The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria in Toronto

Amaaaaaaaaazingggggf

I can t recommend this place enough! Such kind staff and delicious pizza that is fairly priced!! :)

Very bad service

This is the best pizza in Toronto

Honestly, the food is just okay. The pizzas are gigantic, like 18, but for 3 toppings on each side of a half and half pizza, it was pretty pricey for what we got. Maybe come here if youre in the area, have 2 other people to split a pizza with, and happen to all agree on the ingredients. That said, if youre into it, the pineapple slices are gigantic, so that was interesting.

Cute little pizzaria and inventor of The famous cake donut which is a must try after downing a pie of course.

Ordered on Uber, food arrives cold and they give you a lesser portion of dipping sauce at the same price as dine in. Note left by staff saying dine in receives the full portion of sauces, so it seems like a blatant rip off since you are paying the same price, if not more because of delivery charges. Food is good for dine in, service is just ok.

Great service... 5 star just for having a sink by the tables to wash your hands. Great food, youll have to resist coming too often...

Food is exceptional but some staff members are rude. Additionally, the fact that you have to order online even if you re sat down in the restaurant is very weird.

When you charge 12.99 for a slice of coconut cream pie it communicates to me you wanna get as much money from me as possible at all costs even if it means ripping me off.So 12 slices to a pie...You believe your coconut pie is worth 150 odd dollars .....lol..

Awesome pizza and donuts!! And people are so kind.

We order the pizza for take out it was ready upon my arrival. It was fresh hot and delicious, definitely one of the best pizzas in Toronto. Also loved the donuts, light fluffy and not too sweet!

A little pricier pie, but worth it! Cant wait to try it again

Great pizza! Great sauce :)

The best service you re going to get in Toronto! It s a cozy place, the pizza is fantastic and the staff are so wonderful and nice. Love the donuts too!

What an incredible place. Had thr most amazing donut today and the most amazing experience. You can really tekk they love what they do and take great pride in making their customers feel special!

Well...I must say...after eating pizza in many places in Italy...my experience here was amazing. The pizza, succulent! taste and the crust was marvelously made! Best pizza in Toronto...and maybe the best I have tried in America. Thanks

Great pizza! Not too doughy Food

Tasted like a slightly elevated Pizza Pizza. Donuts were fluffy but had little taste. Don t believe the hype. Service was great, though. Staff were very kind.

Pizza was amazing and portions were huge. Only thing that was horrible was the service. Place wasn t packed on a Sunday which is no excuse for the servers to be attentive to the customers. One of the servers tried to argue that I didn t order a creamy garlic when he brought the hot honey. Kind of embarrassing. Towards the end of our meal the server finally cleared the large trays that were disturbing the table need new servers for sure.

We ordered lots of food from here for the office party and everything was amazing. The delivery was on time - the order was correct and the food was delicious. Thank you!

Best pizza place in Toronto

This is the best pizza in Toronto, especially by the slice. It would hold its own in any neighborhood of NYC.

Simranjeet is amazing !! Her staff is great! Cant wait to go back!!!! Service is fantastic Food

Fire Pizza.

Beautiful pepperoni and mushroom pizza!

Fourth Man In The Fire is always absolutely fantastic, Spectacular Pizza, Epic Sandwiches and the donuts are truly next level ..Well done FMITF Team, you never disappoint!!!!!

Great pizza, great donuts and great service!

I have never dined in yet but this is my goto pizza. Hands down the best flavor and crust that works for me. The sauce has the slightest spice which is phenomenal. I always get the donuts too as they are so fluffy and the icing is my preference for icing making them perfect. Last time I bought 3 donuts, they gave me 5 probably because I bought so much so recently from them debating ordering again tomorrow that s how delicious the pizza is here!

Amazing service and fantastic food. One of the best pizza places here in Toronto!

Tremendous. Absolutely tremendous.

probably one of the best pizzas i ve ever had. the staff was so nice and welcoming.they don t just have pizza they also have these big donuts that are so good and so filling i would recommend this place 10x over

Ordered ahead and sandwiches were perfection

Pizza and Donuts

AMAZING one word tells it all! Amazing Pizza, Amazing Donuts. I mean Amazing. Can t say enough about this place, thank you Sim Food : 5/5 |

THE RATING IS SPECIFICALLY FOR THE DONUTS: if there was a 6th star I would give it to them for the donuts.

