Magnone's Italian Kitchen in The Blue Mountains

I called ahead for a party of 6 and they dont take reservation and told us to come down to join the waiting list. When we arrived they told us they dont know when a table will be ready, and took my phone number and will call when a table is ready, and they never call. It seems that they dont want to serve us, and just sent us away. Glad we found another place to eat and not stupid enough to sit and wait all night.

John was spectacular!

Writng an update to my 2023 review: Amazing food! Great vibes! We had the Gnocchi Bolognese and the Funghi pizza. The funghi pizza was so light and so full of flavor. The gnocchi was melting in our mouth and the sauce was so rich. Our server was Sarah and she was the best! She made sure we were comfortable and made the experience even better! Update on December 2024: came here for our annual family trip. Went back to magnones to relive our date. I am not sure if there was a change in management but the restaurant food has completely changed. Terrible terrible food. We ordered the calamari. There were 8 pieces of calamari that was so salty we couldnt eat it. The funghi pizza, we reordered based on what we had last year. The pizza looked or tasted nothing like the one I had. Cheap cheese, pre made dough, cheap mushrooms and crunchy parmesan. I left 2 behind. The gnocchi had gone from the menu. I should have taken the hint then but I ended up ordering the carbonara. Im no Italian but if an Italian saw that carbonara they would lose their mind. I have no words to describe the atrocity that me and wife had to eat. Needles to say, this has ruined Blue Mountain for me. I wont be coming here. I asked what changed from last year and they told me that its a seasonal menu which doesnt make sense as I was here last November. I miss the old Magnones.

Had an enjoyable night at Magnones. Great service from Mila, and the pasta dishes were tasty.

OMG everything was sooo perfect and our friendly server Mel was amazing! And thanks to our kitchen staff who made the food sooooooo delicious i had the pizza , it was perfect . Thank you Mel, hoping to visit again with my family soon.

Melissa was very sweet, her recommendations were amazing and my girlfriend and I had a wonderful time

MEL!!!!

Mila is amazing

Had a great time! Delicious food and our server Andrew was amazing!! Thank you so much for making this dinner a great time

Food was low-key mid and EXPENSIVE ash - dough and pasta tasted store bought. Waiters were nice and the ambiance was super cozy though.

Fantastic food & atmosphere, the garlic knots were so good we got a second order of them! Mel & Mila served us and were awesome, we ll come back

Mila and Mel took amazing care of us! Food and service was 10/10! I had the mussels and my husband had the carbonara and both were fantastic. Service was great, attentive and welcoming! Thanks for a great meal!

Ordered bruschetta bread and truly the worst I ve ever had. It was dry and tasted like old pizza. There were a few tomatoes on it but mainly just tons of mozzarella cheese. Our server also didn t ask us how our appetizer or meal tasted. The pasta was ok got the chicken carbonara but it reminded me of Kraft dinner. Also expensive and for the taste wouldn t recommend.

We were seated promptly and our server was very good. Appetizers came out promptly: mushroom soup was excellent, beet salad was good, calamari was salty and dry and very little calamari in the order. One person in our party ordered the seafood pasta and the pasta seemed off, sent it back. Entrees came at different times for the table. Pizza was cooked okay but nothing special. It was unfortunate for the server who was excellent, that the food was sub par.

Quality of the food 10/10, service was wonderful, had a great experience with our host Andrew. Highly recommend !

Andrew is an amazing waiter and so funny!

Mel and Allie were exceptional. Best Italian food since we have been to Florence

Exceptional service by Andrew! Food was amazing and fast service :) Vegetarian options: Lots of options Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly!

We celebrated my mother in laws 60th birthday here and had an amazing time. The food was delicious and Robbie was amazing! We were a large party but he made sure everyone was taken care of and was always tended to. We would definitely come back again.

Food was great tasting, Robbie was a wonderful waiter and gave us a great experience at Magnones Italian Kitchen.

Julian provided exceptional service and the atmosphere was wonderful! The food was good as well

Calamari and mushroom pizza were amazing!

Had a great time eating at Magnones Italian Kitchen! Food was great, service was even better! Andrew and John made sure we enjoyed our food and explained all dinner items very clearly. Andrew went above and beyond to ensure that we loved every single item we ordered. Would definitely recommend coming here :)

John was great!

Pizza, that satiates my inner Ninja Turtle. Now back to the ski hill

John was the best server!

Vegetarian options: Limited. Food

Robbie has been very helpful throughout our stay here ambiance is good, food is perfect!

Love the food and the ambience! Robbie is so amazing and very accommodating

Robbie was so great and welcoming. The food was delicious and we love the mushroom pizza!

Robbie was really accommodating and attentive to our group. The food was good and big enough to share for a group.

Amazing atmosphere, food was delicious, every course came out better. The service was amazing (shout out to Robbie!). I would definitely recommend this place!

Andrew L is great

Andrew Leto was the best

Our server Andrew Leto was very attentive and efficient. Loved it! Alfredo pasta wa amazing!!!

