza and wings I have had in a very very very long time! Will definitely be back!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

From the initial order to pick staff were great to deal with. They helped with my order and made some suggestions with my order. The pizza and wings were great and as ordered. The whole family enjoyed it and will order again from Pie Guys.

December 23, 2021

The two dipping sauces were missing and the pizza was extremely under done. We just received it and it is currently in our oven, it was inedible. So annoyed!

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Best pizza and wings in Niagara Falls Seriously. Stop reading this and get an order in ! Bravo !!

★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Ive ordered their wings a few times and was always pleased... until last Thursday. I always order the same thing, so I know what to expect. When I picked them up last time, the box was smaller and there was definitely less wings. When I asked, the girl said its right as she walked away from me.... great service. So being as I was in a hurry, I took her word for it When I got home, the first thing I noticed was they were burnt. I mean, severely over fried. To the point that when you bit into a wing, it crumbled and flaked. Now I actually decided to count the wings, and they were definitely a pound short. (Before anyone asks, Im from the restaurant industry, I know how many wings comes in a pound and that it varies with the size of wing ordered). I was annoyed so decided to call, and was left on hold for 15 minutes before being disconnected..... Im sure someone was having a bad day and simply made some mistakes...but the girl not even investigating my original.concern and then sending out a clearly overcooked product and then leaving someone on hold and not taking the call because you know they are an unhappy customer? Too many things to forgive. There are plenty of wing places in Niagara, and unfortunately this one wont see my money again

★★★★
December 23, 2021

Pizza was excellant.my go to place in Falls.

★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Pizza was burnt

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

First time ordering last week. We really enjoyed the pizza & wings! The wings were huge must try Forty Creek BBQ sauce! We loved it! Pizza had cup & char pep & it was also delicious! Thanks Pie Guys!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Best wings. Pizza is good.

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Pie Guys Pizzeria is the best in town and never fails to deliver a delicious pie baked to perfection!! Their chicken wings are by far the best in town! This pizzeria has a friendly staff that always makes you feel welcome.

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Best pizza AND wings in Niagara! Greek pizza is amazing, classic cheese and pep is just is good. Cant go wrong here.

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Great customer service & fresh delicious pizza!

★★★★
December 23, 2021

Pizza was burnt

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Cup and char pepperoni all I have to say

December 23, 2021

Ordered over 100 dollars in food and received raw pizza and dried chicken wings absolutely DISGUSTING AND NO RESPONSE FROM A MANAGER OR ANYONE ABOUT IT

★★★
December 23, 2021

Its one thing to mess up an order once in a while, but this is the third time in a row even after i asked to verify the pizza was done right and daughter wouldnt eat it.. you guys make great pizza get it together and do stuff right please!

December 23, 2021

Horrible

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

So Ive ordered twice from this new pizzeria and it isnt your run of the mill pizza place. The price is high but you get what you pay for, this is gourmet pizza with gourmet toppings, real sausage, real bacon and the cheese is fantastic. Support local businesses like The Pie Guys.

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Ordered the steak sub , with double steak, 12oz. Hands down the best steak Ive ever had. Better than Sammys or Violas over the river. It was $19.50 taxes in. Well worth the money. Hopefully it stays the exact same way for years to come. Ill definitely go back.

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Best pizza and wigs in town

December 23, 2021

Very poor customer service , called 21 minutes befour close, was on an auto system transfer befour hand, the employee then answered and placed me on hold she came back after and said sorry we can not take orders now we are closing in 10 minutes and a large pizza can t be done, 100% has lost a local customer who has spent a lot of money here, further the last few times the quality has been sub par !

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

The girl on the phone i think her name was Giovanna was the sweetest girl on the phone. She took my order and repeated it back to make sure everything is correct. This place has the nicest people ever cant wait to order again

★★
December 23, 2021

Have ordered a few times from here, usually a half decent pizza. Customer service is always pleasant. Delivery usually sooner than expected but not always. Doneness varies despite requests. Ordered a pizza with 3 toppings, one being pineapple that may as well have not been there at all. It was white in appearance and had no taste to it whatsoever. Wings are mediocre, same you find at every mediocre pizza place. My search continues for a decent pizza in Niagara.