Food was excellent. They have chicken cutlet sandwich done in a beautiful vodka sauce - out of this world, A car prese salad so fresh, service was excellent. My waitress was Christie - she was excellent helpf very very pleasant. Nice atmosphere, Nice selection of pizza - the place smelt so good, you gotta check them out - well worth it ! Oh don t let the massive doughnuts when you walk in the door fool ya - they are huge ! And I mean huge !

Just had such a lovely experience here. There was a woman in the front of the line complaining about an uber delivery order and the employee was so patient and kind helping her out and really listening and providing support. Once she left, he was so apologetic for the wait that he gave me a free donut! The service here is really exceptional.

When you charge $3 for a can of soda, it makes me believe the entire menu is a rip-off.

Best in the City

Our go too pizza place when visiting! Great crispy pizza with great service and amazing manager who always takes care of us!!

Preface: this is about the GLUTEN FREE pizza. I never complain about food, but Im going to about this pizza because this pizza cost $27.00 BEFORE tax and I only got pep on it. This was literally the worst pizza I have ever had. The tomato sauce tasted like it came from a can and the pizza was drowning in it. The cheese was like its own layer that could have literally been picked up off of the crust. The crust was DRENCHED in oil. I could not finish this pizza. Ive been burping it up for the past 20 minutes and can feel it turning in my stomach. To be fair - I know their non-gluten free crust pizzas are amazing and thats cool. But to charge nearly $30 for a pizza of this quality is ridiculous. Others like pi co, Pappa Johns and pizzialo make a great gluten free pizza and are almost $10 cheaper. Im not trying to be a dick but please stop selling gluten free pizza here until its fixed. This was genuinely upsetting

It was good to try once .

A great place near little italy to sit down with friends and have some great pizza! Maybe some donuts for dessert too ;)

This is our favourite neighbourhood pizzeria and donut shop. Not only is the food great, the service and staff go above and beyond.

Good food. Good donuts. Might be victims of their own success. Ordered at 6:30. Still waiting at 8:50. Like we are talking 2.5 hours to get a pizza. Not Ubers fault this time.

Might be the best pizza I ve ever had (Brooklyn squares). Taste was incredible - fresh and high quality! 10/10 recommend Vegetarian options: Lots of vegetarian options

Some of the better pizza in the neighbourhood. Add a box of donuts while you re at it!

Just unbelievably good pizza. I wouldnt hesitate, go there Food

Tried this delicious pizza with a perfect crust and fresh toppings! The mix of mushrooms, jalapeños, red peppers, and pineapple was fantastic. The dipping sauces were great. Highly recommended for veggie pizza lovers!

Our favourite donut spot in the city! Service is exceptional and everything is baked to perfection.

One of the best pizzas I have ever had for sure. Pleasant employees as well and nice atmosphere inside even though I ordered take out.

Was the pizza good? Yes. We ordered the American cheese pizza. Outside of the tomatoes sauce they added on top of the cheese it was really good especially the crust. But $33 plus tax for a large plain cheese pizza is too much. Whats even worse was the garlic sauce was basically $4. I had better pizza for less. Staff were cool though and atmosphere was also a plus

Love it!!!

all is perfect

The food was and service was great. The atmosphere was perfect and the donuts where delicious.

Curious, then recommended by my son. Found the Sausage/Onion pizza quite good. Am enjoying a donut as I write! Thanks!

Favourite pizza down town! Super nice staff. Get the American cheese, she s a beaut!

The food here is unbelievable. Fresh and hot from the oven, you cant go wrong. The tomatoe sauce is the secret magic that brings everything together but all elements work in beautiful harmony. Save room for dessert because the doughnuts are to die for.

The owner treated my guests from Italy and Germany great.

Well i think its just hyped alot its normal round pizza i found it similar to pizza pizza tho Soo yeah its normal pizza Food

The pizza we ordered was delicious, and Vanessa was a kind and attentive server and host!

Its really delicious. Its an American cheese pizza, and its the most delicious cheese pizza Ive ever had. The dough is not thick and delicious. Highly recommended The bread is delicious too! I plan to visit regularly good luck!