I wish the reviews were not this misleading. Overall I will never step foot in that restaurant again. I read all the reviews online and this place seemed to be the best. The waiters were great especially hope. The atmosphere was also decent. The seats are uncomfortable and too small. So if you are a bigger male this place isn t for you. Now the food, the apps were okay, wish more marinara sauce was included and the garlic was too much. Now for pastas, I ordered the tasteless Alfredo, my date ordered the rose sauce pasta. Her pasta was mostly sauce with 4 pieces of shrimp(I counted). Mine was 4 oz of chicken on flavourless pasta with no salt. The prices for such par food were Insane. We spent over 30$ per past plate which had barely any protein and tasteless food. Plus we got charged an extra 3% on top of the inflated prices for convenience fee. The mango gelato was good, tasted like real fruit! Overall get in your car drive 10 minutes out and get real food for real prices. Hope was great though!

We had an amazing experience dining here! Caesar Salad: 10/10 Perfectly balanced and flavorful. Mozzarella Balls: 7/10 A nice appetizer, but could be a bit more exciting. Margherita Pizza: 100/10 Absolutely phenomenal, a must-try! Pomodoro GF Pasta: 8/10 Delicious, and great to have gluten-free options, however didn t feel authentic enough. The staff were incredibly friendly and provided excellent service. The atmosphere was cozy and welcoming, making it a great spot for a relaxed meal. Highly recommend, especially for the pizza lovers!

There is no way this place has a 4.5 star rating without getting friends and family/staff to write these. I was going to get the chicken parm but decided to go for the three course meal (regretted 2/3 courses). The appetizer was probably the best course and the other two fell flat. The music was annoying for an Italian restaurant but seeing as no one was Italian this is not surprising and service got severely slower as the meal went on (which was weird seeing as less people were in the establishment). I would or recommend this place to anyone I know as it is overpriced and under performing. The one in for the app solely not the brine soaked 9.00 chicken I got added

I went there with my boyfriend, we asked for no chicken in the pizza but we were still served that. The person serving us was very rude, no sorry thank you manners! The price for just one pizza and pasta was $114 with Zero Service! Would never come back here Food

Andrew was a great server/host! Our food came out so quickly and his service was excellent. This was our first time visiting blue mountain and Magnone, and we will be back!

Andrew is the funniest guy I ve ever met! Such a great dinner, and came out so fast.

Andrew was great!!

Andrew was great 10/10

Extremely average Italian food. Do not go for the pasta. I am not sure why an Italian place would want to put carbonara on their menu and trash the dish by adding cream, white wine (?!?!), parsley. I am lost for words. Pizza is passable, better then the pizza chains nothing else. On the positive, service is good.

They charged $2.50 for Parmigiano cheeses to put in the pasta and there was no offer of fresh pepper

Overall food was mediocre at best. The pasta sauce was sticky something you would get from a frozen dinner and the shrimps small. However, when I asked for parmigiana for my pasta I was told it would be an extra $2.50. The waitress acted very indignant when our table all agreed it was shocking.

I dont typically write a review, but feel I need too. The waitress was lovely. The expensive mocktail came in a water glass with very little ice. (It could have been a childs drink). It should have come in a stemmed wine glass for the price. The food was disappointing. My husband did the Blulioucious special and the Caesar salad was so small it arrived on a bread plate. The Pasta Alfredo had no taste (not even a hint of garlic). When I asked for parmesan cheese, they told me it would be an extra $2.50. First time Ive ever been in an Italian restaurant where they have charge for parmesan cheese. I would not recommend this restaurant and we will never go back.

Terrible food, the expo girl(long brown hair) was rude and lacking a personality. She stood at the front of the table and had us pass the food to the appropriate person. She had more than enough room to serve each individual customer. She didnt smile, was very rude. Actually rolled her eyes with annoyance. The pasta (at an Italian restaurant) was actually pretty gross. No flavor, over cooked, and way too saucy. For the price you pay, I expect a lot better food, and better service.

The restaurant wasnt busy when we went, tiramisu and the mushrooms on the pizza was really good but service needs to be improved.

Bad experience with a simple drink. Horrible service they dont know how to handle their own work . Food

Terrible experience from start to finish! they took forever to get our drinks and it wasnt even that busy! the menu says italian cuisine but our dishes looked anything but Italian! (and this is coming from a pure-blooded Italian). Of the various dishes ordered, the worst was definitely the Carbonara, described on the menu as authentic, with the right ingredients; unfortunately I was presented with a watery pasta, full of cream and parmesan, to mask the flavour! oh.. and to be completely honest there was no trace of egg yolk! Not to mention the completely exaggerated prices for a restaurant like this. $23 for a glass of wine, with an unclean and still wet wine glass! The waitress was quite sarcastic, unprofessional and definitely not attentive to the customer needs! To put the cherry on top of the cake, when leaving the place, we saw kitchen staff sitting on the kitchen counter, which in my opinion is not at all hygienic! In conclusion, after a night awake with indigestion, I can say that a fast food or pub would probably have been better!