★★
December 23, 2021

Twice now in the last couple months that the pizza is soggy in the middle where the crust is almost nonexistent.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

I ordered pizza and a meatball sub. The pizza had lots of toppings and tasted delicious. The sub was very good as well. I cant wait to try more of their food.

★★
December 23, 2021

Ordered a tray of pizza and 2 pounds of wings, unfortunately only got 1lb in the box, I called the store to ask for my other pound and a little extra for having to go all the way back on their mistake. They refused to go above and beyond, and you will gladly fail as a business if you don t for your customers. The 5$ at wholesale it would ve costed you to give me wings, is way cheaper than the customer you just lost forever, plus the people that customer says about you guys, plus the google review you re reading.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Yummy pizza and Cajun wings

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Good pizza last evening

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Large wings done right. Pizza crust and topping are not skimped on. We had 4 lbs wings, buffalo hot, 40 creek, salt and pepper,honey hot. Tray with cup and char and sausage. Definitely will order again.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Addendum April 20th: changed to 5 star. Original review: I anticipate eventually changing this rating to 5 stars, because initially the wait was very long and the food was inconsistent. However, over the past few months the dough has improved, the pizza is better when its slightly more well done and the organization overall is definitely improving and rhe customer service was and still is very good. Biggest drawback right now is the hours are limited, as they dont open til 3 and they close most days at 10. My typical order is a cheese or BBQ chicken pizza with wings, the medium buffalo wings are great and not very spicy. Again, I would suggest slightly well done on the pizza. This is right ok the edge of a 5 star for me, maybe if they keep up the great work Ill be changing this in the future.

★★
December 23, 2021

Im giving it 2 star because yesterday night I tried to get wings and I know its wasnt the girl fault on the phone. Jovanna called me telling me that unfortunately we only had drumsticks left and no flats left. I was execpeting jumbo wings like usually but the pizza was good. Girl was super sweet really appreciated her letting me place an order last minute.

December 23, 2021

Total RIP-OFF advertising Jumbo Wings for a price of $12 to have received only 6 chicken wings, regular size, and NOT what is considered the standard for a pound of wings!!! Just brutal undercutting customers! Missing those days when restaurant gems like Kelly s were serving 9 cent wings!!!

Local Guide
December 23, 2021

To much to mention the wait given the wrong amount $ 11.80 more never got tin crust we had other issues in the past I was never so insulted like that before today theres more issues but to many to keep texting

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

I usually cant order from these guys because they are a little pricey. But... I found out they have 6.99lb wings on Thursday. A lrg pizza a d 4lbs of wings 4 blue cheese cane to 57$ it was so worth it and so yummy! They really do have the best pizza. You pay for quality.

December 23, 2021

We got a pizza was not great at all i picked it up on Friday my friend Dave picked it up . I think he picked it up between 2pm and 230 pm . The order was med pizza pepperoni pineapple sausage. there was no pepperoni on the pizza . All that was on there was sausage and pineapple . the sausage was more like bread crumbs i never had sausage like that before . The pizza was not cooked enough . It was so droopy every thing just fell off of it . Was super messy to eat . Was not impressed at all . The wings were okay but i would not say jumbo at all they looked the same size as i have gotten before at other pizza places . I also emailed them and got no response back from the owner that was four days ago . So thought all do my review seeing they have not responded to my email . . Any how do not think i would go back there

★★★
December 23, 2021

pizza is good, wings are good. issue i have is i ask for extra sauce on pizza, saucy wings. for th price you pay, id pay for the extra Sause. i watched a customer walk in and they charge 3 bucks for blue cheese. sour cream and mayonnaise. the blue cheese i got with wings had no blue cheese in it. sad. over priced food id recommend petes pizza in the falls before pie guys. but if you want good pizza its rose city in welland

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Our first night ordering from Pie Guys Pizzeria. One of the biggest hurdles with a Pizzeria is consistency. Pizza and wings were top notch. It was a bit of a wait, but well be back for round two. Well see if its another 5 star order! Follow up. Two more orders. Both 5 star. Could be our new go to for pizza and wings!!!

