Mikey's pizzeria in St Thomas
100 Wilson Ave, St Thomas, ON N5R 3R2, Canada
About
pizza takeout and delivery. authentic thin crust made by hand
Business Hours
Services
Photos
Reviews
Most Mentioned
So I ordered this pizza off skip the dishes and it was here relatively fast and it did arrive hot but I gotta say I was disappointed because the crust is horrible I can tell it was made with a low doe hydration level As the crust is very hard and brittle. Also caned mushrooms… it’s very meh pizza. Also for a thin crust pizza I get the dough needs to be lower hydration but usually it’s it enriched with butter to make it flaky and delicious…it doesn’t really seem like they put the work into developing a good crust. if you’re doing pizza crust is like the most important part besides sauce.
Great zza. St Thomas needs a great pizza place. Don’t listen to the haters who don’t know pizza. Also the 3.7 on Google is soo wrong. Look up Dave eats the Mikey’s pizza episode 👍
Decided to order Mikey’s for a family dinner tonight and was left utterly disappointed with the staff, including the owner. We placed the order over the phone and when I went to pick up 2 large pizzas and a dip, the total was $60. When I returned home I pondered on the price so we decided to call back just to confirm it was correct. My mother made the phone call just looking for clarification as we were a little shocked but still happy to pay this as we have been going here for years. As I was sitting in the room with her on the phone I couldn’t help but hear the blatant attitude from the lady, to which my mother asked to speak to Mike (who could be heard saying “just hang up” in the background). Instead of apologizing for the lady’s attitude, (which continued over the phone in the background as we could hear her rude comments being made) he told my mother that the prices are rising due to inflation and that she was wrong in her accusations about the attitude. Backing up your staff over a rude customer is one thing, but condoning rude behaviour is unacceptable. I hope Mike and whoever that lady was can learn from this, as we won’t be going back again. There’s many other local pizza joints in town that have friendly staff and better prices.
Pizza is disgusting. Congealed cheap cheese, meat is gross. Canned mushrooms? Blech. Terrible, defensive owner who doesn't give a damn. Don't waste your money.
Thought I would try a local business for a change. Ordered 2 large pizzas through Skip the Dishes. They use their own delivery person. Person delivered to wrong street. Continued to blame skip the dishes for putting down wrong address. Person at restaurant wrote down wrong address on bill, but would not take ownership. Pizza was cold by the time we got it. Way overpriced. 25.99 for a large pepperoni? Canned vegetables on pizza. Gross. Terrible first impression. Never again.
This pizza was utterly flavorless. Unseasoned sauce, unseasoned crust, even pepperoni that, against all odds, tasted like nothing. This pizzeria must be so ashamed of their boring, bland creations that they don't even have a label on their take away boxes. There is nary a design in sight! They also do not offer first-party delivery, opting instead to deliver through Doordash. This is not history's greatest tragedy but as someone who does not particularly enjoy paying the exorbitant fees charged by Doordash and also likes to get drunk and order a pizza it was a tinge frustrating to find out that Mikey's only offers pickup from their website. In conclusion, this was undoubtedly the worst pizza I have ever had in my life and I will recommend everybody try this joint just once to see what I mean.
The best thin crust pizza made the way I like it! I have stomach issues so I asked for very little sauce and it was made perfectly! I prefer canned mushrooms on my pizza and that is exactly what this place uses. I can't say enough positive about the amazing flavor of the food here. I would eat their pizza 7 days a week if I could afford to do so! Supper friendly staff as well.
This was the most horrible pizza experience of my life. Last night me and my wife ordered a pizza with pepperoni, bacon and pineapple on half but in to order we removed the pineapple all together and made it pepperoni, bacon, and ham. When the pizza arrived we paid delivery and tipped $2 but when opening the pizza I was shocked to discover it was a all pepperoni, bacon, and pineapple. We then called and asked about our order and if we could get a replacement as I cannot eat pineapple, then lady on the phone then started to get very rude and argued with my wife saying we didn't change the order and that we were wrong and she was right, we asked for a refund but refused and only offered us store credit or a new pizza. After 10 min of arguing we got then to make a replacement pizza, upon the driver coming back we were charged ANOTHER $4 delivery fee or would couldn't have our pizza. They didn't tell us this and so didn't have a debit machine and we needed to run around the house for $4. Disgusted with how this has all happened we finally paid the $4 and got our pizza. Unfortunately upon opening the new pizza we were absolutely disgusted with how it looked, nothing was done with care and it looked like like they just slapped everything on and to top it all off the pizza was barely cut at all we had to do it ourselves or it would have all come apparent as tried to take even 1 slice. My wife will swear it looks like a pizza the makers may have spit in just because we wanted out correct order. In the end after all this I was so angry and disgusted with how poor this place runs and treats customers and the quality of the pizza that we couldn't bring ourselves to to even eat it and we ordered from a proper pizza establishment, cost us another $22 because this place so in my advice avoid at all costs, spend you money on a place that actually know what they are doing and how to treat their customers. Here is a picture of the difference between the two company pizza's Mikey's is clearly on the left.