We had high expectations based on all the 5-star reviews. Definitely not authentic Italian food. Pizza was okay, a bit salty. The bruschetta was cold in the center and a bit thick for our liking. The pasta wasnt spectacular but the sauce was okay. All pasta was served al dente which is fine if you like it that way. Overall not too impressed. Didnt taste Italian at all. Wont be back based on the food. Some positives: service was amazing and huge portions. Definitely shareable.

Expensive bad service bad food never going again over price for the bad tasting pasta they served me and the big dude serving us Oct 27 2024 around 6pm shift definitely needs to find himself to do something else

We waited over an hour for a table (even though they had said it would 20-30 minutes at most) at this restaurant and had high expectations based on all the glowing reviews. Unfortunately, the food was incredibly disappointing it was some of the most flavorless food Ive ever had. The pizza was all bread, with hardly any cheese, and the sauce had no taste whatsoever; it seemed like they didn t add any salt. The mozzarella balls and garlic knots were equally bland. Overall, it felt like a colossal waste of time and money.

We were in on a weekend in October, the village and restaurant were very busy, our dinner was so good, we had appetizers, pizza, and chicken parmesan, wine!! For dessert the choc cake and a latte, both were so delicious, Our server Madison did amazing! Thank you for a great night.

The atmosphere is laid back and relaxing and the waiters/waitresses were really nice and one of the waiters named Andrew was really good

Thanks so much to Andrew and John they were amazing.. they helped us bring the stroller upstairs. What a great team and amazing food. Thank you..

Andrew was a greay server. Very personable

Andrew was an incredible waiter and very knowledgeable.

Too loud. Too dark. So many people drunk. The menu online is not the same they have at the restaurant. Cheaper items. The wait was more than they said.

My wife and I came here to relive our time in Italy and unfortunately we were very disappointed. This is not an Italian restaurant or atmosphere. First, we ordered an appetizer which was poor, tasteless and we had to get our own plates to eat it as the server was oblivious. Second, the Apirol Spritz was mostly water for $19. Third, our pasta dishes were atrocious, no taste, mushy noodles, minimal meat, minimal cheese and whats mostly not Italian, no bread served with the pasta to enjoy the sauce which was poor at best anyway. The restaurant was loud and they seemed to push you out to get the table turned over to another customer which is also not the Italian mindset or lifestyle. The prices are outrageous for the quality and portions. Go somewhere else if you want an authentic Italian restaurant for a better price.

Andrew was an amazing server and great experience.

Food was great, and an even better experience with Andrew!

Very delicious! Our waiter did an amazing job. The cream of mushroom soup was top notch and we loved their Pizza Margarita.

I would not recommend dining at Magnones. A majority of the food was very basic and not worth the price. We had the Focaccia pomodorini as a starter. It was two simple pieces of toasted bread with a single cherry tomato. We also had the homemade ravioli which was under cooked and tuff. The other main was the beef short rib with polenta. The short rib was the only part of the meal that was tasty and tender. The polenta that was served with the ribs was cold and we had to have them bring a new order of polenta. Overall the food was below par and expensive. Id recommend choosing another restaurant and not waste you money for a poor meal.

Food was good, but very unaccomodating. Unwilling to make even the slightest change to menu items. Rushed us out of there the second we put our forks down. And, as is everything else in Blue Mountain, quite pricy.

Andrew was an amazing server! We loved our dinner and service was great.

Andrew was the best !

Andrew was so amazing, he was not a great singer, but he tried and saying happy birthday to me all by himself. It was the best birthday gift ever.

ANDREWS GREAT... best service ever. Danced for our birthday

Great Ambience and service. The food was very delicious and the Vodka Ragatoni is a must have. Our server Julian was very sweet and helpful and made our visit very pleasant. Food : 5/5

Food was world class. Best vodka pasta Ive ever had. Exceptional service by Julian as well. Very friendly and helpful.

This place was an absolute blast to have dinner here. Andrew was the best server and gave our table of 7 people 4 free deserts. Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free

Andrew was a fantastic server!!

Andrew was a fantastic server, he was very mindful of our table and was very kind and charismatic. Very enjoyable experience. Dietary restrictions: We had gluten free person with us and our server was very helpful

It s a nice place with super friendly staff especially the young girl who served us by the name of Hope. She was so sweet, professional and friendly. The only thing I didn t like was that they charge $ 1.50 for extra cheese! That s embarrassing!

We split a Caesar salad and had the rigatoni bolognese and a salsiccia pizza. The food was great! The flavour and quality of the ingredients was excellent. Mel and Emma we awesome were very helpful and attentive for our visit. We will return and highly recommend.

Excellent service from our waitresses Mel and Emma. Friendly and accommodating. The food here was delicious. Well prepared and fresh. Highly recommend for those looking for a nice Italian restaurant.

Food was decent. But be prepared to stop at Wendys on the way home if you re hungry. Small portions and never got drink refills

Our dinner last night was great. This was our first choice for restaurants in the village, and we were lucky to get a table. It was really getting busy. We all ordered from the Bluelicious menu and I am glad we did. Everything was yummy and we took home the left overs since we were so full. Beautiful restaurant!