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

Finally a local pizza joint in Niagara that knows how to do proper pizza and chicken wings. Ive tried wings from all over southern Ontario and nobody can rival true chicken wings from Buffalo NY until I tried Pie Guys last weekend. With the NY-Ontario border closed my withdrawls are over. I ordered a 24 slice tray of pizza and 2 lbs of wings from these guys last weekend it was awesome. I asked for the wings medium and softly cooked. Guess what? They served me perfect medium and softly cooked. I thought I was eating from the Anchor Bar in Buffalo NY. Outstanding pizza and wings. This joint will now be my go-to place for Sunday football action. Go Packers.

★★★★★
December 23, 2021

We ordered today first time! The Pizza was amazing! Hot and had it delivered too.Even the delivery person was friendly.Becca that answered the phone and took my order was pleasant as well.We wished we ordered more.lol We will order again!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Usually fast good service. Pizza is excellent Today was told would be ready in 35 minutes. Arrived at 36 minutes and had to wait another 20 minutes. Not acceptable

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Quick pick up service

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Yummy in my tummy!!

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Great quality They didnt mess up the order

★★★
December 23, 2021

Pizza and wings were good but delivery was waaay too long. I get Saturdays are busy, but 1.5 hours is ridiculous!

★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2021

Good food prices a little on the high end

★★★
December 23, 2021

Ordered this on Skip while visiting in Niagara. Pizza tasted great, but I asked for regular (not well done) and the outer crust was blackened. Additionally, I got the Italian Stallion Pie with extra toppings. Toppings were great in taste and proportions, however they did not add one of the toppings that comes with that Pie (hot banana peppers). Either way, worth a try if you are in the area.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2020

Had the best time of my life here! Never Disappointed With Pie Guys Pizza! I Can Finally Say Goodbye To Twice The Deal And Any Other Pizza Place Because Pie Guys Is The Best! I Will Always Come Here!

December 23, 2020

Called 3:55 Sunday afternoon was on hold for 26mins was next one to be served for 11min. Pie guys in St. Catherines is awesome Niagara Falls you suck.

★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2020

Ordered here tonight around 2045, ordered a 12 slice pizza and 3 pounds of wings. The pizza was a bit overdone and pretty average nothing special at all, the wings were way over done and had barely any sauce. The lady working at the cash forgot to give us a pound of wings and was quite rude and seemed to not care a whole lot. Not to sure what all of the rave is about this place, found it a bit pricey for over cooked pizza and wings with bad service.

December 23, 2020

Not worth it. Poor customer service, long wait and meh pizza. The specials are a complete.rip off. I would strongly recommend Zappis or somewhere else, really anywhere else.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2020

Always friendly on the phone and their pizza is consistently good

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2020

Order #31. First time here and will not be the Last! Great Pizza. Was a Franks Fan, but have a New Place Now!!!

★★
December 23, 2020

Great pizza. Terrible service. Two weeks in a row I went in when they confirmed the pizzas would be ready. Both times they had not even put them in the oven yet. I complained and they simply asked if I wanted to cancel my order. Unbelievable.

December 23, 2020

Waited 20-30 minutes longer than the 40 minutes they said it would take then when I got it home realized half was soggy. The time alone made me never want to come back but then the fact the pizza was soggy made me really dislike this restaurant. I ve heard the pizza is suppose to be good but would never recommend this location that s for sure just never worth the wait or the quality of pizza.

★★★★★
December 23, 2020

Our pizza was burnt, replaced in in great time sooo good, thank you.

