Pi Co. Pizza Bar in North York

Nomnomnom

If I could give zero stars, I would. This so-called gourmet pizza restaurant is an absolute disgrace. The crust was unbelievably soggy, to the point where it felt like eating a wet sponge, poor quality and flavorless, bordering on what I d imagine dog food might taste like. I can confidently say it s the worst pizza I ve ever had in my entire life. Save your time, money, and taste buds, and go literally anywhere else.

Had the margherita pizza. Made fast, done well amd the staff was courteous

Margherita pizza is great!!!

Great pizza

August 23rd 2024 I went to shops at Don Mills at 7:30 pm with family and friends.I ordered craft my pizza with unlimited toppings I asked the supervisor to put 5 bocconcini on my pizza and he refused to. he had told me that theres a limit of two where the sign says unlimited he would not accommodate my order. I then asked where it says theres a limit and he cannot answer my question. I told him that the sign on the wall says unlimited to me that is false advertisement I have been going there every second week. Ive brought a lot of friends there and last night the way I was treated by the supervisor was unprofessional

The food itself tastes good when made correctly (used to visit often)....the problem is the new hires have no idea what theyre doing. Ordered a simple cheese pizza - worker placed No basil, no oil, no Parmesan on the pizza - had to let them know these are the standards of Pico. theyre reply was indifference. 16 bucks for a sloppy pizza - Ill take my money elsewhere.

Food

I love the chain but I would like some consistency in the. The ones downtown keep the olive oil and chilli flakes on the table. But this one does not. Not sure why but they prefer to add that for you. Otherwise food is pretty standard.

The pizza was terrible, the service even worse. I won t be coming back.

After going to 3 different pizza shops to try and buy 12 empty pizza boxes for a non-profit education program, Pi Co provided them free of charge! Definitely coming back for more than just boxes!

Ordered a pizza and it was very burnt. As well it lacked any flavor and after about 5 minutes it was cold. I will not be going again

Excellent pizza I ever had, Navin was amazing in crafting the pizza I want

Great pizza! Great service!!! Vegetarian options: Lots of topi ga to choose from! Parking: Big parking lot

Free parking, although it can be very busy, I just park in the multi level garage. Clean inside, not a huge menu which is good as it means the food is turned over quicker and fresh. Salad options are really good. Pizza crust is very thin, fresh tasting items on their pies. Definitely going back again.

Pizza was delicious and staff was friendly !

Love the gluten free crust here!

I ordered margarita pizza and it was so dry , didnt put enough sauce and toppings.hardly seen 2-3 leaves of basils and not enough cheese slices. Chewed a dough. Not recommended at all.

Burnt

Delicious pizza

It was very good experience. my first time and i got costumized pizza love the crust. yummy

Fun and great pizza

The quality was lower than before . Pizza was burnt Drink was not cold

Vegetarian options: Looks great but I am not vegetarian Dietary restrictions: Special allergy care available Parking: Many Kid-friendliness: Kids allowed and special kids pizzas available Wheelchair accessibility: Easy wheel chair entry and egress available, but meunuvering space inside,a little tricky.

Tasted ok but I thought the margherita pizza was a bit too thin. I probably won t go back again.

Fast food style pizza but taste better than restaurant pizza. For some reason they only have a small menu printed on a letter sized paper. I tried the avenue and really liked it.

Really tasty Margherita pizza, quick service.

Good quality pizzas, def better than domino s & pizza hut

No question about it, great pizza always fresh and to your taste. Love the food and staff is great.

Had experience dining at this location, Navin was so helpful on choosing a better option

We usually stop here for a late night snack or for dinner after skating. We (2 of us) split 1 make your own pizza; we each end up with 2 slices. The fact that you can put anything on the pizza (they have an insane number of topping options) makes this place fun and unique. Give it a try!!

Pizza s are always great at Pi Co, but the service at this location was amazing! The gentleman was very patient and also gave his own recommendations. Will definitely be back :)

Great authentic Pizza. Love their unlimited toppings option.

Love the variety of toppings, crust and sauses!