Cafeteria food with fine dining prices. Incredibly poor quality food-I ve had better at Eastside Mario s! The bruschetta tasted like an undercooked frozen pizza bagel- It was shockingly bad. $30 for what tasted exactly like a jar of grocery store tomato sauce and basic shelf pasta and then they tried to charge $2.50 for a sprinkle of parmesan cheese! So tacky and embarrassing. Another person at the table ordered chicken Parmesan- it was burnt and tasted like frozen chicken breasts- same jarred sauce and over $40. The carbonara was so salty it was inedible. We were also charged a 2% visa charge and we didn t even pay with credit card. The nickel and diming was so off putting. I ve never seen a restaurant charge for parmesan cheese and a visa usage. So many better restaurants in the area- will not be returning.

Overpriced pasta and they request to pay for the cheese that tops off your pasta!!!

Absolutely the best place to dine in at blue mountain village. Give it a shot, authentic Italian cuisine and delicious food with excellent service by the staff and shift manager. Will repeat for sure

Did not have a pleasant experience at this establishment servers were extremely rude to myself and my family and to top it off the server got upset after seeing what i left as a tip and as for the food it was very dispointing quality of food

They dont make them like robbie anymore. Great service, even was able to pick up through paying attention that it was my wifes bday and made it special. Thanks!

Robbie was so attentive and went above and beyond! He even found out it was my birthday and brought out a candle on my dessert. Would definitely recommend this place for great food and service!

Robbie was excellent, service was wonderful.

Great place to visit. Food was scramptious and the customer service was exemplary. Great menu selection.

One of the only places to dine in the village. We came a few weeks ago as a family to dine in. Will was our sever. He was fantastic, friendly and very attentive to our kids, which many servers aren t these days. The food was really delicious and fresh - we ordered pizza, burrata and the gnocchi. It did not disappoint. We look forward to come back again!

Posting this after watching the guy and his family do a dine and dash on Global News and skipped out on his almost $400 bill at this great restaurant. My friend and I enjoyed our early dinner last week at Magnones and we actually paid our bill like you are supposed to. Our server was just perfect and made our visit most enjoyable. I ate every single bite because it was so good and my friend ended up wearing some of her meal. I do not recommend ordering the linguine if you are wearing white. She was flinging the tomato sauce all over the place. Too funny. Thanks to that guys bad behaviour being caught on video and social media stepping in, he has been charged. His familys days of being professional scammers of free dining are over.

Had great service with Andrew tonight!

Had Robbie as a server and it was such a great experience if you come here request to be seated in his section

Mushroom pizza was AMAZING!! Classy yet warm ambience. Our server Robbie was so wonderful. Great recommendations and exceptional service. Will come back again and again and hope to be in his section. Vegetarian options: Amazing options

Great service. Superb food.

Must try for authentic Italian food when in the mountains. Simple yet flavourful...

Just-so-so pasta. Rather pricey due to its location.

The ravioli, pasta, and pizza were very good. The chocolate cake wasnt good at all... Food

Great food! Our server Andrew was amazing and so helpful

They do not allow baby strollers in the restaurant. The food is mostly tomato sause based, similar taste dishes whatevr you ordered. Some dishes, such as calamari and pizza are not hot when served. Kid-friendliness: They are not baby friendly. If you bring a baby stroller, they do not allow a baby stroller in the restaurant with the reason of fire safety.

Great food and service. Robbie was awesome and very attentive. Thanks!

It just okay, nothing special, salad dressing was too acidic to taste anything. Seabass was so-so, short rib and spaghetti was good. Portions are small for the price. Food

The food was really good and the service was quite quick even with my large group of 13 people. The staff were also very friendly and helpful.

Amazon Italian restaurant with tasty dishes. The alavotca pasta is spicy and delicious. Chicken Parmesan is so juicy and delicious.

Food is not worth the price and they charge extra for everything.

The hostess was a bit of a pain. She told us the wait would be 20 minutes and we waited an hour and a half. Id rather she just been honest so we could go somewhere else. Food was fantastic and our server was amazing. The only downside was they wouldnt allow any substitutions. I understand a kitchen and restaurant of this magnitude needs to run quickly but when it comes to food allergies I cant mess with the food I eat. I ended up ordering the chicken parm which was amazing, however, my friend ordered the carbonara and was disappointed at the child like portion size. Pasta is cheap so not sure why theyre serving such small portions. Dietary restrictions: They wont make substitutions Parking: Its a bit of a walk from the parking lot into the village where the restaurant is.

Mel was an excellent server. We had a great dinner!!

Love the food and our server was excellent

The food is good, the service is impossibly slow. We sat there for 15 minutes, no one came up to us. We asked the administrator when we can get anything to drink she said they only had one server for the whole restaurant and we had to wait

Definitely not fresh food here. Our focaccia was both burnt and cold in the middle. We advised the server and she brought us another one that was just warmer but more burnt. Would not recommend.

