Pizza Tonite St Thomas in St Thomas

Great everything - best wings and pizza in town from josh

Good food good price

I try to order whenever we come home!

Pizza is consistently delicious and the delivery guy was well mannered and prompt!

I drive from London just to get quality pizza and wings there! The staff is great. Food

Best pie in town

Everything from this restaurant is amazing. They do not have a single bad item on the menu.

Good food and prices Parking: Only a few spots in front and also parking lot Food : 5/5 |

Best wings in town

Fantastic Deep fried Panzo. They have anchovies!!

Simply rude and not very friendly. That applies to the two times Ive come here. I have to say though, theres a young teenager who works here that is an example of what the rest of the staff, and owners, should strive for in terms of customer service. But he is unfortunately one person of a half dozen Ive interacted with here. The food is fine. Prices are okayish. The main thing thats driven me off here is the borderline disrespect and unexpected annoyance that I perceived.

I am not a huge fan of their staff ...

panzerotti was good dip was not

I order pizza, wings and poutine (well done) and they NEVER disappoint. Great all around, but I would argue they have one of the best poutines in town for taste and value, hands down. The staff is always super friendly, and the food is always delicious. A++

First time having their pizza. Truly incredible. It will become my pizza go to. Cant wait until I try their wings next.

Amazing food, awesome wings, great pizza, keto crust available for us people sensitive to gluten. Friendly staff. Love this place, were frequently visiting here for take out. Wish they had a nice section set up to eat there. Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free crust!!! And also have the option of unbreaded wings,

Bought a pizza today and thought we would try this place out since im from out town!! And all I can say is absolutely amazing pizza the amount of topping and the way it s cooked was just perfect I ll definitely be returning and trying out there wings in the near future (next time in town)

Been getting wings from here for years. Got them again for the first time in a couple months and was disappointed. Not sure if they changed supplier but the wings seemed smaller and they were insanely tough. Basically had to rip them off the bone with my teeth and could hear the meat actually tearing off the bone. Unfortunately I m likely going to start looking to places like Wing Boyz for takeout wings from now on.

Just try to call and get the weekly special 1 pound of wings and large pizza one topping and do it online and it wouldnt process because it was saying not close enough to store but literally in same town so weird and I explained that to the guy I was talking too so he spoke to the manager and the manager said they would honor it since its not working on website , okay cool but then when we asked to add two extra topping which we were GOING TO PAY THE EXTRA the manager said no are you serious right now Im a paying customer ? Fix the website then and because on website it was allowing us to pay the extra ..... great service not ! Did like pizza tonight but after this Hassel and the not wanting our money lol we will go to place who will accept our money and not play the back and forth games. St. Thomas location.

Food quality has gone down in last year pizzas are hit and miss. Always used to be our go to. Recommend trying others. And delivery is very questionable. Never have problem with delivery in the past but now it s 50/50 if they will

Best wings in the world and there pizza is amazing also the BBQ chicken pizza is addictive

We love these guys. We tried em all in town since we moved here 4 and a 1/2 years ago. The best wings, hands down! Really good fries too. Great value for your money Food

Ordered from out of town for my stepson, it was late night and they accommodated a personal request for me without hesitation! Very good service, responded quickly the messages I sent as well! 10/10

I ve been getting wings and fries from here since 2000 Through the ownership changes. It only consistently gets better Fair prices. Good portions. Quality product Delivery drivers are super nice and efficient. Keep up the good work! (The guy who orders wings every Sunday to st Joesph st)

Not only is the food amazing, the customer service is impeccable

Im always a fan of local shops. When I tested the very first time I was like...wow... delicious. After that its hard for me to resist myself not to buy pizza from there. Its far better than any pizza chain you can think of. Pizza Tonite please keep the delicious test.

I really like the pizza here, the panzerottis are good, the chicken wings are mutantly big!! I have had them mess up my order twice now with saying no mushrooms on a pizza and still getting mushrooms, though I still think its one of the best pizza places in town.

Onion rings a fabulous.