Good pizza friendly service. - Devon
I asked for light cheese and extra sauce with mushrooms,ham and tomato. It was one of the most delicious and perfect pizzas I have ever had.
Growing up, Capri pizza was the best pizza in town! This in my personal opinion, is the next best pizza to that.
The toppings arent great and the sauce is awful.
Okay pizza. Saucy and thin crust. The mushrooms were canned. The cashier seemed upset there was no tip.
Best thin crust around. If you re looking for thin crust, this place has the best in town. Uses only the best quality ingredients.
Ordered two panzos tonight. Lady on the phone was great to deal with and was also great in person. Panzo was perfect and delicious, also large. We probably could have shared one and they are generous with cheese. I would like to see more toppings on the inside. Great product, thanks for dinner guys
I have read most of reviews about Mikey s pizza and I do like their style of pizza. Reminds me of Capri but better price. Nice to support a family business to grow and exceed. If you have a problem with pizza I believe you should make them aware of any issues. There is other pizza places I don t like but never left bad reviews because it was not my type of pizza. Think before you put reviews that may not be fair!
My pizza was cold upon delivery. The crust wasnt cooked it was doey on the bottom. The crust on top had burn marks black! The pepperoni was not cooked. The bacon was raw and out of two panzorriitis we only had one sliver of bacon. The inside filling was practically bare and it had nothing inside! I had to rebake the two of them!!! I will NEVER ORDER FROM THEM AGAIN
The owner/couple/team are amazing. They ve had a lot of challenges in the town and overcame them 10 fold. Nothing makes me happier knowing the quality and service has not only gotten better over time but now they offer employment opportunities to younger kids in the community instilling hard work and discipline to their workers(hearing training and communication back and forth during pick ups). Not many places in town feel like a homegrown backstory anymore with exception of Andy s legends but Mikey and team are what makes this town maintain legendary status. Kid-friendliness: Kids have mouths and ears. Respectful environment for pick up no dinning..
Just ordered pizza . What a waste of money, I ordered 1 medium 3 topping and 1 large 3 topping plus tip came to over 50 bucks . outrageous!!!!! I ve had better frozen pizza from the grocery store. Starting with using canned mushrooms , cheap cheese, thin crust that was under cooked. Completely disappointed and will not ever order or recommend this pizza to anyone. Just another reason to quit eating out poor quality for way to much money !!!!!
Ive eaten at dozens of different pizza places, and I can honestly say without a shadow of a doubt, this was the absolute worst pizza I have ever head in my entire life. The pepperoni wasnt even edible. It tasted like it was under cooked. Very soft and no crunch to it.
I definitely dont leave reviews often, but I feel that for my level of dissapointment its worth saving others from wasting their money! Lets start with the outside sign not even being lit, when you walk in theres no overhead menu or pricing available so youre ordering blindly. They take cash only, and the staff is just unprofessional, flirting with eachother right at the counter like Im not even standing there. I ordered a panzerotti - the sauce wasnt even IN my food, it was in a cup in the box to the side. The ingredients were absolutely terrible. Mushrooms and sauce clearly straight from a can, cheese was like chewing on a rubber band and the crust was horrible. I also ordered a pepperoni pizza, the crust was thin, pepperoni was like rubber and wasnt fully cooked. For what take out is worth these days we usually finish our food but this was just force feeding ourselves. In the garbage it went. Never going back!
Great food and great service
They cant deliver on time , Mike needs to hire employees who cares , was a big fan of his pizza ! Pizza Tonight are way better ! At least they deliver on time ! Sorry Mike , Ill never order from you again !