We made reservations. It specifically asked if we were celebrating anything special so I made a note that it was out 10th anniversary that evening. I mentioned it to the waiter, and he said theres nothing complimentary not happy anniversary, just that. Ok. No problem. My wife asked for extra parmesan cheese. The waiter informed us there was a charge. Ive traveled all over the world, and this is maybe the 2nd italian restaurant Ive been to that charges for extra cheese. The service was horrible. The server was abrupt, basically dropping our plates and leaving, or answering questions with one word responses. The only saving grace was the good food. Which Ive had similar tasting dishes at less expensive places. The website recommends an 18% tip, which Im not opposed to, but as a server if you expect an 18% tip, then as a customer, I expect service worth 18% we will likely return to blue mountain, but not Magnones.

The food was fresh and flavourful....real authentic Italian cooking. The restaurant atmosphere and furnishings helped convey a quality establishment, enjoyable to eat in. John, our waiter was excellent. He was very friendly, attentive to our needs without us having to ask and extremely knowledgeable about the menu items. He also presented this menu information in a very enthusiastic and pleasant manner.

Mel, our server, was very cheerful and energetic. It added a pleasant atmosphere. Dietary restrictions: My mom has quite a few allergies, and seeing that they were able to accommodate her without issue was a nice surprise.

Small portion for expensive meals. Great restaurant location, busy and noisy most of the time. Kid-friendliness: Safe for kids to be around.

Excellent experience at this restaurant! The atmosphere was perfect as was the food But the best part was our server, Italian Margarita AKA Mel! She is unequivocally the best :) Food : 5/5 |

Pasta was extremely undercooked and it s very overpriced for how little portion you get.

Very good food, a bit on the pricey side. Would definitely recommend it if you want to treat yourself.

Good tasting food, don t go if hungry or in a hurry.

Ordered a pizza which was $30 and what was served was flat bread obviously pre made. I felt completely ripped off as I was expecting a decent pizza, not an appetizer of 6 pieces. Manager was unwilling to make amends after I explained that they do not advertise it as flatbread pizza.

Food is fantastic, tastes very authentic Italian. The staff helps you make right choice for your occasion (Thank you, Andrew!)

The food here is great! But our dining experience was made even better by our server Andrew! What a fantastic and attentive server!! Thank you so much Andrew, you are amazing!

My family and I came to eat here while staying in Blue Mountain. I m sad to say I was a bit disappointed. I ordered the pasta carbonara but it was more like an Alfredo sauce. Not even close to carbonara. The pizzas were above average but nothing special. Fairly average Canadian Italian food. But the prices are as expensive as a 5 star restaurant. For these prices, they should at least hire some Italian chefs. I would not come back.

The gelato was just . The calamari was crispy and delicious with their sauce. Our waiter Andrew was very helpful and kind and had our food come out fresh and hot!

Andrew was awesome with our dining experience. Cant wait to come back again! Food

The Alfredo is not worth it and the appetizers are pretty small for what you re paying. Also, they don t let you split the bill multiple ways which is pretty odd. The food isn t worth the price either.

The best Italian food we had since our trip to Italy in 2019. The whole Sea Bass dish was delicious. Pasta was cooked to perfection and Tiramisu is to die for. Highly recommended.

Michaela was an amazing and attentive waitress! She was quick to arrive, checked on us often, and super friendly with a great smiling face! My wife and I would be sure to ask for her again! Food was phenomenal! Loved everything about our experience!

best mr andrew thanks

First time visiting and this restaurant was fantastic. We are big Italian fans and this did not disappoint. Our server Andrew was super friendly and extremely helpful and I can t wait to come back and eat here again!

Overpriced but what can you expect in the village at Blue. The food was at best Olive Garden, East Side Marios quality. Never again!!

Great food!! I had Alfredo Pasta and that s the best I ever had in my life. Would love to come back.

Service was good. Other than that, everything was terrible. Food was bland. Pizza was soggy and tasted like Tim s pizza, very disappointing for an Italian restaurant. Alfredo pasta had 0 flavour. Even the salads and appetizers were really bad. Don t be deceived by the lineups. Not worth the money at all. Save your money and go elsewhere.

I was disappointed with my experience at Magnone Italian Eatery. The food was mediocre at best, with little to justify the high prices. Service was notably slow, and the ambiance was lacking the place is in need of a renovation to match its price point. Overall, I expected more given the cost and location.

Great food ! Andrew took great care of us and even befriended the kids ! A+ service Kid-friendliness: Nice kids menu ! Took great care of them

Food was excellent and staff are friendly.

Highly recommend italian authentic cousin . We ordered margaritas pizza and ravioli were really delicious . Costumer service also great. Special thanks to Our waiter jon.

If I could give 20 stars I would. Hands down our best meal in the village. Handmade pasta was incredible and so was the pizza. This is my new favourite restaurant. Im already waiting to come back next year. Only downside is youve kind of ruined pizza and pasta for me now because it wont be anywhere near as good.

Food was tasteless, considering the pricing

Ordered the peach salad & focaccia bread starter and it wasn t worth it . The bread is very dry and doesn t have a flavour . The salad was tasteless too. I really had high expectations from this place Food

$26 for 23 pieces of pasta $36 for chicken Parm, which looked like a half order. If your hungry, dont go here. Saw the waitress once, had to flag her down for the bill. The bill came from another waiter. For a nice romantic night out, we were pumped out in 36min and seated in the middle of two families of four and we had reservations for over a month.