Local Guide
December 23, 2020

Terrible. First time I ordered from you, you accidentally cancelled my ordered and I had to wait 2 hours for my pizza. The second time I ordered, I ordered wings with extra sauce and I got completely dry wings. So not impressed. Doubt Ill ever order again.

★★
December 23, 2020

Gave this location second try after the first one failed to understand extra sauce on both the pizza and the wings. Not only that the pizza came burnt and the wings were so dry that we thought about adding sauce from our own fridge! Manager did refund our money but this pizza place is not one that I would recommend personally.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2020

Ordered takeout from this restaurant twice in a week, that should tell you how good the food is

★★★★★
December 23, 2020

Amazing pizza, great customer service & friendly staff! Highly recommend.

★★★★★
December 23, 2020

Pizza and wings are amazing!!! One of the only places around with new York style pepperoni too yum yum!!!

★★★★★
December 23, 2020

Never disappointed ordering here. Pizza is always great ,wings are big and delicious , veggies fresh & crunchy Staff is friendly and courteous Honestly I don t order pizza anywhere else anymore.

★★★★★
December 23, 2020

Food here is EXCELLENT! Go there all the time. Staff is very nice and no complaints. I definitely recommend this place. I order weekly it truly is awesome.

December 23, 2020

Ordered pizza, wings, and wontons. Delivery driver showed up with only pizza and wontons. I called the restaurant and they said they could deliver the wings in 30 minutes. An hour later I called to find out where the wings were and they said my address didnt exist. What???? You were already here once! And you have my phone number! Why didnt you call me??? Forget this place, their service is pathetic. No wonder they have 6/10 on Skip the Dishes.

★★
December 23, 2020

Way over priced for bakery style pizza..wings were good ..but not worth 65 bucks..took hr and half to deliver to north end..

December 23, 2020

I will not order from this place again. I place the order at 6pm, get told 45 minutes. Arrive to.pick up my order at 6:45pm and get told they are just waiting on wings and it will be 6 to 10 minutes. So my order should be ready at 6:55pm...30 minutes later, 7:15pm my order is finally ready. So never again will I order from there.

★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2020

Friendly staff when I ordered. Prices are decent. When I arrived my order was not ready when promised. Waited an extra 15 minutes while other customers with higher order numbers were served before me. Pizza was average. Wings were average. Will not be in a hurry to return.

★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2020

Great pizza, and the wing deal Thursday night is good value.

★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2020

Decent pizza. Really frustrating they have 6.99lb wing special. But a large pizza 3 toppings and 2 lbs of wings for 36.99. I tried to just order 2 lbs of wings and a large double pepperoni pizza but got upsold to get triple pepperoni!!! Sounds like a lot of pepperoni and with the cup and char it sounded amazing. Instead Im afraid what single pepperoni is.. to be upsold and pay about 4 extra dollars to get this deal vs separate and the pizza will show how many pepperoni were on this. First and last time having pie guys. Love the pepperoni flavor but to be sold on adding more to my bill for what we got just not good enough.

★★★★
December 23, 2020

Niagara Falls Best Pizza... have the bacon & the cupped pepperoni... a little expensive but worth it

★★★★★
December 23, 2020

Always my familys go to place to order pizza, but wish they had lunch hours so I could order it for my work

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2020

Really good pizza and wings really like those cup and Char pepperoni

December 23, 2020

$11.00 for 7 Medi size wings. No thank you. Never again. Even 14 wings wouldnt have been enough. Could find better value for a $20.00 meal plus tax.

December 23, 2020

Ordered a Pizza from them through Skip, pizza was not good and barley had any topping on it. Ordered it with salami and there was maybe all of 3 slices on the entire pizza. wont be ordering again.

★★★★★
Local Guide
December 23, 2020

Excellent, tasty pizza done to perfection. Ordered The Works which is loaded with toppings and will definitely have it again.

★★★★★
December 23, 2020

Excellent Pizza and wings and great customer service!

Local Guide
December 23, 2020

Horrible food , not well prepared , took over 40 minutes to prepare and yet it arrived cold.