Super Mario's Pizza in Port Colborne

Bar and bands are lots of fun game time special cant be beat

Great place for food and entertainment.

Excellent food and service, great daily deals especially on Sunday with football game

Did not visit the his place

Supper good time food great

Great Pizza.

Great band! Fun time.

Lovely staff

The gentleman that answered the phone was very polite and very nice he read my order back to me to make sure my order was right, When I got home I was very surprised at how good the food has been lately, Ive noticed the change in the food it has tasted alot better. Thank you super Marios good job.

Moved here 4 years ago, super Marios great pizza .and wings Thats very affortable! Update april 2/24. My best bud James is now working there just had taco Tuesday with order of taco fries so good!

Amazing food

Amazing staff and wonderful pizza! Would definitely go here every time I m in Port Colborne!!

Delicious food, my favourite take out, plus restaurant/bar. This friendly family run business also brings live, day time music on Sunday afternoons.

From out of town only been a few times but the bands on Sunday from 4-8 are great, lots of dancing friendly staff, and food is great, will be back for sure

Pizza was a 6.6 outta 10.. prolly would of been better if it was so doughie..Id give another try but I wouldnt go outta my way..

Great food, vibe, people and owners. Bands on Sunday rock. Go Bills.

Excellent pizza and wings for a great combo price! Friday night order was ready in 30 minutes

My husband and I ate here today for the first time, it was fantastic! We will definitely be coming back. The pizza and wings is 10/10. And the service was a 12/10 such kind and welcoming staff and owners. Thanks Super Mario s! See you again soon! Parking: Parking was certainly simple, the way it should be.

Great brucheta and wings. Sunday entertainment is great to. Check out The Working Stiffs playing on the 26th of March from 4pm to 8pm.

The first time there last Saturday there was a band playing and the place was packed Unfortunately they only had two waitresses on and I dont know how many in the kitchen waited over 45 minutes for a coffee when the food came in it was dry burnt and had been sitting under the heat lamp now I know it has good ratings so I might just go and try it again. But a note to the owner when it is busy and you have a band you should have more people on you are losing Revenue

Favourite pizza!

Pepperoni + Cheese: While I liked the crust and the thickness of the dough, I found the sauce and cheese lacking in flavour and amount, respectively. While it is affordable for a large pizza at $15, the lack of depth in flavour overall is enough reason not to have it again. I ended up eating something else after to satisfy my appetite. It was as if I ate oven roasted bread with tomato sauce on the side for dipping. I resorted to sprinkling dried oregano and basil in hopes to add some depth/flavour. Perhaps, Ill go back for something else; Ill try their subs next time...?

Focaccia sandwich so fresh and delicious

pleasantly surprised having the pool hall and bar/ restaurant area in the back. Ill definitely go back to this place!

This pizza is very inconsistent. Completely hit & miss. The most recent purchases were not much better than eating a cardboard box. So dry and tasteless, you couldn t find tomato sauce if your life depended on it. Look at the pictures, the slices could be used as building material. Most of the pizza went into the compost bin. Dominos here I come

Been eating here almost my entire life the last while the quality of food has gone way down . Everytime I order pizza the crust is so dry it is disguisting.little to no flavour. Wish mario still ran this place

My kids absolutely love the pizza, and I love the panzerotti. Best pizza place in Port Colborne by far!

We went to see a band there tonight and have dinner and some drinks. The band was excellent! The food was not so great and the service was horrible. Our food came out barely tepid temperatures. We managed to get 1 round of drinks. Our DD tried ordering a water 3x and it never came. When she finally got the servers attention she was given attitude and then said she didn t want it. If this place is out to make more revenue by hosting bands then they need better service. Not once did the server come and ask if we wanted to order more drinks. I have never visited a restaurant/bar that didn t try and push drinks to make money. Totally illogical business sense to me. If the 1 server was overwhelmed with how large the crowd was then have another person scheduled for those days. You d make a heck of a lot more money that way. Needless to say we ll never go there again and we definitely being telling our friends and family the same.

Super solid pizza. Best poutine in the region.

Was happy to hear they had a 18.99 part tray special one topping until It came and I got 5 dollar charge for pepperoni thanks for my special 25.90. Thanks 33 bucks for what

I ordered a turkey sub paid 12.99 the lettuce they put on it looked like you would of put it on a hamburger. The sub bun was beyond stale it was freezer burnt. When I called to let them know they said we well let the girl know. WOW great customer service. Perhaps they should let customer know they use frozen buns they microwave to defrost before the customer waste there money. The turkey meat they use it the slice turkey you get from Food basic the 2 pack for 5.00. I also waited a half for it. Very disappointed. Sign Misty D Parking: lots

Went in to get slices today, they coulda given me a cardboard box and it woulda been more edible

Deliver driver overcharged and they wouldn t fix it

Called to order a pizza ten minutes before they close to them to answer and tell me they re closed I worked in restaurants my whole life dont matter if there 1 minute left poor service

I was just enjoying some pizza, and then out of nowhere, there were red and green plumbers riding on green dinosaurs, and then there went down a green pipe

I cant speak to the atmosphere because I had a take out order. The people who work there are very friendly.