Fresh pasta, homemade style sauce, this lead to an amazing meal. Very special Thank you to Andrew for going above and beyond on making our anniversary dinner even more special by surprising my Wife and I with a slice of chocolate cake. Food : 5/5

Its expensive but food tastes good and service is great too!

Hannah was a delightful server, very attentive and pleasant. We appreciated that the music was at a level that allowed for conversation. The food was delicious.

The prices are too high given the quality of the food. Despite being an Italian restaurant that serves pizza and pasta, they charged us extra for parmesan cheese, which felt unreasonable. The pizza itself was far from an authentic Italian pizza.

As an Italian i gotta say that I expected a place more for tourists, but i was gladly surprised, me and my wife were super satisfied about the food and service, a good experience

This is my first time ever writing a review yet a negative review, We had a server who was not nice and would rather to be somewhere other than there. I felt the negativity right away and asked him if right away if he was all right etc. sometimes we all have bad days, but he said no it s just a regular Sunday Beside our experience I noticed he was also rude to a family with a todler . We didn t want to spend our wedding anniversary there so we left our food paid our bill and left. Hopefully you ll have better experience than us.

Came here for a friend s birthday .food was fantastic and Hannah was a gem highly recommend

What a fabulous way to spend my birthday! The food was amazing and the service was equally amazing! Hannah was there for our every need and answered all our questions to make sure we were satisfied and had the best experience! Thank you so much Hannah! We will definitely be back!

The meal was extremely disappointing. I had to send back the chicken parmesan as it had an unusual taste, almost as though it was spoiled. Despite this, I was not offered a menu to select another dish and was instead given the same dish as another member of my party, as I mentioned hers tasted better. The replacement dish was poorly prepared by the chef and did not match the quality of the other party member s meal, despite being the same item. The sauce was watered down, and the chicken was dry and overly salty. The waiter was unprofessional, clearly aware of my dissatisfaction but made no effort to address it. I will not be returning.

Service was quite slow, food was satisfactory.

Mel was an amazing server, loved the food and the atmosphere

Mel was an amazing server and took great care of our party of 8.

The food is sooo good! I highly recommend the pasta Alfredo with spicy sausage !Mel was the best! My son remembered her Ans she was so warm and inviting!

mel was great Parking: good parking Kid-friendliness: kid friendly

Love the food and service was good too!!! All nice people working in this place!

This is the first time we visit this restaurant, the waiter gave us an unforgettable experience. We informed the waiter while we found a fly in the pizza. He replied that he can redo it, but there may still have fly in the next one caused there are flies everywhere . This is really an disaster. Besides, the appearance of Foccasi is not bad, but actually this is cold inside.

Loved the carbonara and the pepperoni pizza. You can give the tiramisu a miss but definitely try the chocolate cake!!

Maddi was our server and she was so sweet and nice

Selwyn was great

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Magnone s in Blue Mountain, Canada, and I must say, their Rigatoni alla Vodka is an absolute delight! The pasta was perfectly cooked, maintaining that ideal al dente texture. The vodka sauce was rich, creamy, and wonderfully balanced, with just the right hint of vodka adding depth without overpowering the dish.

Selwyn was kind, attentive and thorough in getting our food right! Thank you so much!

Selwyn had a really food service with us, we enjoyed our night

Selwyn was excellent. Very attentive. I wish we could have mushrooms on our pizza though.

Selwyn was great!!

Amazing food and desserts, Selwyn was a great server and super friendly!

Selwyn yay

Over priced, food was below average, waitress was fake. Bread , salad, parm cheese extra

The mushroom pizza was amazing!

Andrew was amazing! Thanks so much!

The pastas were the WORST no toppings at all and only salty and texture were so bad. DONT EVER GO THERE. Trust me its so bad and expensive. I ate like 3 spons and gave up

The service and food was amazing!!

Mainly writing this review for the server who was manning the entire place on his own during peak lunch rush, and never missing a beat. Food and drinks were great as well!

The food and service were impeccable!! Andrew was our server. He knew his stuff and was able to make great recommendations to my father-in-law who requires a gluten free diet. My in-laws are by no means Italian and so the guidance was much appreciated. Also, my 11 year old was indicating that he wanted the adult pizza as opposed to the pizza on the childrens menu. Andrew was able to reassure my 11 year old that the pizza on the childrens menu would suffice just fine for him, and it sure did! Lastly, my husband was able to nonchalantly communicate with Andrew that we were hoping to pay, and treat my in-laws to this meal. Andrew understood the assignment and approached this task with the necessary tact and consideration it required. Also, on the kids menu was an option for meatballs, which my four year old thoroughly enjoyed (thats all he ever wants, and Magnones delivered). I highly recommend the lemoncello drink, and my 14 year old daughter enjoyed a drink from their non-alcoholic options. My only constructive feedback is to make the upstairs area, where we sat, a bit more inviting. Need to do something to elevate the atmosphere up there. As we headed up the stairs I wasnt sure what we were in-store for; it was a slight let down upon arrival. Its a bit dark up there, with dated carpet. The chairs are small and sit a bit high for the table, which is made of beautiful natural wood. All in all, a really great experience at Magnones. So pleased to add a five star review to their already stellar record!