We tried Pizza Tonite for the first time and absolutely loved it! We shared a Hawaiian pizza, a panzerotti and wings. They do not skimp on toppings at all, everything is fresh and the wings are huge!! I especially found the customer service to be excellent and delivery was fast! This is our new go to, happy to support a local family business!

Friendly staff nice clean waiting area. Vegetarian options: More than willingly to help out customers so every family member can enjoy, they go above and beyond Food : 5/5 |

Great value, great service.

Amazing pizza. First time trying it on new years day , will be back again for sure.

UPDATE the food just keeps getting better and the menu is awesome.

Very friendly and quick service. Picked up order each time weve ordered. Great deep fried panzerottis and pizza!

One of the best pizzas in st.thomas also have some of the best wings in town

I decided to try this place for the first time last night and was disappointed. It was almost 2am so I obviously wasnt going to call the store and complain as I was home already. However, when someone takes a pizza out of a pizza oven and you see its burnt you dont serve it, common sense, and to do it twice is ridiculous.

Love this place!!! The food is delicious and the family atmosphere is amazing! I will never order from another place ever!!! Customer for life!!!!

I got the 1lb of hot wings and the jalapeño poppers with fries last night through take out. The jalapeño poppers and fries were really good. Was disappointed with the wings because I saw so many good reviews. My wings were very soggy/wet so the texture kinda put me off. Donno if it s just because I ordered delivery but the breading on it was falling off and just very soggy. The sauce tasted good though. Donno how to reply to ur comment but it was around 8pm and it was delivery through skip.

hey great food

Their Boneless chicken wings are absolutely the BEST ONES in town, hands down.. the mild sauce is soo good and not really spicy. I cannot handle spicey stuff whatsoever but can eat a whole batch of their mild sauce myself no problem. Mmm! Honey garlic ones are to die for aswell!! The poutine is amazing. Great portion size for what you pay for. Even the plain fries are really good so you dont even need to upgrade them to a poutine. Im not the biggest fan of their pizza unfortunately. Not even sure why, but i dont like pizza to begin with.

Used to order from here weekly, been probably a year since I ordered last. And I won t be doing it again. It used to be much better. Tonight the first bite of my caesar salad had a very long hair in it. Uneatable. There were missing toppings on my pizza and wasn t well done as I requested. It s a shame because it used to be pretty decent.

I order wings from here almost every night after work and i appreciate how quick the delivery is and how good the wings are. I ve ordered almost all the flavours of wings and they ve all been cooked and sauced perfectly. Delivery guy always calls before he actually arrives which gives me time to go down the elevator, would give a 10/5 stars if I could

Love this place. Best panzerotti and wings in St Thomas. Recently tried the lasagne - its to die for. The seating area appeared quite dated so its not really appealing to dine in. Probably best to take home or have delivered

Best pizza and wings in St.thomas! Great staff too!!

Best pizza in St Thomas and great staff thank you guys pizza and wing were amazing

Ordered two panzarottis delivered tonight. Amazing!! Short delivery time, accurate order and delicious!

pizza was excellent, wings were OK and the Caesar salad was alright ( wont but again tho) seemed pretty expensive for what it was I believe almost $70 for pizza, wings and a salad seems a bit much to me Food

I got 2 lbs of wings, and they are good! Always recommend.

Not bad pizza pretty friendly people

Pizza was priced similar to specialty pizzas at dominos but the flavor wasn t there. The dough was nice and they use lots of cheese and did not cheap out on ingredients but it was missing taste/flavour somehow. It d be ok if the price was competitive but for the same price you get a better pizza in other chain pizzarias

The food was horrible. We were in st. Thomas for a weekend away. Decided to support a local. We got pizza and wings and both were dissappointing. The pizza tasted very bad. I love pizza but this aint upto par. The chicken wings were extremely soggy with no crispness to them had two and threw the rest away. The pizza felt like it had old toppings and also soggy.