Excellent quality pizza. The sauce and dough must be made in-house. The cheese is high quality and lots of it. The toppings are real and fresh. The crust is thin crispy and delicious. I wont order pizza from anywhere else. Staff is friendly, courteous and helpful.
Awesome panzerotis, great pizzas too. Very helpful staff for handicap ppl.
I wish I checked the reviews before wasting my $21
My husband bought a pizza last night and it was we wont be buying one again
The pizza crust is a bit on the thin side, but I personally love a thinner crust so it worked perfect for me. Got the 3 cheese and a half cheeseburger half Canadian. 3 cheese was basically garlic bread, but pretty good. Cheeseburger was good as well, but we really loved the Canadian. Dont know if it was the sauce or what but it was very good. The person who served us was kind as well. Will definitely be back for it.
Decided to give Mikeys a try. Pretty disappointing. Maybe other like this. But we definitely do not like canned mushrooms. The crush had no rise to it. And the cheese appeared to be pre shredded, instead of classic hand shredded cheese on standard pizza. Price was $57 for 2 larges and some cheese bread. Pricey for what you get. Was very similar to a grocery store pizza. Not interested in trying a second time.
I grew up eating pizza like this and its the BEST. FYI I love the canned mushrooms! Food : 5/5
I love the thin crust and pizza was delicious.
Well the pizza was very soaky the meat was fowl old omg it made me puked we had a few bite and spit it out horrible and never ever again we have ever had in our life the meat was rotten and it was so bad and we brought back the pizza and they refuse to give us our money back and we will report this to everyone we work with the bad old rotten meat and service we had all our family and family will be notified I give them not 1 way below 0 we had to bring it back the next day opening to the store cause we live out of town and we only had 3 pieces not half I taken a picture how do I install it but it was fowl and rotten meat unable to eat
First and last pizza from Mikeys. Canned mushrooms and cardboard crust.
It is a great pizza joint come out and try it
Great pizza. Almost like Capri Canned mushrooms .....only way to make real pizza great job and dont switch ever . Driving from Milton tomorrow for another pizza. Food
Great pizza!!!
Just moved to St. Thomas and wanted to try another local pizza business. The pizza was ok but the customer service was terrible. Every customer interaction is key either in person or over the phone and the lady on the phone taking the order was extremely rude. She was very dismissive and was getting frustrated because I was asking her a few questions. Sorry, but we will not be coming back.
EXCELLENT PIZZA. I loved Capri and these guys are even better. I will definitely be a return customer!! Thanks guys for the best pizza in town!!
My family use to buy Capri Pizza since I was very young, I grew up with Capri, when I heard of this new Pizzeria that was making pizza just like Capri did, We ordered a selection from Mikeys and it was like we were back in Italy. My 90 year old grandma swore by Capri pizza and she was so happy to try it again after so many years. Keep up the great Pizza.
Mikeys pizza are a great prices as well as fast delivery!! I love theyre & wings as well as panzerottis
Fantastic pizza made by Fantastic people, and the staff there are super kind.
So baby brain was in full effect and I called in an order of Pineapple pizza instead of Hawaiian and garlic bread. Then called back a few minutes later saying I just ordered a Hawaiian pizza and garlic bread and was asking if they had a chicken ranch and they said no so I said ok just the Hawaiian. So hubby went to pick it up and lo and behold it was just the Pineapple pizza. It was kinda gross. I tried eating it and got one slice slice but couldnt eat anymore. Plus both the pizza and the garlic bread were on a thin crust. Nowhere did we say we wanted that or were warned that it was like that. I called back to say that I was disappointed that not only the pizza was gross but that when I had called saying I had ordered Hawaiian they didnt clarify with me whatsoever that originally I ordered Pineapple. They offered to make one but I was just about to leave for a meeting and didnt have time for that. Then was offered a refund and said all we need to do is to come in the store. So my husband who was now feeling quite sick drove there to get the refund and was told he needed the pizza as proof as they dont give refunds without it. He was literally about to throw up and they just kept changing the narrative. Money down the drain. Dont go. They cant get their $h!t together. Never going to order from them again.
Worst pizza experience ever! Service was horrible, rude and unfriendly. If you want thin floppy pizza with a bad stomach ache the next day then this is a good place to go.