Faith was amazing!

Magnones Restaurant provided an excellent dining experience, thanks to our server Faith. Her attentive and friendly service stood out. The Gamberi Pasta and Salsiccia Pizza were both superb rich flavors and perfect portions for the family. Highly recommend this spot for great food and outstanding service.

I am from Boston and we were visiting blue hills with family. We ordered Chicken Parmigiana and it was bland. The food was not made with love and there was no soul in it. Other reviews are good and I think, it depends on the chef inside. On July 6th, 2024 at 5:00 pm, chef made horrible chicken parm. It was KFC food at three times the price. please visit north end in Boston and see what fine dine Italian food is. We do not plan to return.

Had the pleasure of dining at Magnone s during my most recent village to the resort. Overall was super impressed by the service, food and overall atmosphere of the restaurant. Our server, Faith, recommended the rigatoni which was one of our favourite dishes of the meal. Simply delectable. We finished off with a chocolate cake that is simply memorable. Do recommend to anyone at Blue Mountain!

We rank this restaurant as the best in the village. Our waiter was very friendly and attentive. Our food tasted fresh.

Great authentic Italian food. Accompanied by a great atmosphere and customer service from our waitress, Piper. The margarita pizza was very fresh and authentic, as well as the excellent tomato sauce on the pomodoro. Would highly recommend the next time you come to blue mountain.

Dined at Magnone s Italian Kitchen in Blue Mountains and had an exceptional experience. The classic pepperoni pizza and rigatoni pasta were both delicious, showcasing the restaurant s commitment to authentic Italian flavors. However, the standout was undoubtedly the Tiramisu di Magnone s it was the perfect end to a wonderful meal. The dessert was rich, creamy, and absolutely divine, making it a must-try for anyone visiting. The ambiance was cozy and inviting, and the service was top-notch. I highly recommend Magnone s for anyone looking to enjoy a fantastic Italian meal in Blue Mountains.

Chicken parmigiana was not that good as expected.

We had dinner at Magnone s Italian Kitchen. The starter we ordered - olive e Nodini was burnt and we were surprised the chef let it be served and more so the waitress did not say a word! There is no reason to serve burnt food even if you are busy. The pasta pomodoro was over cooked and again the order was messed up and we had to remind the waitress to correct the order. Over rated restaurant serving sub standard food!

Horrible horrible experience. We went with family to enjoy some time together. The waitress was super rude, no service, the food was not good, the attitudes were not acceptable at all, customer service was 0. I wouldn t recommend this restaurant to anyone if customer service and attitude is important to you. Even the manager s attitude was not how you expect it to be. Overall 0 not even a 1

having made the reservation through Tock and noted in the reservation that we wanted to surprise my husband for this birthday with a cake. We originally booked for 3 p.m. but arrived at 2:30 p.m. in the village, and were kindly accommodated early. The ambiance of the restaurant was fantastic, and the food was excellent. Our waitress was very attentive and helpful throughout our meal. However, I was disappointed that l made the note through tock about my husband s birthday, which I had asked the waitress to read, seemed to be overlooked. Despite my expectation that they would bring out a dessert to mark the occasion, nothing was brought to our table. This oversight was particularly disheartening given the special nature of our visit. Overall, while the dining experience was pleasant, the missed opportunity to celebrate my husband s birthday as requested was a letdown.

Nice place, food was ok. Service by our waiter John was great!

Felt my dinner was not homemade authentic Italian. Asked for extra parm cheese and they want to charge you 2.50$ for tiny container. Have never experienced this at any restaurant. Would not return.

This is a terrible and overpriced restaurant. I will never dine here again. They also treat their staff terribly. Do not support this business.

Disastrous experience! The food took forever to arrive and when it did, it wasn t good. Ordered the chicken parmigiana and the sauce was watery and the chicken was terribly unseasoned!! It was so bad that I wasn t even sure it was real chicken, tasted like tofu (in a bad way). Had my family member try it and she wasn t sure either. The service was the only good part of this mess. Other guests seemed displeased at the wait time for food as well. Horribly overpriced as well, even after they comped my order (which was again was the only good part of the meal).

The extra charges on everything is not good. They charge extra if you use a credit card, want cheese on a pasta. Chicken parm was just okay.

Great food! Great service!

Terrible Experience!!! We were visiting Blue Mountain for two days and from Tik tok videos we chose to dine on the first day at Magnone s Kitchen. We waited around 5 mins to be seated although the restaurant wasn t busy at that time. Then the waiter came and welcomed us and said he will come after couple of minutes to take our order. Suddenly the waiter came back and said sorry we won t be able to serve you the pizza oven just got broken ! Haha We didn t even order pizza and they are serving a lot of dishes and pizza was one of them but not the main dish on the menu It was a big surprise for all of us even some of the kids were saying we want Alfredo pasta not pizza but no one cares. We left the restaurant and waiters were gathered and looking from time to time to us. Anyway I don t recommend it at all even if it has the best food , I would say it has the worst environment and zero respect !