I didnt eat the pizza but its looked and smelled amazing in my friends car

This place is just awesome. Great service great atmosphere and also the food is just simple and perfect. Will not stop coming here. P.S donuts are the best in the city

We ordered take out through skip the dishes and even though the pizza was not hot anymore it was still delicious. Can t wait to have it in store! Also ordered the donuts and they were so good. Will be coming to the store for an in person visit soon!

Incredible donuts. Excellent service.

I order pizza for noon rounds just about every week. Our team loves the pizza and the staff are amazing!!

Donuts are the best! Try a plain donut and you won t regret it!!!!!

Went in there in the evening hours, just for a quick slice, one person was ahead of me, he also ordered a slice, when he was done the Indian guy that was working the cash, decided he was gonna ignore me and not take my order, I dont have the faintest idea why, but he wouldnt even make eye contact, thankfully another worker, working in the back saw the awkward situation and decided to ask me what I need. Maybe a quick tutorial in basic customer service is at hand. Anyways, pizza was

Its a great local place for a creative donut, a slice, or a whole (pizza) pie. In for take out, a quick bite, or a chat with a friend they offer it all.

Loved this place. Pizza was one of the best Ive ever had. Donuts were so amazing too.

I ordererationalized the panzerotto. It s easily line of the best I ve ever had in North America. The Fourth Man serves them fried as the Neapolitan tradition demands. But even while being perfectly fried, they re not too greasy. Very pleasant and clean to eat. I ordered the small, and using a very personal scale of mine, I was able to determine that it was 14 long. After investigating, I discovered the large is 18 . I also recommend their donuts. Excellent; especially, the apple fritter. My one complaintation is that it s a bit expensive. But that means, it will help me moderate my orders and ensure I stay as slim as Slim Whitman; but, unlike him, I don t fall to pieces

Lunch with a friend

Delicious pizza, we got half cheese and half pepperoni and look forward to coming back.

By far the best pizza in Toronto. And the donuts are the BEST youll ever have! Whenever Im asked for recommendations of where to eat in Toronto I always recommend fourth man. Sim is awesome and always makes sure your experience is exceptional.

One of my new favourite spots in Toronto!! The food is incredible, from the delicious donuts to the finger liking good pizza. But the service and atmosphere are what really makes this place stand out. Every time my friends and I have come here, the service has been incredible. Sim and her team make this place feel so welcoming. Best pizza and service I ve had in a long long time!! Definitely check it out if you have the chance

A staple in the neighborhood and one of the most welcoming restaurants I ve been to. On top of the excellent pizzas and sandwiches, they make the best donuts I ve ever had. Sim and the whole team provide top notch service and create an awesome vibe every time. The consistency, quality and service is what keeps me coming back. Highly recommend!

my favourite pizza in the area, good donuts too

Excellent service. Grab a few slices and the team packaged it in a box so it was easy for us to take to the park. Get a doughnut:)

Best meatball sub Ive ever had. Im guilty of having it more than once in a week. The bread is perfect. I add jalapenos and onions. The chicken sandwich is even better!!! Get lots of extras on it and dont forget the incredible donuts. Food

BBQ chicken pizza was so good but would probably have been better if it was fresh out the oven. Delivery took a bit of time.

Pizza was amazing! Best NY style slice in Toronto. Crust was crisped to perfection. Sauce was delicious. The Brooklyn squares are a Detroit Style pizza and was amazing as well. I m surprised they have managed to perfect 2 different styles of pizza (NY and Detroit). I also like the fact that you can buy pizza by the slice as well. Mozzarella sticks are OK. I found the outside coating to be too think. For dessert you can get Kawartha icecream donut sandwiches. What?! These were huge and delicious. Coconut Cream Pie is also a must have. They have a nice patio outside as well if you go in the summer. Overall, one of the best pizza places in Toronto if you re looking for NY or Detroit style pizza. EDIT TO ADD: Donuts themselves are high quality!

Excellent pizza and warm friendly kind service. Enjoy!

Stopped by for a slice , honestly one of best slices of pizza Ive had this year, light, airy, crispy and flavorful crust, fresh sauce, left you wanting another one right away, definitely worth a try.

Amazing pizza. Great service. Will absolutely be coming back.