Good pizza and wings

Okay.. Ive walked and biked and drove by Soper Marios pizza since i moved here 5 years ago.. I never realized that there was a side door going to a pub. Terry was fantastic and welcoming. The beer was cold. The food was great. Highly recommend a visit to folks like me who enjoy a pub atmosphere.

Its been awhile since I have ordered from here, And I am pleased to say, its still really good food. My order was exactly as I wanted and delivery was quick and food hot. My mozzarella sticks were a little over cooked. But still tasted good. Will order again.

Food is very tasty and generous portions. Staff r very friendly and fast.

Ive only been once, but what I tried was very good and good value, I will be returning.

Best pizza and subs in town

Very hearty meat lovers pizza!

Super unhappy with the pizza I received it was dry and had no flavor and tasted like cardboard no sause or anything very unappealing...

Good price on party trays, decent pizza and wings.

Great Pizza

New to town. Met the owner and he told us all about our area and more. The pizza is incredible!

We only get our pizza here! Great Staff

Barb and Terry are amazing hosts and owners. They offer awesome take out and dine in menus and service. If you want the best wings in Niagara order from Super Marios. So that our wings stay crispy I ask for them to be cooked and left dry, with their special Butter and Franks sauce on the side

Great place, great owners and staff

Love their pizza. There are so many places in town and some that are closer to my house, but we will pay for delivery or pick up because its a favoutite.

Always very good, where as I say its the best around. The only disappointment is that they always give a time for pickup, and always I have to wait, even half hour.

Found the overall location to need a good cleaning. Order meatball sub even though it did have a good amount of meatballs the sauce was bland and I dont like anything spicy. Asked for extra sauce and got very little amount. I would hate to see what the regular amount would have been.

Amazing pizza and great, friendly people. I always go here when in port and wouldnt go anywhere else

Great Pizza and Chicken Wings tonight! Pizza was Outstanding!!!!

Ordered a serving of lasagne for a family member who doesn t like pizza in addition to a pizza and wings. Called at 4:45, order arrived at 6 without the lasagne. The driver was very put out about having to go back for the lasagne. It is now 6:40 and the lasagne has not arrived. Called to find out what was going on and was told it still had a few minutes to cook. So the rest of us are done the pizza while my father waits on his lasagne. Ridiculous.

Good pizza and not too greasy. But i wont order the wings again.

Tonight I had a huge craving for chicken wings. This was my first time ordering from the restaurant, I have heard good things about the jumbo wings so I decided to try it tonight.... I was not disappointed!!! The wings were giant, cooked to perfection, seasoned and sauced to the max! I will definitely be returning and trying more flavors and menu items! Very impressed with the staff as well, one staff was mid-call and immediately I was acknowledged by a staff from the kitchen. Very friendly!

Had pizza here a couple of times and its been good everytime. The wings are also good.

Best pizza in Port Colborne!

Got takeout from super Marios, while it took a bit long, the wait was worth it. Cheeseburger pizza and the Franks and butter wings were delicious!

Dry and tasteless. From the kid on the phone hanging up on me, staff walking around on all the spilled food on the floor, I assume the manager screaming at the staff youre lucky you have a job disappointed all the way around. Will not be returning.

Great medium wing sauce. We had the Tuesday special and it was great value for the money.

Best in Port Colborne

Best pizza in Port Colborne! Have tried pretty much every place in Port and nowhere else compares. Amazing wings too, always tender, never dry. Try their meat lovers pizza!

Amazing pizza and wings. Regularly receive fast delivery, even during COVID times. Friendly staff and owners.

the pizza is always delicious, the wings are always saucy, and the staff is truly magnificent. 10/10 .. I would highly recommend

The best prices and the best pizza and subs in town

Best subs hands down. The ingredients and toppings are very very fresh aswell as the bread which is very hard to find these days . I couldnt eat one half so I saved it for the next day and even after being in the car for hours it was no soggy at all. you are my new favorite sub place for sure

Excellent

If I could give this zero stars I would. Why I kid myself to think they could actually make a pizza properly or on time is beyond me. I have tried a few times in the past few months knowing at one point they could actually make a pizza worth eating. Order pizza tell me it will be 40 mins to show up and wait 25 for my pizza that s not ready yet to get it home and half it burnt. From now on will just go to ANY other pizza place being there is a few others that seem to care about the food that they put out not the money coming in.

