North of Brooklyn Pizzeria in Toronto

The best place to eat a good pizza, drink special beer and listen good music

Great pizza, great vibes, bar with pool and old games like moon patrol, miss pacman and galaga, Tetris DK Jr and pinball.

Bad

Amazing place!! great pizza great vibes and great service

Ordered in-person, sat at the bar for 45 mins, pizza never arrived. So much for dinner! Lets hope they at least know how to do refunds.

Good atmosphere. But waited more than 45 min for my pizza, and never got it. Ordered in store, got a receipt and almost an hour later, no pizza or garlic knots, and no record of it. They may not know how to make a pizza or take an order, lets hope they know how to process a refund. But I cant in good conscience review their food, because they never made it. Would not return.

I love their Green out with mozzarella cheese and dried tomatoes!! The atmosphere and service is too apt!

One of the best pies in the city. Packed with people, and so food takes a lot of time to get. Delivery is also kinda slow tbh, but always with the wait.

One of the best pizza spots in the city, plus you play a variety of arcade games. They also have this really tasty spicy honey from a farm in Ontario. Dietary restrictions: Gluten free option available Kid-friendliness: 19+ after 8pm

Always good as usual

The best slice you can get in Toronto and the bar staff are excellent!

Killer bee is a must try item!!

Truffle shuffle is amazing but you can t go wrong with any of the pies. Don t sleep on the garlic knots!!

Goood pizza but why char the kale to blackness????

Portions were huge, it was really delicious, thanks.

Best pizza Ive had a long time

I tried the whole menu, everything is great. Biggest complaint is I offer my roommate a slice and by the next day they give me $40 because they ate a whole pizza.

Food was fine service is terrible Indian short guy was extremely rude other locations are fine but this one worst customer service ever

Oh man, I ordered a margarita pizza on Saturday , and it was delicious. Unfortunately, the cook who handed it over to me seems he hates it there..... acted like I was begging for the pizza when, in reality, I paid for it!! Really bad costumer service.!

Best thin crust pizza i ever had! Vegetarian options: Vodka verde, mushroom and spinach pizza Food : 5/5 |

If not The best, One of the best pizza s around.

Hate this place. Extremely rude staff. No manners at all

Very unhelpful and mean staff. Will never go again

Never ordering Door-dash from here again. Never received a pizza/knots which is even warm. Cold pizzas always. Clearly they keep online orders their last priority and put zero attention to it. I want to see what the owner responds to this review. I m sure others who have ordered online from this spot has had the exact same experience.

One of the tastiest pizzas in town

Great pizza, however inconsistent with the pepperoni. Some time its perfect, sometimes theres barely any

My go to pizza chain. Have been ordering for years and never has disappointed. If you like a thin, crispy yet chewy pizza dough, look no further. Highly recommend the killer bee, margherita, truffle shuffle and vodka verde. & Cant forget their garlic knots! Food

I was drunk and wanted pizza. Lo and behold I stumbled upon this joint 10/10 would drink and discover again

Great place to go after work in the evening if you work downtown.

Love their pizza. End of story.

Love there vodka verde.

This place is NOT for families. Thee music is absolutely blaring making it difficult to speak and when you ask to lower it a little they give you a blunt NO. Youll leave with a full stomach and a massive headache

Garbage staff

Pizzas are good but very thin crust. Have vegetarian options too.

Way better than Queens Pizza

I recently visited North of Brooklyn Pizza on Geary Avenue, and overall, it was a pleasant experience. The venue offers multiple seating options, including a patio, an upper floor, and indoor seating. If youre looking for a quieter spot, I recommend sitting outside the indoor area can get a bit loud, especially during peak hours. One thing to note is that you have to purchase drinks separately inside the store at a designated area. The food ordering is also separate, done at a pop-up café of Brooklyn Pizza located inside. The outdoor seating was particularly enjoyable, providing a relaxed atmosphere that contrasted nicely with the busier indoor space. It s a great spot for a casual outing, especially if you enjoy dining al fresco.

Magical mushroom pizza! Wow! New york style and authentic and amazing and wonderful !!! Wow!

Great pizza and great quality toppings! Definitely worth checking out if youre looking for a great pizza. Location is ok, however dont expect a quiet evening out on the patio as the surrounding traffic and train noises, definitely can be annoying to a certain degree. Seating is first come, first serve. Parking is also limited, so the location is transit friendly. Great selection of craft beers and mixed drinks, at a premium price and the walk up bar can be busy and slightly unorganized.