Pizza was burnt tonight the cheese was all dried out tasted like rubber and the owner didn t care . Very poor customer service I don t think I will order another one. I was a steady customer there but Mike don t care
Just ordered for the first time based on a recommendation and man, Mikeys did not disappoint! 2 large panzerottis. I ate a quarter of one, my boyfriend ate half of his, and they were fantastic!!
A really good place for thin crust pizza. The crust has a nice crunch to it as well without being burnt.
One of my favourite pizza joints in town. I love the thin crust pizza.
Im giving 1 more chance to redeem been a costumer since opening but customer service needs to be better in all departments
After weeks of debate, we gave Mikeys a shot this past week. Its a local pizza joint and we thought it might be a diamond in the rough, but this was not the case. First off, the positives: theyve got a great crust, decent sauce, and pretty alright cheese. Despite these positives, we werent able to finish our order because of their toppings. Mikeys uses canned mushrooms, which is not great. It seemed like the other toppings were not cooked all the way through. Plus, the meat toppings were sliced pretty thick and they seemed to be store-bought quality. It was a disappointing pizza for the price. Mikeys would have decent pizza if they would improve their toppings.
The best pizza in St.Thomas!!
Callum is by far the best employee so kind and respectful towards customers
Fantastic pizza and great service. Started going after a friend recommended and has been my only pizza place in St Thomas since. Great for people that like a thin crust pizza that is still soft on the bottom and the cheese is nice as well. Only problem Ive ever had was when they ran out of feta, and when I came to pickup they insisted it was free. The pizza was still fantastic
Great place..fast service with excellent value on superb products
Pizza was very lacking in flavor. Canned mushrooms are not ok on pizza. Cheese was rubbery. Sauce needs work. I hope the owner can find there passion they once had to make people great food.
Kid-friendliness: This place that Ive ate at before was beyond rude when I asked if they had two bone/flat wings. They said no I cant do that and I asked ok if I ordered more can they put flats in one order. The lady said no and I dont like your attitude. I was very nice and polite when I asked what can you do? I dont get her attitude when Im spending my money there. Anyways I do NOT RECOMMEND MIKEYS PIZZA!!!!!!! If you cant handle people asking questions dont start a business. Ps all there toppings are caned. Poor service and quality
Love this place. Proper thin crust pizza
Tried for first time - good taste and value but no excuse for using canned mushrooms!
This was my second time ordering from this place. My first and last. Thought I would give a new business a shot. Never again!! Worst food I have ever eaten. Very disappointed
Continuing the Capri quality! Near perfect thin crust pizza. A must get when Im in town
Awe job guys, great panzeroti and pizza, thin crust cheese on top, great tasting and a great price
Excellent pizza will be back
It was pretty good. I had the small pizza with bacon, sausage and tomato. It was not a bad pizza in any way other than the fact that their crust comes thin. But there is room for improvement in terms of menu and setting but they seem new so i cant say to many bad things. Its better than lambeth pizza and Byron pizza thats for sure! And a lot better prices than both of them.
First time trying this place. Absolutely rubbish. Flimsy pizza, sauce has a hint of grossness and biggest mistake of all... canned mushrooms. Puke!!! And the wings were over cooked and dried out. Even my three children were disgusted by the pizza and the wings.
Pizza was awful. It was really soggy. Bacon wasnt cooked.
Worst pizza we ve ever ordered. And on top of that, there was a long hair cooked into the toppings. Will never be ordering again. Gave one star because it would not let me select none.
I have had pizza from coast too coast .and Mikeys is deft in the top 5 ..the crust was perfectly cooked and they use ovens .not cooked on assembly line .the toppings were delicious. The pepperoni plenty. Deft the best pizza in st thomas hands down ..
Had a Deluxe and a Canadian Pizza tonight from Mikeys. Both were absolutely delicious
Great thin crust pizza
my go to pizza when I want thin crust quality pizza
The best Pizza around!! If I could give it more than 5 stars I would! Delicious! And Im not even a relative! Haha sooooo good. The only thing is I wish they opened earlier. Why do they open so late? Should open at noon. You could sell pizza by the slice at noon seeing how Parkside school is so close. Not to mention I live out of town and Id rather pick it up earlier.
not as good as good as Capri was, but a close second. you either like thin crust or you dont . I would buy again in a min
Quality Ingredients (Real Bacon!!!), thin crust. True Pizza Perfection!
Long time waiting for a great tasting pizza. Super busy but well worth the wait.