Our server Laura was fantastic. Highly recommend the gnocchi in bolognese sauce.

My friends and I had a great experience dining here. The customer service is amazing! All the employees are extremely cordial and polite. Great food and atmosphere.

Julien was a very attentive, knowledgeable server. We had the amazing carbonara with a very nicely paired bottle of wine and tiramisu was spectacular. Highly recommend! Food

Wonderful food, wonderful service. Great place. Clean and cozy.

Service and atmosphere were great. Had some very small chairs, which after about 30 min were not comfortable. The food was good, but not great. I think I was given tofu chicken by mistake, so if that was it then the food was great otherwise.

The food was delicious. Loved their bruschetta and the alfredo pasta . Drinks were okay, not a lot of options. Food

Nice patio. My meal was good. Service was attentive. My friend ordered a beer and there was something off about it and they brought him a different kind immediately and it was fine. No charge for the first one. Parking: Because the restaurant is inside Blue Mountain Village, there are large parking lots around. You then walk through the village to reach the restaurant.

I had the Italian mushroom pizza and my wife had the Alfredo shrimp pasta. Authenic italian approved. Would definitely recommend if youre in the Blue Mountains looking for Italian Eatery is the service was great the patio is great the flavors are great Food

Food was good not great but very poor service Took over an hour for our order with no apology or follow up while waiting for order Our server took our order and we did not see her until the bill came.

We read the Google reviews and decided to order take out. The only thing that tasted good was the chicken parmigiana sandwich, the salad that came with it was wilted. The rest of the food was bland. The Caesar salad had no taste and for the price, it was the size of a side salad. We added chicken breast to the salad, they forgot to include the chicken and we had to drive back from Collingwood to the mountain to get it since it was paid for. It looks like they sent one chicken breast for the two salads ordered. We placed two orders of the Pappardelle Alfredo, one with shrimp and one with chicken. The pasta had no flavour and it too was the size of a side dish, not a main meal. We had to add our own cheese plus salt and pepper to get some taste. I would not recommend ordering take out. I wont be giving them a second chance, way too much money for small portions and tasteless food. We would have been better off to drive the extra distance to Sheardowns in Meaford.

Food was great and Will was a fantastic server. He was personable, engaged with our group and social. Shared some tips about the area which was very helpful.

We went for dinner. We has Ravioli Estivi, Rigatoni alla vodka and Verdure bianka Pizza. Ravioli was nice and tasty. Pizza was ok , it had potato on it. Not my taste though that is personal taste. Rigatori was first undercooked. They changed it gracefully , then it came with a watery sauce which showed the chef s haste to send back the food. Again understandable. To compensate, they offered gelato on the house but my daughter was full so we declined. Food is pricey for the quality in my opinion. Staff are nice though.

Probably one of my all time favourite restaurant experiences, amazing food, even more amazing service! Our server Andrew went above and beyond for our table! Give him a raise!!!

Not only was the food amazing, but our waiter Andrew was so helpful with our questions and was very caring about our food restrictions. Thank you so much. Dietary restrictions: Nut allergy safe.

I wish I could give more stars, the service was amazing. Andrew our waiter was so delightful, helpful and kind. The food was authentic and tasted delicious. We came with a big group of 6 and everyones food was delicious. Andrew went above and beyond. Kid-friendliness: N/A

Me and my friends are actually still here but i truly could not wait to write a review. It was my 5 friends and I and we had such aba amazing time at Magnones but the most memorable part was the service. As amazing as the food was we had a server named Andrew and i cannot explain with enough words how amazing he was. He was SO friendly and checked up on us frequently, he accommodated to our every annoying request and i just want to say he was one of the best servers i genuinely have ever had. Magnone s is so lucky to have him, made the experience 100000 times better. Me and my friends are so so glad we decided to have dinner here. If Andrew sees this, you were amazing Andrew! :) Dietary restrictions: Halal

One of the best restaurants in the Blue Mountain Village! Our family of 4 had dinner mid week in late August. We made a reservation which I would recommend. The servers were very personable and professional. The food was some for the best food we ate in the village. The Caesar salad was good. The Linguini Carbonara was a standout dish. Great flavour in the sauce. The Ravioli Estivi was bursting with flavour even for diners who don t love eggplant. The Margherita pizza had great flavour and a good ratio of toppings to crust. I did opt for the prosciutto which was thick cut but I would leave that out next time. The Gnocchi Bolognese was just ok. We followed the advice of another reviewer and ordered the chocolate cake for dessert. A nice balance of a creamy pudding like frosting with a surprising hit or rich cocoa flavour from the cake itself. A delightful surprise. This is definitely one of the better restaurants and a must try when visiting the Blue Mountain Village. A special shoutout to our wait staff, Lauren H, who made a delicious meal even more enjoyable. We never knew the restaurant happened to be understaffed until speaking with the Manager to provide praise for Lauren s service. Bravo!