I m a regular of this location. Donno why but the quality of pizza really depends on which staff works on ur pizza. I just ordered a 13dollar maghreta pizza, and the lady who made the pizza must be the owner or shareholder LOL, as she literally just put three basil leaves, one mozzarella cheese on my pizza. The trick is she divided one basil leaf into three pieces, One mozzarella cheese into several little pieces. I am not a big fan of pizza, but the way they are trying tocheap out the toppings, really not impressive. I will not go to this place anymore. I think the next door Chipotle make much more sense

Its a great option for quick pizza with friends or family

Pizza was burned But taste good Food

Best gluten-free pizza I ve ever had. I order all the time. Fantastic. I never review anything, but I had to it s so good.

Very tasty and satisfying pizza place. $16 for a custom unlimited topping, thin crust pizza.

Appreciate all of the options and the consistency. Wish they had an option for a large size of pizza or salad.

If you want a fast food pizza but also something healthy, this is your place. You have the liberty to pick all your favourite ingredients for the pizza and it s done in no time. Price is fair as well. However, the flavours might not be at par to blaze pizza which Carries the same ideology but has better taste.

Wood fire fresh ingredients

Haven t tried the pizza but don t sleep on the build your own salad - it s large enough for 2 meals (or people) and 2 protein choices + unlimited toppings.

Tried out this place again. It was again disappointing. There were tiny shards and of olive pits throughout the salad which is very dangerous especially when feeding young children. The pizza was very poorly made as well as the dough was thinned out to the point where it was impossible to hold and the topping just fell off because there was not very much cheese on it. I have noticed a distinct difference in ordering in person from here and ordering delivery because in person there is never any problems and ordering delivery there is always major problems.

Great pizza but kinda overpriced

The staff is very friendly, the salad is great, and you can customize your own toppings for the pizza. Its fantastic!

Clean and well kept restaurant! Good quality food and a cute gas fired pizza oven. Family enjoyed it, but don t expect much other than pizza. If you re having a pizza crazing, this is the place to go!

I ordered a pizza but they made a salad.

The whole experience was positive.

Employees need training but the pizza is good. Came here an hour before closure at 8pm, two south Asian female employees acted as they were already closed Closed washrooms, chairs on tables and she came to make pizza right after washing the floor! Ruined appetite for sure.

Only ate here once and never again. First off, I ordered ahead, when I came to pick it up the employees forgot to even make it (ordered at 7:30pm for a 9:30 pickup). They did try to rush the order, and that didn t end well. Half the dough of my pizza was still uncooked. I spent the next four days with food poisoning. Best I can say about this place is unlimited toppings for no extra charge, but enjoy at your own risk.

Amazing pizza amazing staff they really knocked it out of the park

The pizzas are very delicious and at a very good price.

I like their pizzas , dough and the diy pizza , a bit pricy though .. staff are nice , the place doesnt have its own atmosphere or vibe.. Its just a bunch of tables and chairs for people to use. The shops at Don Mills branch is nicely located in the corner.

Food and atmosphere are great! Workers are extremely rude and just look like the hate working there (the girl specifically). Unpleasant experience but the food made up for it

I come here at least twice a month (Shops at Don Mills location) as its one of my favourite places to eat but there has been such a high turnover lately and some of the newer people dont know what theyre doing. I ordered my usual craft to go and the guy who made it was fine but the new girl who turned the pizza left it in too long then on top of that she lifted it towards the heat and burnt it. I kept telling l her that its going to burnt but she either didnt hear me or chose to ignore me and sure enough it was burnt. I told the guy who boxed it that its looking burnt but he too did nothing about it! Im extremely disappointed as this place always cheers me up with their food and great staff so this was such a let down - and the pizza tasted horrible!

Must try margherita pizza!!! I had an amazing customer service experience yesterday. The staff was really friendly and helpful.

Great service

The staff was really friendly and helped us with the menu. Plus, the pizza was delicious with fresh ingredients. I left very happy with both the service and the food.

Pizza was amazing, fast and the staff were welcoming! I tried jack aastors and south street burger before coming here and it was terrible. Thank you for saving the day Pi Co!

So yummy!