This spot has some amazing pizzas and donuts and the staff members are super nice and welcoming!

Service and food was great!! Chloe was great!

Absolutely amazing food and service !! Vanessa made our time here so enjoyable and was great. The food is amazing, definitely reccomend their Caesar salad, mozzarella sticks and sausage and onion pizza. Defo grab a doughnut on the way out too

DO NOT ORDER DELIVERY!!! They are on DoorDash with a 25 min time to delivery. After hitting the order button the time went to 1.5hours. If you ask for a refund they will only give a fraction back (literally offered me $15 on a $75 order).

Amazing pizza! Absolutely delicious, donuts are top tier.

Had a great time at 4th man on a sunny Friday evening. Called ahead to book a spot on the patio and it was so nice out there. We shared a Caesar salad, cheese pizza and Mozza sticks. All were delicious. As were the donuts for dessert with the pink icing one as the surprise winner. We ll be back soon!

I cant speak for the pizza but I would literally die for one of these donuts. The best ive ever had and I have to get one every time im in Toronto.

My favourite pizza in Toronto. Service is always friendly and the food is always fresh!

Amazing pizza

Best beats place hands-down

Best pizza in town :) great atmosphere and excellent customer service. Never disappoints :)

The pizza is very delicious, it is the Italian crispy type, the normal size is suitable for 3 people to eat together, because I am only one person, so the clerk specially made a small one for me, the person is very nice, the service is also great, it is an explosion The head clerk is very nice.

Absolutely loved this place. I really enjoyed the pizza, the Donuts are a dream and the staff, the friendliest ever!! Well be coming here a lot

Edit 08/92/24 Thanks very much for those donuts the other evening and youre most welcome for the custom box. Always happy to say hello when Im in the neighborhood FM. PS Please dont order any take out after 9pm so these kind chefs can get home at a reasonable hour. ---- Edit 07/25/24 Did you know these mavens will do split pies on the back deck and perhaps share a cheese stick when you have a black panther to protect I didnt hey Google© tell Zuckermusk® to add a star 6ix stars out of 5ive 4 Fourth (hu)Man in the ---- Edit 07/20/24 How are there so many beautiful monsters working their magic here this boy is attracted and afraid no human centipede Update 07/19/24 Stopped in after a long day of tomfoolery, told a few fortunes and even had a homer X doughnut sticker for my best friend Chloe. An understandable snafu with the order led to a bit of a delay and our kindly on-shift manager comped my meal which was a classy move. ------ {Did anyone see that fifi JHH x Çloud1???? I herd it was down the street og} Brimming with (kind) attitude, everyone from the queens at front of house to the gentlemen stoking the fires in the back looks sharp and keeps their cuts for the slices. Ty very much for that complimentary doughnut the other evening, youll laugh when we have the chance to chat next in person x

Never ordering again. I ve been a loyal customer and I ve always paid for the premium pizza, but the delivery is terrible. The last five times I ve ordered, food has been missing. I can t do it again. Goodbye fourth man, it s too bad you re so disorganized

Great pizza!

I never received my food. Absolutely worst service ever. I ordered food at 2 pm with my very hungry family including two toddlers. 45 minutes later and no pizza. I asked three times and got excuses and false promises of itll be a few minutes. We ended up leaving.

awesome pizza and even better meatball subs

Nice pie. Fresh ingredients. Love the marinara they use. Light, airy, thin crust. Friendly, welcoming service. They appear to love what they do. Decent-sized sitting area. Their work area seems to spill into the dining area. Its nice to get to see them make the dough for the pies and the doughnuts right in front. They make doughnuts BTW. Great apple fritter, which was also delicious and really fresh. It could use more apples. I think you have to go in person to experience and not through a delivery service. In any rate, great place. I wholeheartedly recommend making the trip.

First time here. Staffs there is very helpful and welcoming. There s indoor and patio for you to sit, eat and enjoy the view.

Great food and staff. Lovely experience!

The staff is very warm and welcoming, very calm atmosphere. The pizza was delicious and the ingredients were very fresh. The pizzas are large too.

Gluten free pizza sauce was canned tomatos so crust was soaked.

Insane pizza. Ordered vegetarian and American cheese. Best pizza I ever had. Obsessed. And their donuts are phenomenal. I have tried all the best pizza spots in the city this one takes the cake.