My fave pizza place!! Always consistent and delicious, either by the slice or a whole pie. Have eaten in and taken out and am never disappointed. This location in particular I would highly recommend :) we have a location closer to us but the quality is subpar in comparison.

Best Pizza in Town!! You can always expect Excellence!!! Parking: If it was really busy on the strip, you probably wouldn t get parking. Food : 5/5 |

The staff is very rude! I walked in to order a pizza and was told they don t take orders at the counter. You have to order online and then pick up the order. It s the most ridiculous thing that I have ever heard. There s a person standing right in front of you but they will not let your order for in person for take out. The staff hate their job! They are rude and unprofessional. I live in the area and walk by all the time but unfortunately I will not be retuning. The price for a pizza is excessive.

Refused to make me a pie cause they were too tired, who runs this place!

I ve had this place in person and it was wildly awesome. But this delivery is pathetically undercooked.

Top quality

One of the best pies in TO

Always a hit, never a miss! One of my favourites pizzas. Edit: spoke too soon, was a miss this time but not terrible. Saved it with some marinara Food : 4/5

Rude behaviour with uber eat drivers

The pizza actually slapped but it feels like a quintessential downtown eatery, how do people afford to live downtown idgi

Definitely one of the best pizza in Toronto.

The place was chill. Went with friends for a slice of pizza and tried different slives both veg and non-veg, they didnt disappoint at all. Will visit this place again.

Vegetarian options: Vegan friends recommend Food

Amazing pizza

I m honestly pretty disappointed I read such amazing things about this place just to have all expectations let down. The pizza was extremely over cooked to the point where it was almost inedible. The Asian girl at the door was very sweet and that the only reason for the second star. I ve tried all the hyped pizza spots in Toronto and honestly this one should not be on the list. I hate posting bad reviews because I understand the struggles of building and maintaining a reputation but this really needed to be said. It was $56 for two medium pizzas and two dips! That absolutely ridiculous for what we got. When I tried to fold the pizza it literally snapped it was so over cooked. I think if you guys want to keep your good reputation you re going to need to stop trying to pump out fast pizzas and focus back on quality. If the pizza is Burnt toss it tf out and make a new one. For the price we re paying the least we should get is a properly cooked pie. Very disappointing, I drove over an hour for this.

My favorite pizza place in the city, it comes out perfect every time we order.

Good food. Greenout is the best one from them. Food

Nice Spot! Parking can be fun, overall A+

Amazing pizza, summer time is hot outside so try to sit inside

Really good dough, best pizza in area.

They don t take reservations for party of nine at 6pm on a Tuesday we wanted to try but they were not receptive We went elsewhere had a great time, spent lot of money, there s lots of choices

229 Geary Ave location - I arrived Friday at 8:00 with my son (16 years old) for sit down pizza dinner and was told (with attitude) that the age limit is 19 years or age after 8pm. Totally pissed me off after driving through city traffic in the rain for 30 minutes then had difficulty finding parking only to be told to go away. Nothing on website warned me of this scenario. Who heard of an effn pizza joint that won t accept minors? Besides the place looked like a dive anyways. Save yourself the aggravation and patronize another establishment.

Best pizza in town!

Still the best, thank you for the creation that is the truffle shuffle! Have been searching around Toronto for the something better, have not succeeded, still the best 2023 update:Ordered with Door dash and : First of all way better than Uber for some reason, but my god I had to come and just add this here , I ordered the Truffle shuffle which is a favorite and NBP has outdone themselves again and who ever was working that day July 27th 7pm should absolutely get a prize , I have had pizza at technically the best pizza in the world in Phoenix at Biancos after 3hr wait but the dough wasnt this good. 2024: grown in past year in number of stores but hasnt changed one bit in quality! Thanks

Terrible pizza spot. Tired to order at 10:20pm to tell them I d be by in 10 min to take my order and they said I had to order online. Went to pizza pizza. Losers

Arguably the best pizza in Toronto - try the margarita! You won t be disappointed

Vodka verde is absolutely delicious.

People hyped it up so much but in reality it was uninspired. Meh!