Love the pizza and wings most definetly my favorite place for pizza night. The customer service is out of this world! Im not sure of the guys name who answers the phone but he is ALWAYS SUPER FRIENDLY AND COMICAL I will be a long time customer for sure!

This is the best place in Port for authentic Italian style pizza shop pizza. Of the pizzeria places Ive tried, in Canada, in my lifetime, this place is easily in the top 5. The prices are competitive too. Enjoy!

Excellent service and delivery was on time and arrived hot and delicious!

Nice place, serve beer while you wait

Great pizza

Good food very filling and decent price

Terry is the best n best pizza

Everything this restaurant offers tastes amazing, not just the pizza. Definitely our favorite Italian restaurant in Niagara region. And very reasonable prices too. .

Great fresh cheap slices! Highly recommend

Steak sub was awesome!

Tried a few pizza joints since we moved to Port and I am pleased to say Super Mario pizza has earned our business. Great pizza and wings. Friendly and helpful staff.

wake

I look forward to my pizza from there best pizza ever Thanks all the way from London

I m at a loss for words. The pizza has to be the worst I ve ever had! I was greatly disappointed that I didn t wait to get back to Welland to order food! I couldn t even finish a second slice. But that staff seemed super nice..

Thanks very much for a great time and service when we had our birthday party at your establishment. Would recommend to anyone.

Hands down the best panzerotti around!!

My partners hockey team reserved the backroom on a Sunday night after a game and it was a great experience. They preordered all the food so it was buffet style and it was a one cost for the whole team, drinks were extra, it was a very reasonable price. The food tasted great and there was lots to go around. They even stayed open later than closing time to accommodate us. The backroom had TVs to watch the games and also free pool. It was an all around good experience and would definitely recommend it.

Good pizza

Been here a few times and ive noticed the slices you get from walking in are pretty good but if you order a carry out pizza its really greasy and undercooked. The last time I went here was around 3pm, I waited around for about 5 minutes just to get kicked out by the owner and told they open at 4pm. Very strange expireience

Sooooo yummy

Friendly staff food is always great and good prices.

Have been waiting 1hour and 50 minutes for delivery and still not here. 1 tray and 4 pounds of wings. Unbelievable. Just called and they couldnt give any info and said they have no communication going on there. Canceled the order. Done with them.

Since new ownership this pizza joint has stepped it up! Still with the classic crust recipe Mario used to make and now the addition of cupped pepperoni, just like the states! What a great combination. $2 square slices are an awesome snack as well.

Great pizza and friendly staff

Rude service, won t be back.

Been going downhill steadily. The pizza is hit and miss, and more missing lately. Not sure if theyre freezing stuff beforehand, but the pizza has a bland taste.. The last 3 or 4 times Ive ordered from there its been the same. I think its fair to say Im done with them. Also, during the Covid pandemic, they are very careless. 2 people drinking beer in the waiting area, and theres two other people waiting for food in a 2 by 10 area. Not very safety conscious for the public. I was not impressed.

Service here has really gone down hill. The owner is extremely rude to both his clients and his underage staff. He has no intentions of making good on any of his customers complaints. Waited 1 hour and a half for delivery only to be told to come pick it up myself without any customer satisfaction discount. Smh with this kind of service. Buying my pizza else where moving forward.

During this pandemic, my family and I order takeout locally once a week(way more than our normal) to help support our local businesses. Last night we ordered from Super Marios pizza. Wings were good, pizza overcooked and service was disgusting. When my husband questioned our bill he was given huge attitude from the owner who then turned away and under his breath told my husband to get off the pipe. This was witnessed by another customer. We will never order from this establishment again. Very disappointing.

First time ordering from here in over 4 years lol we were happy with the food :) Pizza was cut a bit uneven lol but tasted good and their blue cheese is amazing!

Great Pizza and Wings. Love the blue cheese too! Very accommodating owners, I ask for my pizza a little thinner because thats how I like it and they never disappoint. Thanks guys

Love there pizza and wings

Pizza was as slimy soggy disaster. Guy behind counter copped an attitude. I was a regular visitor to my bathroom though out the nite . Never again!

The pizza was very good nd so are the wings. They are very friendly there.

Owner is great, love the pizza order almost every friday but every friday so far the kitchen forgot to give the driver my 2 pops, I said forget about it I wont make you drive back, and the 2nd time so far the driver gave me 4$ because it happened again. Great people but they are really busy with I understand but next time for the extra star to make 5 maybe send me my pop please :)

Best Pizza in Town hands down!!