Sim is an absolute beauty. Great service, great food and great vibes. Would recommend the cesar salad, the mozzarella sticks and the doughnuts on top of the pizza. Huge W

We tried the Brooklyn squares, it was delicious !

Cutting two meatballs in half for a meatball sub is a 2024 food joint vibe for sure. The sun itself was alright. Bread: chewy but moist from the sauce Meatballs: meaty and a nice level of herby Sauce: sharp and tomato-y, like a mild salsa, but pretty salty

We had a great experience here!! Pizza was delicious! Was recommended Sausage and Onion by our server Kevin, and it was amazing!! Thank you Kevin and Team! Would highly recommend a visit!!

If youre searching for a pizza spot that nails high-quality food with simple ingredients and top-notch customer service, look no further than Fourth Man in the Fire. This gem has a cozy, inviting vibe, making it perfect for a date night or a chill hangout with friends. Their pizza is incredible one pizza will definitely take you far. Plus, their donuts are a must-try! Whether youre pre-gaming or just enjoying a quiet evening with fantastic food, Fourth Man in the Fire is the place to be. Highly recommended!

Food was great! Definitely one of the best pizzas in town!

Amazing service and lovely pizza!

Nice staff Vegetarian options: Lots of variety available Parking: You can park on street parking considering green paas

Pizza was good Donuts were great

Casual restaurant , brick oven pizza, special boston deep dish pizza was delicious. They also have a donut counter in the restaurant. Big, beautiful, delicious and innovative combinations.

We ordered Gluten free pizza and it was so delicious! We loved it!

Holy hell this is the BEST pizza and donut place in Toronto. Exceptional food, you can tell the ingredients are top quality we ve had the margarita and pepperoni pizza and the Boston dohnut - WOW the flavour is just sensational. Superb. Also lovely staff every time we visit.

I had an amazing experience at The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria! The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, perfect for a relaxed evening. But what truly made the night exceptional was Vanessa. From the moment we arrived, Vanessas warm and friendly demeanor made us feel right at home. She was incredibly attentive, always checking in to ensure we had everything we needed without being intrusive. Her beautiful smile and upbeat attitude were a highlight of the evening, adding a special touch to our dining experience. It s obvious that Vanessa takes great pride in her work. She was efficient, thoughtful, and made sure our meal went off without a hitch. Her genuine care and charm were evident throughout the evening. I m definitely planning to return, and I m really hoping Vanessa will be our waitress again. She truly made the night memorable. If you re heading to The Fourth Man in the Fire, don t miss the chance to be served by her she s outstanding!

Its really salty, and the price is not cheap, a serving costs 40 Canadian dollars. But still praise it, but there will be no next time. The salad is also very salty, and the bathroom environment is good. Friends also say its hard to eat. Very disappointed

Excellent pizza, perfect dough cooking, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside! Warm welcome and efficient service. Very good address close to Kensington Market and Little Italy in Toronto.

Friendly staff and some of the fluffiest donuts ever!!

Ordered the chicken Parm (i know not a pizza) took like 30 mins for them to make a sandwhich. The sauce was cold in places. Tasted great and had an amazing amount of cheese. Will give them another try soonish. Donuts priced outrageously. Gross

The pizzas are very generous! We didnt manage to finish even though we only took 3 for 7 people! Its very pleasant to see. A little disappointed however with the pizzas themselves which I would have thought had more garnishes.

Three options for pizza by the slice one of the best pizza in New York hands-down I believe if you focus on perfect in your craft, you don t need many options and that s what they just did amazing flavour amazing crisp and fresh pizza plus the interior is amazing. shout out to the owner of the Restaurant. They did an amazing job.

The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria is hands down our favorite pizza spot and restaurant in the city. The place has a vibrant, retro vibe that instantly makes you feel at home. Whether we re dining inside or enjoying the outdoor patio, the atmosphere is always perfect. The customer service is top-notch everyone is welcoming, and the management is incredibly sweet. But what truly sets this place apart is the food. As pizza lovers, we can confidently say that they serve the best pizza in the city. The fresh ingredients, aged dough, and the love they put into each pie make it a pizza connoisseurs dream. My personal favorite is the sausage and onion pizza, paired with a vanilla Coke an absolutely perfect combo. The appetizers and sides are also delicious, and as a bonus, they serve Harry and Heels California Donuts right in the same storefront! Overall, we would highly recommend The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria. It s one of our go-to spots in the city, and it never disappoints.