Best pizza in Toronto

Stopped by to relax and enjoy some pizza, but unfortunately were greeted with very rude staff immediately upon entering. Didnt realize that the pizzeria is housed within The Greater Good Bar, and THEIR staff are the absolute worst. It seemed our presence was a huge inconvenience to them (especially the guy with long hair behind the bar), and he was only scrolling sunset pictures on his phone. Our overall atmosphere was tainted by the staff s attitude. It s clear that customer service is not a priority here. If you are wanting a nice evening out, go ANYWHERE other than here! Our margherita pizza at North of Brooklyn Pizza was great, BUT wont be back to experience the rudeness again. There are plenty of other dining options where you can expect to be treated with basic respect and courtesy.

10/10

Absolutely love this place the pizza is amazing! Love the vodka pizza

Delicious pizza with a super chill vibe what more else is there to say! Stop by and grab a slice!

Absolutely amazing pizza!!!

Killer bee and truffle shuffle are unforgettable, go back wherever I can.

Pizza is great, definitely come here its a good time, Im just confused as to why they couldnt do half and half on a pizza when theyve done it for me in the past

Want pizza? N.O.B.

Great Pizza and a wide Variety of Craft Beers!!!

The pizza is soooo good! Thin and crunchy, with a fluffy crust. Highly recommend the Vodka pizza with sesame seeds on the crust!

I went last sunday, and i ordered 2 pizzas. After i paid, I was informed that i had to wait 45 minutes, after those 45 minutes they told me to wait 10 more, at the end of the story i waited 1 hour for 2 pizzas and they were just okay. I felt a lack of cheese on both. But the first one looked like cooked 15 minutes before the second one. I been here a couple of times with very good experiences, but this time was disappointing.

Be careful ordering from here through Uber eats I just did and they gave the wrong order and are now not taking any phone calls. so Ryan, if you ordered a pepperoni with mushrooms, I don t know where your pizza is going to be, as I gave it back to the driver. Food

Nice place, both to eat in the restaurant and for delivery. Pleasant atmosphere and wonderful service

Vegetarian options: Great pizza Food

North of Brooklyn is the best pizza joint in Toronto. Period. Nothing else compares. The quality of the cheese and dough are head and shoulders above anything else Ive had. And the best part about it is I can kill an entire pie on my own without feeling like I was hit by a truck. Absolutely guilt-free and simply out of this world NY-style pies.

Always a great experience here!

A go-to pizza spot for me and my girlfriend! Always delicious and made well, and the service is excellent.

Pep > cheese. Pass on vodka pesto. Good beer selection.

pizza was good! paired with good craft beer~

Today I had a bad experience they sold me Burnt pizza, I told them and they told me like that, its serious, then a guy the cook told me like that, with an angry tone, the truth is its not worth coming to eat a burnt pizza like that, Ill never come back

I ve been a customer for years and this pizza specifically was not up to the Nobro standard. The dough was stretched way too much in the middle, especially for a Killer Bee. No undercarriage, almost no jalapeños or pickled onions. If being floppy was not enough, came in with part of it folded. Flavour was there but in general, this pizza did not slap. Service also was not the best, and I always had the nicest most friendly staff helping me out but not today.

What an ambience to hangout with your loved ones. Especially the arcade games and the bar makes it a perfect combo for the weekend.

pizza very fresh, staff is great!

Definitely the best pizza in Toronto... Love the Verde, green out and cheese pizza!

Wonderful pizza shop inside a bar. Pepperoni was amazing, the sauce was top notch however the crust wasnt as good as Bandiali (had both the same night) as it was lacking that beautiful crisp hot bite. In addition the pizza decayed rapidly as the heat dissipated so definitely a dine in spot. The bar has a really nice feel with dark lighting, second floor pool table, and great tunes for fans of alt rock.

Great pizza! Very thin but still tender with a good chew. My wife and I went on a Friday evening and the place was slammed, we each ordered a medium pie and while it took a while, it wasnt unreasonable given the crowd. Its self-serve seating, and while it did take a little effort, we found a couple of seats on the back patio that was the perfect temp on an otherwise slightly chilly spring night Overall a great down to earth vibe, perfect spot for an after work hang orba lte night bite with great food and a fantastic beer selection Vegetarian options: There are plenty of pizzas that are only vegetarian toppings and a good selection of vegetarian toppings for a custom pie

10/10 Pizza I recommend eating at the restaurant definitely worth eating fresh. The Bar/Pizza place is a great way to spend an evening!