I was here for shopping my winter essentials and saw this pizza shop and wanted to try out the usual Margherita Pizza. It was so soft and cheesy with a hint of tomato. I like the crunchy base and soft inner crust. The tomato base was quite tangy but worth a try. I did like the pizza though. It was a friendly and quick service. It was a worth visit and I was full after 2 pieces, big thumbs up. Cheers on your visit !

Absolutely delicious food and this location was great! Staff were so kind and this Holiday Bundle deal for $45 was awesome!

Great made to order pizza, so fast, so good

Love that you can customize, order any topping. Im not sure if this is the part I like about it, or if the pizza itself and how its made is what I love. I just recall it was filling, enjoyed it so much, and would come back again.

Overpriced with less quantity. Just a fancy pizza place no tastes even that good as it has to be.

Just delicious.......

Pizza is always amazing here. Made to order, hot, fresh and made with love. Service is always great and never had a disappointing pie. Always satisfies my pizza craving, cant wait to go back.

I m never going to this location again, I have a 3 month old puppy who I was holding in my arms and was told I wouldn t be served unless I left her outside in -26 degree weather. They have no signage up stating that animals aren t allowed but the sheer disrespect of their staff telling me to leave my pet in extreme cold will ensure I never spend a dollar there again. This location used to be busy but is dead traffic wise, I wonder why

Pizzas were fresh and very good. But the sizes are small and not very filling. For a 4 people portion, 2 orders were not enough. But taste good.

Interesting take on pizza, where you can build your own pizza with as many fresh ingredients as you like, all at 1 cost. Oven reaches extremely hot tempertures to have your pizza ready in 5 minutes while you wait. Its not the cheapest pizza out there, but great value when you factor in the quantity and quality of ingredients. Staff here seems friendly enough and there are indoor table options as well as outdoor tables in fair weather.

We ordered from this place for the first time and honestly it was a HUGE disappointment. For the money you pay, you will get MUCH better pizza from Maker Pizza.

All you can eat toppings on a pizza of 10-12 Create your own pizza!

Good Pizza, very different experience. Great place......

Good for 10 bucks but not much more...

Easily one of my new favourite restaurants. The flat-priced build-your-own pizza concept is fantastic. The size of the pizza is a little bit small for the price but the quality of the ingredients makes up for it. The staff at this location were friendly and professional. Your pizza is in and out of the oven in just a few minutes and comes out perfect.

Always with fresh ingredients, serving patrons with a smile.

Build your own pizza! So good when it is still hot and fresh from the oven!!

Good/10

They have gluten free crust, but cross contamination is questionable. I was sick for 3 days after.

One of the best pizzas I have eaten in Toronto. They make the pizza in front of you and its ready within 5 minutes. Very fresh and delicious.

Changing my rating to even 2 is more because of customer service. I asked for dine in and lady gave me pizza in boz. If i wanted to eat it out from cardboard box, i could have went somewhere else. When i reminded her that its for here she said thats ok. What do you mean thats ok. Its my preference how i want to eat. If you are going to give me my pizza in a box then why are you even asking. Completely spoild my evening. 2 stars im giving just because of franchise taste.

Its a great spot for a pretty good pizza. Make it how you want, its all up to you. The price is on point with what youd expect. Yes the pizza is smaller, but typically 2 people can split one. They offer a large quantity of toppings at no additional cost, but keep it simple for the best result. The service is quick and options are endless. Its a great spot.

Pizza was good Customized and no complaints Attitude of the lady staff so rude.. our order taken for dine inn and when we are about to seat and start dinner she told you cant seat and eat our closing time is near They are open till 10 but she started closing at 9.30 pm

Fraud person in Charge! The most pathetic customer service of all times! Ordered pizza through PiCo app. The person in charge at this location refused to give pizza to the delivery personnel saying other driver already picked up the order and when we called at the store, he told us customer picked up the order which we did not. kept shamelessly lying and refusing to talk to any of us or even trying to resolve the issue. Ended up cancelling the order after two hours. If you want to get frustrated, this is the best PiCo outlet for it. Edit - As per your Rude comment - I would like to have those imaginary pictures you are talking about. If that s not me, I want written apology and PiCo to take action against you.

As expected for Pi Co and fast casual pizza. We hit it right at lunch and looked to be behind an order of about 20 margarita pizzas. Ill likely order ahead next time.