Your ULTIMATE single slice pizza fix!! Do it!!

Reminds me of getting pizza with my family back in the 80 s. Brooklyn Pizza with hot honey is perfect Food : 5/5

Definitely lives up to the hype, one of the top pizzas in the city. Staff were also very friendly. Got the meatball sub and a slice to share. Both were amazing. They even gave us free donut samples of a new flavour they were trying out.

Great pizza. Great pizza. Great pizza. Classic NYC pie + pepperoni and mushroom. Very busy dine-in and lots of delivery/pick-up, but servers + host managed the in-store traffic. Next time (there will definitely be a return visit), well leave room for a donut (they look looked yum.)

I like their pizza better than Badiali to be honest

Tried many pizzas in Toronto but this is by far the best. Went to Fourth Man in the Fire for a dinner date, we ended up ordering the Friends and Family dinner, absolutely amazing deal. Toronto has become unbearable expensive but it s so refreshing to come to a restaurant which has phenomenal quality food for such a reasonable price. We had the BBQ chicken pizza and it was delicious, along with their mozzarella sticks and looney bread, 4 drinks, all for 59.99$. An 18 pie, perfect balanced between sweet and savoury with the bbq sauce and pickled onions, entirely unpretentious- I can t wait to try more of their pizzas. Our server named Z was super attentive, helpful, friendly - just a great guy in general. The kitchen was firing pizzas and got a little in the weeds and for the slightest delay, the manager Sim (I think that s her name) treated us to their world class donuts. Perfectly proofed, perfect temperature on the fry (not oily in the slightest) - amazing. You cannot find service like this in Toronto anymore. I would also venture to say it s impossible to find a better pizza. Highly highly recommend trying Fourth Man in the Fire.

Many places in the area sell quality, upmarket pizza and sandwiches and have never given me a burnt one. Typically quite tasty but sending food out like this at a premium price is not cute.

We had ordered the pizza once and loved it. This time we decided to go to the restaurant for a lil date night. It was a rainy Friday, we got seated right away, Z was helping us and he had great suggestions. We ordered the family and friends deal, which is UNBEATABLE - 59.99 for a 18 pie, 2 appetizers and 4 drinks. Z recommended us the BBQ chicken pizza which was 10/10! Considering it was a Friday and this place is so busy, the pie got a lil delayed which is no issue at all considering that the vibe there is so nice, and we had appetizers. Z and Sim (which we even joked could be the owners and siblings) made sure to check on us regularly and gave us two donuts to try for the wait. The donuts were made to perfection - the cherry one was my favourite, it was not oily, not super sweet but super delicious! Furthermore, we have multiple allergies, and they made sure to be extra careful when it comes to that. This is so important to us and it allows people with allergies to enjoy delicious food outside of their house!! Thanks Sim and Z for the amazing service! The food was already a 10/10 but the service was simply out of this world! Definitely recommend it. Dietary restrictions: We have a severe nut allergy and a shellfish allergy, they were very accommodating and made sure it was safe for us! We felt very well taken care of!

Their Donuts are amazing specially the chocolate one! But a few staff members are not helpful, rest is okay!

Pleasant atmosphere and delicious pizza, a lot better than other Italian restaurants.

Absolutely love this place! Food, service and atmosphere it s our go to for pizza and donuts. To say we will be back is an understatement.

Great meatball sandwich and the donuts are the best!

We thoroughly enjoyed our dinner at Fourth Man in the Fire during a recent trip to Toronto. The vibe of the restaurant is casual and it has a nice energy. The pizzas were delicious and the service was friendly and efficient. The delicious donuts were an added bonus to an already successful meal. Would highly recommend and I wish we lived int he neighbourhood so we could go every week.