Best pizza in the area. Staff are always nice.

Service was very slow.

Always good service never had bad food from them!

Good pizza

I ordered delivery, got the party tray pizza with garlic sauce, dill pickles, hot sausage and sundried tomato, and the wings with cajun spice, montreal spice, extra hot buffallo and hot honey garlic sauces- It was all spectacular! Some awesome toppings and unique wing flavours they offer here, and its of the highest quality for a reasonable price! 5/5 would definitely recommend to anyone in the Port Colborne area (they deliver within 20km).

Best pizza in town, hands down.

Super

Excellent pizza and wings. Nice little bar and eat in area in the back also.

Awesome owner

Ordered pizza and wings for delivery. Waited over an hour and a half for our food. Pizza was cold. Not even luke warm COLD! called to let them know and they told me it left hot and once it leaves them there is nothing they can do. Bad business! Waiting that long for cold food. Horrible customer service!!!!!!!!!

Best pizza ever and free pool !

Amazing wings and gotta try the cheeseburger pizza... Best pizza I ever had.

We used to love it here but it hasnt been as good lately. Way too greasy, when you buy slices they put them on top of each other so by the time you get home everything is stuck together and nothing but a mess. Every. Time. The cheap slices on Thursdays also seem to have gotten way way smaller. So disappointed- we used to eat here all the time :(

Great pizza

Love all you do from food to helping the community

Ordered 1 pound of wings and got a half pound of wings.

Hands down the best pizza in Port Colborne. Love the $1 slices on Thursdays!

Great pizza and wings a local favorite

Good pizzas and friendly bar.

Good food, friendly staff, sports bar atmosphere in rear of building. Tables , pool , TVs great service. Fair prices.

Great pizza ! The chicken wing pizza is absolutely amazing, I hate tomatoe sauce so its hard to find a good pizza with a white base and these guys nailed it!

Love it

Sub par food... prices keep going up... $11 for 7 over cooked wings... no thanks

They take foreverrrrrrr. Ive already finished the movie I rented and still havent got my pizza. At least it sometimes tastes good

Used to be good. Since it was taken over havent had a good experience. Pizza is always super greasy, last two times I ordered, All my chicken wings were broken, I mean All. Who sells wings like this?

npt great

I love this place. When me & my parents I go to see my family in Port, this is the place we order out from. Unlike traditional pizza places like Pizza Pizza & Square boys, this Pizza has a more unique & authentic taste!. The Wings & Celery sticks are great too.

My go to place to grab a slice or to order pizza

I drive from St Catharines just for a slice of . Decent food at decent prices.

The service was friendly and the pizza was delicious. Ill definitely be back.

The middle aged man that was working today was so rude. Never ordering from Marios again. Christophers pizza or the Belmont for a good pie!

Best pizza I have ever had. 6 stars.

Pizza, wings and service were all incredible.

Good pizza but a little overpriced.

Used to love this place but seems there have been some significant changes recently. Still decently priced but food isnt quite what it once was.

Like how they upgraded and great wings and pizza

The wings are the best in the Niagara Region. You have to try them.

Good for breakfast

Very good pizza and wings

Gave the new Marios two chances. First time i ordered 6 subs for pick up and a 40 something year old male employee or owner complained when I arrived that subways up the street, dont order this many subs again. Second time i ordered pizza and wings for delivery. 2 hours went by and i called, to which i was told the pizza was on its way. Another hour went by and i called to cancel. They wouldnt let me cancel. The driver arrived at my house trying to muscle us to buy the late pizza, to which i declined. Should change the restaurant name from super Marios to super late, or super rude.

Almost 2hrs late and cold as hell. This the second chance I gave this place a chance. Will not be a third!

Number #1 pizza place around. The owners make you feel welcomed. And the bar tender Steve is very friendly and quick. Love playing pool here too.

Very good food but I find once you complain about something they get very ignorant quick but still good food

Pizza is delicious but quite greasy

Great pizza! The crust was light and flavourful, the sauce was plentiful as well as tasty. The pizza was loaded with fresh toppings. My wife and I were pleasantly surprised that the pizza far exceeded my expectations. Leftover pizza didnt last a day at home. We will definitely be back. Keep up the good work SMP!

The food was amazing and the service was excellent.. definitely will be going back :)

Horrendous. 20 mins. late on pick-up. Twice this place has forgotten to include the wings with the pizza. Asked to speak with the manager, he hid behind the wall...apparently making too much money to regard customer service. If you want a great pizza and good customer service, go to The Lock. Ill never go to Super Marios again.

Great everything

Very good