You pair the best pizza with beer AND theres arcade games?? This place is amazing for any occasion. Whether its a first date, or hanging out with colleagues after work, or just anyone. This place is just a great icebreaker and a great vibe. The bartenders are super cool and take good care of you. Lots of IPA choices that are always on rotation to keep things interesting too!

A bit expensive

Wow guys .. came here after a year, lived in the area my whole life. Yall make good pizza but DANG.. Ordered no mushrooms yall gave me extra mushrooms and it was so burnt i could snap it in half. Literally so bad yo I dont know if its the quality or if whoever was working just is so checked out but.. its not the same as it was. I remember when the medium wasnt that small also..

One of the best pizzas in Toronto for sure! I tried the margherita and the pesto pizzas. Both were super delicious. Full of flavour and right amount of cheese. The crust is the USP about this place for me. This location shares the space with a brewery so you can grab a fresh beer from a varied menu, along with a pizza and enjoy the patio (if you can find the space) & sit indoors with some nice music.

That s a good pie, but that garlic dipping sauce was *chefs kiss*. I could drink that sauce by the gallon. The sauce was not pictured, but you should know what garlic sauce looks like. By the way, the pie needs more truffle cream or maybe some drizzle of truffle oil. But at 11pm after a night of drinking, anything tastes good.

I ve tried the normal whole pies but this was the first time trying the slice. I have to say, highly impressed with it! Made it into my Top 5 slices in Toronto!

Great place, where you can sit and have a pizza and while waiting have a beer and enjoy the music. I believe this is the only North Brooklyn pizza that has a seating area. Food

One of the best late night slices you will find on this side of the city

Excellent pizza. Wish they had more of the vintage video games. They were fun to play. Good selection of beer

The pizza slice was good. The atmosphere is okay! Toilets really sink badly please maintain the hygiene.

Great food, went back again today and an employee told us we couldn t wait and to get off the patio out front because we were 15 minutes before opening . Went to the pizza place down the street instead.

A very delicious pizza. A real treat!

Save yourself the trip. Unnecessarily hyped! Unorganized seating, its basically a college cafeteria with open tables and customers will sit there for hours without ordering any food and play games. No decency for people waiting in the line up for a table. Disappointing experience. No customer service. You cannot enjoy your pizza. Take out is best

Parking: On the street Food

Loved the truffle pizza !

One of the best pizzas in Toronto! So tasty . The location is inside The Greater Good bar. Plenty of seating. Good atmosphere, with an arcade and a couple of patios. Highly recommend Food

BEST PIZZA in Toronto! Their flavors esp Vodka Verde is a masterpiece. Also Geary branch is great esp for a good night out with friends. A must try for everyone! Vegetarian options: Has good vegetarian options and its pretty good too!

Pretty frustrating that they have decided to start charging for the sesame seed crust on the pepperoni when it used to come as standard - that s not simply inflation, it s pure greed and price gouging. Also, if I m paying $1(!!!!) for a sesame seed crust, I want the seeds on the crust, not piled on the sauce. The garlic dip is more chive than garlic, disappointingly. I remember the pizza as being better than it was. Probably wouldn t return.

I will have to confirm my review when I eat this a second time, I m an avid pizza lover and I think this might be the best pizza i ve ever had.

Very bad experience

Staff is very arrogant

Staff is very arrogant

Staff is arrogant

I went to pick up a pizza here on a late Saturday night. This is located inside the Greater Good Bar and the atmosphere is really cool. I ordered online from Google and I learned not to trust the pick-up time Google gave me. It said the pizza would be ready in 30-40 mins, but when I actually picked up the pizza the guy said it was ready in 10 mins. It was 1 a.m. so Im guessing the wait times this late are much shorter and Google didnt take it into account. But the guy working ended up giving me an extra garlic dipping sauce for the wait. I got a medium pepperoni pizza, options for Large pies are not available late night. The pepperoni pizza is a very thin New York style slice and was really good. The dipping sauce had an odd taste to it, not sure if they are all like that or the one I got. But I dont like the dipping sauce here. Would come back to order pizza again.

North of Brooklyn Pizzeria delivers an amazing pizza experience. The crust is perfectly crisp, and the toppings are fresh and flavorful. Each bite is a delight, making it a go-to spot for pizza enthusiasts. The quality and taste truly set this pizzeria apart, earning it a well-deserved reputation for excellence.

Great time out. Fun and exciting place.