The pizza was good but i ordered other item and never received! The last time i take my pizza there

Chose to try this place because it was on the food networks list. Ordered the margherita and the veg pizza. Marg was better than the veg but there wasn t really anything interesting about the pizza. Seems like the restaurant has some other decent things on the menu which I didn t try but I don t think the pizza is it.

five stars across the board. so, so good

Stopped for lunch yesterday. Pizza and service was great. Our server was very helpful and made sure we did not order more than we really needed. Restaurant pizza is 18, plenty big for three for lunch. Crust was thin, crusty and toppings were just right. Make sure you get a doughnut. Pricey, but well worth it. Will definitely go back next time we are in Toronto.

Came in to try the famed apple fritters and a pepperoni pizza slice - unfortunately they were sold out of both (it was mid-afternoon on a Sunday). Had a sausage/onion slice and donut instead. The pizza tasted great but was served cold (even though we waited five minutes to get it). The portion was big enough for two people and worth the price. The donut was light, airy and not overly sweet.

The service provided by host Simran was truly exceptional - she made us feel incredibly welcome and even surprised us with a lovely treat.

Excellent pizza, amazing sauce, killer donuts. Can t go wrong with 4MITF.

It goes without saying .. one of the best pizzerias in the city

Hubby and I had our first experience today. Whomever your front staff was she was so welcoming, kind and efficient! I grew up in this area in the 70 s and we chatted about that too! The pizza was phenomenal,crispy bottom thin and passed the fold test lol. Toppings were fresh and vibrant. We ordered half dozen donuts to go and those were fantastic! Will definitely come again. The star of today was your front end staff who managed everything on her own so well..

Ordered single slice pizza - variety limited but was fresh, hot and delish. Then theres the doughnuts - they are just wow! A must-try

Sausage and onion pizza was delicious!! Perfect size for 2 people. The garlic sauce was also very good. Dont forget to ask for chili flakes.

Loveee The Fourth Man! It s such a cozy place to enjoy a good slice of pizza, drinks, or a freshly made donut. This is my go-to spot for a casual day/night out, never disappoints! Staff is very friendly and service is great as well. Some of my recommendations are their deep dish pizzas and their salads :) Side note: The apple fritter is to die for! <3

From the moment I walked in until the time I left, I enjoyed my experience here. The service is 10/10 and just as good as the food. I came from Scarborough and I felt it was worth the drive. I will probably dine in next time but I took it to go.

Great Margherita pizzas!

Really delicious sour cream glaze donuts. The chocolate dip is great also with a slightly bitter chocolate that is great with the soft donut. The cashier at the front was also really pleasant and friendly!

Wooooow !!! Pizza and donuts are insane !

After years of ordering from this restaurant over Uber Eats, my friend and I sat down at The Fourth Man in the Fire. Ive tried all the other top pizzerias in Toronto, including Fresca Pizza and North of Brooklyn. My friend and I rank Fourth Man as the BEST pizzeria we have ever tried! The pizza is a blend of traditional and American styles, combining a crispy, high-quality crust that is topped by rich ingredients. The service provided by Sim and other staff was some of the friendliest I have ever experienced at a restaurant. The vibe is very relaxed, while top quality food is provided. My personal favourites are: the pepperoni-mushroom pizza, the meatball sandwich, the Caesar Salad, and the amazing donuts. This spot is a must-try if you havent already gone. I know Ill be back soon!

Gluten-Free Options: Yes Cross Contamination: Low Halal/ Kosher Options: No Vegan Option: Unsure Vegetarian Options: Yes Nut Free Options: Yes First Impression: A nice casual spot, perfect for a family get together. Favourite: All the pizzas here are very good. Critiques: The staff is very friendly but the attention is not the best. Bonus: they have gluten free crust that is actually on the thicker side and tastes like real bread! They also sell harry and heels doughnuts for those doughnut lovers. Take Away: I will definitely be brining my family here the next time they visit. The food is good, service is good and it s a good place to gather. Follow on tiktok: @eatwithbuns

Best donuts in my area

Tried their Margherita pizza and the crust was pretty good but topping is underwhelming. Also tried their donuts and its a bit overpriced for the quality of it. It is airy, but lacks flavour. Food

Best Sunday decision of my life. Eating your donuts was a full sensory experience from the top of my tongue to the roof of my mouth, I never wanted it to end.

Got it delivered via door dash. Great pizza

My favourite pizza in Toronto. We went tonight for my daughters birthday, and ordered the friends and family meal - fantastic deal! The waiter provided exceptional service throughout the meal, and brought over a treasure chest for our kids to search through to select the gift of their choice. This place is the best!!