Great choice for fast customized pizza. Salad was wonderful fruity none.

Good place for a quick fired pizza!

Ordered through skip. Two large salads with extras. Extras have gone yup by a dollar each. $4 now instead of 3. And they didn t include all that was ordered! Pizza was part of the same order, and they sent the wrong pizza! Pathetic. Won t be ordering from here again. Used to be very good.

My order didnt arrive...when I called the store they said they have no way to contact the driver. Employee was laughing. Poor customer service and wont order from them again!

Very good pizza here! At first I was not sure if I will like it but the flavours and everything was spot on! Nothing beats pizza cravings by eating a freshly baked pizza right out of the oven!!!

Friendly service, fresh ingredients, reasonably priced, and very quick.

Pizza is good Only few tables inside and a patio

Loved it. Crust was a bit too thin and soft towards the center.

Tonight our pizza was good (could be a bit more crispy tho )but the lady taking our order had a bad attitude ! Didn t ask if we wanted any dipping sauce or a drink and didn t even say our total amount ! Just turned the screen and showed us the amount to pay ! So rude !!!!

Good pizzas

One of my favorite places in the don mills area. They make live pizza in front of you. Try truffle pizza and its good. They have a patio and dine-in option as well

One of the worst location to have PI CO pizza. No customer service at all. Money is not worth. We also requested chilli flakes the guy gave us on small container without lid , no tissues, felt like we are getting free pizza and the guy was doing favour to us.

Dough was very basic; combination of salt , water , and flour , nothing else.But , right fermentation gave an amazing flavor to the dough.Way better than many Italian restaurant pizzas.

Fresh and delicious.

Goodbye

paid close to $30 on doordash for this sad glob of a pizza. did you run out of cheese (serious question)? oh and the black cockroach looking things are supposed to be walnuts in case you re wondering. pics #2 and #3 are from their bay st. branch same yorkville pizza. can you spot the difference?

Like my homemade pizza but faster.

Vegetarian options: You can choose the veggies that you want for your pizza or salad Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free pizza and vegetarian options

Bit overpriced but they have good quality ingredients and the pizzas are made fresh in front of you.

All toppings are burnt (dough was burnt in oven as well)i paid almost $28 and i got just one bite from it. (Name:yorkville PI with gluten free)

Im happy every time!!! The ingredients are fresh, dough is fresh, oven is amazing. Wide and amazing selection of cheeses for it. Two tomato sauces. I love Pi Co. You should eat here!

Some of the best pizza in Toronto. Prices seemed high at first but definitely worth it. Unlimited toppings and a huge selection more than I ve seen anywhere else. Will definitely be going back!

Delicious pizza with a large variety of topping choices! Choose make your own and add as many toppings as you want. Dont over do it or else the pizza will be too heavy for the crust. Ask for well done and it will be super tasty when the toppings crisp at the top. Add some arugula at the end for some garnish. Also great with pesto in the sauce too! Garlic dip is also wonderful to add!

Great pizza!

Just like a clam

Recently they run out of gluten free pizza and we went elsewhere.

Tried all locations for GF and Margarita their tastes THE BEST :)

Love it. $15 for all the toppings and beautiful crust. Best pizza around

Too expensive for a plain pizza

I love this place - the food and service are both top notch! Sitting in their patio is a must if you are in the area

Great selection

Great pizza

Great taste! Quick and delicious

Custom pizza is the best.

Average pizza.

Last two times we ordered we didn t get the toppings that we wanted pizza was also cold by the time it got to our door. When we go in person to buy pizza from this specific location the costumer service is horrible and also super slow the people that work there have bad attitude and use theirs phone to much during work hrs. I don t recommend this location.

Delicious and allows u to build ur pizza with as much as you want for no extra fee and cook in front of you in a pizza oven

Great concept in making your own pizza. Plus, their salads are a gem, truly underrated! Its a must try!

Amazing quality

That Margherita

Good little restaurant!

Great pizza place! Wouldnt get pizza anywhere else if Im in this area. Love the fact that their pizzas are completely customizable and are baked in a fire oven... Just makes it taste so much better.

A great quick pizza!