Great pizza, Great Selection of Craft Beer on tap, Open late Vegetarian options: Truffle Shuffle Pizza is amazing!! My go to pizza Food : 5/5 |

Theyre definitely one of the best pizza joints in the city. Also at a very reasonable price per slice!

Repeatedly coming to this place. Staff is very polite, welcoming and accommodating. They read and follow special instructions very well. Keep up the good work.

Incredible

March 13, 2024 update...okay the take-out pizza may occasionally be cancelled, but the absolutely stellar response from head office (presumably) has been lovely! Really appreciated the personal response and explanation. Good pizza is one thing, good people are another. North of Brooklyn has both. (And yes, the service stars went from 1 to 4 thanks to K*****s response.... Happy to boost it to 5 the next time unsuccessfully get a takeout pizza!) March 8, 2024 update...cancel culture at the Geary Avenue North of Brooklyn strikes again. Sigh. Order accepted. Order confirmed. Order cancelled. I was foolish to try again on a Friday. 2023 - Have gone here for years (Covid excepted) & done takeout pizza. Lovely atmosphere and aside from a long wait for food its solid. But dont bother with takeout! Theyll charge your credit card and then send an email cancelling your order! Has happened 3x recently. Last time we didnt see the email - because who constantly checks email on a Friday night?! I waited 25minutes in line only to be told it was probably cancelled because they couldnt get it done on time!! Other than that suggestion the staff wad obviously overwhelmed and not in a position to care about my cancelled order. VERY irritating that theyve still charged us!! Aside from this feeling a bit like a reverse restaurant robbery...how about having systems in place where a) you dont charge a customer until youve provided the product, and b) you have a separate line for pizza pickup so I dont have to wait 25 minutes to be told my order has been cancelled. Eat in. Do NOT takeout. Also need my money back.

Best pizza in Toronto!!

Great pizza good sauce excellent cheese

Because I was going to a party, I passed by a shop with a lot of people. I bought a single piece recommended by the clerk, which has a spicy and sweet flavor. I was so surprised that I bought it. I then queued up to buy another flavor. It was so delicious. Yeah~ I want to try all the flavors Thank you to the service staff and chef~

One of the best slices in the city! Nothing complicated or extra with these slices: thin centre with airy crust, just enough cheese and sauce that aren t too overpowering, and balanced toppings to compliment the over all pie! The truffle shuffle is bombbbbbbb! They will be seeing me again soon

Hole in the wall no nonsense pizza and beer!

Great pizza! If you want good beer and service, go to blood Brothers down the street and then come here for some great pizza! Dont bother with the drinks at greater good, trash employees , trash service , trashy owner. If it wasnt for North of Brooklyn I would never even enter this establishment.

Best pizza in Toronto. The cheese pizza is incredible. Highly recommend the garlic knots! Vegetarian options: Cheese pizza is better than anything on the menu!

Really good pizza and beer. It was my first time there and will definitely come back.

Favourite pizza in the city. Killer Bee leaves all your taste buds buzzing with honey, hot peppers, sour pickled onions and savoury sausage. Best enjoyed freshly-baked, sitting outside. Truffle Shuffle partners up mushrooms with caramelized onions (and the truffle complements rather than overpowers - always smells like BO elsewhere to me).

Pizza arrived cold. Staff member said. We are not responsible for pizza temp after it leaves goes out for delivery. Food

Vodka verde was delishhhh

The BEST pizza in Toronto!! This location s atmosphere is 10000/10.

North of Brooklyn is my favorite pizza joint in the city. Absolutely love their fermented hot sauce!

Great pizza, but they forgot the dipping sauce I paid for when they delivered. They did give a refund at least.

the food was good, i feel like it s very hyped up in the city, it s truly basic but good! i prefer north of brooklyn over king slice. the garlic knots were also so good. the ambiance was amazing with the candles and dim lights. i would recommend trying it out especially if you are in the area

Delicious pizza!!!!

Its a great place for a pizza-and-beer date!

Delicious pizza

Dear North of Brooklyn Pizzeria, We love your Killer Bee pizza and have purchased it many times, particularly through a delivery service - but please, please, PLEASE, consider adding a seal to the pizza box. We would be comforted to know that it remained sealed during transit, especially in this day and age. Thank you!

The best pizza weve ever had!!! Omg The best!! We had the kale, the honey spicy, and the pepperoni with cheese. Sooo good . Ingredients so fresh!! Our new favourite spot!

One of my favourite pizza spots in Toronto. They never disappoint!