2.5 stars. The pizza was fine, tasted a lil like cardboard when it came out fresh, but when the leftovers were reheated, it was 5 stars! My issue is mainly with the dining experience. The place was way too cold, and the ordering process was a little misleading. The online menu says $24, but QR code on the table lists $32.75+. I overhead the staff explaining to another patron that dining in is only available with the largest size pizza. Also, while waiting we saw at least 15 people turned away when asking for slices.

Today, I am visited this pizzeria first time. Its the best pizza and donuts that we have eaten with my son for the last 5 years. Stuff is very polite and kind. Thank you so much for everything.

The best donuts and customer service !!!! LOVE LOVE LOVE

Bad pizza

Quality of food was good. Some sandwiches are quite large. At 3pm on a Saturday they might be sold out of your preferred option. (The online menu which also takes your order and payment) does not update to tell you if an item is sold out so you might try to purchase an item that is no longer in stock. The staff is really busy trying to fulfill bulk orders outside store. I would recommend take out as the in house staff a really busy. We got food before we got water. Best very busy and were a little bit stressed and were relieved to leave. Also I didnt find the donut special personally but I only tried one flavor.

Pizza was hit and fresh 8.5/10. Had go crunch to it as well. Donuts are a 10/10 Service could be a little better, seem to be all over the place when they are busy, which I can understand. Parking: They have street parking but you are only aloud to be there for 1 hour

Tipped 10% and that was too high. I ve been to worse restaurants, but not in a very long time.

Went there 2 times and both times had really bad customer service. Pizza was delicious but the snarky employees and slow service is not worth the pizza. Employees are rude, not attentive and very snarky.

Excellent pizza and donuts served by a friendly staff in a comfortable atmosphere. Highly recommend a visit to this gem!

Food was delicious! We ordered the Sausage & Onion pizza and Garlic & Mushroom pizza. Couldn t resist a donut after lunch which was very tasty as well. Staff are awesome and super friendly!! I ll be back again to try a sub

Fast and Friendly services. Always greeted and made to feel part of the family. Pizza is always delicious, and always baked perfectly! Food

Not what we expected. Pick up experience was a head scratcher. Gluten free I think they thought it was a suggestion. There was definitely some cross contamination there. Dietary restrictions: Gluten free is not for people with celiac. However I m sure it s gluten free

Average pizza that is definitely not worth the wait. Very unpleasant atmosphere inside and it s only okay if you seat outside. Waiters are unwelcoming. I was going to leave a lower rating but one of the employees in contrast to all the others was super nice and professional, sad we didn t ask for his name. Only recommend this place if there are no other options left around.

We did takeout for a party at a nearby bar - everything was delicious but the Brooklyn squares were the hit of the night, beloved by everyone!

Our family of four had the pleasure of dining at The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria on a very busy Father s Day, and despite the crowd, it was a fantastic experience. We opted for the Friends and Family deal at $59.99, which included an 18-inch pizza, four drinks, and two appetizers. It s hard to beat a deal that satisfies everyone s cravings without breaking the bank these days. The pizza was amazing perfect crust and sauce, delicious gooey cheese, and fresh toppings. Oh, and then there were their mammoth donuts the apple fritter and sour cream glazed are must-tries. The staff deserve a special mention. Despite the Father s Day rush, they were friendly, attentive, and on top of everything. They made sure we were well taken care of and never let the busy atmosphere affect their service. Looking forward to returning again soon!

Amazing service I love it Food

Best pepperoni pizza in the city!!!

Awful place with dirty tables, uneducated waiters and long wait time even with empty tables

I absolutely adore this place. Their pizza is one of the best in Toronto. Have gone a few times and they consistently make an amazing pizza. Everything about it is great- the crust, the sauce, the pepps, the cheese. Their pizza is just so good. Oh and their donuts. They make amazing donuts! Highly recommend grabbing a pizza and donuts from Fourth Man

I have no experience because i am still waiting for my pizza for the past 35 minutes after waiting for 15 minutes to be seated. Bottom line, if you plan on eating here, plan to spend at least 3 hours for a quick pizza bite.