Wont answer the phone due to laziness

Best panzorati in St. Thomas delicious wings and reasonably priced

I used to absolutely love pizza tonight and their medium walk-in pepperoni pizza was the best deal around. Now theyve upped the price big time! I went from only having to pay $50-$55 for a bday party to $80-$85. From 5-8 dollars + tax is just ludicrous Parking: Every time I go, theres always plenty of parking spots left Wheelchair accessibility: Its more wheelchair friendly than accessible

Me and my freind ordered food from here then they never showed up and wouldnt anwser the phone. Very bad service

Great pizza and more. Pizza tonight has been in this location for years. Exceptional customer service. Not wheelchair friendly, but ample parking. Wheelchair accessibility: Not wheelchair friendly

On time. Great wings! Pizza fair. Deep fried battered mushrooms great..ask for well done. Friendly.

Great pizza, and so much more!

ordered a small pizza wirh bacon and a side of ranch at 1103 . the said 30 to 40 minutes. it was 45 minutes with no ranch.

Pizza was BUSSIN

Yummy food!

Good pizza and wings

Its take out only

Not a lot to say other than explore your options.

Went in for slice Came out with med. special .lol Guy behind counter was very helpful and pizza tastes great ! Food : 5/5

Called in our order for pick up and fantastic service over the phone. The gentleman on the phone double checked our order and was polite and fantastic customer service.

Pizza is good. Seems it is hit or miss. Most times a hit

Great wings!

Picked up a large Pep and Cheese pizza here 01/23/2022 at 2:22am. An older gentlemen boxed my pizza with his mask off and one of those chocolate sticks with a crunchy coating sticking out of his mouth like a cigarette over top of my pizza. There were also two other people sitting in eating a pizza who witnessed this, there were also two other workers a young lady who made the pizza and a young man who took my payment. Unbelievable for the pandemic in food services, this is exactly how all these restricts come into place because of people like this, I will never return and I should report it to the Middlesex Health Authority.

Great wings and they deliver super late!!

Pizza was okay, the wings were a bit disappointing though. Loved them when I was a kid, so maybe it was just the night. The chicken was pretty dry and tasted off. The honey garlic sauce was actually quite good though.

Fast, good quality!

wow...broke your own record...bust pizza Keep it going..everyone in the dust.

I love the wings..lots of flavors.. breaded or non breaded.

We like ordering the wings when we are having a blah day and funny feel like cooking always yummy thank you

Best wings in town!

Worst pizza in town, below average wings. Sauce is too salty and sour, cheese is too greasy. Everything just slides off the pizza as soon as you take a slice. The Pizza Tonite in London has the same menu but it s fantastic there, so I don t understand why it s so terrible here. Would not recommend.

I ordered 2 penzarottis and some garlic bread for me and my friend. When I brought the boxes in we were missing a penzarotti and we assumed the delivery guy had gotten hungry. We reported this and were very confused. The restaurant said driver was Albanian and wouldnt eat the toppings. After further investigation I checked my cameras and found the culprit. A hungry raccoon. I apologize to Pizza Tonight and their driver. The food that survived was great and properly delivered. Thanks and sorry once again for the mix up!

Say that they would answer before midnight and dont!!! IVE been calling SINCE 11:30P.M. and it keeps ringing and hangs up?????

Pizza was not cooked properly

Great staff great food

People there are very friendly to go out of your way for you and your pizza and wings are good I mean good

Very Big delicious wings, pizza is ok sauce is kind of runny and cheese is a little dry

Love the wings

Took a hour and fries are soggy wings are cold very disappointed because they use to be great

Food was good Parking: Theres a few spots but is connected to the store next door

Great Food - Period!

Another contender for the best pizza in St. Thomas! Gus pizza was excellent: lots of cheese with a perfect level of crispiness in the crust. Super friendly people. Update: next day, my wife tried it and agreed it was perfect.

It s amazing how late their open till, it s incredibly convenient! past that I enjoy their pizza a lot!

I ve been getting the wings here for as long as I ve lived in St. Thomas and they re by far the best I ve ever had. The food is great, superb service and the staff have a huge heart for the community! Best pizza place in town 10/10.

Just ordered plain wings & small pizza. It was absolutely delicious. The wings were huge..pizza as usual always good..thank you

I come here regularly and order the same thing everytime. I always ask for extra cheese on my pizza and have no issue paying for it. Tonight I ordered and when I got home there was barely enough cheese for 1 pizza, let alone extra. Empty patches of just sauce, no cheese, everywhere. I have no issue paying for the things I ask for, but when I ask for it; get charged for it; and then not receive it? This happens far too often at this place, and a quality pizza all depends on who s making it. Who ever was making pizza on Sunday November 20th 2022 skimped out big time. Won t be back for a while now.