Toppings were great size, pizza delicious
The closest thing youll find to good old Capri Pizza that used to be on talbot st in st thomas. Amazing super thin crust pizza
I love there puzza
I still mourn Capri but this is the best pizza in town now!
Just had Pizza From Mikeys It Was Absolutely Awful, Way Too Much Sauce, crust Is Way Too Thin & Crunchy I Will Never Ever Eat Pizza From There Ever Again I Will Go Back To Pizza Tonite
We just ordered their specialty chicken ranch pizza and wow was it horrible the pizza was under cooked showed up cold. the chicken on it wow I didnt know it was possible to make chicken so terrible it tasted like it was boiled and many days old the worst part was it was in such small chunks we couldnt even pick it off this was by far one of the worst pizzas I have ever tasted
Amazing pizza
Amazing pizza!! Definitely reminds me of Capri on Talbot. They dont skimp on the toppings, the thin crust is incredible, and everything is of high quality. Really excited to have a good pizza place in St. Thomas again.
Mike s pizza was recommended by a friend. Excellent taste, the sauce is a highlight, reminds us of pizza enjoyed in Italy. A hit with the whole family. Also, a thank you for your safety protocol. It was noticed and appreciated. See you again!
Excellent Pizza ..first time eating Mikeys definately will return!
Love it! Only place in St. Thomas now that still does canned mushrooms.
First time I ordered from here and it will be my last ordered the Thursday special.. wings were good but that was the only thing that was... placed order along with the garlic bread and asked how much for delivery.. it was 4.00 as long as in city limits and she asked how I was going to pay.. I said debit.. got my pizza 1 hour and a half later cold and to top it all off she charged me 5.oo for delivery because I was in Dalewood opposite corner of st Thomas but still in city limits and 1.00 for debit machine and the charged taxes on top. of the 5 and 1 dollar.. BS and was rude when I called to inquire about cost... It was the worst service and pizza Ive ever had
I ordered a pizza with bacon on it. The bacon was RAW. All 4 of us that were eating it were disgusted by the raw bacon and couldn t eat it. The bacon was pink and white. Not cooked at all. I called and said that s what we thought and I thought for sure they d say oh so sorry about that, let us send you a new pizza but no, instead they gave total attitude and said that their bacon is precooked.... yah no it s not. It was so pink and white. Looked like it just came out of the package. I said that 4 people are very unhappy and can t eat the pizza because of it. She gave more attitude and I said that s a terrible way to run a business and that there s now 4 people who will never be back. I do not recommend this place.
Best pizza in St. Thomas, hands down
Yum!! Amazing garlic bread, i mean honestly the taste is amazing. Not bland at all!! Tried the wings tonight, and absolutely impressed.
Delicious, hot pizza every time and really nice staff. Not made by some mega-chain, so the flavour is excellent. Thin crust is their usual format but they will make it a bit thicker if you ask when placing your order. My only request would be for them to add non-pork meat options for toppings (ground beef, chicken, etc.), but that doesnt stop us from ordering.
Easy ordering via phone&quick delivery,Delivery person Amazing & PERFECT PIZZA !! HOT & exactly how we ordered,will get again(many times)
I should say that I have never ordered from this place before. The reason why is because I never, until today, thought this business was operating. There is no signage on the pylon sign or on the storefront. The business does not open during the day, and whenever I have called the phone number, nobody answers and there is no voicemail. If this owner makes any money, I am shocked because the operations are terrible. I am surprised that the Landlord of the plaza even allows a tenant to operate without signage and regular business hours!
Best pizza in St T thats for sure. This is yum, just see the pic it says it all. Real ingredients Wish I ordered moar!
First time there pizza was very good and good prices and staff are very friendly
My family and I tried Mikeys Pizza and it was really great food! The price is fair too!
Love it...it reminds me of Capri pizza
Awesome pizza a little pricey but way better then capris
Mikeys Pizza..........the best there is. All other pizza places can shove it up their rear ends.
Tasty pizza ...thin crust no grease ..very good pizza
My new favorite pizzeria in St Thomas.
Theres finally good pizza in St.thomas! We ordered delivery on a Friday night,got in within a half hour,piping hot. Amazing pizza. You have to try it!
Popular place. Reminds me of Capri Pizza before they closed. They use real bacon which is a ++. Expect to wait, but it is a quality product worth waiting for.