Best deep fried panzerottis

Best pizza and wings in town but everyone knows that, good job tonite !

Second best pizza joint in town by far but best place to get wings other then wing boys

Love there deep fried Panzerotti!

Best wings in town.

Have only been here twice, but in my experience Nice pizza good price and friendly service could not ask more of a pizza store. And when I am out that way again I will certainly go there

Chicken WINGS YUMMY!

Used to be the best wings in town but something has changed in the batter and theyre not what they used to be. Friendly staff though

Best wings.

Always there to cook for me when its my turn good job guys

Delicious food, great service, amazing pizza and wings!!

Mild sauce tasted like ketchup. Cold upon delivery. Texas toast from the grocery store with cheese for garlic bread. Not worth it. Only thing was good chicken wings minus the sauce. Size wise. They could do better.

My husband says they have the best wings in town! The ceasar salad is not worth ordering. There was no parmesan cheese, just lettuce and croutons. I got the bacon bits taken off as they are the fake gross kind. The poutine was a good size for a small. The gravy was good but it was made with shredded cheese and not cheese curds.

Great wings! Theyre huge.

I just love pizza tonite they have amazing stuff and always quick and the food is just amazing and omg those chicken wings theyre to die for the best wings in town and this will always be my go to place because my step dad Russell Phillips used to be theyre delivery driver up until 10 years ago when he was taken from us due to cancer the most wonderful loving guy you could ever know so I will always support pizza tonite in memory of him

Greatest wings ever!!! Panzerotti is My favourite as well as the Spicy Onion Scoops! This place Rocks!!!

Best poutine ever

Best wings and chicken fingers and great fries they have some sort of a coating on them its nice and crispy love them

Been ordering happily from this place for years but got two panzerottis tonight that were basically like trying to chew through a pair of bricks. The toppings inside were sparse and there was next to no cheese. We called to inform them of this and, after asking us to text photos and/or bring the remnants back to the shop, were told that the panzerottis are always like that and that they were using new oil in the fryers. Well, Im here to tell you that they are NOT always like that or I would have stopped ordering from them long before now. There was absolutely no attempt to make things right and we threw what remained in the trash. The garbage pail even had trouble choking it down. Honestly, I can buy cheeseless bricks cheaper if thats what Im in the mood to eat so I guess this is goodbye, Pizza (not) Tonite.

Great pizza. Thin crust almost. Hot wongs have a good bite.

Great pizza and wings

Just moved to st thomas 2nd time trying it great pizza an awesome prices

Awsome place wings and pizza are are enough said.

Best pizza in St. Thomas!!!!

Deeeeeeeeeeelllishioussssssssss...

It used to be really good, but they kept burning pizzas, the toppings have been sparse, and the flavour seems to have really died down. Even the quality of the cheese seemed to fall off about a year ago 5 stars for what they used to be a year and a half ago, 1 star now, I wont be ordering from them again soon that I can see. A pizza next door that has been sitting under a heat lamp is definitely the better go for me now, which is sad considering how they used to be my favourite place to go. I would even drive an hour to get one. If that taste comes back, I definitely will again. Im a bit confused by the some of the other reviews recently, as people I talk to in person have stopped going as well. It seems like recipes and ingredient suppliers have changed, which seems contrary to what the review responses suggest. To be clear, I dont want any handouts, Im not looking for any compensation of any sort for the burnt food. I just want the old quality back.

Good friendly.

Wings are amazing!!! And I love how you can order online now

Pizza Tonite - picked up one of their pizzas as we were in St.Thomas, passing through. Lovely town btw. If youve read any of my other food critiques, youll know how picky I am. Pizza Tonite has EXCELLENT PIZZA!!! It was so good in fact, that after we finished it, while sitting in a local park, we ordered another one to pick up, before heading home! So SO good! Yum. We will definitely be back, next time were in the area. _______ 2021AU Went back to the St.Thomas area and picked up another Pizza. Once again, Great Pizza! Were last there last year. Still a 5* rating

Great pizza and panzerottis

Very accommodating for dietary restrictions. Delicious gluten free crust!

Big fan of their poutine pizza and chicken wings. Their panzerottis are well made and I like that they have a variety of options for their menu. I like my pizzas well done and theyve done a pretty good job achieving that. Delivery is usually pretty quick and theyll deliver to factories for break time. I also like that its a family owned establishment.

pizza tonight used to be the best.. however I ve the years they have seem to cut cost dramatically I was a devoted customer. how ever after paying 67 dollars to get nothing near what I expected I d pay more for the delicious well cooked pizzas with real bacon again yes it was crispy chopped pieces instead of the pink undercooked crumble or the jalapeño poppers that were large crispy and served with sour cream instead of the small boiled balls of mush I received, I remember the delicious meaty big chicken wings that they served best in town now they are small and fatty. I loved you guys please bring back the old ways if your cutting cost your cutting customers too :(

Great wings and pizza

Food got here so damn fast the mozza sticks were still gooey. Amazing! We love pizza tonite!!!

Food is always good and great service. So many options to choose from.

Great food and service

Ordered one of their 2 pizza s & wings combo s tonight for my Dad & I to have during the hockey game. Delivery came within a reasonable amount of time. Both pizza s were perfectly cooked, and the wings were HUGE. All I can say is flavour explosion in the mouth. Pizza Tonite you guys did a fantastic job. Everything was delicious and very well priced. St Thomas is lucky to still have you guys around - we will definitely be ordering again soon!

We ordered a Mediterranean Pizza with a couple of extra toppings yesterday for a take out. It was the worst pizza we had in 21 years in Canada. It was very greasy and there is no feta cheese on top which is very important for Mediterranean pizza. You need a microscope to search for olives and other toppings Very disappointing.

Amazing wings!

Good pizza and best wings

One of our staples

My go to pizza place. Great pizza, wings and panzerotti. I order from these guys at least once per month. Never dissapointed. Great deals and fair prices.

Best pizzas in town, and you ll never know why until you try it.

Best food in town when it comes to pizza and wings. The staff can be hit or miss but its worth the order once you taste the food. The owners and cooks are top notch.

Great pizza and wings! The wings are freaking huge and the flavor options are good.

Best wings, great wedges, good deep fried cauliflower. Strangely good sour cream. Ive never had the pizza though.

Nice and friendly staff and The Amazing Pizza

We only order the wings, Best wings in town! And there so big!

Its like they heated up a frozen pizza

Absolutely amazing pizza garlic bread and chicken wings , when in town will order again

Wings are amazing!

This is pretty good pizza n the panseroties are amazing!!!

Very good

Its affordable. Its fast and even the gluten free pizza is tasty and thats saying something.

Wings were great. Didnt try their pizza after a terrible experience with the pizza tonite in Chatham.

Best wings in st thomas. Although I havent tried their pizza yet, their wings are amazing. They have plenty of flavors and variety to choose from. The price is also reasonable as far as wings go. If you are looking to order out or get delivery; pizzatonites wings are the way to go!

I asked for a deluxe panzaratti. They sent me whatever they felt like sending. The guy that i talked to a the place didnt even care to hear me out. Thats okay. I dont have to spend my money there. Dont waste your time. AND, AS YOU CAN SEE BY THE OWNERS RESPONSE. OR LIE. THEY DONT CARE. Ive spent a lot of money there. But you wont get any more out of me.

I ordered from here as a chef you guys need to work on your customer service anytime Ive ordered from here the person answering the phone is really rude if you hate your job that much try to make it less noticeable to the customer

Always amazing food. Best pizza & wings in town! Always quick service and nice people!

Lime was busy for a bit so I waited but when I called back no one anwserd ... 2 times ....

Incredible service. They told us it would arrive in 40 min, it arrived in 15 on the dot. Shout out evan and the delivery driver.

Delicious wings!!

Amazing

The best pizza, wings, and everything else. Great staff

Simply delish

Best panzerotti in town